Comcast Blocks BitTorrent Traffic 24/7?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
What’s this? Comcast actually blocks BitTorrent traffic most of the time, regardless what they said to the FCC earlier this year? I can’t believe the FCC would allow huge corporations to lie like that. Wait…did I say “can’t” believe?

This is far from the truth. As can be seen for the graph below, there is little difference in the percentage of blocked customers throughout day. Furthermore, the data shows that there is also no difference between weekends and weekdays. BitTorrent is simply blocked all day long, no matter how busy their network is.
 
When your the number 1 ISP in North America you get a big head and think you can do what ever the hell you wana do. Thank God Road Runner hasn't gone down that road.... Yet....
 
Doncha know? File sharing = terrorism!

They're blocking the torrents here so they don't have block them over there...or something.
 
Well.. I am a ComCrap user in NY, and I play WoW. I've had no problems downloading patches via BitTorrent. I'm sure many more people would be screaming for heads to be lopped off if ALL BitTorrent traffic was squelched.
 
I am Comcast user. Bittorrent does work, very very slowly. Years to get anything.

DM
 
I work for an ISP that deals mostly with business-class service rather than the residential stuff. Just throwing that out there so you know where I'm coming from.

I think the companies who are charging folks for massive usage have the right idea. The typical consumer here in the US pays what, anywhere between $20 to $100 for internet access with speeds that can range anywhere between 512k to 10Mb down depending on service availability. Let's say you have cable capable of delivering 10 Mb of downstream and you slam that baby full throttle...

10 Mb/s * 128 kB/Mb * 3600 s/h = about 4.6 GB / hour. That's right, you can down a single layer DVD in about an hour... and down here that'll cost ya anywhere between $30 and $60 per month depending.

Now, that's just a straight leech. If you're receiving something P2P your upstream is going to be taxed as well (and in my experience my downstream is NEVER fully utilized moving P2P traffic over a 5Mx640k line, but that's besides the point... let's pretend we're slammed both ways), so let's say you have 256k up to be conservative. I'm not entirely sure what cable operators are giving away nowadays. The point is the service is asymmetric in nature, so you're not REALLY doing as much damage to the upstream on the trunks and any edge connections in the provider network. That's a good thing, too, because most providers count on that usage trend so that they can use that upstream for dedicated hosting solutions and other happy stuff that needs upstream rather than downstream.

Now, here's where P2P (and increased bandwidth consumption in general) become a real pain in the ass (ignoring all the politics, lawsuits, and what not)...

Scenario A:
Everyone and his little sister hops on some kind of P2P distribution network. Let's face it, P2P is very popular with the kids nowadays. Why you would ever use something like that for copyrighted material is beyond me, but hey whatever. All of those 256k's start to add up. Let's say you have 50 people out of a 100-customer area chugging away... yep. You're right there at 10 Mb/s of upstream usage. You're also looking at about 500 Mb/sec of downstream consumption assuming the trunk is big enough to transmit that much... (It may not be!) Now, I have no idea what a cable operator's oversubscription statistics look like (they tend to keep quiet about that kinda thing), but you can bet it's oversubscribed because that's where you make the shiny coins. Depending on the network, you may be facing a situation where you have to either buy more dedicated bandwidth at the network edge because your P2P-loving-hippie-customers are eating up all your hosting bandwidth, or you may also be faced with over-used trunks that need to be upgraded. Either way, it costs money.

Scenario B:
Forget P2P in general. Let's say everyone hops on their 10Mb lines and goes nuts with the downloading. Again, I don't know the actual build because I don't work for a cable company, but let's say a neighborhood of 100 homes is served by a 100 Mb trunk. It will only take 10 customers to fill up that trunk. Now, the ISP might be able to live with that if it were only a bit here and a bit there, but some people just go nuckin futz downloading whatever it is they get. Music, warez, gay porn, whatever. Just don't tell me about it. So now you're looking at 10 customers EASILY creating a situation where you need more trunks. $30-$60/mo? screw that! I'm charging that son of a beeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeep

And now for the reality check. Dedicated bandwidth and trunk capacity cost a lot of money. It's not uncommon to see anywhere from what, $80-$150 per Mbit of dedicated bandwidth nowadays? It really depends on who you're buying from and where your POP is located. So, let's multiply that by 10 for the people who want to download all damn day and night and you get... oh yeah, you don't REALLY want to pay for as much as you consume, do you?

