Ok, I'm confused. Input lag vs Response Time

Overspeed

Limp Gawd
Joined
Feb 21, 2008
Messages
227
I'm in the market for an LCD for the first time, moving away from my NEC 22" CRT. For what it's worth I have my eye on the new Dell 2408WFP at present. Being new to the LCD realm, I've been doing my research on different panel types, manufacturers, and specifications. I decided on the Dell because it was an 8bit panel and S-PVA is said to produce best viewing angles, better color range and deeper blacks than TN's or S-IPS's. Now one thing every manufacturer advertises is the response time in ms. I always thought of this measurement as the time it takes for the pixels to shift colors. After reading more about LCD panels I have learned about input lag. And I thought of this as the difference in time it takes between mouse movement and screen response. Am I wrong on these two points? According to wiki, a S-IPS is the best for no to very little input lag, but suffer higher response times. So what I am wondering is what exactly is response time? What does this mean visually when playing a fast moving game for instance? What would I expect so see on a panel like S-IPS with a poor response time? I have no base of reference having never owned an LCD.

Today I went to my local computer store and played CS on an Acer P243Waid. This panel has 3000:1 contract and 2ms response and is TN. My thinking suggests this panel would be great in responding to my actions but I found that the delay in input was very noticeable. On my CRT, when I put my crosshairs on a baddy, that's exactly what happens. On this screen I was constantly overshooting the crosshairs position and had to correct. So I assume this is not bad response time but bad input lag? I thought it was awful and I'm confused why TN's are considered the gamers panel. I'm curious how the game would play on an Apple S-IPS. With no input lag, but bad response time, I have no clue what that actually means. I am hoping that you might shed some light on this for me.

Here's another thought. If a S-PVA panel has poor input lag, would that not mean that when I play a DVD for instance the audio would be out of sync with the picture? That would drive me crazy. I cannot find any PVA panels at local computers stores so I am going to rely on your feedback to help me understand. Much appreciated.
 
Now one thing every manufacturer advertises is the response time in ms. I always thought of this measurement as the time it takes for the pixels to shift colors.
Correct.
It's just often such vaguely measured that it doesn't tell much anything from real response time: "5ms" vs 16ms.
That ghosting behind moving object is what response time causes.

Input lag is delay between receiving image from graphic card and showing it on screen and is entirely separate from response time.
You'll find input lag measurements by selecting delay compared to CRT from "step 3"-menu.
And some more from here. (many latest 22" TNs are even with VAs in input lag)


And that "3000:1" is fraud called dynamic contrast which just blinks backlight basing to content of image and doesn't increase contrast between black and white in any way. (and brightness pumping up and down can be annoying)
 
Thanx for clearing that up E.T. On a different note, seems one of the main specs I was concerned about when choosing a S-PVA panel ... viewing angles ... has absolutely nothing to do with what I thought it was. I wanted a panel that had consistent colors when looking at it head on throughout the screen, and this has nothing to do with viewing angles .... this I'm told is color shift :p I had a look at a VA panel at best buy and it is exactly the same as their TN's. When I look at the VA panel dead on at 3 feet, while looking at a fully white screen, the center is nice and white while the edges have a yellow tint. I move my head so that I'm center with the right edge, and now the middle is yellow tint and the far left is a heavy yellow. The same was seen on an Apple S-IPS. So I guess this is a reality of all panel types. All of a sudden I don't care about VA's so much. I just wish there was a 24" TN 8bit for the color reproduction, that way I'd get the fast response times. I'll still order the 2408 from Dell, so I get the 8bit color and inputs.

Bottom line I guess is ALL panels are both loved and hated equally in the community as per each individuals needs and tastes. There is no "perfect" panel for all needs. My research is ending now and I'll take a shot and see how I like it. I'll post a review when I get it.

Thanx again
 
just a warning:

I personally do not consider the "deeper blacks" of the VA panels as an advantage compared to IPS, cause the VA panels also have black crush...

so although VA panels will display blacks that are darker then on IPS panels, you will see less detail in the darker regions. And for me at least, the amount of details seen in the darker regions is MUCH MUCH more important, then how deep the blacks are...

If anyone thinks I'm misunderstanding black crush: please let me know...
 
just a warning:

I personally do not consider the "deeper blacks" of the VA panels as an advantage compared to IPS, cause the VA panels also have black crush...

so although VA panels will display blacks that are darker then on IPS panels, you will see less detail in the darker regions. And for me at least, the amount of details seen in the darker regions is MUCH MUCH more important, then how deep the blacks are...

If anyone thinks I'm misunderstanding black crush: please let me know...

no, you're spot on.

well said.
 
Back
Top