Good Video Card for Phoshop

nilepez

[H]F Junkie
Joined
Jan 21, 2005
Messages
11,829
I'm getting ready to build my mom a machine, but I'm clueless on what's the minimum video card I could get that will work for her.

She'll run vista, but she'll run no games (aside form bridge or solitaire).

Her primary use is working on photos. The monitor is up in the air, but I assume she'll either get a 24" monitor or a 30" monitor (probably 24, but I'm not sure it'll matter, so long as the card has dual-dvi out).

Anyway, if I can get a $50.00 card that gives about the same 2D quality as a more expensive card, then that's what I'd like to do. All the 3D section needs to handle is whatever Aero requires to run smoothly.

I really appreciate any help anyone can throw my way. If it matter's, I'm probably building this with x64 Vista and putting in 8GB of ram. Ram is cheap and it should mean she'll never have to worry about memory in Photoshop (though I recall thinking that at 2GB too).

Thanks

nilepez
 
For 2D applications, an Nvidia Geforce 8400GS with Dual DVI or ATI Radeon HD 2400 pro will be fine for your needs. Something like this will also be good

Look for these cards

Nvidia Line
8400GS
8500GT
8600GT

ATI Line
HD 2400Pro
HD 2400XT
HD 2600Pro

Any of these cards will do fine.

If you're going with a 30" LCD display with 2560 x 1600. Then this MSI 2600Pro with Dual Link DVI will be ideal

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814127330
 
Photoshop is all CPU and RAM. A recent low-end discrete card like the 8400 is all you'll need.
 
Can that card easily play Starcraft 2 at max settings? :)

Why are you asking this in a thread about Photoshop? Also, how do you expect us to tell you how well Starcraft 2 will run when it's not even released?
 
Why are you asking this in a thread about Photoshop? Also, how do you expect us to tell you how well Starcraft 2 will run when it's not even released?

Battle.net mental cases post wherever they'd like.
 
Why are you asking this in a thread about Photoshop? Also, how do you expect us to tell you how well Starcraft 2 will run when it's not even released?

;)

Well I too am a heavy Photoshop user and found this thread to suit me well. Plus the only game I'll only really play in the future is Starcraft 2. I didn't want to start a new thread just for that...

I think a better question is, would the 8600GT be able to play...Crysis at a reasonable rate?
 
014558b7dde17bc5_m.jpg
 
ROFL. I was puzzled on why this pic was there? I thought it was used to compare the image quality of a video card.
 
Sorry if I veered the topic of course...I just looked up the system requirements for Crysis. Dang....haha
 
ROFL. I was puzzled on why this pic was there? I thought it was used to compare the image quality of a video card.

No, it's just being used to compare the hunger of our stomachs. ;)

Though my card displays this image perhaps, too well.
 
don't the new integrated chipsets run aero perfectly fine? if there really is no 3d work going on then a newer integrated graphics card will do fine. are you going with amd or intel?

intel... the g31/g33/g35 should do very nicely. the nvidia 700 series is very nice too (quite cheap as well), but they only have room for 2 sticks of ram.

amd... go with ati 780g chipset as they are very good with graphics and video (also has options for multiple monitor output as well as hybrid crossfire), an nvidia 7000 series will do fine as well.

i think a discrete graphics card is overkill for just photoshop. a beefier processor might be a better option. there are a few options out there for dual monitor setups on igps too..

http://www.tomshardware.com/2008/03/04/amd_780g_chipset/
 
Title says Pho-Shop ;) So I posted a picture of Pho.
9f74b88d-446e-4f00-92a8-7bc836f0b6e7.jpg

Weeeeeeeeeee!!!!
Horray for pictures!
 
Isn't the Pho restaurant somewhere in San Jose, CA? I may have dined in it before if it is. Kind of forgot the name, though.
 
Hmm...I dunno, I found that picture when I typed Pho shop into google images.:p
 
Photoshop is all CPU and RAM. A recent low-end discrete card like the 8400 is all you'll need.

Unless she's using CS3 extended edition. This does more 3D modelling and animation and can use the GPU for rendering. The GPU is used to compute the output as well as display it when doing a preview. If she's using these options, it may still not be very taxing on the GPU and low-end may be fine - check with Adobe.

If CS3 standard - anything will do. You might want to make sure it has dual-link DVI in case she gets a 30" monitor some day. None of the cards you'll find commonly recommended here will have dual LUTs. You need to go to Quadros and other pro cards to get those features that will allow two connected monitors to be independently profiled and calibrated.
 
Unless she's using CS3 extended edition. This does more 3D modelling and animation and can use the GPU for rendering. The GPU is used to compute the output as well as display it when doing a preview. If she's using these options, it may still not be very taxing on the GPU and low-end may be fine - check with Adobe.

If CS3 standard - anything will do. You might want to make sure it has dual-link DVI in case she gets a 30" monitor some day. None of the cards you'll find commonly recommended here will have dual LUTs. You need to go to Quadros and other pro cards to get those features that will allow two connected monitors to be independently profiled and calibrated.

I doubt she'll use CS3. It's almost exclusively working with photos. She was reading some book where the author recommended some Matrox card. And while I know they were always good with 2D, I kinda figured that by now the differences in 2D are slim, but I just wanted to make sure that was, in fact, the case.

If she goes to CS3, she can eat the $50.00 card and buy a new video card, but if she's going to a 30", I guess that's out the door....but my guess is 24" is enough.

Thanks to all for the advice. :D

Nilepez
 
I doubt she'll use CS3. It's almost exclusively working with photos. She was reading some book where the author recommended some Matrox card. And while I know they were always good with 2D, I kinda figured that by now the differences in 2D are slim, but I just wanted to make sure that was, in fact, the case.

If she goes to CS3, she can eat the $50.00 card and buy a new video card, but if she's going to a 30", I guess that's out the door....but my guess is 24" is enough.

Thanks to all for the advice. :D

Nilepez

She should be using CS3, there are major advances over CS2 even for the work that I do as an amateur. The thing is there are two versions of Photoshop CS3 - standard and extended. The EXTENDED version uses 3D functions and can "outsource" processing to a GPU.

I do believe the basic version uses the GPU in some places. I believe that Adobe Bridge uses OpenGL to build and manipulate the views of photos and make them twirl and zoom as you work in bridge. I believe this because I could hear the fan on my old 7600GT start when I went into bridge. In Photoshop itself, however, I don't think it was ever used. IMO it's smart of them to use GPU acceleration like that in Bridge. I don't think it adds any particular minimum requirements. Adobe's system requirements http://www.adobe.com/products/photoshop/photoshop/systemreqs/ indicate that "64M" of video memory is the requirement.

On the other issue, the 8600GT has 2x dual-link DVI outputs. The 8500 has a single dual-link DVI. Even the 8400GS has a single dual-link DVI. (source: BFGTech)

I think "you're good".

If she'll just be using Photoshop elements, and that's what you meant, it requires "a 16-bit video card".
 
Back
Top