Anyhow, I really doubt Comcast has a beef with you getting your kiddie gay porn over bit torrent. I really doubt it. The problem is you're starting to cost more money than you pay, and they can either start billing you for what you really use or chop off the most common traffic that introduces the problem in the first place. Personally, I think they should bill you into sumbission. After all, business is business.

Speaking of business, when we see P2P going nuts on someone's service we give the boss a call real quick. Should this be going on? Do you know that Billy Bob your computer guy is using your Internet access to download Dirk Diggler vs. The Bearded Clamatron 7? 9 times out of 10 the first question out of the boss's mouth is "Can you block it?"

Sure. Oh, your Internet isn't crawling anymore? Glad I could help.
 
Hmm... I have Comcast and I've seen no evidence that my torrents are being blocked. I have uTorrent set to select a new random port when it starts and to use encryption. I also limit upload speeds to 6 KB/s (I know, it's mean).
 
Oh, forgot to mention, I can pull in around 600 KB/s if I have several torrents running, which is about the limit of my connection, so it doesn't seem like there's much if any throttling going on either.
 
STFU about the newgroups, you want all the WoWers and script kiddes to screw that up too ?
 
SHhhhhhhh !!! about the newgroups, you want all the WoWers and script kiddes to screw that up too ?

I have no problem paying for what I use, it seems the fee structure is the root issue. We are charged based (mainly) on speed of connection. Like everything else we should probably pay based on speed and volume.

You can buy a car that will go 100mph for 2 hours for $20,000, try running it 100mph for 2 days continous. To get that capability the price goes way up.

Oh and try an engineer a network that would allow 100% utilization by everyone on it all the time, you can do it easily, but no one would pay the price required to recoup the cost.

/obscure on-topic reference
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JEQeRLT1HNQ
 
I work for an ISP that deals mostly with business-class service rather than the residential stuff. Just throwing that out there so you know where I'm coming from.

I think the companies who are charging folks for massive usage have the right idea. The typical consumer here in the US pays what, anywhere between $20 to $100 for internet access with speeds that can range anywhere between 512k to 10Mb down depending on service availability. Let's say you have cable capable of delivering 10 Mb of downstream and you slam that baby full throttle...

10 Mb/s * 128 kB/Mb * 3600 s/h = about 4.6 GB / hour. That's right, you can down a single layer DVD in about an hour... and down here that'll cost ya anywhere between $30 and $60 per month depending.

Now, that's just a straight leech. If you're receiving something P2P your upstream is going to be taxed as well (and in my experience my downstream is NEVER fully utilized moving P2P traffic over a 5Mx640k line, but that's besides the point... let's pretend we're slammed both ways), so let's say you have 256k up to be conservative. I'm not entirely sure what cable operators are giving away nowadays. The point is the service is asymmetric in nature, so you're not REALLY doing as much damage to the upstream on the trunks and any edge connections in the provider network. That's a good thing, too, because most providers count on that usage trend so that they can use that upstream for dedicated hosting solutions and other happy stuff that needs upstream rather than downstream.

Now, here's where P2P (and increased bandwidth consumption in general) become a real pain in the ass (ignoring all the politics, lawsuits, and what not)...

Scenario A:
Everyone and his little sister hops on some kind of P2P distribution network. Let's face it, P2P is very popular with the kids nowadays. Why you would ever use something like that for copyrighted material is beyond me, but hey whatever. All of those 256k's start to add up. Let's say you have 50 people out of a 100-customer area chugging away... yep. You're right there at 10 Mb/s of upstream usage. You're also looking at about 500 Mb/sec of downstream consumption assuming the trunk is big enough to transmit that much... (It may not be!) Now, I have no idea what a cable operator's oversubscription statistics look like (they tend to keep quiet about that kinda thing), but you can bet it's oversubscribed because that's where you make the shiny coins. Depending on the network, you may be facing a situation where you have to either buy more dedicated bandwidth at the network edge because your P2P-loving-hippie-customers are eating up all your hosting bandwidth, or you may also be faced with over-used trunks that need to be upgraded. Either way, it costs money.

