Critics Slam 'GTA IV' Without Test Drive

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
GTA IV is a video game intended for a mature audience. With that said, GTA IV is guaranteed to bring out the worst in certain people, just not the people the media would have you believe. The people it happens to be bringing the worst out in are the politicians, activists and pundits…most of whom have never even played the game.

In the lead-up to the midnight Tuesday release of Rockstar Games' follow-up game, Grand Theft Auto IV, Thompson was at it again. According to online technology news site Softpedia, Thompson wrote an e-mail to Take-Two Interactive CEO Strauss Zelnick's mother (Take-Two is Rockstar's parent company).
 
It's typical for critics, politicians, and media to judge something without even playing it.
 
I was too young to vote in 1996, but I supported Bob Dole over Bill Clinton.

Then Bob Dole came out and said how Trainspotting was a movie that glorified drug use.

Then he admitted he'd never actually seen it.

...douchebag...

Most politicians on both sides of the aisle suck.
 
It's typical for critics, politicians, and media to judge something without even playing it.

yea but do they need to play it? really now... isn't it pretty much as bad as they'd think?

there are plenty of videos out there of gameplay
 
What the hell does it matter what the game contains. Even if it were to contain images of the most horrifying things imaginable. (I'd think up something to put here, but with the weird porn fetishes out there, I probably couldn't shock some of you) The game is marketed and branded, so only consenting adults can buy it. It isn't like this is being added as mandatory playtime in your childs daycare center.
 
Hmmm let see these same politicans go after violence, or sexuality in movies.. oh wait Hollywood donates BOATLOADS of cash to Democrats(who are the most vocal against games like GTA, not to say there aren't spineless Republicans out there)...
 
The drive by media does this on just about every topic. It's all about what's hot today and we'll research it later. That hype gets politicans onboard even when they don't have a clue either. Look at global warming. You hear about it all the time yet most of the reporters and politicans don't have a clue. They just know that bad news sells and fear drums up votes no matter if it's entirely true.
 
This is just business as usual. Every media, political, and especially "activist" out there forms opinions by generally just reading some story, interestingly enough from some media, political or activist source, without ever experiencing it for themselves. Media just does it for the ratings, politicians to try and show they care, and "activists" to try and sway people to their type of thinking.

It's like the whole Mass Effect "sex scene" like thing. Everyone is trying to show it's some form of pornographic section in the game, but once some people actually played it they start saying, "oh, I have seen worse on TV in prime time." They may try to retract their statements but those retractions are never heard since they don't get ratings and show the fallibility of the person or message they were trying to spread.
 
FYI

I bought GTA 4 at Best Buy today and they had a big sticker slapped on it saying you must be 18 to buy. Plus I got carded at the checked and I'll be 29 next month! The cashier said that they have to do it to everyone per management, even seniors. lol
 
What? The government hating on violent video games? Say it ain't so!
 
Well if the "critics" and Happy Jack are slamming it I know right off the bat it is a good game. I was going to pass on this installment but now, well, with their ringing endorsement I guess I too shall buy it.
 
FYI

I bought GTA 4 at Best Buy today and they had a big sticker slapped on it saying you must be 18 to buy. Plus I got carded at the checked and I'll be 29 next month! The cashier said that they have to do it to everyone per management, even seniors. lol

Works for me.
 
What? The government hating on violent video games? Say it ain't so!

People, not just the government, hate on every mass media type in this. It used to be comic books, and movies they kicked around. Now that video games have the same level of sophistication it is their turn.
 
before i even read all these post, I will say one thing:

PARENTING! why is it so hard to be a god damn parent and teach your kids to be responsible?

I mean come on....be responsible... pretty soon you wont be able to do or make ANYTHING without any negative effects on some people. IF your stupid enough to let a game influence you.... then by all means please remove yourslef from the gene pool. Only lord knows how you will raise your own kids.

This country is becomeing a bunch of pansies. Lets all hug. Lets not hurt anyones feelings, OMG WE GOTTA PROTECT OUR KIDS FROM ALL THIS BAD STUFF.

People in power have brain washed most of you into believing this garbage. I feel sorry for the country... I can only imagine what its going to be like ... I use the same quote as i do with guns " games dont kill people... people kill people."

rant done
 
There's really nothing new or shocking here. Politicians will take on virtually any issue to gain public favor. This guy is simply doing what is in his best interest. Why should we be surprised?

