Motherboard / Processor: What should I go with?

Punkrulz

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Nov 11, 2001
Messages
1,458
Hey guys,

Yet again I'm back at that time where it's time to revise what I was originally intending on purchasing. Previously on the list, I had an Intel Q6600 Kentsfield, and also the Gigabyte P35-DS3L I believe. I know there are newer chipsets that are out there, and I'm not sure what's better than the P35 right now. I'm also going to be using a nVidia card. I don't believe the motherboard has to be able to do SLI right now, but it may be a partial consideration.

I have also had people question why I would be going with the Q6600, which struck me as kind of odd. Why would I go with a Core2Duo over a Quad? I'm going to be doing gaming on this machine. Right now I also have the GeForce 8800GTS planned for purchase. I have been reading a lot of reviews, and the Gigabyte boards seem to be sitting on the top (at least with the x38 chipset) at performance on almost every margin...

Also, can motherboards that are Crossfire ready, handle just 1 nVidia graphics card? And vice versa?
 
Getting a SLI capable board (meaning with an Nvidia chipset) is not a good idea at all unless you intend to go SLI from the start; they are potentially problematic and not near as reliable as their Intel counterparts. If you're on the kind of budget where a DS3L is at the top of your motherboard list, forget SLI now. A single card will always be faster, cheaper, and less problematic.

The Q6600 is still the best "bang for buck" Quad. The P35 is still a great chipset. X38/48 isn't worthwhile unless you're going with two or more ATI cards for CrossfireX.

The 8800 GTS 512MB or 9600 GT 512MB is probably the best bang for buck card right now, but this will likely change come mid to late June. I would /strongly/ recommend you hold off on building until ATI and Nvidia release their new cards. It's just too close at this point -- something like 3, 4 weeks.
 
Thank you sir. For starters, this machine won't be built any time soon. I just continue to go around, looking at the wish list of what I want to build, periodically updating it as the changes come out. I'm broke as a joke. :)

Secondly, the DS3L was only my list because I know it was a good board. Not really arguing it's standard right now, I'm just trying to find out what is in it's class that performs better, or is it still kind of at the top? I definitely would not be going SLI at the top, I want to do decent res gaming on a single card for now... so what chipset would be the best? Motherboard?

Also, while the Q6600 is the best bang for the buck quad core, I think my question more in lies with, "Should I go for a Dual Core, or a Quad... what benefits would I be looking at from one over the other?"

Thanks!
 
The 8800 GTS 512MB or 9600 GT 512MB is probably the best bang for buck card right now, but this will likely change come mid to late June. I would /strongly/ recommend you hold off on building until ATI and Nvidia release their new cards. It's just too close at this point -- something like 3, 4 weeks.

Isn't the Nvidia 9800 series cards the latest new release? I'm also trying to piece together a gaming system and not sure SLI is for me yet. Is it easy to overclock the Intel Q6600 quad core on a Gigabyte GA P35 DS3L board?
 
Danny put it well, but I can't find the post to quote. The message is simple, though: A faster clocked dual core will outperform a quad core in current games, but a quad core will most likely outperform a dual core in future games. So it really depends on what your upgrade plans are at the time, as well as what's available when you build. At $200 - $220, the Q6600 is definitely the best bang for buck, as silent pointed out, especially if you plan on keeping the system for a while (2-3+ yrs).

A quad core will be better at multi-tasking, media encoding/decoding, and anything else thats optimized to use it. The Q6600 is pretty old, but the newer chips aren't as nicely priced and only offer a tiny bit more performance for such a huge price premium.

The Gigabyte GA-P35-DS3L has been replaced with the GA-EP35-DS3L, which is just a newer revision with some power saving features. An alternative board would be the MSI P35 Neo2-FR. It has better chipset/mosfet cooling, too. The Intel P45 Express replacement still isn't out yet, so it will most likely be released in June.

Isn't the Nvidia 9800 series cards the latest new release? I'm also trying to piece together a gaming system and not sure SLI is for me yet. Is it easy to overclock the Intel Q6600 quad core on a Gigabyte GA P35 DS3L board?

