New Build Time! Need Opinions/Suggestions!

WhiteZero

2[H]4U
Joined
Oct 21, 2004
Messages
3,638
Ok, so I've been holding off on making a new PC for a long time, but my current one pretty much just crapped out on me, so its time. I already have a monitor, so thats covered. Monitor is running @ 1680x1050
Heres what I'm lookin at:

Mobo: Asus Maximus Formula Intel X38 $259
[H] gave it a Gold award, and it OCs well, so I'm going with it.

CPU: Intel E8400 $224
Don't really need a Quad right now, since I'm only gaming. And people are pushing this thing over 4GHz on air. :)

RAM: G.Skill DDR2-1000 4GB (2x2GB) $114
I don't want to hassle with OCing my RAM, since it seems to be hit or miss, so this RAM will let me get a 4.5GHz OC on the CPU before having to alter the RAM.

PSU: PC Power & Cooling 610W $119
Little brother of the most well-reviewed PSU on AnandTech, I dont really need 700+ watts and this brand seems to be top tier.

VGA: eVGA GeForce 8800GTS (G92) 512MB $319
Good price on a great card. And with EVGA I'll have 3 months for Step-Up (if I dont send in the Mail in Rebate)

Case: Thermaltake Armor (with large window fan) $159
I'm not 100% on this case, but it seems to be a good choice. I really like the large window fan that'll blow directly on the mobo.

HDD: Western Digital 750GB AAKS model $154
Really fast hard drive. Benches faster than the Raptor in some cases.

Optical: Lite-On DVD DL Burner $37
Basic DVD burner drive, nothing special here.

CPU Heatsink: Thermalright Ultra Extreme 120 $55
Probably the best heatsink for air cooling, sure to help get a good OC.

Heatsink Fan: Scythe Slip-Steam 88CFM @ 33dBA $8
Newer Scythe model, getting good reviews

Total: About $1456 before shipping or Mail in Rebates
I'm counting on getting at least 4GHz out o that E8400, if not more.

Any recommendations for changing out parts or buying them from another e-tailer?
 
Setup looks good to me.

Mobo: Asus Maximus Formula Intel X38 $259
[H] gave it a Gold award, and it OCs well, so I'm going with it.
I personally would not spend $260 on an X38 when the P45 + ICH10 is coming in three months. ICH10 will be highly desirable.

CPU: Intel E8400 $224
Don't really need a Quad right now, since I'm only gaming. And people are pushing this thing over 4GHz on air. :)

RAM: G.Skill DDR2-1000 4GB (2x2GB) $114
I don't want to hassle with OCing my RAM, since it seems to be hit or miss, so this RAM will let me get a 4.5GHz OC on the CPU before having to alter the RAM.
Looks good to me.

PSU: PC Power & Cooling 610W $119
Little brother of the most well-reviewed PSU on AnandTech, I dont really need 700+ watts and this brand seems to be top tier.
Not familiar with that.

VGA: eVGA GeForce 8800GTS (G92) 512MB $319
Good price on a great card. And with EVGA I'll have 3 months for Step-Up (if I dont send in the Mail in Rebate)
Do you have a 24" 1920x1080 monitor? I hope so, because that graphics card is overkill for anything smaller.

With a 20-22" monitor, an overclocked 8800GT is more appropriate. You get 90+% of the performance for 65% of the price.

HDD: Western Digital 750GB AAKS model $154
Really fast hard drive. Benches faster than the Raptor in some cases.
Be aware that Western Digital is in the process of replacing the 250/500/750 AAKS with faster 320/640/1280 versions based on 320 gigabytes per platter. Anandtech will have a review posted soon.

From what I understand, the new models go by WD3200AAKS-00B3A0 and WD6400AAKS-00B3A0. The B3 tells you that it is a new 320Gb per platter drive.
 
Thanks for the input Ken. I would have liked to wait for P45, but like I said, my main PC is dead, so I need to build ASAP. Besides, you can always wait for the next big chipset, then I'd always be waiting.

As for the video card, I'm going to be running at 1680x1050, and after looking over some benches, I do see that the performance difference at this res isnt too big. So I guess I could bump the card down to the GT if you guys really think it'll be a better idea.

And thanks for the info on the hard drive. I'll have to look into it, but again, I do want to do this build with in about a week.
 
With the Newegg deal on the GTS right now, go for it. It runs cooler, it OCs better, it's quieter. Many people spend more on aftermarket cooling for their GTs than the price difference between the GT and GTS. It's not overkill if you're demanding (like me). For me an 8800GTX wasn't overkill at 1600x1200, though quiet a few people were saying I should go with a 640MB GTS -- never regretted that decision. I do wish I'd got a P35 instead of the 680i as I've yet to make use of SLI, though.

The Maximus is overkill of the worst sort, and ASUS customer support is some of the worst in the industry. You only need a P35, so get a nice one. I recommend the DFI LanParty P35 Dark P35-TR2S for $140 shipped most highly. Could also look at the Abit IP35-Pro and Gigabyte P35-DS3R and DQ6 boards. There is /zero/ reason to get an X38 board unless you're making use of CrossfireX... and you aren't. The P35s OC just as well, and they run cooler.