Scenario B:
Forget P2P in general. Let's say everyone hops on their 10Mb lines and goes nuts with the downloading. Again, I don't know the actual build because I don't work for a cable company, but let's say a neighborhood of 100 homes is served by a 100 Mb trunk. It will only take 10 customers to fill up that trunk. Now, the ISP might be able to live with that if it were only a bit here and a bit there, but some people just go nuckin futz downloading whatever it is they get. Music, warez, gay porn, whatever. Just don't tell me about it. So now you're looking at 10 customers EASILY creating a situation where you need more trunks. $30-$60/mo? screw that! I'm charging that son of a beeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeep

And now for the reality check. Dedicated bandwidth and trunk capacity cost a lot of money. It's not uncommon to see anywhere from what, $80-$150 per Mbit of dedicated bandwidth nowadays? It really depends on who you're buying from and where your POP is located. So, let's multiply that by 10 for the people who want to download all damn day and night and you get... oh yeah, you don't REALLY want to pay for as much as you consume, do you?

Anyhow, I really doubt Comcast has a beef with you getting your kiddie gay porn over bit torrent. I really doubt it. The problem is you're starting to cost more money than you pay, and they can either start billing you for what you really use or chop off the most common traffic that introduces the problem in the first place. Personally, I think they should bill you into sumbission. After all, business is business.

Speaking of business, when we see P2P going nuts on someone's service we give the boss a call real quick. Should this be going on? Do you know that Billy Bob your computer guy is using your Internet access to download Dirk Diggler vs. The Bearded Clamatron 7? 9 times out of 10 the first question out of the boss's mouth is "Can you block it?"

Sure. Oh, your Internet isn't crawling anymore? Glad I could help.

Hmmm, so your saying that, although I am paying $60-$100 for some certain advertised bandwidth, I shouldn't be allowed to utilize it because it is costing the company more money than what I am paying? It shouldn't be any of comcast business what I download from the internet. What about the customers who use an insane amount of bandwidth but aren't using torrents. IMO the infrastructure in this nation needs a serious upgrade.
 
STFU about the newgroups, you want all the WoWers and script kiddes to screw that up too ?

They already have...

Sadly, it's been on a serious downhill plunge since about 2003-4.
Alot of the old-schoolers have long since bailed on most A.B. groups.

What with Dutchies (w-their 100MB pipes) shoving 170+ 50mb files upstream in A HALF HOUR, thus pushing off posts before anyone can even realize they've been posted. [Seriously!!!! 8 hour retention on a 100 DAY based retention paid NNTP provider in Boneless, due to sheer volume of the Dutch *alone*.]

And EFNET kiddies trying to do the same in the "normal" AB groups with no regard to group protocol/charter, rendering the same results (though on a much less severe scale).

There used to be a "common sense", and more importantly, common courtesy in alot of the AB groups. Fills, REQ's, etc. There was actual interaction and much more 'intelligent discourse' within the scene at large.

It's devolved into an online "post-King" or "it's important my nick is seen" pissing contest for some years now. And there's no way to reverse it.

Just like Comcast (et al), appreciate what you've got while you can get it, because there will come a day... :eek:

In an odd way, I'm actually kinda looking forward to it too. All that will remain is those who actually use NG's for their 'intended purpose' (IMO), and the level of discourse and decency will hopefully return.
 
Hmmm, so your saying that, although I am paying $60-$100 for some certain advertised bandwidth, I shouldn't be allowed to utilize it because it is costing the company more money than what I am paying? It shouldn't be any of comcast business what I download from the internet. What about the customers who use an insane amount of bandwidth but aren't using torrents. IMO the infrastructure in this nation needs a serious upgrade.