The 9800GTX is just an OC'd 8800GTS G92. Both NVIDIA and ATI have newer, better cards coming out soon.

Yes, its easy to OC a Q6600 on a DS3L.

SLI is only needed for high resolution 3D rendering. So, if you have or plan on getting a 1920x1080 LCD or higher, and want to game on it at native resolution, then keep SLI as an option. Otherwise, theres no need for it. There should be a single card solution that can still handle a 1920x1080 (or 1920x1200) LCD screen, and it should be more cost effective than an SLI setup. SLI as an upgrade path isn't worth it unless, again, a large LCD is in the future plans. There should always be a better single card solution, and you could sell your old card to help offset the cost.
 
enginurd has you covered.

I only talk down on the DS3L because it has rather weak cooling and 4 SATA ports. I feel it was a great deal for $60 AR back when the "craze" over it started, but now that it's up to $90 no rebate and other nicer, much more fully-featured boards can be had for ~$120-150, unless you have a fairly tight budget I don't recommend it. The Gigabyte EP35-DS3R is nicer, as is the DFI P35-TR2S, the MSI P35 Neo2-FR, and the Abit IP35-Pro.
 
Thanks Enginurd & Silent-circuit for your helpful info. Since I won't build my gaming system until Nvidia releases their new gfx card, I'll wait to see what ATI brings out as well. Also, a 22" or 20" LCD monitor will probably be the biggest resolution I'll be gaming on (1600 x 1000) and not a 24" (1900 x 12000) a single solution should do me fine. Right now I have a Dell 24" for my PowerMac and an old 17" Nec LCD for my PC which will have to go.

I guess the hardest part will be for me to decide which non-SLI motherboard will DDR2 support will offer then best features overall. If I can get a Q6600 or Q9300 quads to overclock past 3GHz with air cooling, it should be fine for me for 3 years or so. Yes, I do a lot of video encoding an my P4 2.8Ghz is really showing its age now.
 
Thanks for all of the input guys. Here are a couple things I'd like to ask questions on, just to narrow it down a bit further.

After reading a particular guide, which compared the best processor and video card combination, it appears that we are definitely sticking with the 8800GTS 512 G92 video card, and the Intel Core2Quad Q6600, which will be overclocked. My friend, would really prefer to get a motherboard that is SLI capable. He wants that added security that he could always upgrade to an SLI setup if he needs to.

1) Are any of the aforementioned motherboards SLI Capable?

2) Someone mentioned before that if you buy an SLI mobo, and don't go SLI from the get go... there will be problems. Is that true?

3) We will be overclocking the processor. Not by too much, the guide we read had 3.2GHz on Air Cooling stable, so I know it's possible. Are any motherboards factored into that change the decision?

4) Memory. I have seen the posting from Enginurd before about why you should only go with the memory for the FSB... so for a Q6600, DDR2 800 Memory should be the max. Does this still remain true, or is there any time when I should get higher frequency memory?

5) Some motherboards are DDR3 and DDR2 capable. Which set should we purchased?

I believe that is it for now... thanks!
 
1) I'm too lazy to see what was aforementioned, but if he wants SLI, go for the 750i SLI FTW, since he wants to OC a quadcore.

2) Not problems, but just wasted money. SLI isn't a good upgrade path unless a huge LCD is in the plans (24" or larger; namely 1920x1080 or larger). If you don't need SLI in the beginning, you probably won't need it later down the road unless you get a new, larger monitor. If you stick with the same monitor, vidcards just get better and better, so a single card solution would not only be a less complex config, but it will also be more cost effective (and you can sell your old card to help offset the cost of the new card).

3) Nope, most boards that get recommended here are capable of such an OC (8x400).

4) Not really "go with the memory for the FSB," but rather, choose your RAM depending on your OC goals. DDR2-800 is all you need because the Q6600 most likely cant reach higher than 3.6Ghz (9x400). Besides, you don't even plan on going that high, but its good to know your RAM isn't holding you back, even at 3.2Ghz (8x400).

5) DDR2. There are no performance benefits with DDR3 over DDR2 right now. Maybe later, when Nehalem is out, with its integrated memory controller.
 
Awesome yet again... I'm loving researching this stuff!!!