If you can get the Corsair 620HX for the same or less than the Silencer, go with that. It uses a 120mm fan so it's quieter, it's modular whereas the Silencer is not, and it's rated for 620 watts at 50C vs. 610 watts at 40C for the Silencer. Both have 5 year warranties.
 
With the Newegg deal on the GTS right now, go for it. It runs cooler, it OCs better, it's quieter. Many people spend more on aftermarket cooling for their GTs than the price difference between the GT and GTS.

The Maximus is overkill of the worst sort, and ASUS customer support is some of the worst in the industry. You only need a P35. I recommend the DFI LanParty P35 Dark P35-TR2S for $140 shipped most highly. Could also look at the Abit IP35-Pro and Gigabyte P35-DS3R and DQ6 boards. There is /zero/ reason to get an X38 board unless you're making use of CrossfireX... and you aren't. The P35s OC just as well, and they run cooler.

If you can get the Corsair 620HX for the same or less than the Silencer, go with that. It uses a 120mm fan so it's quieter, it's modular whereas the Silencer is not, and it's rated for 620 watts at 50C vs. 610 watts at 40C for the Silencer. Both have 5 year warranties.

Well, really the only reason I wanted to go with X38 is for PCIe 2.0, and thats because 2 years down the road, if I decide to upgrade my video card, I would think most video cards down the road will only fully perform on PCIe 2.0. But if you guys dont think so, and I can get the same performance and lower price with P45, then I'd probably go for the IP35 Pro.

I'll look into and consider the Corsair 620HX, but the Silencer seems to be well known for really good stability. Is that Corsair very reliable and stable?
 
Well, really the only reason I wanted to go with X38 is for PCIe 2.0, and thats because 2 years down the road, if I decide to upgrade my video card, I would think most video cards down the road will only fully perform on PCIe 2.0. But if you guys dont think so, and I can get the same performance and lower price with P45, then I'd probably go for the IP35 Pro.

I'll look into and consider the Corsair 620HX, but the Silencer seems to be well known for really good stability. Is that Corsair very reliable and stable?

They're both built by Seasonic. Pretty much the same unit, though the Corsairs use higher temperature rated capacitors.

I look at it this way with the motherboards. You're ready to spend $260+ on a board right now. For $140 you can get the same performance and it'll run cooler now.

In 2 years we'll be past the point of socket change -- S775 is dead after the 45nm die shrink. Nehelim (I'm spelling it wrong) will use a new socket and likely require DDR3, so trying to future-proof right now makes little sense. Waiting is also pretty much out of the question, as we're still talking ~1 year from now before the socket change. End result: P35. Don't worry about it. If you decide you /must/ have PCIe 2.0 in ~6 months you can sell your board and buy a P45 or X48 board.
 
I concur with silent-circuit on all points and recommendations.

@ silent-circuit
It's spelled: Nehalem :)
 
They're both built by Seasonic. Pretty much the same unit, though the Corsairs use higher temperature rated capacitors.

I look at it this way with the motherboards. You're ready to spend $260+ on a board right now. For $140 you can get the same performance and it'll run cooler now.

In 2 years we'll be past the point of socket change -- S775 is dead after the 45nm die shrink. Nehelim (I'm spelling it wrong) will use a new socket and likely require DDR3, so trying to future-proof right now makes little sense. Waiting is also pretty much out of the question, as we're still talking ~1 year from now before the socket change. End result: P35. Don't worry about it. If you decide you /must/ have PCIe 2.0 in ~6 months you can sell your board and buy a P45 or X48 board.

qft
 
Despite the above appeals to reason I am so struck by the pure badassnissity of the build list I just made for some random guy that I must share here. Consider this the devil on your shoulder to my earlier angel. ;)

$270 - Q6600 G0 CPU (ClubIT.com)
$50 ($40 AR, $10 MIR) - ZeroTherm Nirvana NV120 HSF (NewEgg.com)
$155 - Corsair 750 TX PSU
$800 - 2x Radeon HD 3870GX2 graphics cards @ ~$400 each, look around for deals.
$230 ($200 AR, $30 MIR) - Abit IX38 Quad GT motherboard (NewEgg.com)
$90 ($70 AR, $20 MIR) - 4GB (2x2GB) OCZ Vista Upgrade Edition DDR2-800 CAS5 RAM (NewEgg.com)
$115 - Seagate 500GB SATA 7200.11 HDD (look around)
$30 - Samsung 20x SATA DVDRW (look around)
$75 - Antec P182 case (Amazon.com)

$1661 before shipping, not counting the rebates, ~$1640 when all is said and done.
 
Ok, so I've changed the mobo to the IP35 Pro and the PSU to the Corsair 620HX. So the price is knocked down to about $1280.

I think I'll still keep the 8800GTS.
 
Ok, so I've changed the mobo to the IP35 Pro and the PSU to the Corsair 620HX. So the price is knocked down to about $1280.

I think I'll still keep the 8800GTS.
For any CPU except the E8x00 series, the IP35 Pro is the best "overall" motherboard on the market, imo. The current firmware still doesn't fully support the Penryn E8x00 CPUs. That may or may not be fixed in the next two weeks.