I agree. I think residential providers need to be more up-front with what you're actually paying for and what they consider over-usage. A lot of times it's left to ambiguous terminology in the 5-mile-long-service-agreement-from-hell, and while I don't find it hard to believe that companies here in the US would do things like that, I am surprised at how slow businesses in general are to react to the idea that we're using the Internet, we're using it more heavily, and the trend is going to continue.

I also think the entire system where a handful of large telecom providers pretty much own the backbone of the Internet is a big part of why a rediculously small amount of bandwidth costs so much. Unfortunately, there are some steep barriers to entry in that market, so I doubt we'll see any change unless someone with a big wad of cash decides enough is enough... or the government steps in... (anyone got cash?) At this rate, the entire planet will be AT&T all over again and we'll be paying through the nose anyways.
 
As much as I hate them, in their defense, I will say:

1) They haven't blocked any of my traffic, and have never said anything about my usage
2) Their speeds are amazing if you follow the rules:
comcrap.jpg
 
Agreed. Why is it are we second-class in terms of speed when compared to so many other countries??

Profit to greed ratio. :(

second-class DUDE we are like 50th class ROFLMAO. The US SUCKS DONKEY BALLS when it comes to internet access.

Oh and for some of the other posts before this one (I won't quote them.. too big and full of crap) If I pay for 10M download I BETTER FUCKING GET 10M download ALL THE TIME!! no matter what the hell I am downloading. The technology is out there but comcast and other ISP's are to fat on profits to put it in place. Look at Japan for example there average internet speed for there end users is like over 45M/s if they can do it the we sure the hell can. Instead of the CEO of comcast making 1B/year maybe he should use some of that money to fucking upgrade the networks so it can handle any type of traffic we want to put on it.

Sorry but it REALY pisses me off when someone basicly says we should get something less then what we pay for. That would be like going to Wendy's and paying for a burger but only getting a half of a burger because there are "too many people in the store right now getting burgers) FUCK THAT!!!
 
I work for an ISP that deals mostly with business-class service rather than the residential stuff. Just throwing that out there so you know where I'm coming from.

I think the companies who are charging folks for massive usage have the right idea. The typical consumer here in the US pays what, anywhere between $20 to $100 for internet access with speeds that can range anywhere between 512k to 10Mb down depending on service availability. Let's say you have cable capable of delivering 10 Mb of downstream and you slam that baby full throttle...

10 Mb/s * 128 kB/Mb * 3600 s/h = about 4.6 GB / hour. That's right, you can down a single layer DVD in about an hour... and down here that'll cost ya anywhere between $30 and $60 per month depending.

Now, that's just a straight leech. If you're receiving something P2P your upstream is going to be taxed as well (and in my experience my downstream is NEVER fully utilized moving P2P traffic over a 5Mx640k line, but that's besides the point... let's pretend we're slammed both ways), so let's say you have 256k up to be conservative. I'm not entirely sure what cable operators are giving away nowadays. The point is the service is asymmetric in nature, so you're not REALLY doing as much damage to the upstream on the trunks and any edge connections in the provider network. That's a good thing, too, because most providers count on that usage trend so that they can use that upstream for dedicated hosting solutions and other happy stuff that needs upstream rather than downstream.

Now, here's where P2P (and increased bandwidth consumption in general) become a real pain in the ass (ignoring all the politics, lawsuits, and what not)...

Scenario A:
Everyone and his little sister hops on some kind of P2P distribution network. Let's face it, P2P is very popular with the kids nowadays. Why you would ever use something like that for copyrighted material is beyond me, but hey whatever. All of those 256k's start to add up. Let's say you have 50 people out of a 100-customer area chugging away... yep. You're right there at 10 Mb/s of upstream usage. You're also looking at about 500 Mb/sec of downstream consumption assuming the trunk is big enough to transmit that much... (It may not be!) Now, I have no idea what a cable operator's oversubscription statistics look like (they tend to keep quiet about that kinda thing), but you can bet it's oversubscribed because that's where you make the shiny coins. Depending on the network, you may be facing a situation where you have to either buy more dedicated bandwidth at the network edge because your P2P-loving-hippie-customers are eating up all your hosting bandwidth, or you may also be faced with over-used trunks that need to be upgraded. Either way, it costs money.

