Specifics on how future intel CPU's will be locked from overclocking

defiant007

2[H]4U
Joined
Feb 27, 2006
Messages
3,497
As we told you some time ago, Intel has put in what can only be called an overclocking lock in the upcoming LGA1160 processors which are currently going under the codenames of Lynnfield and Havendale.

Until now we didn't know how this had been implemented, but we've learned some more about it and it looks like there is no easy work around. As these processors have the memory controller and a few more bits integrated into the CPU itself, Intel suddenly has a lot more control than it has had with past designs that utilized a separate chipset which contains the memory controller.

As Intel seems to want to push the much more expensive Bloomfield platform to overclockers, the company implemented a lock that prevents these new processors from being overclocked by adding two PLL clock generators, one inside the CPU itself and one in the PCH.

This might not sound like it's a big problem in itself, but what Intel has done is that these two will clock generators will reference eachother and this means that just changing the bus speed won't have any effect if you're trying to overclock the CPU as it will dissregard the information from the PCH if it's not a correct value.

There might still be options for overclocking these CPU's, but our understanding is that this isn't easily done and Intel doesn't want it to be and as such Intel is unlikely to give out this information to third party motherboard manufacturers.

The sum of all this is that Intel might loose out a few enthusiast users that don't have deep enough pockets to get a Bloomfield system to AMD, which might not be a bad thing for AMD in the end.

http://www.fudzilla.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=7255&Itemid=1

If true I can see the enthusiasts being driven back to AMD's open arms in their droves.
 
lemme see the numbers first. If performance is beautiful, I'd still stay with Intel. I don't think they should try to reinvent the wheel as their system works for both enthusiast and the general public alike. IOW, don't fix what aint broke. We'll have to wait and see though.
 
This is bad. Very bad. If AMD continues to fail at putting out a decent competitor to Intel's CPUs, Intel might be able to kill off overclocking altogether within a few CPU generations, which would be very bad for enthusiasts. If this info really is true, we better hope that AMD will start making some overclockable CPUs that are competitive with Nehalem.
 
I can actually agree with this move since I personally just bought an Extreme Edition CPU and feel like if I paid $1000 for a CPU I should see something for that kind of money that a guy who paid $300 can't. I guess the other way to look at it is to lower the price of the Extreme Edition's, and I'd think that be way better. But its a business decision, and the overclocking crowd is a subset of even the enthusiast market, and in the end the true enthusiast will usually pay the money to have top of the line gear.

And really, how many of us really see much of difference with 50% higher clocks than stock. Benches look great and it might as a couple of FPS to a game, but its not a deal breaker for most.
 
I would go with AMD simply because I enjoy overclocking. I know that people like me are pretty niche, but there's no way I could buy something and keep it stock.

Just think about all the ripples this would send through the PC cooling market. A bunch of companies would take a giant hit. Who would buy a new heatsink when you can't overclock?

And motherboard manufacturers like DFI. Would anyone buy a DFI board? They'd see their sales dropping like a rock.

Watercooling would disappear. It'd be horrible.

And spending big money on the high end intel platform is ridiculous. There's no way I'd ever go for something like that. A large chunk of the enthusiast platform revolves around high school and college people who can't afford the top end stuff.
 
The total authority/background for the article and its predecessor is "I have learned", hardly convincing. And even if true all it says is that the high end chipset is needed for OCing. More likely a result of the sensitivity of the on-board memory controller and the need to ensure stability on lesser platforms in the hands of technically unsophisticated users. But whatever. The market place will quickly respond, lets see, Intel until very recently had NO support at all for overclocking and even today it instantly voids the cpu warranty, but I remember a couple of Celeron 300a running at 550MHz 10 years or so ago. And where does it say that the chipset will not be sold all over with manufacturers doing exactly what they do now, offering a wide range of boards with a chipset with widely differing features and price ranges. OK, so maybe you will not be able to take the low cost office drone chipset and OC a CPU on it. While I do like doing that sort of thing for fun, another additional $100 for a higher quality board does not take the hobby out of anyones reach. Mow a few more lawns. Article might have some grain of truth in it but its mostly FUD crap.

Or Intel will not sell the chipset to 3rd parties keeping the high performance end all to itself coupled with Larabee and in one fell swoop kill ASUS, Gigabyte, Nvidia (consider a driver check done by Intel like Nvidia does for SLI so that only Intel video cards will run on a Intel platform) etc. etc. Or even further not sell/license any of the new technology to third parties making the new corp. tag line "ALL Intel Inside or Nothing. " /sarcasm off.
 
