New TV Recommendations For Gaming (Etc.)?

Joined
Mar 7, 2008
Messages
41
I checked into the stickied thread with the many various set-ups people have, but man... finding the right TV can be almost overwhelming.

My wife and I are looking for (probably) a 42" HD LCD model (maybe a 32"), and I could use some specific recommendations about what models are currently the best out there for gaming and in general.

We seem to be leaning towards Samsung, which has an incredible picture on some models, but so does Sony and perhaps a couple others, though I don't know how well any of these perform with gaming.

Any/all suggestions appreciated!
 
it may not be exactly what you are looking for, but if you have a BJs wholesale around you...they are clearing out their remaining sony SXRD stock pretty cheap...i think the 60inch at mine was at like 1400, ymmv of course but its worth a try right?
 
it may not be exactly what you are looking for, but if you have a BJs wholesale around you...they are clearing out their remaining sony SXRD stock pretty cheap...i think the 60inch at mine was at like 1400, ymmv of course but its worth a try right?

Thanks for the suggestion, though we unfortunately don't have a BJ's near us (we're in northern AZ). 60" for $1,400 is insane, though! Definitely a bit bigger than what we're looking for as well. 42" is about the biggest I think we'd like to go.

But, please keep the suggestions coming! :)

P.S.
I'm assuming that a 1080i is what we should looking into, as they will also run in 720p? Or am I off on that?
 
if you are looking at the samsungs, most of their 37inch + tvs are 1080p so you shouldn't really have to look into to much, and yes, if it runs 1080p/1080i it will run 720p as well.
 
I'm assuming that a 1080i is what we should looking into, as they will also run in 720p? Or am I off on that?

You won't find any 1080i TVs out there anymore. You want either 720p or 1080p. If you plan on using the TV for Blu-Rays, and you sit close enough (maybe 5-6 feet from a 42" TV), then go with 1080p. Otherwise, the rest of your sources are going to be 720p so you can save the cost and go with a 720p TV.

Out of the 720p TVs out there, your best options are LCD and Plasma. Same goes for 1080p, really.

For LCD, look at:

Samsung
Sharp
Sony

For Plasma, look at:

Pioneer
Panasonic

If you're going to be using the TV in a bright room, then LCD can be your only option. If the room will have controlled lighting, then Plasma becomes a great option as well.

Plasmas have better color, black levels, and generally better standard definition upscaling. Their disadvantages are that their brightness level will diminish over time (brightness half-life on newer Panasonics is around 100,000 hours), that their black levels raise and lower with the amount of light in the room (just like CRTs), and that there can be some image retention.

LCDs are sharper (as they generally don't oversaturate as much as Plasmas), have longer life (though the bulb must be replaced every so often...maybe 20,000+ hours or so), and are cheaper. LCDs main disadvantages are ghosting (kind of like motion blur, so they're generally worse for sports and gaming), less color accuracy (due to low contrast), and bad blacks (they generally look blue, due to the fluorescent lighting). Of course, you can get a newer LCD with LED backlighting, and this completely fixes the color and black level problems...but they can be a tad pricey I believe.

Both technologies have varying degrees of input lag, depending on the manufacturer. Usually the input lag won't affect your gaming too much in anything but rythm games. Games like Guitar Hero and Rock Band can have quite a bit of input lag on these technologies, which makes them much less enjoyable. I'm not sure whether or not any TV manufacturer excels at decreasing the input lag, but it's something worth looking into if you plan on playing rythm games on the TV.

Whatever technology you decide with, I urge you to wait until mid/late April to buy, since many of the manufacturers are releasing their new televisions then. The Panasonic 1080p Plasmas look particularly tasty at around $1800 for a 42". I'm waiting to see how the LED backlit LCDs are going to be priced as well, because they look pretty awesome.
 
Wow, thanks for all the great info.

Yeah, it's been a while since I've looked into TV tech stuff, so I wouldn't even have thought of the difference between 1080i/p, so thanks for that.

Any yeah, like I said, we've found ourselves drawn to/torn between Samsung and Sony from what we've seen thus far, so thanks for confirming that as well.

So are prices on current models dropping in April with the new releases then?
We'll definitely hold-off until then if we can save some money on the investment, so that's another very helpful piece of info.

