High-end build ($2000+) ...need some inspections

AugB.

n00b
Joined
Jan 4, 2006
Messages
37
***UPDATED SPECS****


There are some problem areas in my list that I've indicated below; your input on those along with any other suggestions are greatly appreciated. Thanks for helping out!



MOBO (undecided; see GPU):
ASUS P5Q Pro LGA 775 Intel P45 ATX Intel Motherboard
-----------------

CPU:
Intel Core 2 Quad Q9450 Yorkfield 2.66GHz
-----------------

[size=+2]GPU[/size] (undecided):
GeForce GTX 280 SuperClocked Edition

OR

2x ATi Radeon 4850's in Xfire?

I will game on a 22" monitor so I probably won't go above 1920x1200. Which GPU would be the ideal choice? The two 4850's would cost me $200 less, but will they underperform considerably compared to a gtx 280? Which would give me the best overall picture quality?

Also, if crossfire is the way to go, which MOBO would you recommend?
-----------------

RAM:
G.SKILL 4GB (2 x 2GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 1000 (PC2 8000)
-----------------

PSU:
CORSAIR CMPSU-750TX 750W ATX12V
-----------------

HDD:
2x Western Digital Caviar SE16 WD6400AAKS 640GB 7200 RPM 16MB Cache
-----------------

DVD BURNER:
SAMSUNG Black 20X DVD+R
-----------------

CASE (somewhat undecided):
LIAN LI PC-A71B Black Aluminum ATX Full Tower

Thoughts on this? Lian-Li's aren't cheap but I've consistently heard good things about them and I really don't want to skimp out on a case.

---------------------------------------------------


EXTRA:

SAMSUNG 2253BW Black 22" 2ms Monitor


Thanks again.
 
Why not wait for the new GPU's?

elaborate please? Will they outperform the 9800GX2? Are you just speaking of the 48xx series for ATI or is there something I'm missing (I haven't kept up with the latest hardware news)
 
nvidia is coming out with new stuff as well, next week, and ATi the following week. Can read more about it in the Video Card sub, will it out prerform? no clue
 
You obviously don't need Dual 16x crossfire, so ditch the X38 board. Go for a P35 board instead, like the Abit IP35 Pro, Asus P5K, or Gigabyte GA-EP35-DS4. If you still want PCI-E 2.0, you could go for a P45 board instead, like the Gigabyte GA-EP45-DS3R.

Thats some expensive RAM. There's some G.Skill DDR2-1000 for only $85. It works great and will save you some money.
$85 - G.Skill 4GB(2x2GB) DDR2-1000 F2-8000CL5D-4GBPQ

You don't need a 750W PSU, but if you insist, get the Corsair 750W from provantage.com or buy.com instead... much cheaper and just as good.

The WD6400AAKS is a much faster drive than the WD5000AAKS. In fact, it transfers files faster than that WD1500ADFD you have listed there, lol. So, go for that instead. I also don't think the Raptor is worth it anymore. Check out my tests... there's also a link at the top of the page to other HDTune scores posted on the Storage subforum here at [H]:
http://alphaq.org/enginurd/hdd/main.html

That Lite-On drive is LOUD. Trust me, I have one. I replaced mine with Samsung models instead... SH-S203B and SH-S203N (lightscribe). They're MUCH quieter and actually faster, too.


EDIT: You don't need a GX2 for a 22" monitor, btw, but it is a nice card for a 24" monitor. :D As said above (and below) wait for the new cards.
 
agreed, you chose some unnecessary parts with stuff you dont need. you can save on these and inevst it in something else, 24" lcd?
 
With the monitor you're considering, you don't need the X38 motherboard or the 9800GX2. Take enginurd's advice regarding the motherboard change, and consider the 8800GTS/9800GTX for right now and/or waiting a couple of weeks for the new video cards to arrive. (Seriously: Wait for the new cards to arrive. They'll start to trickle in before the end of this month.)
 
+1 for waiting for the new video cards. If rumors are correct, you'll be able to get an HD 4850 for $199, and it will perform better than an 8800GTX. You don't need SLI or CrossFire for a 22" monitor.

