FCC Debates Wireless Early Termination Fees

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
The days of the exorbitant early termination fees mobile service providers charge may be limited. The FCC, faced with escalating complaints about the fees, is considering regulation of the practice. At least one carrier, Verizon Wireless, believes that any changes to this practice should be done at the federal level, which allows a uniform approach rather than leaving it to individual states with widely differing standards in consumer protection.

Congress has even stepped into the matter, with a bill introduced last year in the Senate mandating prorating. "Too often, consumers find out only after committing to a multi-year contract that their wireless service doesn't meet their needs," said Sen. Amy Klouchbar (D - Minn.), a co-sponsor of that bill.
 
hmm I have mixed feelings about this. On the one hand, it'll become really easy to migrate between different carriers, but on the other, if this happens, we can say goodbye to the subsidized prices we get on phones today.
 
we can say goodbye to the subsidized prices we get on phones today.

Yep, if this goes ahead then cell phone prices will rise to the same price as PAYG phones Which will make a massive difference in prices, for instance the new Iphone which will sell (in the UK) for free or £99 depending on your contract, will have to sell for the rumoured £300-£400 PAYG price.

I also think it will slow down the amount of new models comming to market, as with the steeper price it will stop people changing there phones every 6-12 months, which is typical in europe. On the otherhand it might also force the companies to bring out newer features on there phone quicker, as a reason to buy it, rather than just a case change.
 
Maybe if we went to a month-to-month type service and ended the subsidies on phones, it would put more pressure on phone manufacturers to not turn out the same slight revisions to shitty phones. Put more pressure on them from a cost to profit point of view. Just a thought.
 
Ive been with my carrier for 8 years. How many people do you know who can say the same? They earned there money off me a long goddamn time ago. It pisses me off that I have to renew a contract every time I change my plan, or get a new phone. I should be able to leave at a drop of a hate and they should send me away with flowers and cake.

Think of it like this.

You are a landlord. You have a tenant on a one year lease. After one year, they are month to month. The landlord is happy, he got his money for a year and anything else is gravy. Stay as long as you want, or leave whenever u want. Who cares.

It should be NO DIFFERENT for cell phones. A termination fee for the first year and thats all. And the first 30-45 days or so should be a grace period to determine if the service fits your needs.

Here is another way to think of it. If im pissed off at my carrier and want to leave early, when they slap me with a big fine, I am going to really be pissed. If they said "we are sorry mr jones that you arent happy, we are going to waive the termination fee because you are not satisfied", then I would leave with a MUCH better impression of the company. I might even say something good about them to my friends instead of doing my damnedest to bad mouth them to all my friends. I might even go some where else and find out that it wasnt as bad as I thought, and go back since they were so NICE when I left.

Cell phone companies need to realize that they already have a bad reputation, penalizing customers only makes it worse. I would venture to say that cell phone companies have taken the place of cable companies on the "top 10 list of companies that people hate". My cable company ( cox ) bends over backwards to make people happy. They are definitely better than the sorry ass phone company ( bell south ) which still operates like they have a monopoly ( shitty customer service )
 

I've been with T-Mobile for 7 years.

They did one thing that impressed me. My parents bought a new house and they talked to T-Mobile and they said the area is covered. They get there, and it turns out the signal sucks and they have to be outside to make a call. They call up T-mobile and explain the situation. It turns out that they are going to be installing a new tower in the area in a couple of months. So here is the thing that really impressed me. They offered to wave the cost of their plan for the 2 months they would have shitty service or allow them to drop their plan without a termination fee.

They took the 2 months free, but they would have probably gone with another carrier if they hadn't offered to let them drop. Needless to say, this is one of the reasons I chose to stay with them so long.
 
It should be NO DIFFERENT for cell phones. A termination fee for the first year and thats all. And the first 30-45 days or so should be a grace period to determine if the service fits your needs
This is how it is with cell phone companies though. Unless you decide to get a new plan (which is making a new contract with your landlord), or don't buy an unlocked phone from somewhere other than the company for use on their network. People fail to realize that the cell phone company isn't the only place that sells cell phones.

I've been with T-Mobile for ~7 years, and I've been contract free for most of them. Don't see the reason to change my plan, and if I get a new phone, all I need is the SIM card from my current; no need for upgrading through them.
 
I've been with T-Mobile for 7 years.

They did one thing that impressed me. My parents bought a new house and they talked to T-Mobile and they said the area is covered. They get there, and it turns out the signal sucks and they have to be outside to make a call. They call up T-mobile and explain the situation. It turns out that they are going to be installing a new tower in the area in a couple of months. So here is the thing that really impressed me. They offered to wave the cost of their plan for the 2 months they would have shitty service or allow them to drop their plan without a termination fee.

They took the 2 months free, but they would have probably gone with another carrier if they hadn't offered to let them drop. Needless to say, this is one of the reasons I chose to stay with them so long.