Thanks again!
 
So are prices on current models dropping in April with the new releases then?
We'll definitely hold-off until then if we can save some money on the investment, so that's another very helpful piece of info.

Thanks again!

No problem :D.

And yeah, prices should drop in April, and quite dramatically at that. Panasonic's Plasma line from last year I think featured their top end 50" for roughly $4300. The top end 50" this year is even better than last year's, and is priced at only $2800! That means you'll probably see last year's model drop to $2000 or so (just guessing here). That's a whopping 50% I'm sure we'll see similar price drop to TVs like the Samsung LED TVs.

I think if the LED TVs are cheap enough this year, that they'd be a fairly ideal solution. Almost all the advantages of LCDs and Plasmas, with the main drawback being ghosting.

My personal draw towards a TV, is how good the blacks are. I'm picky when it comes to blacks, and am somewhat annoyed with the "dark blue" that I get from LCDs.

Of course, I'm a 20 year old university student living at home. Beggars can't be choosers, so I'm getting my dad's 37" Sharp Aquos for $400 in April :). We're doing shopping for a TV in April (for the basement, so it's a light controlled room), and I've researched the subject quite a bit, so I'll let you know what we're deciding as well. The TV is going to be used mainly for television and gaming, as we have a projector + screen for movies :cool:.

--------------------

You know, if I can give you one piece of advice, is don't follow my advice (or anyone else's for that matter) too closely. If you see a regular Samsung LCD, and an LED Samsung LCD, and can't see the difference, then don't pay for the difference in price! Spend as much as you need to for a TV that you're happy with.

My last piece of advice is this: don't be fooled by in-store displays. TVs are calibrated very differently in stores, and are often set to "torch mode" to attract your attention. The Panasonics, for example, have very oversaturated colors by default, and need to be calibrated to make the colors more natural. Your TV will end up looking very different at home than it does in the store. Don't be afraid of buying a TV and having to return it if you're not happy with it. Just try to stick with the brands I recommended, and I think you should be pretty satisfied (but don't forget to follow my first piece of advice for this point ;)).

Heh, buying a TV is a tad bit complicated :D. At least for those of us who like to strive for perfection (best TV for the price).
 
Don't buy an HP tv!

They don't make them anymore, but I bought the pl4260n plasma last year, and out of the year i've had it, it's been repaired twice, replaced by a reman', and then the reman was repaired 3 times and the unit still does not power on. My replacement 42" lcd arrived today, so hopefully I won't have problems with it.

Their customer service has been great though lol.
 
i purchased a new set last month after spending a ton of time in CC and BB comparing different tv's. ex0du5 is correct about retailers adjusting sets to torch mode, so make sure to grab the remote and tweak the settings while you're in store. I narrowed my search down to the Samsung LN-T4061F and the Sony KDL-40V3000. Once i was able to see both sets side by side it became immediately clear that the Sony had superior picture quality. both Samsung and Sony make really nice sets, but i highly recommend Sony. the V3000 is a 10bit panel with 10bit processing and has the capability of displaying 1080/24p. PS3 games look amazing, blu-ray movies look unbelievably crisp and detailed.
 
I did a bit of hunting and ended up with a Samsung xx65f . The contrast is quite good for an LCD and the black level is superb for an LCD. Plasmas typically blow LCDs out of the water on contrast and black level, but this LCD is actually competitive in this regard (15,000:1). However, it has a glossy finish over the entire front that can clause glare in certain lighting arrangements. You should be aware of where this TV would go in the room and check first.

The xx61f isn't quite as good in terms of contrast (10,000:1) but uses a matte finish so there's no glare.

(The "xx" is the inches, while the last 2 numbers note the series model, so a 4065f and 4665f are the same specs, just 6 inches difference in size).

I spent some time going to multiple stores to compare TV displays. The reason is because store displays are inconsistent so seeing a few different samples is a bit more reliable, since you would judge by the best looking sample to see what the actual potential is. One store must have seriously #@%&ed up their connections because the image quality was horrendous. Higher end model TVs looked terrible next to their lower end counterparts so it was pretty obvious the stores had screwed up. Perhaps they split cables too often or stretched them too far.