And +1 for taking enginurd's advice :)
 
so 'if' rumors are true the 4850 will out do the 8800 gtx, that would mean it would be a lil less than 9800 gtx yes?
 
so 'if' rumors are true the 4850 will out do the 8800 gtx, that would mean it would be a lil less than 9800 gtx yes?

One graph showed the 4850 ($199) outperforming the 8800GT by an average of 40%, and another graph showed the 4870 ($299) outperforming the 9800GTX by an average of 40%.

The point is, wait and see what the actual reviews show, and then you'll know what to buy.
 
You obviously don't need Dual 16x crossfire, so ditch the X38 board. Go for a P35 board instead, like the Abit IP35 Pro, Asus P5K, or Gigabyte GA-EP35-DS4. If you still want PCI-E 2.0, you could go for a P45 board instead, like the Gigabyte GA-EP45-DS3R.

Right. So do I really need PCI-e 2.0? If not, which board do you think would best suit my specs (price isn't that big of an issue here)

Thats some expensive RAM. There's some G.Skill DDR2-1000 for only $85. It works great and will save you some money.
$85 - G.Skill 4GB(2x2GB) DDR2-1000 F2-8000CL5D-4GBPQ

Is there any significant performance difference between 5-5-5-15 and 4-4-4-12?

You don't need a 750W PSU, but if you insist, get the Corsair 750W from provantage.com or buy.com instead... much cheaper and just as good.

The WD6400AAKS is a much faster drive than the WD5000AAKS. In fact, it transfers files faster than that WD1500ADFD you have listed there, lol. So, go for that instead. I also don't think the Raptor is worth it anymore. Check out my tests... there's also a link at the top of the page to other HDTune scores posted on the Storage subforum here at [H]:
http://alphaq.org/enginurd/hdd/main.html

What are your thoughts on the Velociraptor? Is it worth the price?

That Lite-On drive is LOUD. Trust me, I have one. I replaced mine with Samsung models instead... SH-S203B and SH-S203N (lightscribe). They're MUCH quieter and actually faster, too.

Cool, will do.



Thanks for the help everyone.
 
Right. So do I really need PCI-e 2.0? If not, which board do you think would best suit my specs (price isn't that big of an issue here)

Is there any significant performance difference between 5-5-5-15 and 4-4-4-12?

What are your thoughts on the Velociraptor? Is it worth the price?

Thanks for the help everyone.

Are you overclocking? Do you need RAID support? Do you seriously want multi-gpu capability?

Very very minimal. The timings of the ram are really just an indication of how far you can push em. Most DDR2 800 sticks that run at 4-4-4-12 will hit DDR2 1066 speeds without a hitch. the DDR2 800 5-5-5-15 stuff might require some pretty serious voltages to get equally as high. DDR2 1000 5-5-5-15 is usually identical to DDR2 800 4-4-4-12 just pre-overclocked. Your motherboard will also not automatically recognize it as DDR2 1000, plug and play, your ram will appear as DDR2 800 4-4-4-12. the DDR2 1000 speed is an EPP profile (over clock to reach it).

Velociraptor? Loud, hot, and smokin fast. An HD tune bench I saw showed it holding a sustained average read of 100MB/s. I suggest two WD640GB drives instead. Those things hold several 7200 rpm records.

Also, in terms of power supplies, I think the BFG 680W LS deserves an honorable mention here because [1] one of the guys who (presumably) worked on it is a member of this forum [2] that same guy ran the Jonyguru.com [3] it has an o-scope shot thats flatter than a granite counter top (full review here) [4] It at least matches and usually outperforms the corsair and the PC P&C 750W PSUs in every other category. It really is the best performing power supply in that power range.
 
Are you overclocking? Do you need RAID support? Do you seriously want multi-gpu capability?

I have no experience in overclocking any components except the GPU, but I'll be likely to OC both the GPU and CPU.

I've heard both good and bad things about RAID (0, specifically), so I'm not sure. Recommendations here? If I were to get two WD 7200's, would it be beneficial to RAID them?

I might go SLI somewhere down the road, so it's a plus.


Also, in terms of power supplies, I think the BFG 680W LS deserves an honorable mention here because [1] one of the guys who (presumably) worked on it is a member of this forum [2] that same guy ran the Jonyguru.com [3] it has an o-scope shot thats flatter than a granite counter top (full review here) [4] It at least matches and usually outperforms the corsair and the PC P&C 750W PSUs in every other category. It really is the best performing power supply in that power range.