And this is why Sprint is losing customers and Tmobile isnt. Sprint customer service sucks. You just made my point. They should go out of their way to help customers, and customer will remain loyal ( mostly )
 
if this happens, we can say goodbye to the subsidized prices we get on phones today.
Wonder what exactly they can come up with as far as "regulations".

1) If the service sucks- no termination fee.
2) If constant billing screwups or other issues with their CS- no termination fee.
3) If moving somewhere where there is no service- no termination fee (I think they already have this though)

Most contracts (which equates to "early termination fees") are based of the PHONE's cost. For cheaper phone- you sign a contract.

IMO, instead of a termination fee, the contract needs to state you make up the difference of the phone or something to that extent. This would of course vary depending on the phone.
More expensive phones would cost more though.

Or even something based off 50% of your remaining bills or something, up to $XXX dollars.

And this is why Sprint is losing customers and Tmobile isnt. Sprint customer service sucks. You just made my point. They should go out of their way to help customers, and customer will remain loyal ( mostly )
I agree.
I love Sprint's service. Just hate their customer service support people. I spent probably 9 months solid from the time I bought my plan to the time they finally seamed out my billing errors (All in all, I overpaid $250 dollars or so, and it was too freaking complicated for them to understand this because they made a mess of all the credits/adjustments).

However, with the business account, I call one person and the problem is fixed. Night and day.


ATT's support sucks on ANY end. Business or personal accounts, I haven't been happy with them at all.


Cannot comment on Verizon, they (At that time- should change now that they added Alltel) don't service here.
 
What other utility service binds you into a year or two contract?

Power? no
Water? no
Sewer? no
Phone (land based)? no
TV (forget those 3 month intros)? no

If they can operate on a month-to-month basis, wireless carriers should be no different. IMO you want to know why they don't want to? It is because they'll have to step up their customer service and stay more competitive with plan pricing/features which cuts their profit.

Can FCC/Congress do anything about those BS taxes too? This is my latest bill from t-mobile:

Code:
Item  	Amount
Msg Value Bundle 400 	4.99
myFaves 300 	39.99
Monthly Recurring Charges 	44.98 


Government Fees and Taxes  	 
Federal Universal Service Fund 	1.65
State Communication Service Tax 	7.55
Local Communication Service Tax 	4.96
County 911 	0.50
Regulatory Programs Fee* 	0.86
Taxes, Fees and Surcharges 	15.52

So basically, I am taxed 35%...complete fucking bullshit if you ask me. (please ask)


/rant
 
If they said "we are sorry mr jones that you arent happy, we are going to waive the termination fee because you are not satisfied", then I would leave with a MUCH better impression of the company

But then people would sign up with the most expensive contract so they get expensive phones like the iphone2 free, then simpy ring up and cancel within 30 days. Customer now has a 300£ Iphone......Carrier has 1 months billing £45, see the problem?

If they bring in termination fees, then the price of many mobiles phones is going to skyrocket upwards. Personally i would prefer a cheaper phone and termination fees.
 
So basically, I am taxed 35%...complete fucking bullshit if you ask me. (please ask)

Yep, it is BS.
20 years ago, people weren't having all the troubles making their mortgage payments they are now.
Nothing has changed. Mortgage payments are still the same percentage of their paycheck.

What has changed, then? Taxes. We are taxed so bad, you work for first 3 or 4 months of the year for the government. They suck so much out of your pocket, THAT is why people have harder troubles making those payments nowadays.



But like ^^^ said... You run into problems like that.
That's what I said, I'd understand them putting something in the contract to make up for the price of the phone. But of course- they base it off the MSRP higher than a kite pricing, too.

I'm all for month-to-month. I'd agree to make up the difference on my phone if I cancel early, too.
 
Yep, it is BS.
20 years ago, people weren't having all the troubles making their mortgage payments they are now.
Nothing has changed. Mortgage payments are still the same percentage of their paycheck.

What the fuck are you talking about? The banks used the extreme low interest rates to lock tens of millions of people into mortgages they'd never be able to afford at more typical rates. Then when rates rose to calm inflation their mortgage payments skyrocketed. And yes, the percentage of their paycheque going to mortgages has skyrocketed along with their payment.
 
why is the FCC getting involved in this? every contract ive seen has a 30day grace period where there's no termination fee or penalty for swapping out the phone. if a consumer decides 3 months into their plan that they dont want it anymore, that's their fault...they signed a legally binding contract for 1 or 2 years and are passed the 30-day "return" policy.

as for the sub-prime mortgage crises...what the mass media fails to tell everyone is that the vast majority of people stuck in these mortgages they now cant afford are people flipping houses for profit and were never living in the now foreclosed house. it's also common sense to realize that SOME THINGS ARE TOO GOOD TO BE TRUE.