It's fudzilla, and the author references himself as "proof." The site is pretty worthless.

Relatively few % of people overclock. It's not a big deal overall and Intel knows that. As long as there are external factors a BIOS has to initialize, there is always room to overclock.
 
I can believe it, especially with the piss-poor overclock displayed by the Q9450 compared to the Q6600. Mostly cost/performance, but it's definitely there, and we're already experiencing it before this article is proven to be true or not.

I'm sure they'll try it, and if they make more money doing it, then they'll continue doing it, whatever "it" may be, and that my friends cannot be disputed.
 
If this is true, i hope intel realizes that they are essentially shooting themselves in the foot....
 
First to the person who said you should get something special for an extreme edition... you do. Surely you know that? Otherwise why did you buy it? It is much easier to overclock an extreme edition and your chances for success depend on fewer variables than us slobs with upwards locked multipliers and the price of high multipliers on quads climbing steeply.

To the OP - we haven't seen what the relative pricing and performance of Bloomfield is either, nor have we seen for sure that overclocking is not possible on non-Bloomfield platforms. I remember similar doom and gloom when intel first locked multipliers, and that didn't last long.
 
lemme see the numbers first. If performance is beautiful, I'd still stay with Intel. I don't think they should try to reinvent the wheel as their system works for both enthusiast and the general public alike. IOW, don't fix what aint broke. We'll have to wait and see though.

Actually it is broke and Intel is now fixing it. If you think buying a $80 cpu and oc'ing it to performance level of a $500 is working as intended then you're sadly mistaken.
 
I can actually agree with this move since I personally just bought an Extreme Edition CPU and feel like if I paid $1000 for a CPU I should see something for that kind of money that a guy who paid $300 can't. I guess the other way to look at it is to lower the price of the Extreme Edition's, and I'd think that be way better. But its a business decision, and the overclocking crowd is a subset of even the enthusiast market, and in the end the true enthusiast will usually pay the money to have top of the line gear.

And really, how many of us really see much of difference with 50% higher clocks than stock. Benches look great and it might as a couple of FPS to a game, but its not a deal breaker for most.

So enthusiasts should get the shaft because they're smart enough to not spend $1000 on a CPU and to make you feel better about your purchase? Get over yourself. :rolleyes:

Personally I don't see this happening unless AMD goes bankrupt or something and we simply don't have a choice. While I'm sure Intel COULD implement such measures, I don't think they will.
 
So enthusiasts should get the shaft because they're smart enough to not spend $1000 on a CPU and to make you feel better about your purchase? Get over yourself. :rolleyes:

I was just waiting for someone to make this type of comment!:p

I'm very well aware of the state of overclocking for Core CPU's. The QX9650 is my second, I already have a Q6600 based system. I've known for a long time that you can take a Q6600 and run it up to 3.6 or higher. I made the choice to get a QX9650 based system because I wanted to do only multiplier overclocking with the sig rig.

Secondly, I am not saying people should get screwed, I am saying that if I or anyone else for that matter is willing to pay top dollar for a product, they should get something tangible for that money. How's that different from anything else in life? Should someone expect the same kind of car for $20,000 that others can pay $100,000? When were any of us entitled to anything? It the nature of the capitalistic world we live in.

I would prefer that Intel add more value to their high end products rather restricting existing capabilities in lower end ones, but I do not think its fair for the person that buys the lower end product to expect to easily reproduce those capabilities in the more expensive product.

Fairness goes both ways.:)
 
Intel = Creative Labs?

Seems to be a similar debacle if this holds true. I'd be surprised if Intel pulled this, but like someone mentioned, look at the multipliers on the Q9***'s. If this happens, I'll change back to AMD, even if they aren't as good atm.
 
I was just waiting for someone to make this type of comment!:p

I'm very well aware of the state of overclocking for Core CPU's. The QX9650 is my second, I already have a Q6600 based system. I've known for a long time that you can take a Q6600 and run it up to 3.6 or higher. I made the choice to get a QX9650 based system because I wanted to do only multiplier overclocking with the sig rig.

Secondly, I am not saying people should get screwed, I am saying that if I or anyone else for that matter is willing to pay top dollar for a product, they should get something tangible for that money. How's that different from anything else in life? Should someone expect the same kind of car for $20,000 that others can pay $100,000? When were any of us entitled to anything? It the nature of the capitalistic world we live in.

