How much is BenQ paying [H]

A good deal of them are the user reviews... eesh relax a bit. Even if [H] is making some cash off the advertisment why is that a bad thing?

Exactly..

I wish NEC or DoubleSight would flood the [H] with their IPS Panels for users to review :D
 
A good deal of them are the user reviews... eesh relax a bit. Even if [H] is making some cash off the advertisment why is that a bad thing?

Yes, most of them are user reviews. I'd be mad if [H] was making money off it. That'd be just as bad as them biasing reviews for a few bucks. [H]'s revenue should be completely advertising-driven.
 
A good deal of them are the user reviews... eesh relax a bit. Even if [H] is making some cash off the advertisment why is that a bad thing?

I don't think H making money from advertisement is a bad thing it's just that the forum is flooding. They should at least have a "Fact or Information" thread with links to all the reviews and articles instead of what you see now.
 
I've got the v2400w and it's a good panel. If it had turned out to be disappointing, maybe I would have been suspicious of foul play, but since it lives up to what was said about it I'm fine.
Like jonathan said, I hope other companies identify user reviews as a potentially good marketing technique if they're confident of their monitors...
 
I really like my g2400wd. I bought a samsung 245bw and compared the two. I'm selling the Samsung.
 
I still say more than one BenQ sticky is annoying and unnecessary.

Roll 'em up into one

Dave
 
those are all user reviews done for benQ, those people have the monitor for free and can get it at a discount price for doing the review! thanks to benQ not bash the H :p
 
I have no objection to what was done. I think it was great in fact. Ten time better than most "professional reviews" of LCD monitors.

But the amount of stickies is a bit messy.

It would be better if they had one sticked post with links to each review. It would be easier to spot if a new one was added and when there was any real updates.
 
I have no objection to what was done. I think it was great in fact. Ten time better than most "professional reviews" of LCD monitors.

But the amount of stickies is a bit messy.

It would be better if they had one sticked post with links to each review. It would be easier to spot if a new one was added and when there was any real updates.

I agree. User reviews are awesome, but having a half dozen threads all for the same monitor just looks really excessive. One master thread with all the reviews linked would look MUCH cleaner.
 
Hey, be happy that BenQ is paying, their monitor are the top of TNs :)
Imagine it would be Samsung trying to convince us that their S-PVA are better then H-IPS :)
Or even worse... Acer!
 
Yea, sorry I posted the original topic wrong, I have no problem with user reviews. But its a whole page view of stickies about ONE MONITOR depending on the resolution u view at. completely unnecessary.
 
Well, I thought the idea of stickys was for threads that have become more like FAQs.

(For example, it was great having the FW900 thread as a sticky...)
 
Review sites don't get paid for reviews generally. Advertising revenue can result out of a favorable review. Advertising revenue can be lost after a very unfavorable review. Remember the Ultra power supply review? I'm sure I used to see "Ultra" ads on HardOCP, but I don't see them any more after they reviewed that piece of junk power supply fairly recently.

Some people thought my review was too "nice", but I reviewed based on the price point and the competition, which I found the V2400W was favorable against. I could have cried about the viewing angles being inferior to S-PVA/MVA or IPS, but those monitors are not direct competition (unless you can get a deal on the MVA alternatives). Compared to other TNs, the viewing angles were as good or better.

For gamers I do find it above average considering the mostly usable ratio scaling and image sizing support that is very good over DVI and HDMI, and decent with VGA, as well as the accurate (to a fault) colors.

I do agree that one main sticky to all the reviews would be better, and I doubt the [H] is gonna leave this up for too much longer.

I think what was good about this whole thing, was that the [H] had four user reviews all with salient points, and certain amount of different experiences (ie. GTG465X had a monitor with worse backlight bleed than I did, and Jim Robbins' display had a stuck pixel), and these reviews together far outrstripped the "Trusted Reviews" half-ass version.

But honestly, I don't think the added or lost advertising revenue motivates [H] to alter their reviews or recommendations, and that is why I'm an avid reader.

Regards,

10e
 
Back
Top