4870 or GTX 260?

Uberbob102000

2[H]4U
Joined
Apr 29, 2006
Messages
2,243
I'm getting a new video card for my secondary rig and I was wondering which card would be better @ 1920x1200 and 2560x1600.

Thank You in advance.
 
The ATi 4870 would be the most logical choice for cost/performance. ;)
 
The 4870 preforms all most as good and some time better then the 280 and it only a little over $300.00, instead of over $600.00 for the 280. It would be foolish to buy a 280 right now.
 
How so? GTX260 runs cooler, sucks less power, and whoops on the 4870 in AoC.

But, you do have to consider price! For a secondary rig, I would most definitely go with a 4870.

It runs cooler because PowerPlay isn't working properly yet. And it only draws less power on idle, again because PowerPlay isn't working yet.

And it beats the 4870 in AoC... which is one game. Have you seen how the 4870 destroys even the GTX280 in some games?
 
4870 VS 260

4870 beats 260 in the ratio 2:1

http://en.expreview.com/2008/06/24/first-review-hd-4870-and-hd-4850/19/

4870vsgtx260.png
 
GTX 260 Still looks good to me, just wish they would drop the price...gonna give them 2 weeks. If they haven't changed the price I will buy my first ATI card.
 
It runs cooler because PowerPlay isn't working properly yet. And it only draws less power on idle, again because PowerPlay isn't working yet.

And it beats the 4870 in AoC... which is one game. Have you seen how the 4870 destroys even the GTX280 in some games?

According to [H]'s review, the GTX 260 is comparable to the 4870. What RB30 posted above also confirms this. Not seeing how it is destroying the GTX 280 if that's the case.

And don't give me the link to Anandtech's article, because it showed the 3870x2 outperforming like the 8800GTX in that one.

To the OP: For the money, the 4870 is a way better buy than the GTX 260, like others have been saying. The only difference here is that the GTX 260 has more memory and is thus better when you are applying AA in high resolutions. Other than that, it's your call.
 
That's because [H], despite how good they are, only tested THREE games.

In any case, I'm thinking about Bioshock where even the 4850 can almost (but doesn't) match the GTX280. I've confirmed this with my own testing. For some unknown reason, the 4xxx series is blindingly fast with Bioshock.

Then there's CoD4. Techreport shows that the 4870 matches the GTX280.
 
If you are BUYING the 4870 is the better choice. But if you can step up to the 260 for 130 like me, its a better option than trying to sell your card and buying a new card.
 
<mini-rant>

I won't buy the 4870 on principle. It could be the most awesome card in the world and yet it's still plagued by that god awful bloated piece of shit they call 'Catalyst Control Center'. It sucked 3 years ago when they introduced it, and it's never really gotten any better. Your fucking driver control panel shouldn't take several seconds to load on one of today's high end systems - hell it shouldn't take several seconds on a low end machine.

</mini-rant>

I say grab a 260...
 
That's because [H], despite how good they are, only tested THREE games.

In any case, I'm thinking about Bioshock where even the 4850 can almost match the GTX280. I've confirmed this with my own testing. For some unknown reason, the 4xxx series is blindingly fast with Bioshock.

Then there's CoD4. Techreport shows that the 4870 matches the GTX280.

The reason why [H] tested those three games is because the games you mentioned above can be maxed out with a 9600GT at 1920x1200. At any rate, all high-performance cards are pulling 100+ FPS at max settings, which is more than plenty. For the new cards, games like Crysis and AoC are what matter. Whether or not we get 100 FPS or 140 FPS matters in CoD4 or Bioshock matters zero.

I mean, I could load up Quake 3 and say, "Oh my gosh! The GTX 280 gets 300 FPS, but the 4870 gets 400 FPS!"
 
And yet you don't even have to install the CCC at all.

Of course, it only takes 10MB of RAM on my machine and after the first time I've opened it, it takes 1 second to open.


Maybe you're just operating on old information.
 
The reason why [H] tested those three games is because the games you mentioned above can be maxed out with a 9600GT at 1920x1200. At any rate, all high-performance cards are pulling 100+ FPS at max settings, which is more than plenty. For the new cards, games like Crysis and AoC are what matter. Whether or not we get 100 FPS or 140 FPS matters in CoD4 or Bioshock matters zero.

I mean, I could load up Quake 3 and say, "Oh my gosh! The GTX 280 gets 300 FPS, but the 4870 gets 400 FPS!"

If you're getting 140FPS on a high resolution in Bioshock in DX10 mode on a single GPU, you're from the future o_O

It's definitely above the 60FPS plateau on modern cards at middling resolutions (like 1680x1050) but not quite that high.
 
And yet you don't even have to install the CCC at all.

Of course, it only takes 10MB of RAM on my machine and after the first time I've opened it, it takes 1 second to open.


Maybe you're just operating on old information.

Yeah, seriously. And I only use it maybe once per week? CCC isn't even a valid complaint anymore.
 
According to [H]'s review, the GTX 260 is comparable to the 4870. What RB30 posted above also confirms this. Not seeing how it is destroying the GTX 280 if that's the case.

And don't give me the link to Anandtech's article, because it showed the 3870x2 outperforming like the 8800GTX in that one.

To the OP: For the money, the 4870 is a way better buy than the GTX 260, like others have been saying. The only difference here is that the GTX 260 has more memory and is thus better when you are applying AA in high resolutions. Other than that, it's your call.