Conversely, most of their critics are not opposed on purely theoretical grounds, but rather because they like playing video games. They take opposition simply because, as game players, its in their best interest. Most critics in this dept. have never had to raise children of their own, and conveniently neglect to mention the game's effects on children, opting to focus on the responsibility of the parent to shield their kids from such material. Great. So what happens to all the at-risk kids with irresponsible or absent parents? Do we shortchange them for the rights of the adults? (I dont believe there to be a right answer here, just opinions)

Everyone has a right to disagree with either side, but there is really nothing shocking about this whatsoever. People will continue to do whatever is in their best interest.
 
This is just business as usual. Every media, political, and especially "activist" out there forms opinions by generally just reading some story, interestingly enough from some media, political or activist source, without ever experiencing it for themselves. Media just does it for the ratings, politicians to try and show they care, and "activists" to try and sway people to their type of thinking.

It's like the whole Mass Effect "sex scene" like thing. Everyone is trying to show it's some form of pornographic section in the game, but once some people actually played it they start saying, "oh, I have seen worse on TV in prime time." They may try to retract their statements but those retractions are never heard since they don't get ratings and show the fallibility of the person or message they were trying to spread.

You hit it on the head. Watching even popular shows like "charmed" ( not willingly i may add ) you can see strong sexual suggestions in that show sometimes... Plus the way they dress ( I know i never let my daughter leave the house wearing some stuff they did )

It all comes down to parenting. is it so hard to understand? Politicians let alone special interest group have no place to tell parents whats right or wrong . IT should be up to the parents. The problem is , People now have gotten so used to the government telling them what is right or wrong that some now dont even know how to discipline kids let alone teach em the rights and wrongs in life.
 
I don't even like GTA and hate this game gets is rediculous. As many have already stated why don't they focus on those superviolent horror films. There's plenty of gratuitous nudity and violence in those.

It's like the whole Mass Effect "sex scene" like thing. Everyone is trying to show it's some form of pornographic section in the game, but once some people actually played it they start saying, "oh, I have seen worse on TV in prime time." They may try to retract their statements but those retractions are never heard since they don't get ratings and show the fallibility of the person or message they were trying to spread.

Wasn't that part an optional path if you chose to pursue it? I haven't played Mass Effect but it doesn't seem like Bioware to force you to do anything.
 
People, not just the government, hate on every mass media type in this. It used to be comic books, and movies they kicked around. Now that video games have the same level of sophistication it is their turn.

I know that. I was being sarcastic.

Even religious leaders and civil rights leaders and your mother's mother would complain about the game without ever playing it or even watching it being played. They take a commercial at face value.

Used to be back when boys swordfight with sticks and wore strainers on their heads and used pot lids are shields were considered violent too
 
They don't need to play GTA IV. What will they find? An immersive world filled with crime, sex, violence, and cursing. I wouldn't expect the critics to admit the game is great, even if they enjoyed it. To them it's only about the content, they're not contesting how good the gameplay is.
 
Same politicians that pushed for the ESRB, then put absolutely no faith in it.
 
I shit you not, some old Harpie at work heard me mention this game and said "well it can't be any worse than that halo..."

I looked at her like she'd lost her mind, and after asking her a few questions about violence in general, and whether or not it's perceivably worse to be "shooting space aliens in a future setting or regular humans in modern day New York" she replied "Shooting anything is bad"

ugh, .

I responded "Yeah, if you do it real life"

Regular people are so misinformed on these issues it's ridiculous.

Oh, and I'm 29 and was also carded at Wal-Mart last night. Which I'm totally fine with.
 
Someone needs to make a mod that makes everyone's face like Osama's so they wouldn't get angry about shooting everyone up in the game anymore.
 
I'm not sure if you need to play it to know it's going to be about hijacking cars and killing people, lol. Lets not play silly here :D
 
The only problem I see with these games is that the VAST majority of copies will be played by young kids.

I was working retail when GTA 2 & 3 came out. 90% of the sales were by pissed off mothers who actually had to come into my store and buy the game after I refused to sell it to their 8 yr old....

I'd explain that the game was loaded with adult content and that you were encouraged to earn bonus points by bashing hookers skulls in with a baseball bat after having sex with them...

But apparently, for the pretty, boob jobbed, crucifix wearing, bottle blond average American mom, that is acceptable content for a 3rd grader...

RockStar has every right to make these games. Freedom of speech\expression is vital to humanity in general.

But lets face it, most humans are too stupid to ensure proper use of this type of media. And it is SERIOUSLY fucking up our kids.
 
The only problem I see with these games is that the VAST majority of copies will be played by young kids.

I was working retail when GTA 2 & 3 came out. 90% of the sales were by pissed off mothers who actually had to come into my store and buy the game after I refused to sell it to their 8 yr old....

I'd explain that the game was loaded with adult content and that you were encouraged to earn bonus points by bashing hookers skulls in with a baseball bat after having sex with them...