Interesting. I've found the US counterpart to the site here.


Thanks for the advice.
 
I don't recommend using RAID in your case - just get one OS drive and one storage drive as you originally planned. Some people swear by RAID 0 but most agree it doesn't make your average gaming desktop that much faster; at least not enough to justify the extra cost.

Similarly, if you have the money to spend then a Velociraptor would be a great OS drive, but you probably won't notice it being THAT much faster in everyday stuff. If you want to do this, definately get the Veloci over the original 150 version.

I would just get two of the WD6400AAKS as Wizard suggested.
 
As far as Raptor drives are concerned, big OEMs using them for 2nd tier storage still don't use them. Every EMC or IBM array I configure just uses good ol' 7200 RPM drives. Why? They don't need the faster access times and nor do about 95% of the people on this site need it either. Not to mention my past experiences with 10k RPM drives is that they're pretty noisy!

Save your money there and just get a 7200 RPM drive with a big cache. As long as you aren't using a 4-5 year old 1st generation SATA drive like I am as your OS drive, anything on the market today should be plenty fast.

Buying RAM using 1GB DIMMs instead of 2GB DIMMS will be cheaper. Yes, it will occupy all of the RAM slots on your board, but until mainstream applications and games are written specifically for 64-bit OSs, 4GB RAM is going to be more than sufficient for at least the next couple of years.

I agree with everyone else's assessments though, get a less expensive motherboard, probably one half the price of that ASUS will get the job done just fine, and wait to see what comes about with the new video cards. If you can get equal performance for $100 less, you won't be kicking yourself just as the exchange period lapses on that 9800!
 
Buying RAM using 1GB DIMMs instead of 2GB DIMMS will be cheaper. Yes, it will occupy all of the RAM slots on your board, but until mainstream applications and games are written specifically for 64-bit OSs, 4GB RAM is going to be more than sufficient for at least the next couple of years.

Using all 4 RAM slots will limit OC'ing anywhere from 5% - 15%. Theres really no point in using up all the RAM slots with 1GB sticks when 2GB sticks will suffice. So, the best option is a single 2x2GB kit.


Right. So do I really need PCI-e 2.0? If not, which board do you think would best suit my specs (price isn't that big of an issue here)

Current gen cards do not saturate the bandwidth of PCI-E 1.1, so any P35 is still a good choice. By the time PCI-E1.1 slots severely limit PCI-E2.0 cards, it will be time for a new motherboard; and by that time, there will be PCI-E3.0, so you'll be back in the same predicament. Typical higher-end P35 boards are the Gigabyte GA-EP35-DS4, Asus P5K-E, and the crowd favorite, Abit IP35 Pro. For serious OC'ers, the DFI boards are the favorite, but may be intimidating to first time builders/OCers.

Do note that P45 Express is now out, and despite a lack of many reviews, I believe it will be as stable and overclockable as P35. If cost isn't an issue, I'd suggest one of the new P45 boards that suffice your needs, eg. as mentioned earlier, the P45-DS3R. They'll have a first-kid-on-the-block price premium until around Aug.

Is there any significant performance difference between 5-5-5-15 and 4-4-4-12?

As Wizard mentioned, no, there isn't. You won't notice the difference between CL4 and CL5, unless you're running benchmarks (and even then, its negligible), so don't pay a huge price premium for lower latency.

What are your thoughts on the Velociraptor? Is it worth the price?

Not unless you can get it for around $150. :p As Wizard and others have mentioned, the WD6400AAKS drive is fast enough.

I've heard both good and bad things about RAID (0, specifically), so I'm not sure. Recommendations here? If I were to get two WD 7200's, would it be beneficial to RAID them?

RAID0 is nice and fast, but you double your chance of data loss. So, unless you want to deal with the headache of having to reinstall or re-image your OS, its not really worth it unless you're going for super fast I/O. Also, make sure you have a good backup solution. I've been using RAID0 for several years now, and I've only had my array crash once. My backup image of my OS drive was corrupt, so I had to reinstall everything again. Its a cheaper-than-VRaptor way to get VRaptor-like performance (actually higher), but unless you do a lot of disk I/O intensive things, its neither are worth it (gaming isn't very disk I/O intensive).

