build your own SSD for cheap

Is there a CF adapter that can run at rev. 3.0 or 4.0? I've wanted to do this, but the speeds of the rev. 2.0 are a little to slow to run on a desktop or laptop.
 
Even though Rev 4 of CF allows a maximum throughput of 133MB/s, that's the interface, not the flash itself.

The reason why CF cards are so much cheaper than commercial SSDs is because the flash cells are cheaper and slower, and because the card doesn't have a sophisticated controller. They also don't support wear leveling. I think using CF for a system disk right now is a bad idea.

It won't be too terribly long until middling-performance SSDs become affordable. I'm going to guess that improvements to MLC NAND and controllers will make 100MB/s read, 50MB/s write consumer SSDs cost about $5/GB by the end of the year. Heck, OCZ's SLC SSDs are only $~18.75/GB and SLC is the expensive kind of NAND. If Intel, STEC, and others manage to make MLC controllers that work well, $5/GB is not at all unlikely.
 
I've been running CF cards in my Linux firewalls for years now. I did a most of my research into doing this long term right after college in 2002. Even the CF to IDE converter he has pictured in the article is identical to the one I got back then. I guess it just annoys me that this article makes this sound new when this has been the easy and affordable way to make SSDs for well over 5 years now.

The good news is that I have a flash card that has been running constantly since 2002 and it still works perfectly.
 
I've been running CF cards in my Linux firewalls for years now. I did a most of my research into doing this long term right after college in 2002. Even the CF to IDE converter he has pictured in the article is identical to the one I got back then. I guess it just annoys me that this article makes this sound new when this has been the easy and affordable way to make SSDs for well over 5 years now.

The good news is that I have a flash card that has been running constantly since 2002 and it still works perfectly.

I give you props for your 2002 SSD usage, however, this type of setup IS new to the average consumer. Most people just look at standard HDDs and never think twice, and you usually have to dig a bit further to begin seeing SSDs, even now. After they work out the kinks, and the price falls, this alternative will definitely be reasonable. I understand your frusteration, though, as people are just now 'discovering' and attempting to take credit.

I found the article pretty useful, as I was planning to test SSDs myself. Thanks OP.
 
Just went to my local fry's and bought the syba cf to ide adapter. I also bought a pqi 100x 8gb cf. I was surprised after the setup, I found out the adapter supports udma mode 4. My cf only goes up to 14MB/sec though :rolleyes:. Fry's didn't have the a-data 8gb 266x, that would've been sweet :D. Maybe I should return the pqi and wait for the a-data. Write speed was pretty slow at 9MB/sec.
 
Of course if you Raid 0 half a dozen or so, that would help with the read/write speeds.

Don
 
looks cool, would make a great little scratch drive or something.
also would be good for something that does alot of small file transactions.
id be curious to see how that works with some sort of transactional database setup. (lots of small file writes/reads)
 
I have a few of those dual CF to IDE adapters.
 
Of course if you Raid 0 half a dozen or so, that would help with the read/write speeds.

Don

I was thinking about this the other day- wouldn't that be a cost effective way to get some good speed? Four 133x CF cards would cost about $100, and each gets 20mb/s write speed. So you could theoretically get 80mb/s sustained write with 16gb, wouldn't that be pretty fast? Especially for an SSD?

Or, spend another $100 and have 32gb at 160mb/s?

There must be something wrong with this theory, it seems too easy. It would be a hassle without sata, though, because all of those ribbon cables would be so cluttered.

EDIT: Wow, I really don't read. The article has a card that holds 4 in raid. Nevermind.
 
Meh, I used a CF-IDE adapter in my iOpener in 2002. Eventually the CF died due to over-writes. Not exactly a new idea. I saw the dual CF adapters a few months ago when looking to possibly make a SSD. I was going to use an old PCI Promise ATA RAID controller, but cheap CF cards with decent speeds and capacity aren't easy to find. I figured I could get 30MB/sec, but it would cost more and offer less performance than even a laptop HDD. Plus, it's not a space or power limitation in a desktop and the CPU and PSU fan have eliminated the ability for a silent computer, so I just didn't want to spend the money on a tecnology demonstration. Good job for Guru of 3D showing this, but in most cases this isn't practical.
 
Just out of curiosity, how long did the CF card last before it died? They always talk about the limited life, but I've never heard from anybody who actually had one die on them. I think the novelty of CF drives wears off before the card wears out, heh.

My GF has a laptop with a 1.8" drive that is slllooooowww, so I'm always thinking of ways to get a fast CF card in there, but it almost seems like an oxymoron. I also liked the idea of a CF drive for my mini-itx computer since its tiny, but I'm quickly finding that there are very few circumstances in which CF would be more beneficial than a plain old laptop drive.
 
Too bad he didn't have cheap, fast CF available. You can buy 8GB 266x models (38MB/s) at newegg for $87 shipped. I can get them even cheaper locally at Fry's on sale (~$50). Slightly slower 233x (33MB/s) 16GB CF cards are available for around $80 when they are in stock. http://www.meritline.com/ridata-16g-233x-cf-card.html

I have a couple of those cheap CF to IDE adapters and they work pretty good. A 133x CF or a microdrive (what I have connected to mine) aren't as fast as a hard drive, but it works.
 
Just out of curiosity, how long did the CF card last before it died? They always talk about the limited life, but I've never heard from anybody who actually had one die on them. I think the novelty of CF drives wears off before the card wears out, heh.

I got about 3 months out of it. Swap drives/virtual memory make too many read/writes. You need to disable the virtual memory to keep the number of writes down. I also think that this was before wear leveling was built in, so it would pound one particular area of the CF until eventually it died and took the whole card with it.
 
What's faster: a CF to IDE or a USB 2.0 stick?

USB 2.0 = 480 Mbps = 60 MB/sec

This is the theoretical maximum and doesn't count overhead or take CPU use into account. Most (all?) USB flash isn't fast enough to keep up with the USB spec - about 33 MB/s is the maximum I've seen, with 20 MB/sec still considered very good, 10 MB/sec average, and 6 MB/sec the cheap stuff.
 
Back
Top