I would prefer that Intel add more value to their high end products rather restricting existing capabilities in lower end ones, but I do not think its fair for the person that buys the lower end product to expect to easily reproduce those capabilities in the more expensive product.

Fairness goes both ways.:)

It is going both ways. Just like people spending 30k on a Mustang Cobra, investing another 10k in mods and being able to smoke 100k cars. By your rational, Ford should do something to make their cars unmoddable. Your tangible benefit is no multi lock and binned processor. You said yourself you were kind of glad hearing of this story because you spent $1000 on a CPU. Why exactly? Overclocking lower end processors does not change your processor at all. Locking out lower end CPU's out also does not change your processor at all. Seeing that your 1k CPU stays exactly the way it is regardless of a OC lock or not, I can't think of any reason why you would be "glad" other than wanting to screw other people over to make yourself feel better for spending 1k.

What is boils down to is this... You said yourself you bought it because you wanted to do multiplier overclocking, and that is what you got. Why go another step and make other CPU's un-overclockable? In what way does that serve you? Will your CPU get a higher oc? No. So, in essence, locking out other CPU's gives you absolutely ZERO tangible benefits because yours stays EXACTLY the same.
 
I never said I was glad about this possibility, I said I agreed with it, but I also said that it would be better to lower the price of Extreme Edition CPU's if all they offered was an unlocked multiplier.

If you don't think it’s fair to lock out lower end CPU's, then I think that from the other side that it’s not fair for a person who pays $200 to get almost the same benefit as a person that pays $1000. There needs to be more differentiation. In that spirit, I said it would be better to offer more value to the higher end in new features that were not easily reproducible on the lower end. I see nothing wrong with that.

However, this is very common in the business world, diminishing returns for the consumer as the price goes up.

But when it comes down to this particular subject of CPU overclocking, it’s less than a pebble in the quarry. Only a fraction of a tiny fraction overclock CPU’s, and even less than that get any benefit from it. So I don’t see it a huge deal.

However, I do think that a lot of enthusiasts feel like they are entitled to something they are not. Overclocking is not really an officially supported practice in most cases and when Intel sells a CPU at a certain speed, that’s all you technically get. If you get more, then great, but to think that we entitled to it for free isn’t really the deal.
 
Secondly, I am not saying people should get screwed, I am saying that if I or anyone else for that matter is willing to pay top dollar for a product, they should get something tangible for that money. How's that different from anything else in life? Should someone expect the same kind of car for $20,000 that others can pay $100,000? When were any of us entitled to anything? It the nature of the capitalistic world we live in.

I don't think some people even know what capitalism is. Let me sum it up for you: A system in which all individuals have the right to maintain private property, and use that property to generate a profit.

Now, a profit doesn't necessarily mean you get money from someone. It means that your wealth increases. Say you take a 300 dollar processor, invest in 100 dollars worth of cooling, and end up with the same performance as your stock 1000 processor. 400 dollars worth of investment nets someone 1000 dollar performance. That's capitalism. Overclocking is capitalism in action. You're talking about taking away people's ability to make a profit. That's more accurately referred to as restraint of trade, and is the absolute opposite of a free market.

So think about that before you claim the moral high ground by trying to justify your socialist outlook that further separates the classes.
 
If you don't think it’s fair to lock out lower end CPU's, then I think that from the other side that it’s not fair for a person who pays $200 to get almost the same benefit as a person that pays $1000.

It isn't just the 200 dollar investment. It's additional investment in cooling, investment of time in learning how to overclock, investment in the actual fine-tuning and securing the overclock, and the risks involved with overclocking. Essentially, your work and effort and time adds to the cost. You can go out into the woods, chop down a tree, and chop out firewood for your time and effort. Or, you can skip that and purchase it from someone who already did that work. There's nothing unfair about that. That's free market. You make your choice on whether you want to spend time and effort, or money.
 
It isn't just the 200 dollar investment. It's additional investment in cooling, investment of time in learning how to overclock, investment in the actual fine-tuning and securing the overclock, and the risks involved with overclocking. Essentially, your work and effort and time adds to the cost. You can go out into the woods, chop down a tree, and chop out firewood for your time and effort. Or, you can skip that and purchase it from someone who already did that work. There's nothing unfair about that. That's free market. You make your choice on whether you want to spend time and effort, or money.

I could agree with that but overclocking the current line of Penryn's is ridiculously easy. All you have to do is a few web searches, do a little reading, leave a few notes on a board and it should take all of about 3 hours of time to get setup. It takes a lot longer to test and that's just letting the machine run for some number of hours to know that it works.

