Pentagon Bans Google Teams From Bases

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The Associated Press is saying that the Pentagon has banned Google Earth teams from making detailed street level video maps of U.S. military bases. Umm, was this even a question? Was Google actually going to try to map U.S. bases? Does anyone think mapping our bases is a good idea?

A message sent to all Defense Department bases and installations around the country late last week told officials to not allow the popular mapping Web site from taking panoramic views inside the facilities.
 
The funny thing is that we are just now starting to acquiring Google Earth as a tool to use for Commercial Exploitation Teams to create unclassified maps.
 
Seems like mapping out military bases and stuff to make it public info on the web would be treason or espionage, punishable by death. I don't even know why they'd attempt to do so. Our enemies shouldn't know where every door and window is in all the buildings. (even though they already might through their own intelligence gathering capabilities)
 
I can both agree and disagree with these points, the google teams aren't blocked from using aerial satellite imagery just the google street level stuff. Can't associate building numbers and units with overhead aerial shots and stuff.
 
Military bases are crazy boring.

+1

and being a guy with no affiliation to the army... that drives through the one of the biggest ones on the planet a couple times a day... you can totally see why they'd want to map at least the main roads and highways going through the bases.... the people who gaurd the restricted areas of army bases aren't going to need "the Pentagon" to give them direction on whether to allow ANYBODY through... least of which some guys who aren't keeping secrets about how their intent is to take lots and lots of pictures and post them to the internet for anyone in the world to see

puhlleeeeeze...... now news atall
 
Hey, terrorists, this way to the post General's house. Not that it would be hard to get that info through other means, but I would really rather it was not available via Google maps. Not just for terrorist reason, but also because of the home grown, (I want peace so I must kill you and your family), wacko's. I have seen a few less than peaceful, peace demonstrations.
 
It's not just government buildings under threat. I find it a huge invasion of privacy. My cousin's garage door was open when they drove by and you could see his collection of cars in there. Obviously any neighbor driving by can see it, but Google is posting it for the whole world... Gone in 60 Seconds anybody? ;)
 
+1

and being a guy with no affiliation to the army... that drives through the one of the biggest ones on the planet a couple times a day... you can totally see why they'd want to map at least the main roads and highways going through the bases.... the people who gaurd the restricted areas of army bases aren't going to need "the Pentagon" to give them direction on whether to allow ANYBODY through... least of which some guys who aren't keeping secrets about how their intent is to take lots and lots of pictures and post them to the internet for anyone in the world to see

puhlleeeeeze...... now news atall

The roads can be completely mapped from an aerial overhead view, the security concern comes when they try to map at street level because details that aren't observable from an aerial view become visible from street level. Exact building locations, building numbers, names, entrance locations, etc. that although not classified do fall under the realm of OPSEC concerns.
 
It's not just government buildings under threat. I find it a huge invasion of privacy. My cousin's garage door was open when they drove by and you could see his collection of cars in there. Obviously any neighbor driving by can see it, but Google is posting it for the whole world... Gone in 60 Seconds anybody? ;)


Is there a big underground need for Wayne's World Pacer replica's?
 
It's not just government buildings under threat. I find it a huge invasion of privacy. My cousin's garage door was open when they drove by and you could see his collection of cars in there. Obviously any neighbor driving by can see it, but Google is posting it for the whole world... Gone in 60 Seconds anybody? ;)

Yeah...because a car thief is going to go that far....watch more tv.....lol.
 
It's not just government buildings under threat. I find it a huge invasion of privacy. My cousin's garage door was open when they drove by and you could see his collection of cars in there. Obviously any neighbor driving by can see it, but Google is posting it for the whole world... Gone in 60 Seconds anybody? ;)

Yeah, that is messed up!



So where does your cousin live, exactly? :confused: ;)
 
It's not just government buildings under threat. I find it a huge invasion of privacy. My cousin's garage door was open when they drove by and you could see his collection of cars in there. Obviously any neighbor driving by can see it, but Google is posting it for the whole world... Gone in 60 Seconds anybody? ;)

I was watching that car pass by when they toke the pictures. I also had my garage door open because I just when out and got the mail.
 
well google already has mapped several bases. i live on one and my house is mapped via street view. i was surprised that the car was allowed on post but the pictures are of my house in every detail

D
 
I guess google is just finding a bit more money in China these days....
 