Scenario B:
Forget P2P in general. Let's say everyone hops on their 10Mb lines and goes nuts with the downloading. Again, I don't know the actual build because I don't work for a cable company, but let's say a neighborhood of 100 homes is served by a 100 Mb trunk. It will only take 10 customers to fill up that trunk. Now, the ISP might be able to live with that if it were only a bit here and a bit there, but some people just go nuckin futz downloading whatever it is they get. Music, warez, gay porn, whatever. Just don't tell me about it. So now you're looking at 10 customers EASILY creating a situation where you need more trunks. $30-$60/mo? screw that! I'm charging that son of a beeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeep

And now for the reality check. Dedicated bandwidth and trunk capacity cost a lot of money. It's not uncommon to see anywhere from what, $80-$150 per Mbit of dedicated bandwidth nowadays? It really depends on who you're buying from and where your POP is located. So, let's multiply that by 10 for the people who want to download all damn day and night and you get... oh yeah, you don't REALLY want to pay for as much as you consume, do you?

Anyhow, I really doubt Comcast has a beef with you getting your kiddie gay porn over bit torrent. I really doubt it. The problem is you're starting to cost more money than you pay, and they can either start billing you for what you really use or chop off the most common traffic that introduces the problem in the first place. Personally, I think they should bill you into sumbission. After all, business is business.

Speaking of business, when we see P2P going nuts on someone's service we give the boss a call real quick. Should this be going on? Do you know that Billy Bob your computer guy is using your Internet access to download Dirk Diggler vs. The Bearded Clamatron 7? 9 times out of 10 the first question out of the boss's mouth is "Can you block it?"

Sure. Oh, your Internet isn't crawling anymore? Glad I could help.

Here's an idea, if you don't have the capability, you shouldn't try to sell the service, right?

Comcast needs to quit with their boastful commercials bragging they have the ability like no others, then in the same breath complain they don't have the means.

As with all businesses, if you wish to run a business, you must have the product, or you're just a sham.

It's like saying I'm a car salesmen.. but I don't have cars to sell you.. ever.

Does that make me a car salesmen?
 
This is retarded, ISP's bitching about people hogging all the bandwidth is like the Department of transportation bitching about rush hour traffic. You designed the infrastructure, you either need to make the bandwidth larger to account for usage or design a secondary set of pipes for data like Highways/Interstates did for long distance traffic.
 
There should be some standard when it comes to advertising and selling broadband by speed. For example: advertise by average sustained speed rather than peak theoretical speed. These advertised speeds will have to clearly state any restrictions (such as traffic shaping and/or management) that'll affect those speeds as well as stating the speeds you'll get at various distances (assuming the technology used has significant speed degradation with greater distance).

Basically advertise by speeds one can expect rather than how much the pipe can handle (theoretical or actual).
 
This is retarded, ISP's bitching about people hogging all the bandwidth is like the Department of transportation bitching about rush hour traffic. You designed the infrastructure, you either need to make the bandwidth larger to account for usage or design a secondary set of pipes for data like Highways/Interstates did for long distance traffic.

I like that thats good but you have to admit my Wendy's thing was pritty funny :p
 
second-class DUDE we are like 50th class ROFLMAO. The US SUCKS DONKEY BALLS when it comes to internet access.

Oh and for some of the other posts before this one (I won't quote them.. too big and full of crap) If I pay for 10M download I BETTER FUCKING GET 10M download ALL THE TIME!! no matter what the hell I am downloading. The technology is out there but comcast and other ISP's are to fat on profits to put it in place. Look at Japan for example there average internet speed for there end users is like over 45M/s if they can do it the we sure the hell can. Instead of the CEO of comcast making 1B/year maybe he should use some of that money to fucking upgrade the networks so it can handle any type of traffic we want to put on it.