I have officially convinced him not to go with SLI, thanks to your wonderful argument about it Nurd, so thank you. Now I have to DECIDE on the motherboard, and of course it's amongst the following:

Gigabyte EP-35 DS3L (Or R, but I don't think he needs RAID)
DFI P35-TR2S (Is it me or does the cooling look like it sucks on this one???)
MSI P35 Neo2-FR
Abit IP35-Pro

Back to comparing!

I'm going to do my best to understand the memory, but the final word has been delivered that it will be the DDR2-800... and I understand not to waste the money on the 1066 money since it'll never be utilized by the Q6600... now I just need to look at other processors to understand it all lol. :p
 
I'm on the same boat as you.

I think that i will end up buyin a DFI DK X38 and a Xeon E3110 (E8400 equivalant) , and 4 gigs of ram..
 
I think I have but one more question... I recommended the Gigabyte EP-35 DS3R, the MSI P35 Neo2-FR, and the DFI P35-TR2S, I think with a higher recommendation for the DFI... but I'm still really unable to make up my mind. I do have one question though: For the DFI, it says that the maximum supported memory is DDR2-800... which is fine because that's the memory that he's getting. But is it a bad thing when a motherboard can only handle memory on the lower end?
 
No board can officially support anything higher than DDR2-800 because there's not JDEC spec for anything higher than DDR2-800 -- at least there wasn't when the P35s came out, that may have changed. It will handle at /least/ DDR2-1066, and likely higher, no problem. So should any other P35 based board.
 
So what CPU coolers does everyone here recommend? Especially since I want to over-clock a quad core.

TIA
 
Xigmatech Rifle 120mm (S1283 I think?) - $37
Zeroterm Nirvana NV120 - $50 ($10 MIR, $40 AR)

The Xigmatech is probably a little bit better HSF, but its mounting system is bad (push-pins) so I strongly recommend you get the Thermalright Bolt-Thru kit and use that with it instead ($6 + S/H at Jab-Tech). That makes it more expensive than the Nirvana, which is a very good HSF in its own right, and comes with a bolt-thru style mounting system for LGA775 out of the box.

There are some others, but those are my two "personal favorites" at the moment. They both keep very close to the Thermalright Ultra 120 Extreme, but come with fans and are a good bit less expensive ~$75 for a TRUE including a fan vs. ~$45 for either of those, give or take $5.
 
Of the three you recommended to him, the MSI Neo2-FR has the best chipset/mosfet cooling.
 
I've never once has a blue screen, fail to boot, or compatibility issue with my DFI. It's like the Qantas airline from Rain Man. It's never crashed. :D

-Robert
 
Hey guys,

I just wanted to throw this out there. My friend is ordering his computer components. Was I wrong in suggesting the Zalmon 9700?
 
Shoot. Unfortunately I completely forgot about reading the review on all of the air coolers on another forum, and already knew that the Xigmatech S-283 was the best for it's cost. Unfortunately my friend already ordered the parts, and he can't cancel the HSF from newegg as it's already being packed for shipping. I just hope that while the 9700 is a bit more expensive, it will be suitable for what he will be doing.
 
Should be suitable. He can return it and buy the Xigmatek to get the restocking fee waived, if he wants to save some money, get better performance, and go through all that trouble.
 
Should be suitable. He can return it and buy the Xigmatek to get the restocking fee waived, if he wants to save some money, get better performance, and go through all that trouble.

They'll probably make him pay shipping both ways, so by the time you take that out, not much point.
 
I'd like of like to piggyback onto this thread as I too have a Q6600 (currently running in a SFFmobo) at 3.0. I'd like to take it higher on a ATX form factor. I plan to keep my Q6600 and 4GB (2x 2GB GSkill), but I'm looking for top of the line motherboard to hold me over until Nehelem, since I need the room anyway.

I hear that Asus makes some top of the line motherboards these days (Rampage, was it? Striker?).

Any suggestions for the high end? Thanks
 
You're threadjacking. Please make a new thread. When you do at least answer these questions:
- What features do you need in a motherboard? RAID? Firewire? Etc.
- What's your budget for the motherboard?
 
Back
Top