I might go SLI somewhere down the road, so it's a plus.

SLI is only needed for high resolution 3D rendering. So, if you have or plan on getting a 1920x1080 LCD or higher, and want to game on it at native resolution, then keep SLI as an option. Otherwise, theres no need for it. SLI as an upgrade path is NOT worth it unless, again, a large LCD is in the future plans. There should always be a better, single card solution, and you could sell your old card to help offset the cost.
 
AugB. What will you be putting in the slots of your motherboard besides video? If just the basics, then the P35 boards mentioned so far are good. P45 probably just as good or better. However, if you like to load them up with peripherals, you'll have more resources/lanes available with an X38 board. That would be the only thing to contemplate since you plan on keeping this for awhile. Performance-wise, they are the same.

Since you didn't mention it, also list your planned CPU cooler. I like my Xigmatek, but there are a lot of good ones out there.
 
AugB. What will you be putting in the slots of your motherboard besides video? If just the basics, then the P35 boards mentioned so far are good. P45 probably just as good or better. However, if you like to load them up with peripherals, you'll have more resources/lanes available with an X38 board. That would be the only thing to contemplate since you plan on keeping this for awhile. Performance-wise, they are the same.

Yeah, I think I'll just be using it for the basics.

Since you didn't mention it, also list your planned CPU cooler. I like my Xigmatek, but there are a lot of good ones out there.

Do you think I need a CPU cooler? Is the stock one insufficient? The case I've picked out has pretty good airflow as far as I know, so is it still necessary to play it safe and get a third party cooler anyway?


Also, one more thing - do you think onboard sound is good enough if I use headphones (which I prefer over speakers atm)? I've heard that I need speakers to take advantage of 7.1 so perhaps there's no need to get an aftermarket sound card?..

Thanks for all your replies, I will be updating the specs list shortly.
 
Onboard HD Audio has come a long ways since back in the day. I don't think you'd need a soundcard, but its actually up to you. Try out the onboard sound first. If you find out that its insufficient, buy a soundcard later. Its an easy upgrade after the system is built, if you need it.

You'll need an aftermarket CPU HSF if you want to OC at all. And trust me, you'll want to OC, because these things are SO EASY to OC! The Xigmatek would be a good choice -- great performance for low cost.
 
Stick with an X38 board and get two HD 4850 when they come out in 10 days. Should be roughly equal to a 9800GX2 according to current numbers, though priced considerably cheaper.
 
***UPDATED SPECS****


There are some problem areas in my list that I've indicated below; your input on those along with any other suggestions are greatly appreciated. Thanks for helping out!



MOBO (undecided; see GPU):
ASUS P5Q Pro LGA 775 Intel P45 ATX Intel Motherboard
-----------------

CPU:
Intel Core 2 Quad Q9450 Yorkfield 2.66GHz
-----------------

[size=+2]GPU[/size] (undecided):
GeForce GTX 280 SuperClocked Edition

OR

2x ATi Radeon 4850's in Xfire?

I will game on a 22" monitor so I probably won't go above 1920x1200. Which GPU would be the ideal choice? The two 4850's would cost me $200 less, but will they underperform considerably compared to a gtx 280? Which would give me the best overall picture quality?

Also, if crossfire is the way to go, which MOBO would you recommend?
-----------------

RAM:
G.SKILL 4GB (2 x 2GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 1000 (PC2 8000)
-----------------

PSU:
CORSAIR CMPSU-750TX 750W ATX12V
-----------------

HDD:
2x Western Digital Caviar SE16 WD6400AAKS 640GB 7200 RPM 16MB Cache
-----------------

DVD BURNER:
SAMSUNG Black 20X DVD+R
-----------------

CASE (somewhat undecided):
LIAN LI PC-A71B Black Aluminum ATX Full Tower

Thoughts on this? Lian-Li's aren't cheap but I've consistently heard good things about them and I really don't want to skimp out on a case.

---------------------------------------------------


EXTRA:

SAMSUNG 2253BW Black 22" 2ms Monitor


Thanks again.
 
Cases are personal preference. Get what your heart desires as long as it has enough space and good airflow.

Mobo and Vidcard... wait for more reviews.
 
Back
Top