Actually, only about 5 countries have significantly faster internet speeds than the U.S. Japan, South Korea, Finland, Sweden, and France. Then there are about 15 countries that are a few megabits per second slower or faster than the U.S. Finally, the other 175 or so countries of the world are significantly behind the U.S. So while we're not at the forefront, we're by no means doing terrible, not to mention we have more broadband users than any other country in the world.
 
Actually, only about 5 countries have significantly faster internet speeds than the U.S. Japan, South Korea, Finland, Sweden, and France. Then there are about 15 countries that are a few megabits per second slower or faster than the U.S. Finally, the other 175 or so countries of the world are significantly behind the U.S. So while we're not at the forefront, we're by no means doing terrible, not to mention we have more broadband users than any other country in the world.

Point taken ;) but the difference in those 4-5 in front of is us HUGE. I think I saw us at an average of 5Mbps where Japan is at like 45Mbps (I can't find the front page post with the averages anymore lol) We might as well be 50th with a diference that large.
 
Try to download as many flavors of linux you can while using the bit torrent protocol then claim Comcast is in league with microsoft to suppress linux. Many mass DL sites are now offering the use of the bit torrent protocol as an alternative to ftp and http.

It's not the protocol thats illegal, its merely another P2P technology that is capable of being used to traffic copyrighted content. The content is what should be blocked.

http, irc, ftp and usenet are all capable of being used to transfer copyrighted material, so why not block those too?
 
Actually, only about 5 countries have significantly faster internet speeds than the U.S. Japan, South Korea, Finland, Sweden, and France. Then there are about 15 countries that are a few megabits per second slower or faster than the U.S. Finally, the other 175 or so countries of the world are significantly behind the U.S. So while we're not at the forefront, we're by no means doing terrible, not to mention we have more broadband users than any other country in the world.

Broadband availability and price/MB need to be taken into consideration too; not just speed. Of course, there are a ton of factors to consider when determining if the US is really lagging behind (such as population density), so any meaningful debate will become rather complicated. And somewhat off-topic.
 
Point taken ;) but the difference in those 4-5 in front of is us HUGE. I think I saw us at an average of 5Mbps where Japan is at like 45Mbps (I can't find the front page post with the averages anymore lol) We might as well be 50th with a diference that large.

They're huge because they don't have much land to cover when laying down the wire.

If the United States was the size of Montana, I'm sure we would remain on top (though it'd be fucking crowded lol).
 
I have comcast (unfortunately) - only alternatives are Verizon dsl (what a joke that was when I tried it) or dial up. I'd actually take dial up over the dsl offered, it's that slow and unreliable.

Used to have RR, then Comcast came in and took over their territory, pushing RR further west. I liked RR better - quality of service, kept their up/down speeds really constant and were great to me when I called with a problem. Can't say that for Comcast, and I'm paying more.

I live near a major university, hence we have a large number of students in the area. I don't know if Comcast has completely blocked torrents, but I can tell you that our service is throttled starting Friday through Monday. It's noticeably slower. I d/l stuff like ccleaner, spybot, avg and updates mostly. The occasional free and legal mp3 from download.com ... Right now on a 2.9MB song d/l, I'm at 145KB/sec d/l speed - and it's daytime, most people aren't even home. The college itself has it's own internet, not Comcast. Which is it's own nightmare - the college reporting who's d/l from where and students getting hit with RIAA c&d emails. One guy was d/l Linux and got one.

Am I for piracy? No. Honestly, I'm not. But I'm also not for this enforced you will do as we say or you'll either pay a boatload of money, we'll cut off your ability to use certain sites (If I wanted that, I'd move to, say, China) or we'll cut you off from your internet.

I call BS on this whole monopoly thing that the government has been more than happy to help set in place.
 
Here's an idea, if you don't have the capability, you shouldn't try to sell the service, right?

Comcast needs to quit with their boastful commercials bragging they have the ability like no others, then in the same breath complain they don't have the means.

As with all businesses, if you wish to run a business, you must have the product, or you're just a sham.

It's like saying I'm a car salesmen.. but I don't have cars to sell you.. ever.

Does that make me a car salesmen?