Plasma or LCD? Plasma usually is better black and contrast than LCDs, but LCDs tend to do better in bright environments while Plasmas do best in dark conditions. Plasma burn-in? Not really an issue with modern plasmas, which have much longer lifespans. LCD Ghosting? Same scenario, not really an issue with modern LCDs, which have improved refresh rates. Plasma is still slightly better in terms of bang-for-buck I think, you'd have to look at a case-by-case comparison.

You may not be aware of this, but response time is a factor in HDTV gaming. Due to some of effects that TVs run, they will take an input and spend time processing it before it shows up on the screen(This is different from refresh rate). This can result in you seeing things a bit behind real-time, which wreaks havok on reflex games or rhythm games like Guitar Hero(Guitar Hero actually has a response time offset mode which measures the delay so that this game can still be played. Some even use this to judge TVs) This is not a specification that is commonly advertised. However, if you see a "gaming mode" advertised you should be safe since this mode is geared to drop these effects in favor of immediate response. Many modern TVs have this but there are plenty that do not. For what it's worth the Samsung xx65f and xx71f do have a gaming mode(set per input, so when I play movies via the PC input I can go for picture quality, but when I change the source to play my wii and Xbox360 it's set automatically to gaming mode).
 
I think with LCD purchases right now its a good idea to consider whats the best value too. Fairly big advancements in LCD TV tech are coming on a regular basis and the prices are heading down. A lot of the LCD set on the market have interesting quirks regardless of what you pay, all the LCDs I have used feel kinda beta in actual use of watching TV and switching around through various analog/digital inputs. I am sure some people would argue this, its just my experience.

Like a lot of people said its really hard to see the picture quality in stores, so while testing out sets, check out the menus and remote too, along with the buttons right on the TV too. Switch through channels and inputs and see how fast it is, try a set out on an antenna (if they let you) and see if the channel tuning takes forever and a day. Also get behind the sets and check the input layout, and think of what you need to hook up, and what you might need. Its a nightmare to access the ports on some sets once you wall mount then, or they put all the inputs in one giant cluster and getting to the HDMI port (oir whatever) requires tiny fingers that only a 5 year old would have.

I would agree that Sharp/Sony/Samsung make some of the better sets. I use a Sharp Aquos myself, I enjoy it however I can see myself buying another LCD (or LED LCD) TV in a few years and shoving this in the bedroom or game room. I almost exclusively game on the Sharp, it does not seem to have any notable lag and the TV claims to have fast image prosessing to reduce lag. I suck way too much at Rock Band to notice if I had any TV lag screwing me up anyway. I just set the Rock Band TV setting to LCD and left it there.
 
For LCD's, I would take a look at Vizio... they are an up and comer, but they have amazing picture, and are relatively cheaper than Samsung / Sony.

I have a 37" Vizio myself, and it was definitely an improvement over the Samsung I had... picture quality is great on the Vizio, and it was a good deal cheaper over the other models. No lag or anything of that sort, either. Mine is a 720p, and while I wish I could have gone for a 1080p, it simply wasn't in my budget. However, blu-ray's and 360 / PS3 games still look amazing on it. I think we paid around $600 for our 37" Vizio (was on sale), but it was about a year ago so I don't remember all too well.

A lot of people who have Vizio's swear by them as well. The reason we got the Vizio was because the Samsung we had broke, the speakers went out, and it would have cost about $400 to fix it according to Samsung (limited warranty didn't cover it for whatever reason). I'm sure someone will come in and debunk Vizio and trumpet some brand name, but I'm very impressed with mine and my next television will probably be of the same brand.
 
If you decide on a 32 inch, get the Panasonic TC-32LX700.

It is widely regarded as the best overall 32 inch. I have it and it is definitely the best LCD I've ever used. It has an Alpha IPS panel in it with viewing angles so good that there are basically no problems at any angle. It has the best "120hz" implementation i've ever seen. It eliminates motion blur, judders, and makes motion more consistant from frame to frame---preserving resolution and making every "pop" just a bit more.

you'll have to act quick though because they are discontinued to make room for the 2008 models. So far the one's revealed do not use the Alpha IPS panel...
 