If Abit can fix those compatibility problems, then I agree the IP35 Pro is the board to get. Its fan control options are pretty much unmatched; with the IP35 Pro, you can set the voltage for each fan header independently, depending on current temperature of the CPU/NB/VRM. This allows you to run fan headers at a silent 6w while idle, and 8-12w when certain temps increase (i.e. during gaming) without the need for any software.
 
Heatsink Fan: Scythe Slip-Steam 88CFM @ 33dBA $8
I'm not sure the verdict is out on that fan yet. That fan definitely pushes more air than other 1600rpm fans when unobstructed, but I haven't seen any reviews that comment on its ability to push air through a heatsink. It may or may not outperform the current (previous?) champ -- Scythe S-Flex.

The Scythe S-Flex is still the fan of choice for overclocking at Extremesystems.org.
 
For any CPU except the E8x00 series, the IP35 Pro is the best "overall" motherboard on the market, imo. The current firmware still doesn't fully support the Penryn E8x00 CPUs. That may or may not be fixed in the next two weeks.

Well, some of the people posting their OC results on this forum were using the IP35 Pro, so I assume it works fairly well. I'll have to check that Abit forum link when I'm off work.
 
I agree with Silent-Circuit, Danny Bui, and Enginurd on all points. The Maximus Formula is a great board, and would be the one to get if I were to go X38, but I would only go X38 if I were building a Crossfire 3870 x2 rig. In all other cases, P35 is a better bet, especially since LGA-775 will be eol'd at the end of the year.
 
I'll go with P35, and just hope that down the line PCIe 2.0 wont be required to get full performance out of new video cards.
 
Despite the above appeals to reason I am so struck by the pure badassnissity of the build list I just made for some random guy that I must share here. Consider this the devil on your shoulder to my earlier angel. ;)

$270 - Q6600 G0 CPU (ClubIT.com)
$50 ($40 AR, $10 MIR) - ZeroTherm Nirvana NV120 HSF (NewEgg.com)
$155 - Corsair 750 TX PSU
$800 - 2x Radeon HD 3870GX2 graphics cards @ ~$400 each, look around for deals.
$230 ($200 AR, $30 MIR) - Abit IX38 Quad GT motherboard (NewEgg.com)
$90 ($70 AR, $20 MIR) - 4GB (2x2GB) OCZ Vista Upgrade Edition DDR2-800 CAS5 RAM (NewEgg.com)
$115 - Seagate 500GB SATA 7200.11 HDD (look around)
$30 - Samsung 20x SATA DVDRW (look around)
$75 - Antec P182 case (Amazon.com)

$1661 before shipping, not counting the rebates, ~$1640 when all is said and done.

I'm wondering if drivers are available for CF 3870 X2, as everywhere I've searched in indicates that drivers supporting CF X won't be available until March.
 
I'm wondering if drivers are available for CF 3870 X2, as everywhere I've searched in indicates that drivers supporting CF X won't be available until March.

I'm reasonably certain they work in CFX and you're thinking of the hybrid drivers to allow an X2 and a regular 3870 to play nice, though I could be wrong. In that case, the OP should buy one now and the second once drivers are available. Should be slightly cheaper anyway.
 
Ok, so I just pulled the trigger on this build. I wound up with:
IP35 Pro
Intel 8400
4GB G.Skill DDR2-1000
Corsair 620HX
eVGA 8800GTS 512 (hopefully with free Crysis)
Western Digital 750GB AAKS
Thermalright Ultima 90 + Scythe S-Flex fan
Thermaltake Armor case with 25cm side fan
Lite-On SATA DVD RW Drive

Hope I made the right decision.
 
Oh, and I have $100 in mail-in rebates as well. :D
All of which today was the last day they are eligible.
 
Ok, so I just pulled the trigger on this build. I wound up with:
IP35 Pro
Intel 8400
4GB G.Skill DDR2-1000
Corsair 620HX
eVGA 8800GTS 512 (hopefully with free Crysis)
Western Digital 750GB AAKS
Thermalright Ultima 90 + Scythe S-Flex fan
Thermaltake Armor case with 25cm side fan
Lite-On SATA DVD RW Drive

Hope I made the right decision.
I'm not familiar with that case, but otherwise that looks like an excellent system. Just be prepared to flash the IP35 Pro bios as soon as you get it.

Hopefully, Abit will have refined their E8400 support by the time you receive the board and get everything setup.
 
I'm not familiar with that case, but otherwise that looks like an excellent system. Just be prepared to flash the IP35 Pro bios as soon as you get it.

Hopefully, Abit will have refined their E8400 support by the time you receive the board and get everything setup.

Yeah, I'm keeping up with the large thread on Abit's forums about the issue: http://forums.abit-usa.com/showthread.php?t=133649&page=13
I sure hope they fix it soon. Else I'll just wait on overclocking.

What 120mm fan did you get for the case?
I didnt buy any fans for the case, it has them built in. Heres all the specs:
http://thermaltakeusa.com/product/Chassis/fulltower/armor/va8003bws.asp
 
Back
Top