That's the thing... Most companies are careful to use two happy little words in their advertising "up to". You can have a look at your service terms as well... It's best-effort. You can find out what that means by searching around on the intarwebz; we don't really need to get into it here. The fact of the matter is those two tiny words seem to be enough to absolve them of any legal obligation to let you scream along at full speed 24/7. I don't particularly agree with it - in fact, I believe that the advertisements should be more specific in what the customer should expect and what happens when usage goes beyond a certain point. I think the current situation is a combination of unrealistic consumer expectations, poor communication by the businesses that advertise their services, and an economy where large businesses act like they own every aspect of our lives.

This is retarded, ISP's bitching about people hogging all the bandwidth is like the Department of transportation bitching about rush hour traffic. You designed the infrastructure, you either need to make the bandwidth larger to account for usage or design a secondary set of pipes for data like Highways/Interstates did for long distance traffic.

I love your road analogy. You ever see I-95 (I think, I was only visiting) when people are driving to work in DC in the morning? Rush hour is a bitch up there. The fact of the matter is the capacity is fine most of the time except for some really tough times of the day. Yeah they try to make it better, but in the case of ISPs they probably still havent broken even on the last infrastructure upgrade when folks are already outstripping its capacity. It's a losing battle as far as money is concerned unless they start charging folks more for the service. You want more roads? Sure, but we need to charge you more taxes. Wait, we can't charge taxes? The whole argument leads to nowhere. Larger ISPs have been playing the low price game to the point where it's now biting them in the ass. If anything, people should be happy that the ISPs are in a situation where they have to rethink their strategies. Blocking traffic isn't going to fly, and the business model as a whole is going to have to change... That, or you can be as big as AT&T and not give a rat's ass. Wait for everyone else to lose enough money and gobble them up. MMmmmm Toasty.

Back to the road thing.. I live in a small town where they're 6-laning the main highway through the area. It has taken FOR FRICKEN EVER. On top of that, the area is projected to have a population growth. Yeah, the little street men will be busy playing catch-up for the rest of their lives. Same with the little network people, who ultimately answer to some guy in a suit with his underwear on way too tight.

I'm a boxer guy myself, but I guess wearing tight undies would beat snagging a nut hair in the ol' zipper.
 
a few points:

1) i'm using Comcast right now and all my torrents work just fine, especially those from major distributors (like Blizzard and Revision3)

2) i live in a relatively small city in North Florida (Tallahassee), some few miles from the Georgia border, and around here i can peak at 12megabits sometimes during the night and average around 7-10Mb/s on a normal day

3) i am rarely, and i mean very rarely, without service

in my case those are the facts and i'm more than happy with Comcast's internet service, but as for my cable service... that is another story (and the reason i too dislike Comcast's monopoly over these indusries)
 
I am forced to pay $90 for comcast's shitty internet, my only alternative being satellite providers and I like having a playable ping. I have never seen a download get beyond 300Kb/s and this is with my paid-for fileplanet account. I tried downloading Ubuntu via a torrent program (I'm not good at them because I don't use them) and the download NEVER passed 2Kb/s. It was usually below 1Kb/s. Even with 300+ sources. Meanwhile at the exact same time I can go to fileplanet and download the COD4 demo in a few minutes.

Comcast was granted a legal monopoly in my area and now they are abusing their monopoly powers to restrict my internet use. Please one of you "smart" people come explain how this is legal?

I would LOVE IT if RR would come in and lay cable to compete with Comcast. I would sign up with them in advance, if they would come in here. Of course our idiotic state government would never allow competition.
 
im not gonna quote any long posts but i would like to reply to the points made.

the nations largest isp doesnt own its own backbone? really? they lease from other companies? i find that hard to believe. all this really boils down to is greed. instead of upgrading their infrastructure to meet the needs of the customers they would rather just limit what customers can do. i dont agree with charging per MB downloaded. they have their own networks, they dont have to lease lines from anyone else thus all the problem of running out of bandwidth is because they dont want to part with some $$$ and upgrade.
 
I have noticed any speed throttling on my network, but I'm sure I will soon enough.
Pretty soon they'll be throttling the connections even more so they can support even more users in an area.
 
Back
Top