I did a bit of hunting and ended up with a Samsung xx65f .
*snip*

I have a Samsung 4665f and I absolutely love it. I researched for a LONG time before making my purchase, and the Samsung just had the best picture at the time. I bought the set quite a while ago, so I would think there are likely sets with better pictures now, but I still love the picture on this set.

I would agree with the others that have said to just go to your local stores and look at the pictures. Ask for the remotes and mess around with the settings. There is no need to buy the most expensive set out there if you can't tell the difference in picture from a bargain set. AVSForum.com has a TON of information and it will also give you some really good settings to try out on the TVs to get a true picture.

Let us know what you decide on!
 
Got my 42" HP LCD ( http://www.shopping.hp.com/webapp/s...derflow=1&product_code=RP849AA#ABA&catLevel=2) The picture is just as good as the plasma was, and there is minimal (maybe 5ms) input lag compared to the ~20ms input lag of the plasma.

It's a 1080p set but only through HDMI ( :rolleyes: ) and so far 1080i on my 360 using the "vivid" color setting looks great.

I've read alot about bad black levels in LCD's, especiall the cheaper sets, but according to my eyes the blacks are very black, not blue-ish tinted like I have read about some sets. So far so good.
 
Thanks to everyone for your responses. Definitely an extremely helpful read.

I was actually beginning to "study" whole HD LCD TV situation a while back, but eventually lost track of things and never pursued it further.

Actually, my wife and I have done that very thing multiples times in the last year or so, and have gone to various stores and had an intense look at all the different models. That actually is the reason I had mentioned those two or three manufacturers initially, because we've seen a few of each that were quite difficult to choose between and that looked like the highest quality. It's just been difficult to choose/know what is best, which is why all of these responses and all the information is great to get.

I agree with the Vizio comment, and thanks for reminding me... almost totally forgot. That's a manufacturer we had both seem that we've never heard of, and were surprised that the picture looked better than most other "name brand" manufactures models.

Response time will definitely be a consideration, so we'll keep an eye out for the gaming mode. There seem to be a few models out there even without it that people seem to really enjoying gaming on as well, so I'm taking note on all specific models being mentioned here, as well as some I've seen mentioned in reviews, or the stickied thread on these forums etc.

Again, thanks for all the great feedback. Hopefully soon we'll be ready to "make the move", because the sooner we finally get rid of the the 30" monstrosity that it our main TV (which is starting to cause me nothing but eye strain as well), the better.

Cheers!
 
Glad this topic came up! I was planning on getting one as well, more specific, this one:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16889234011

What do you guys think? The price is low, it has tons of inputs, decent features (1080p) and I hear Westinghouse is a decent brand now.

edit: linked the wrong one

I have the 37" Westinghouse (like millions of others here) and it is pretty spectacular. The 42" is very good as well, and I would definitely go for it for $999 unless you can find something bigger for that price. And that one includes the HDTV tuner too!
 
A local TV repairman I've talked to a few times has said that the Vizio's don't have a very long lifespan compared to the bigger name brands.
 
I read everything I could about either getting Plasma or LCD. I'm sitting on a Sony KDL40V2500 1080p LCD that I bought the winter before last. I want to get either a 46" or 50" (46 if LCD, 50 if Plasma) but still not sure. Heard Plasma is damn good compared to when I was first shopping for TVs but I hear there is a lot of stuff you have to do to take care of the TV and not have it get burn in. Also have to let it break in for 100hours.

LCD doesn't have the colors of a Plasma and so Plasma looks more natural/real over LCD but right now the ease of and LCD sounds better so I can just take it home and hook it up, calibrate it a little and be done with it. I want to get Plasma for the realistic looking colors and stuff but I don't want to make another job out of it where when I come home from work I can just sit and watch whatever or play whatever and not have to sit and worry about black bars sticking or uneven aging.
 
Samsung LNT5271F 52" LCD.