But apparently, for the pretty, boob jobbed, crucifix wearing, bottle blond average American mom, that is acceptable content for a 3rd grader...

RockStar has every right to make these games. Freedom of speech\expression is vital to humanity in general.

But lets face it, most humans are too stupid to ensure proper use of this type of media. And it is SERIOUSLY fucking up our kids.

Okay Im not trying to attack you as a person for your views... this is our freedom after all, but i strongly disagree with your statement that games like this screw up the kids. It starts with the parents to teach the kids the rights and wrongs in life. To be honest with you, I can think of 5 things that we all should worry about over a silly video game
 
There's really nothing new or shocking here. Politicians will take on virtually any issue to gain public favor. This guy is simply doing what is in his best interest. Why should we be surprised?

Conversely, most of their critics are not opposed on purely theoretical grounds, but rather because they like playing video games. They take opposition simply because, as game players, its in their best interest. Most critics in this dept. have never had to raise children of their own, and conveniently neglect to mention the game's effects on children, opting to focus on the responsibility of the parent to shield their kids from such material. Great. So what happens to all the at-risk kids with irresponsible or absent parents? Do we shortchange them for the rights of the adults? (I dont believe there to be a right answer here, just opinions)

Everyone has a right to disagree with either side, but there is really nothing shocking about this whatsoever. People will continue to do whatever is in their best interest.

Those kids with irresponsible or absent parents should be placed in a household that has responsible and present guardians. Those parents should also be on a court order to not have kids until they can improve upon whatever it is that's keeping them from raising their kids properly.

Really, everytime I hear a parent go of about how their kid was harmed from seeing something....why the hell did they let their kid see it? What about their screwup? Didn't an "M" rating mean anything? Oh yeah, ratings are irrelevent, since the parent knows best (but not enough to be responsible for screwing up I suppose).

Laws that are meant to replace bad parenting are never good for the kid or the parents...all it's good for is making more court revenue.
 
The only problem I see with these games is that the VAST majority of copies will be played by young kids.

I was working retail when GTA 2 & 3 came out. 90% of the sales were by pissed off mothers who actually had to come into my store and buy the game after I refused to sell it to their 8 yr old....

I'd explain that the game was loaded with adult content and that you were encouraged to earn bonus points by bashing hookers skulls in with a baseball bat after having sex with them...

But apparently, for the pretty, boob jobbed, crucifix wearing, bottle blond average American mom, that is acceptable content for a 3rd grader...

RockStar has every right to make these games. Freedom of speech\expression is vital to humanity in general.

But lets face it, most humans are too stupid to ensure proper use of this type of media. And it is SERIOUSLY fucking up our kids.


I"m not willing to step over the line to tell someone else how they legally can and can't raise thier own kid. I don't ever want to be told legally how I can and can't raise mine.

I'll say thier dumb idiots though. It is depressing to think that these kind of people are out breeding the smart ones.
 
I like to hear that people regardless of age are being carded buying this, I think that's a step in the RIGHT direction.
 
I hate the fact that these people come out here and try to blame video games, movies, books, etc. for the way people act. If you were to talk to anyone in the field of psychology they would most likely tell you that that is bullshit.

Video games don't condition your personality. Most of who you are and how you act comes to you from your parents during conception. The rest comes from the way you were raised and the environment you were raised in. There have been experiments done to test this theory as well.

So basically, be a good parent. There is a reason that this game was made for adults and not for children. If you are going to buy this for your child and let them play it unsupervised, it is your fault if they start try to re-enact parts of the game.

These people who are so against these games need to realize that the video games are not what is affecting the people in today's society.
 
Okay Im not trying to attack you as a person for your views... this is our freedom after all, but i strongly disagree with your statement that games like this screw up the kids. It starts with the parents to teach the kids the rights and wrongs in life. To be honest with you, I can think of 5 things that we all should worry about over a silly video game

The human brain is a computer, plain and simple. It recieves most of it's programming during the first 15 yrs of life, give or take a few. Not only that, but up until your early 20's, most people process information through their emotional center, pushing logic aside.

So, what these games do is desensitize the emotional response to horrific violence, leaving only a diminished logical response.

If you don't think that's a problem.....

And yes, I do believe it's up to the parents to teach morality to thier kids. But this simply does not happen nearly as often as it should.

Caring for kids has become "throw them the video game they want so momma\pop can have some peace and quiet."
 
The human brain is a computer, plain and simple. It recieves most of it's programming during the first 15 yrs of life, give or take a few. Not only that, but up until your early 20's, most people process information through their emotional center, pushing logic aside.

So, what these games do is desensitize the emotional response to horrific violence, leaving only a diminished logical response.

If you don't think that's a problem.....

