Windows UX Taskforce Soft-Launched

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
If you're a Windows user, there's bound to be some user interface items that drive you nuts. Instead of gritting your teeth in frustration, go to the Windows UX Taskforce site and see if others share your gripe and perhaps even a solution to it. The site has a Digg-like article voting system so if your issue is shared with others, you may see responses on how to mitigate it. The kinks are still being worked out but I thought it was a cool idea.

The way I originally imagined it was to go through each of the suggestions by hand and add them to my post along with a pretty screenshot. Needless to say, I got tired about 20 entries in and couldn’t imagine doing 140 more. I had to come up with something more manageable. With PHP in one hand, MySQL in another and some duct tape in my mouth, I’ve put together a voting-centric community feedback portal over at www.istartedsomething.com/taskforce.
 
About damn time, their are still a few quirks that must be replaced. We aren't (all) using Windows 3.11 still, are we?
 
Everything on that site can be summed up with "someone please port gnome to windows"
 
Wow, a lot of those people have too much time on their hands.

Like this one:

IE Download animation said:
Problem: the IE download animation is pretty old "globe, paper and folder". The icon is jaggy and not clear either.

Solution: time to update the animation to something fresh.

Severity: Medium

User Comments said:
I love IE but this is REALLY emberassing and pathetic.
Just use a dialog like the shell uses for copy/move etc

That one actually had me laughing for a good while. You're embarassed by IE's download animation? Pure gold.
 
All I can say is, around 1990 the application "Neodesk 3" for the AtariST puts current XP/Vista desktop UI to utter shame. Custom icons, totally object oriented so each icon has its own properties (size, etc). You could write type or doodle on the desktop surface. leave yourself a note or to-do right on your desktop, erase it when done, etc. Customize the windows frame, scroll design, etc. All on a tiny computer with a DOS 3.0 equivalent OS, 4MB of ram, and an 8Mhz cpu, maybe a 20MB HDisk too. And it all ran lickidy split.

Here it is almost 20 years later, with literally INFINITELY more computing power at hand and yet the XP/Vista desktop userface is no where near as sophisticated as a $99 application tacked onto a DOS 3.0 equivalent operating system.

Beyond pathetic Microsoft... land of the MILLIONS OF MAN HOURS of work signifying nothing but wasted electrons. A waste of huan resources so aggregious it should be punishable by DEATH. :eek::rolleyes::p
 
That wasn't the latest version that made, and that was also on the bone stock low resolution monitor. Most power users had either hi res B+W or color and the results once you put the effort in to customize it, it looked ALOT better than that.

But the functionality is what I was getting at.

Seriously, I want to leave myself a note for tommorrow.... so I just click onthe desktop and type in a note, right? Windows does that, correct? I could go on, but given the resources available it had more functionality than todays Vista desktop and 18 years later with MILLIONS of manhours microsoft has really not accomplished much in the GUI front.

Don't you find that pathetic?
 
Most power users had either hi res B+W or color and the results once you put the effort in to customize it, it looked ALOT better than that.
The second picture is of the color desktop. GEM was always ugly and NeoDesk 3 looks like Windows 2.11. Please show a picture of how it could be customized to look a lot better. Every screenshot I saw online was equally ugly to the two I posted.

Seriously, I want to leave myself a note for tommorrow.... so I just click onthe desktop and type in a note, right? Windows does that, correct? I could go on,
You're basing how advanced a 3rd party shell (Windows also has those) was on just one feature: notes. If you want to count 3rd party apps, even Sidekick from the early DOS days (1984) had a note taking/calendar/reminder capability. Wow, that's what I call an advanced feature! :p

Please do go on about the other NeoDesk advancements. It looks like it came out 6 months after Windows 3.0 was released, and the comparisons aren't favorable to NeoDesk. NeoDesk may have looked awesome only in comparison to how bad GEM was.
 
That wasn't the latest version that made, and that was also on the bone stock low resolution monitor. Most power users had either hi res B+W or color and the results once you put the effort in to customize it, it looked ALOT better than that.

But the functionality is what I was getting at.

Seriously, I want to leave myself a note for tommorrow.... so I just click onthe desktop and type in a note, right? Windows does that, correct? I could go on, but given the resources available it had more functionality than todays Vista desktop and 18 years later with MILLIONS of manhours microsoft has really not accomplished much in the GUI front.

Don't you find that pathetic?

Windows Vista sidebar has that feature built in. Write as many notes as you'd like.
 
Wow, a lot of those people have too much time on their hands.

Like this one:





That one actually had me laughing for a good while. You're embarassed by IE's download animation? Pure gold.

Well the first complaint is pretty true. If you compare the folder-to-folder file transfer, everything is crystalized and smooth and modern, but then there's internet-to-folder which still uses the old animation. It's nothing major, but it's something that should get looked at by the art department. It seems like something they accidentally missed when redoing Windows art.

As for the "medium" rating, well, this *is* a poll on UI appearance, not the inner working of Windows, so I think it deserves a "medium" too considering how overlooked the animation appears.

The second quote is funny though. Embarrassed? lol. He sounds pretty anal.
 
Back
Top