I love mine. My wife and I looked at almost every brand of LCD and Plasma TV. We always came back to this TV. It is absolutely stunning. I have a PS3, a 360, and a Wii. They all look fantastic. Blu-Ray movies on the PS3 are gorgeous. The colors and black levels are great and you don't have to worry about IR like you do on a Plasma.

https://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/B000U9XMCE/km-20/ref=nosim
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
I'll toss it out there for anyone who cares. If you want a large TV (50"+) it's worth considering a DLP or projection set.
I find that they have less input lag, less motion blur, and for a set of that size they can save you a fortune.
I was hunting a new TV last fall and did a ton of side-by-side comparisons at the store. I found minimal image differences (the main one was viewing angle) and I ended up saving $2K by going with a 61" DLP rather than a 55" LCD. For that money, you could buy a second TV or 3-4 bulbs assuming they go out quickly.
 
Be wary of samsung DLP's, I've read they have pretty bad input lag compared to other brands

* Note that all Samsung DLPs pass the signal through its internal DCDi scaler which will result in lag even if you game at the TV's native resolution (Source: http://gear.ign.com/articles/744/744064p2.html)

Remember: DLP should be avoided at all costs, and Solution A and B are typically a better route than Solution C. However, Solution C may be a more reasonable solution for gamers who do not care about or need perfect time-sensitivity.

taken from

http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=558125
 
You know, I've read stuff like that before, but I've never seen any imput lag at all on my DLP or my friend's either. I'm not just playing some random RPG's either. I'm a competitive level fighting game player (Street Fighter, Tekken) and my buddy can complete Guitar Hero 3 on expert...games that require about as pinpoint button timing as any out there. You'll find similar comments from other owners on here. I've seen those articles before and I just don't see it.
 
Still unsure as to why someone would go with plasma.. they have a short life span, are much more expensive and don't all of them run in non-standard resolutions (like 1024x768)?
 
Still unsure as to why someone would go with plasma.. they have a short life span, are much more expensive and don't all of them run in non-standard resolutions (like 1024x768)?

Do you live in an alternate world? Plasmas are roughly $300+ cheaper(most the time) then LCD. 60k-100k hour lifespans compared to what CRT used to be 30k? A 1080p Plasma runs the same res as a 1080p LCD.
 
Do you live in an alternate world? Plasmas are roughly $300+ cheaper(most the time) then LCD. 60k-100k hour lifespans compared to what CRT used to be 30k? A 1080p Plasma runs the same res as a 1080p LCD.

Whaa? Although I admit its been years since (up until recently) since I've looked at TV prices, but I assumed plasmas were still relatively more expensive than LCDs. A quick glance at newegg is showing plasmas with the same features as about $500-$900 more than the particular one I showed. I'm confused.. they still look more expensive, with less features (minus a few inches in size).
 
Whaa? Although I admit its been years since (up until recently) since I've looked at TV prices, but I assumed plasmas were still relatively more expensive than LCDs. A quick glance at newegg is showing plasmas with the same features as about $500-$900 more than the particular one I showed. I'm confused.. they still look more expensive, with less features (minus a few inches in size).

You're right in saying they're more expensive. The only LCDs more expensive are the LED backlit and 120Hz LCDs.

While plasmas have a few quirks like possible IR (this problem really depends on the brand...and new plasmas seem to be fairly unnaffected by it) and shorter lifespan than LCD, I think they have some major benefits. Great contrast and superb black levels are the reasons to go plasma. Black levels can make an absolutely huge difference when it comes to how natural the picture looks. Only LED backlit LCDs can compare in black levels.
 
Samsung LNT5271F 52" LCD.

I love mine. My wife and I looked at almost every brand of LCD and Plasma TV. We always came back to this TV. It is absolutely stunning. I have a PS3, a 360, and a Wii. They all look fantastic. Blu-Ray movies on the PS3 are gorgeous. The colors and black levels are great and you don't have to worry about IR like you do on a Plasma.

https://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/B000U9XMCE/km-20/ref=nosim

Now for the bad news, the 71f is a flawed set. I have one. Auto motion plus causes some wierd issues, everything from stuttering,TBE(Triple Ball Effect),ect. The new 650 series are out now as well, but I'm still not sure if Samsung has fixed the problems. There is a 700+ page thread on the AVSforum where you can read all about it! The set really does look good though, and has a lot of good things going for it as well. But it's an expensive set, so if your spending that kind of cash you'll want to hear about all the problems.
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
Now for the bad news, the 71f is a flawed set. I have one. Auto motion plus causes some wierd issues, everything from stuttering,TBE(Triple Ball Effect),ect. The new 650 series are out now as well, but I'm still not sure if Samsung has fixed the problems. There is a 700+ page thread on the AVSforum where you can read all about it! The set really does look good though, and has a lot of good things going for it as well. But it's an expensive set, so if your spending that kind of cash you'll want to hear about all the problems.