The thing is who buys Extreme Edition CPU's? Super duper enthusiasts who understand whats going on, overclock like mad, have phase cooling, spend the time and the cash. These are the best of the best customers and they should get some differentiation for there cash investment. That is my only point in this debate and I don't see what's wrong with that.

I'll say it again, I would rather that differentiation come in the form of NEW features that are not easily reproducible rather than restricting a traditional freebie in the form of FSB overclocking.
 
Like I said, and like you said, you purchased your EE because of an unlocked multi, that was enough differentiation for you. What you are proposing does not give you anything more, it just takes away from everyone else.

I am not against EE processors having a greater differentiation than they currently have, it's the method you go about getting it that's in question. If Intel added more features to the EE, that would be perfectly fine with me and just about anyone else. If they chose to differentiate it by keeping it the same and simply giving everyone else the shaft, that would be frowned upon by anyone to truly considered themselves an enthusiast. If you personally would not frown upon that method, you are not an enthusiast, you are an elitist.
 
If you personally would not frown upon that method, you are not an enthusiast, you are an elitist.

I wish I were!:p

As this would effect so few people, I can't possibly see it as a class issue. I do think that a lot of tech enthusiasts have a sense of entitlement that reflects society in general these days. Overclocking is NOT a right. It's not usually part of the formal deal when one buys a CPU. Its really nothing more than good luck for a very small number of consumers.

I would not want to see overclocking locked out of all but the most expensive CPUs. If it were, it wouldn't harm the average consumer, and that's my main concern. The group of people that are most impacted by this are people mainly looking for bragging rights.
 
No one is talking about entitlement. It's about weather or not to change the status quo. EE buyers are not "entitled" to have more differentiation than they already have either, but that's what you're seeking, at the cost of others no less.

I find it hard to believe that you're concerned about the average consumer and at the same time, you're talking about EE buyers getting more differentiation. Newsflash, the average consumer does not buy EE processors. Furthermore, not locking out overclocking won't harm the average consumer either. It's not like the old days where processors were identified by clock speeds alone. Nor is it like a few years back when you can OC an Athlon XP 2500+ to 2.2 GHz and it would be identified as a XP 3200+

The only reason you'd be ok, and would actually like it is because you have an EE and it will not affect you negatively. That is an elitist, not an enthusiast attitude, whether you want to believe it or not.
 
is there anyone who'd think i overclocked my 2.2 e4500 to 3.0 only looking for brag?
that's not even close and that's sad, really.
 
Actually it is broke and Intel is now fixing it. If you think buying a $80 cpu and oc'ing it to performance level of a $500 is working as intended then you're sadly mistaken.

just because u can make an 80 dollar cpu oc to the 500 dollar range doesn't define a broken market strategy. THey know the specifics and yeilds. In fact, I've seen reps singling out some of the lower end cpu's this way (talking the OC factor). You think they didn't make money this way? You think they would have made more the other way around? They hit the market right on and have been appealing to most of us for a while. But like all success stories, they feel they can afford to take a risk on a market that looks like its all there's.

btw, by virtue of unlocked multipliers, Intel obbiously has put thought into those who overclock. THey know junior chips will FSB OC and people will pay for the added benefit of a an unlocked multi. Everything they do says they know wtf is going on.

Can't fault them on any of thier moves because they obviously do something right.

This is all speculative now anyhow right? ref the OPs linkage...
 
Overclockers might be a very small segment of the market but they are a profitable one. One with rather high margins. Though actions have been taken before to urge overclockers into buying higher priced processors.
 
If this is true, i hope intel realizes that they are essentially shooting themselves in the foot....

you do realize that probably 95+% of the chips that intel makes go to large oem's and run in machines that never can, and never will be, overclocked?

You guys have to remember that there is more than the enthusiast aspect to overclocking. Back in the pentium/pentium II days (when the cpu speed was just set by jumpers on the mobo), intel had some big fiascos with OEM's that would overclock cpu's and sell them marked as the higher price point. They have a lot of interest to make sure that crap doesn't happen. Enthusiasts are a very small market (comparitively to dell/hp/apple/etc.) and they end up being accidental collateral on things like this.
 
While this is a great discussion, I can't help to think that it's all too premature. We don't know how Intel is going to lock the Overclocking and CPU manufacturers have talked about his for years, but we've only seen the "market" as a whole change toward the opposite. I mean, look at the Dell XPS, HP Blackbird, Alienware, ETC. type of systems and most mainstream motherboards offered at all of the online retailers. I'd be willing to say that 50% of all motherboards on the market, have some kind of tweaking or OC'ing features. Intel released the EE edition processors with the P4s and has maintained the line ever since.