Actually from ExPreview.com's benchmarks, 4870 beats 260 in the ratio 2:1. 4870 beats 260 in every games they tested except F.E.A.R. : Perseus Mandate and Lost Planet, which are inconsequential because hardly anyone plays them anyway.

4870 scales better than 260/280 when AA is on and at higher resolution. 4870 can actually tie with 280 at 1920x1200 8xAA 16xAF running Enemy Territories: Quake Wars.
 
The 4870 preforms all most as good and some time better then the 280 and it only a little over $300.00, instead of over $600.00 for the 280. It would be foolish to buy a 280 right now.

ROFL what reviews are you reading? GTX280 is undisputed king of performance...but at $650...yea...freak-nut expensive. 4870 doesn't perform almost as good as the GTX280. Must be typos...you meant GTX260?
 
Most of the time the 4870 is simply competitive with the GTX260. There are some cases where it does in fact match the GTX280. However these are far and few in between so the 4870 isn't a serious competitor to the GTX280.

If you want the fastest single gpu, it's the GTX280.
 
I'm getting a new video card for my secondary rig and I was wondering which card would be better @ 1920x1200 and 2560x1600.

Thank You in advance.

Simple.

The 4870, no contest in terms of either price or performance, and especially not both.
 
Most of the Anandtech stuff, he doesn't turn on any AA...I think the GT200 architecture is better "futurized"...as in, it's got more memory basically.

But price/performance the 4850 whoops it up!
 
AA scaling is better in the 4xxx series though. So if AA were turned on, the 4xxx would have even a better showing.
 
4870, no contest...

Unless you can wait and see how the X2 performs...
 
AA scaling is better in the 4xxx series though. So if AA were turned on, the 4xxx would have even a better showing.

Until it runs of memory at high resolutions due to the 512mb. In any case, it was basically the same out of pocket cost for me to stepup to the 260 compared to buying a 4870 and selling my 9800GTX. So i went the easier route and thats stepup.
 
Huh?

Looking at the [H] review here...in Crysis, GTX260 beats 4870, both are playable. In Assassin's Creed, 4870 beats GTX260, both are playable. In AoC, GTX260 destroys 4870, 4870 is NOT playable with the same settings...draw distances are lower on grass and ground textures, AND 4870 has 2x AA turned OFF!
 
yep, as stated, the 4800s actually do BETTER with AA than the gtx cards, especially at 8xAA. Take a look at the firingsquad 8xAA section and the techreport review ( they use actual in game tests like [H]) where 4xAA is used in all tests. The 4870 beats the GTX 260 and sometimes even the GTX 280 in most games. The 4800s crush AA.

At the current price points, the GTX 260 is downright overpriced as is the GTX 280.
 
Most of the Anandtech stuff, he doesn't turn on any AA...I think the GT200 architecture is better "futurized"...as in, it's got more memory basically.

But price/performance the 4850 whoops it up!

Then tell the OP to wait for the one gig 4870s to show up. :rolleyes:
 
Until it runs of memory at high resolutions due to the 512mb. In any case, it was basically the same out of pocket cost for me to stepup to the 260 compared to buying a 4870 and selling my 9800GTX. So i went the easier route and thats stepup.

Yeah, at 2560x1600 it does run out of steam. Still, since it continues to match up to 1920x1200 (Techreport tests at 4xAA/16xAF) one wonders what a 1GB 4870 can do.
 
Huh?

Looking at the [H] review here...in Crysis, GTX260 beats 4870, both are playable. In Assassin's Creed, 4870 beats GTX260, both are playable. In AoC, GTX260 destroys 4870, 4870 is NOT playable with the same settings...draw distances are lower on grass and ground textures, AND 4870 has 2x AA turned OFF!

There is obviously something going wrong with that game and ATI, some people are reporting their GPU not going full load when that game runs, personally I tried loading it up on a 7800GS and it crashes non-stop, I'll be able to test this out better when my 4870's come in.
 
The 512mb argument is hard to say because even the 4850 doesnt seem to slow down with high high resolutions. If you use the G92 as evidence 512mb doesn't work, you can't compare mem usage across architectures cause memory management is done differently. The 3870 saw no improvements going to 1gb either.

Also, AoC supposedly has a bug with ATi gpus as someone said the GPU load never goes above 50% during use. If true and its fixed, the card will fly.
 
I'd say the game has issues on its own from that account >_>

@ZerazaX

Indeed. ATI cards seem to handle running low in VRAM more gracefully (see 8800GT 256MB).
 
Huh?

Looking at the [H] review here...in Crysis, GTX260 beats 4870, both are playable. In Assassin's Creed, 4870 beats GTX260, both are playable. In AoC, GTX260 destroys 4870, 4870 is NOT playable with the same settings...draw distances are lower on grass and ground textures, AND 4870 has 2x AA turned OFF!

And you only look at the [H] review...? :rolleyes:
 
One thing to consider with the 260, aside from the prospect of step-up that applies to many of us, is that it has evidently been overclocked to near-280 performance levels. I'm thinking specifically of the Firingsquad review.
 
ii have always been a die hard Nvidia fan. but with both the 4870 and the 260 getting nearly the same performance with a hundred dollar price gap i can only say one thing... i just bought my first ATI card.
 
If i didnt have a stepup option, i'd be going 4870 crossfire. But since i'm basically getting 100 dollars over what my 9800GTX is worth right now, it makes the 260 the same price as the 4870, and i dont have the hassle of selling my old cards.
 
Back
Top