Is the Auto Motion plus a 120Hz processing option? If so, I always hated it...makes the image look extremely unnatural.
 
Is the Auto Motion plus a 120Hz processing option? If so, I always hated it...makes the image look extremely unnatural.

It's my understanding that the AMP is just frame interpolation. The set is 120hz though. It causes all sorts of artifacts though. I turn if off for most movies except animated or CG films. For that it looks incredible! Have not tried a 360 on it yet though...
 
Yeah I still can't get used to it in any 24Hz material. The interpolation does not work all that well IMO. Even though the framerate should make things look smoother and reduce motion blur, it just makes movement look unnaturally fast.
 
Now for the bad news, the 71f is a flawed set. I have one. Auto motion plus causes some wierd issues, everything from stuttering,TBE(Triple Ball Effect),ect. The new 650 series are out now as well, but I'm still not sure if Samsung has fixed the problems. There is a 700+ page thread on the AVSforum where you can read all about it! The set really does look good though, and has a lot of good things going for it as well. But it's an expensive set, so if your spending that kind of cash you'll want to hear about all the problems.

Correction, some are flawed. Mine was built in December of 07 and I have no stuttering or TBE issues at all. I'm not saying some people don't have problems but there are also some like me that don't. I have read and posted in the 71 series forum on AVS. You pretty much only hear from people who have had a problem with the set. Most of those people were those that bought a set prior to October 2007.

I run AMP on medium all the time. Looks great on HD cable, upscaled DVD, and Blu-Ray through my Onkyo 805.

As far as a projection LCD goes I don't think there is any comparison. I bought a 55" Sony LCD rear projection about 4 years ago (now the bedroom TV) and it pales in comparison to the Samsung 71 series.

If you want to go cheaper I would recommend the Samsung 65 series. I really think Samsung makes the best looking LCD's. Vizio and Westinghouse can't compare. You get what you pay for.

My 2 cents.........:cool:
 
Whaa? Although I admit its been years since (up until recently) since I've looked at TV prices, but I assumed plasmas were still relatively more expensive than LCDs. A quick glance at newegg is showing plasmas with the same features as about $500-$900 more than the particular one I showed. I'm confused.. they still look more expensive, with less features (minus a few inches in size).

Yes, plasma are cheaper than LCD. I just purchased a mid-high end 50" plasma (Panasonic TH-50PZ85U) for $2230. Most 46" LCDs of that level (46XBR4 or T4671F) are $2350-2500.
 
Yes, plasma are cheaper than LCD. I just purchased a mid-high end 50" plasma (Panasonic TH-50PZ85U) for $2230. Most 46" LCDs of that level (46XBR4 or T4671F) are $2350-2500.

Panasonic makes very nice Plasma TV's. Great choice for a Plasma.
 
71 series owner here. I had issues with my initial set, but everything is fine now. Using it as a computer monitor as well
 
i have had both a 42 dell plasma and now a 47 in toshila 1080p lcs. IMO picture quality is excellent on both. the kicker for me was power useage. My 42in plasma had a 320 watt psu while my 47 in lcd, although larger has only a 183 watt psu. i pd 1499 plust tax for the 1080p lcd on sale.
 
Vizio owner here, a 42" LCD at 1080i. They no longer sell 1080i, due to advertisements and dumb consumers. It was $750 when I picked it up six months ago, and I love it! The first had some connection issues (component cables were loose and would fall out the back), but returned it and love the second. XBox 360 through HDMI, Wii through component, PS2 through A/V, DVR through VGA. I especially love that that the TV has SPDIF out, so I route everything to the TV, then audio out to my receiver for surround.

You get what you pay for, but for the Vizio that mostly falls under the built in audio. The speakers are HORRIBLE! Day one, I turned the built-in speakers off and routed through my home theater. Picture quality is very good.
 
Back
Top