Flippers were already taking risks with renovating the houses for profit and many took the additional, known risk of these low rate mortgages b/c they had planned on only having the house a few months. when the house market crashed, these flippers were stuck with these homes (and the risky mortgages) for a LOT longer than expected, and then shit hit the fan and they lost big on the investment AND mortgage. Also, some of the home values dropped so much during the crash that some flippers realized it was cheaper to stop paying the now high mortgage rates and have it foreclosed than it was to keep up payments on a home that is now worth 1/3 to 1/2 their original purchase price. they realized that with such low house prices, it would take 1 or more years to actually turn a profit on the houses and that the currently high mortgage rates on their RISKY mortgages would completely nullify any long-term profits on the house by waiting out the crash and selling high.

it pays to look past the New York Times and read real journalism w/out political agendas.
 
why is the FCC getting involved in this? every contract ive seen has a 30day grace period where there's no termination fee or penalty for swapping out the phone. if a consumer decides 3 months into their plan that they dont want it anymore, that's their fault...they signed a legally binding contract for 1 or 2 years and are passed the 30-day "return" policy.

But what if the carrier doesn't hold up their end of the bargain?

Shitty CS, Shitty service, Shitty billing, anything??? You shouldn't have to pay out the whazoo just to get out of it.
 
But then people would sign up with the most expensive contract so they get expensive phones like the iphone2 free, then simpy ring up and cancel within 30 days. Customer now has a 300£ Iphone......Carrier has 1 months billing £45, see the problem?

If they bring in termination fees, then the price of many mobiles phones is going to skyrocket upwards. Personally i would prefer a cheaper phone and termination fees.

You didnt read my post very well. I said termination fees make sense for the first year or so. After that , no so much. I have been with Sprint 8 years. I still have an early termination fee if I decide to bail out of my most recent contract.That is total bullshit
 
You didnt read my post very well. I said termination fees make sense for the first year or so. After that , no so much. I have been with Sprint 8 years. I still have an early termination fee if I decide to bail out of my most recent contract.That is total bullshit

Sprint now doesn't renew your contract to switch your plan EVER and is introducing a PRO-RATED ETF... that's certainly progress!

People don't understand that phones REALLY cost $100-300+ to the carrier. Sprint did away with "free" phones because don't understand the concept that it really ISN'T free and THAT's why there is a contract. People also treated their phones like shit and expect to be handed another FREE phone for nothing... pitiful. The first few posters understand this concept thankfully.

There should be an option: A reasonable ($20?) activation fee and full price phone with no contract, and subsidized ($200 off) phones with 2-yr contract and pro-rated ETF. Sad that government regulation is necessary because people fail to understand the concept of subsidized phones that cost actual money!
 
With my cable company I get:

Voip
Highspeed Internet
HDTV

For less than my sprint bill. And the cable company still makes a profit.

These "subsidized" phones are part of the cost of doing business, if you ask me. They are making plenty profit off the monthly fees. And I really dont think the phones cost as much as people think... They buy them in mass quantities, Id be surprised if any phone cost them more than $100 no matter what the features. And the last phone I bought, cost me $150. So they got their money to "break even". I only had service a month, they still made money.

Just do away with free phones, charge people $100 bucks for a phone and do away with ETF
 
With my cable company I get:

Voip
Highspeed Internet
HDTV

For less than my sprint bill. And the cable company still makes a profit.

You don't have SERO or Simply Everything, then. ATT is significantly higher.
Heck, was looking into converting the entire cells our company uses over to ATT, and my ATT rep was flat out straight with me: Sprint is cheaper.
 
Clearing some misinformation here...
Sprint for one (may include others)...doesn't require a contract for plan changes, add ons, number changes (including calling area changes). Nothing really requires a 2 year contract except for new service and a discount of some kind. Usually the discount will be in the form of a susidized handset or billing credit.
In the area I live, the carriers here will also waive ETF's if you can show that you moved and now aren't covered by there service. (common sense)
The phones that are typically FREE are crap. Buy a better phone.
The monthly service you pay for wireless, cable, tv, power, water...isn't just for the right to use it. There are other cost to running a buiness besides keeping the power on. (just becuase you pay the bill, doesn't mean other cost are waived or future service will be free)
I say, until all the carriers can provide the same services, that each carrier should have the right to bargin with a contract. If you want Nextel Direct Connect, where else can you go but Sprint? If you want Verizons rural coverage (includes what used to be GTE and now Alltel as well), where else can you go? If you want AT&T bundled services on one bill, where else can you go?
Looks like alot of choices will be gone when the FCC and other federal goverment agencies get involved.
Let the states decide. (or better, read and comprehend things before you sign them)
How many of you have paid a deposit to have wireless service?
How many of you would give your credit card to a stranger and allow complete access to your funds?
How many of you would allow anyone to drive your car anytime they want?
How about letting someone use your home as long as they pay per use?
Other things come to mind when you consider its your stuff, and it will be worn and possibly de-vauled, right?
I like having choices.
 
Back
Top