I can see where looking at detailed maps of military installations is a bad thing.

thats_where_it_is.jpg
 
Hey, terrorists, this way to the post General's house. Not that it would be hard to get that info through other means, but I would really rather it was not available via Google maps. Not just for terrorist reason, but also because of the home grown, (I want peace so I must kill you and your family), wacko's. I have seen a few less than peaceful, peace demonstrations.

all the bases i have been have nice signs everywhere directing you to where everything is... its like, blah blah to the left... criticle design flaw in the deathstar to the right... etc
 
Seriously, who at google thought that this would be a good idea?
 
Let's see the Google Earth team go into N. Korea and map out Kim Jung il's military bases...

Let's see how successful they will be then...
Maybe they can go see if Mugabee will allow them access to map....
 
I especailly like the layout of security forces on the roof of the Whitehouse. Nothing like showing the positioning of the snipers and the stinger missle boyz.

Where was this concern when they were making the satelite views available? At least make the enemy spend the $billions it takes to put thier own damn spy satelites up, rather than letting them use your own against you.

As usual, this adminstration wouldn't know security if it landed on thier fat heads. :eek::rolleyes::p
 
Military bases are crazy boring.
I've mapped a military base. The base itself was boring. The range area was definitely not. Burned out tanks, international exercises going on, experimental areas with all kinds of crazy shit. It was the most interesting few weeks of work I've ever had. Lost 3 tires to shrapnel at once driving through the tank live-fire area after an exercise :D
 
If you've got nothing to hide ;P

exactly, while i am a vocal advocate of civil privacy...the one place that ABSOLUTELY DEFINITELY SHOULD be mapped is anything to do with the military and government. Transparent government is the only government that should exist.
 
all the bases i have been have nice signs everywhere directing you to where everything is... its like, blah blah to the left... criticle design flaw in the deathstar to the right... etc

hahaha, no kidding.
 
exactly, while i am a vocal advocate of civil privacy...the one place that ABSOLUTELY DEFINITELY SHOULD be mapped is anything to do with the military and government. Transparent government is the only government that should exist.

Even to enemy forces? I can only hope you were being sarcastic.
 
Seems like all of the boogyman talk from the government is continuing to create fear....*sigh*
 
exactly, while i am a vocal advocate of civil privacy...the one place that ABSOLUTELY DEFINITELY SHOULD be mapped is anything to do with the military and government. Transparent government is the only government that should exist.

Only China, Venezuela, Iran, North Korea, would agree with you. I think the US is one of the few Armies who actually lets people get so close to thier bases... if you are caught taking even private pictures of a Chinese secrete facility, your head will roll.
 
Even to enemy forces? I can only hope you were being sarcastic.

*imaginary enemy forces....You think china's going to invade? Russia maybe? Because Al-qaeda fights with sticks, stones, and a few IEDs...They rarely get access to electricity let alone computers to map out stuff. Nobody's targeting anything in the middle of the US.
 
Seems like all of the boogyman talk from the government is continuing to create fear....*sigh*

exactly... "enemy forces" are only enemy forces because we can't leave them the hell alone. Instead we are just scared into hating a different target who is demonized and radicalized so that we can be scared into thinking "teh big evil" is coming for us and trying to take away this "wonderful freedom" we have......

as for sarcasm..not at all, transparent is what it should be...period. no subterfuge, spying, or any other underground stuff, If they want to be "safe" and be a military, openly make everything available. Why make it available? you can be just as secure by simply showing what you have if you are messed with.

i think that makes sense, i get pretty riled about govt stuff. I follow Jeffersonian principles for government and study the works of men like chomsky. frankly i'm more afraid of our own government and military than any "enemy force" they can fabricate.
 
Only China, Venezuela, Iran, North Korea, would agree with you. I think the US is one of the few Armies who actually lets people get so close to thier bases... if you are caught taking even private pictures of a Chinese secrete facility, your head will roll.

your head will roll in america too, "homegrown terror act of 2007"

basically take the wrong picture and you are on your way to gitmo under the guise of national security.

I will try to find the pamphlets passed out about reporting people who are taking photographs
 
*imaginary enemy forces....You think china's going to invade? Russia maybe? Because Al-qaeda fights with sticks, stones, and a few IEDs...They rarely get access to electricity let alone computers to map out stuff. Nobody's targeting anything in the middle of the US.

Yes, because lets not forget that 9/11 was done with sticks and stones :rolleyes:

your head will roll in america too, "homegrown terror act of 2007"

basically take the wrong picture and you are on your way to gitmo under the guise of national security.

I will try to find the pamphlets passed out about reporting people who are taking photographs

Actually no it wont, do yourself a favor and search for Area-51 on google maps, then do yourself a favor and do some google searches on secret bases, plenty of photos taken by regular joes.
 
Back
Top