And yes, I do believe it's up to the parents to teach morality to thier kids. But this simply does not happen nearly as often as it should.

Caring for kids has become "throw them the video game they want so momma\pop can have some peace and quiet."

This is exactly what I was trying to say.

Once again, the game was made for adults, and it is the fault of the parents for letting their children play the game.
 
:confused:Hmmm let see these same politicans go after violence, or sexuality in movies.. oh wait Hollywood donates BOATLOADS of cash to Democrats(who are the most vocal against games like GTA, not to say there aren't spineless Republicans out there)...
Don't you mean BUTTLOADS....
 
I hate the fact that these people come out here and try to blame video games, movies, books, etc. for the way people act. If you were to talk to anyone in the field of psychology they would most likely tell you that that is bullshit.

Video games don't condition your personality. Most of who you are and how you act comes to you from your parents during conception. The rest comes from the way you were raised and the environment you were raised in. There have been experiments done to test this theory as well.

So basically, be a good parent. There is a reason that this game was made for adults and not for children. If you are going to buy this for your child and let them play it unsupervised, it is your fault if they start try to re-enact parts of the game.

These people who are so against these games need to realize that the video games are not what is affecting the people in today's society.

I do have a degree in Psych (although I work in the art field) and you are very wrong here. Every highly repetative stimulus has an effect on a developing human brain. Without question.

I am not against these games in any shape or form.

I am however, VERY against the improper distribution of such media.

At least put them behind the counter with an

"ADULTS ONLY-EXTREMELY VIOLENT AND SEXUAL CONTENT" sign.

Much like the skin rags at 7\11.

That would be a good step forward for proper distribution.
 
Someone needs to make a mod that makes everyone's face like Osama's so they wouldn't get angry about shooting everyone up in the game anymore.

Notice how Counter-Strike avoided all the attention. Especially after the bin Laden skin that was released.

Well, attention outside of Jack Thompson anyway. Apparently killing terrorists is a perfectly fine concept, and the casualities on the side of those killing them is an anticipated loss, even in video games.

Also notice no one even dared to say shit about America's Army, or the Battlefield games. At least, I personally never saw either get brought up in the headlines associating their violent content with any real crime committed.
 
Notice how Counter-Strike avoided all the attention. Especially after the bin Laden skin that was released.

Well, attention outside of Jack Thompson anyway. Apparently killing terrorists is a perfectly fine concept, and the casualities on the side of those killing them is an anticipated loss, even in video games.

Also notice no one even dared to say shit about America's Army, or the Battlefield games. At least, I personally never saw either get brought up in the headlines associating their violent content with any real crime committed.

You know the FBI investigagtes the people who play terrorists :D
 
I do have a degree in Psych (although I work in the art field) and you are very wrong here. Every highly repetative stimulus has an effect on a developing human brain. Without question.

I am not against these games in any shape or form.

I am however, VERY against the improper distribution of such media.

At least put them behind the counter with an

"ADULTS ONLY-EXTREMELY VIOLENT AND SEXUAL CONTENT" sign.

Much like the skin rags at 7\11.

That would be a good step forward for proper distribution.

I'm not sure that you have to go that far. Best buy putting giant ass stickers that say you have to be 18 years old to buy it should get some people to poke thier heads up outta thier ass.
 
its all your attitudes that think this stuff with the regulation is okay. You wanna take care of my kids too while your at it? I mean your already telling them what they can and can not buy.

Heck i cant even send my kid to buy me some lighter fluid if i wanted to. My mom or pops always had me do that so it was one less thing they had to worry about getting that day. I get carded for that now. Medicines? yeah great....thats behind the counter. Boy that will solve the drug problem...yeah it will only solve it where it just gets made somewhere else.

All regulation like this does not help. Kids will STILL play the game ( DOH! Who wouldda thunk that! ) So really.... its just another way for you Gov. Regulation, and other things I cant say online cuz im so disgusted right now Ill say em... to yet play another role in telling ME whats is good for my kids
 
I own the game and it's tamer than the previous GTA games, I have no idea what they are bitching about besides the fact that kids are still picking the game up regardless of the giant 18+ sticker on the front. It's not like they can't find a violent movie on TV, or find something being described in all it's detail in a book...what next ban kids from learning how animals and plants reproduce in science class?

Oh heaven forbid that they learn how to treat a girl on a date (it's in the game), and god help us that they learn that driving under the influence will get them arrested or killed (also in the game), or that they might have friends and go out and play darts, go bowling, or possibly *GASP!!!* play pool (again in the game)!?

If anything the game is just as much about going out with your friends and having fun, as well as dating, besides the main part of the game...could this game actually be more educational than it's predecessors?
 
Back
Top