I'd like to see the motherboards first, then we'll know for sure.
 
The extreme edition processors are simply a marketing ploy designed to generate an "extreme" amount of revenue from a tiny marketshare. There's nothing special about an EE processor except the unlocked multiplier and possible binning.

Now, if you're willing to give Intel a fat stack of cash for something "guaranteed", in this case the ability to overclock however you want and getting a processor that runs at a fast speed, then fine. Don't expect the rest of us who are willing to take our chances and push our "lower class" processor to higher than rated speeds to feel sympathy for you spending a fortune on bascially the same processor. You took the easy way out, and paid a premium for it... which is normally the case with all things in life.

Once again, I'll reiterate. The EE processors are a marketing strategy. They aren't "special". If you say that overclocking a normal processor is so easy, then you just made the case that you bought into Intels marketing instead of just buying a slower processor and overclocking it instead. I'm not saying you made a bad choice, but if the differentiation is as small as you claim, then perhaps Intel isn't too happy with their loss of revenue from people who no longer see the "value" in an EE processor. They may hope to regain some high end profit by artificially limiting the low end.

Overclocking got started as a way to save money and use some knowlegede and risk to get value out of our computers and push their performance to the limit. My enjoyment of overclocking got started way before Intel, AMD, Nvidia, and every other company out there hoping to make a buck off overclocking even cared about us. I'll guarantee you one thing though, as hard as they might try, overclockers will still find a way to get value and added performance out of our computers. Golden fingers anyone?

But one big thing to remember is that the overclocking, aftermarket parts market is fairly small, yet very profitable. I don't expect to see overclocking going away anytime soon. If anything, Intel would like a bigger chunk of that overclocking profit to go to them, not to get rid of overclocking altogether.
 
Oh,

I understand what an EE processor is. What I was trying to point out, was that although CPU manufacturers have been talking about limiting OC'ing for years, the market as a whole has moved TOWARD OC'ing. I'm not talking about computers major OEMs and servers for Corporate America or Joe Sixpack.

I mean, off the shelf components. Heck, even video card vendors are selling items as factory "overclocked." Shit, when I was in college I had a friend who OC'd Pentium 1 by changing a jumper on his board, I didn't even know what Overclocking was then. But now, typically consumers know of the term and with all marketing, if it sells something, then it's working.

Those in the know, "know better" but you and I aren't going to fall for an EE processor anytime soon, as you're right they're the same chips, but with unlocked multis.

The only time an EE processor had something different from an unlocked multi, was the Pentium D EE processor, Intel enabled hyperthreading on that dual presscott, and the dual core could take 4 threads.
 
Obviously, they want to push the hardcore users to pay for the faster chips. This makes sense. I can't say that I'm surprised by this sort of a move.
 
My post wasn't aimed at you Flexion, but at heatlesssun. I agree with what you posted.
 
you do realize that probably 95+% of the chips that intel makes go to large oem's and run in machines that never can, and never will be, overclocked?

You guys have to remember that there is more than the enthusiast aspect to overclocking. Back in the pentium/pentium II days (when the cpu speed was just set by jumpers on the mobo), intel had some big fiascos with OEM's that would overclock cpu's and sell them marked as the higher price point. They have a lot of interest to make sure that crap doesn't happen. Enthusiasts are a very small market (comparitively to dell/hp/apple/etc.) and they end up being accidental collateral on things like this.

You do realize that more and more OEM manufactures are starting to overclock now right?
 
Don't expect the rest of us who are willing to take our chances and push our "lower class" processor to higher than rated speeds to feel sympathy for you spending a fortune on bascially the same processor. You took the easy way out, and paid a premium for it... which is normally the case with all things in life.

Once again, I'll reiterate. The EE processors are a marketing strategy. They aren't "special".

No, we didn't. Who buys an EE and doesn't overclock it? They don't overclock themselves. And they are special in that you have another way to overclock, the multiplier and because they can pushed a little harder. I don't think that makes them special enough for the price.

I really don't understand why people are so outraged by this possibility. Not even an EE CPU is guaranteed to overclock, though for the premium they probably had better otherwise they'd be beyond pointless.

And that is my point. Overclocking is something that was never part of the deal. This generation of processors from Intel are just great at it and as a result the lines too much between the bottom and the top are a little too blurry. If guaranteed overclocking is something that the EE’s other that others don’t I do not see the great evil in that. Personally, I’d like the EE’s to go down in price.
 
I can easily see Intel doing this. Unless AMD pulls a rabbit out of its ass where are we going to go? The bean counters probably don't care as much as the brass at Intel, they are probably using the same reasoning as heatlessum. they don't want the rift rats matching their top line products. They want a high status spot, same with the geforce ultras. they are not worth the price they cost but they are a flagship product so they command the price. The market may not be that big (I really can't see it being significant) but the egos are that big. bottom line. And in the end we are going to get screwed out of fast low cost systems. I am only surprised that they let this go on as long as it has or that they let it happen at all.
 
You do realize that more and more OEM manufactures are starting to overclock now right?

yes, and that is exactly the kind of stuff that made intel implement anti-overclocking measures in the first place :p You have to think about it from intel's point of view. They don't want OEM's to buy, for example, a 2ghz cpu at a 2ghz price and then sell it as a 2.6ghz cpu with the price marked up.
 
It is going both ways. Just like people spending 30k on a Mustang Cobra, investing another 10k in mods and being able to smoke 100k cars. By your rational, Ford should do something to make their cars unmoddable.

Please, its more like you buy a Focus, press a switch and it'll be a low end Mustang. There is absolutely no investment involved in overclocking a lot of the Core2 CPU's - especially low end Allendales or Wolfdales. It doesn't make business sense when any joe can flip a switch in bios and turn a budget CPU into a relatively high end product with no additional effort at all. But then again, I can imagine that it also means that your yields are incredibly good and that you're sandbagging new releases because your competitor isn't keeping up in the desktop.

But really, this is all FUD. I remember when Intel was locking the multiplier and the same FUD was spread that overclocking was dead.
 
I can actually agree with this move since I personally just bought an Extreme Edition CPU and feel like if I paid $1000 for a CPU I should see something for that kind of money that a guy who paid $300 can't.

You have unlocked multi, quitcherbitchin. It's not our fault you dropped an extra $700, on something not really worth the premium :p
 
I could accept the argument about Extreme Edition CPUs more if their cost was even remotely in proportion to the benefit you gain. If you had to pay Intel $50, maybe $100 more to get an overclockable chip (compared to a locked one at the same frequency), then people would be upset about it, but it could at least be argued to be somewhat reasonable. However, the price delta is just ridiculously large; it really surprises me that anyone buys Extreme Edition processors at all today, and even if you couldn't overclock standard processors, I wouldn't even think about paying the prices they ask at the moment. They have a dreadful price:performance ratio today, and even locking down the standard chips to try to force a difference wouldn't change my mind on that.
 
If you don't think it’s fair to lock out lower end CPU's, then I think that from the other side that it’s not fair for a person who pays $200 to get almost the same benefit as a person that pays $1000. There needs to be more differentiation. In that spirit, I said it would be better to offer more value to the higher end in new features that were not easily reproducible on the lower end. I see nothing wrong with that.

Excuse me, but there's already a difference. First off, extreme processors are generally clocked higher than normal ones. Second, they usually are built with slightly better materials because they need to be able to support the higher clock natively.

If you buy a processor at 2.4 and crank it to 3.0, it may not be stable. It may not go that far. By paying extra for a processor at 3.0, you're, in essence, buying a guarantee that it will run at that speed (and it will probably run faster than that).

Unlocked multiplier CPU's are sold somewhat because you can overclock them easier than the locked ones. Of course some may argue that it's just as easy, but it's certainly not harder, which is what you're buying.

I see this as a dirty move Intel is making now that they have almost a solid monopoly. If AMD had seriously competitive chips out, Intel wouldn't dare do this. They're exploiting their monopoly and that's what bothers me the most about it.
 
I know there's a difference. There needs to be more for the price delta I believe. That's why most people are upset. By overclocking they feel that they can get a $1000 for $200. If there were greater differentiation would wouldn't be having this debate.

Is this a dirty move by Intel. I don't think its that simple. They have to be aware that they have a problem selling $200 processors that can perform similarly to $1000+ processors. They need a way to differentiate their products better, plain and simple if they are going to have such large price deltas.

For the umpteenth time I'll say that it would be better for them to find a way to do this that doesn't involve totally locking out FSB overclocking on the lower end. Perhaps they could sell ultra cheap CPUs that do have this restriction and come up with a middle pricing tier that doesn't or something else a little creative.
 
Back
Top