680i or 780i

vengence

Level capped
Joined
Nov 7, 2007
Messages
18,469
I'm building a new rig, going with one of the new E8400s with 2 8800GTs (maybe the GTS havn't finalized that yet) and some DDR2. I'm not going to TRI-SLI, I just want do normal SLI. Is there any reason to get a 780i? I may end up OCing the 8400 so I want my board to be able to do that, outside of that I don't need the ultra-extreme-super-delux-extra-epeen-of-DOOM version of a board. It's primary use will be for gaming, although I will run math programs as well. Any need for the 780i? If not then any suggestions on a 680i board? I'm really crossing the waters on this build as my old system was AMD+ATI so unfamiliar with "the dark side". Any imput would be appreciated.
 
I have the EXACT situation. Little help from the more edjumacated peeps out there?
I was trying to decide btwn the P5N32-E and the P5N-T from Asus.

TIA

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DAMN READ READ AND READ AGAIN!!!
 
If you want SLI then I would spend the extra and get 780i, due to from what I heard it is more stable than the 680i...and 680i can be very unstable at times as stories u hear from here and other places. I know if I would of waited to build my rig I would of went for the 780i instead of 680i. Plus having all the "extra" features like Tri-SLI is a bonus if you wish to do so in the future.
 
I'm really wondering how "future proof" the 780i will be. If I knew when I was upgrading in 18 months that I wouldn't upgrade it too I wouldn't have a problem slapping down the $$$. But on the other hand, I'm getting real sticker shock when I'm looking at a E8400 at 225ish (early bird premium :() and a 300-350$ mobo. I'm willing to pay it if it's worth it, but thats the question, is it going to be worth it long term? My understanding is that if I'm going to SLI I have to go nvidia chipset and if I'm planning to get the next gen hardware this fall they're probably gonna be offered in PCI-E2.0 versions and the 680i doesn't have PCI-E2.0 Is that right? or I dunno I'm all confused now...:confused:
 
Have to understand, technology has no such thing as future proofing. If you need something you buy it right now, no matter what it is.
 
definitely 780i. I love mine, and you can definitely get it for around 270usd if you look
 
750i? God and I thought I was confused before....:(

It's a trap.

I thought building my dream rig was going to be fun, it's more like analysis paralysis and confusion of doom.

Are there any brands to avoid on nVidia chipsets? (Obviously ECS but other than that I suppose.) I've seen some good reviews of the ASUS Striker II. Saw a review from the same site and they thought the P5N-T was decent but the striker was better.
 
it really isn't all that confusing. I would just get a reference 780i board since there seems to be no issues with them so far. Evga or XFX would be my choice.
 
I think I've decided on the XFX 780i, saw a good review on it somewhere.

So now the build contains
Case- P182
E8400
8800GTSx2 (g92) BFG
XFX 780i mobo
4 Gig DDR2 RAM (model undecided yet)
Anything else I should think about? Oh, will I get an SLI connector with my V.cards or Mobo or will I need to buy one seperate? I guess I can look at the parts list on newegg
 
I have a 680i board that I bought last November, now running triple SLI like it was built for it.(ASUS P5N32-E SLI) has been rock solid since I bought it and runs triple SLi very well.
My only complaint is it doesnt OC the Quad core very well at all.
Reviews on the ASUS P5N-T Deluxe are not overwhelming, it doesnt OC well and is unstable apparently. ( I was thinking hard on getting this one)
The XFX 780i board has gotten some very good reviews.

To answer your question, a 780i board will come with the triple and plain SLI connectors.
If you bought a 680i board you'd need to buy a triple SLI connector. I got mine from BFG for 10 bucks.
Just remember, at this time, triple Sli only works if you have 8800 GTX or Ultra cards.
 
Yeah, I'm not looking to tri-SLI now, however I know I'm going to be VERY tempted when the "true next gen" cards come out. (The new tech, not the repackaging, relabeling, Die shrinking, 9800GX2, etc of the 8800 series) But seeing as they may never hit the shelves I'll have plenty of timeto save between now and then:D
 
DO NOT PURCHASE EITHER OF THE ASUS BOARDS!!

Read the Asus forum first on these boards, so you do not run into the issues that plague this model.

1.) Intel quad issues.
2.) Memory problems.
3.) Crashing.
4.) Freezing.

This board is not a good choice at the moment. Asus really has no clue what is going on with these boards. The forums are plagued with issues and Asus has already released numerous bios updates which have not been able to fix the issues. I would suggest to wait for the Striker 2's or a proper bios release.

If you can not wait go with EVGA or XFX on the 780i side.
 
a lot of 680i issues showed up after launch, 780i uses the same silicone. Wait for a bit then make the call.
 
a lot of 680i issues showed up after launch, 780i uses the same silicone. Wait for a bit then make the call.

680i was pretty horrible right at launch. Some of the other problems weren't evident immediately, but for the most part, they sucked from the beginning and got better with time
 
I've had the evga 780i board for a few days now and I haven't had any problems. One thing to check is the whole heat pipe assembly though. I was in the bios hardware monitor and I noticed the temp was really high on the NB so I pushed it down a little, heard a click and the temperatures immediately dropped. Other than that it's been very stable
 
No kidding.
Well the 680i SLI is still a pretty shaky product even 14 or 15 months later. If you don't need or want SLI I'd skip them entirely. Scratch that, the 650i Ultra, 650i SLI and 680i LT are pretty solid. However they are not any better than their Intel counterparts so there is very little reason to go for the NVIDIA 600 series when a better option exists.

yup my 650i is pretty stable.. well its only been 4 months may die later on :( Planning on upgrading to 780i very soon too
 
Ah crap... Wondering if I just made a huge mistake. Ordered an EVGA nForce 780i SLI this afternoon to pair up with an E8400 and 8G of RAM. I tossed back and forth, thinking I might go SLI somewhere down the road.

Am I getting ready to crawl through broken glass? My last nVidia chipset mainboard (LanParty nf4 sli-dr) treated me very well. First time since my 400mhz P2 that I've been on the Intel side for a desktop system.
 
Ah crap... Wondering if I just made a huge mistake. Ordered an EVGA nForce 780i SLI this afternoon to pair up with an E8400 and 8G of RAM. I tossed back and forth, thinking I might go SLI somewhere down the road.

Am I getting ready to crawl through broken glass? My last nVidia chipset mainboard (LanParty nf4 sli-dr) treated me very well. First time since my 400mhz P2 that I've been on the Intel side for a desktop system.

I have had no problems with 780i and 8gb of ram. Mind you 680i was god awful. But whatever voltage regulation problem or whatever else was killing everyone's 680i board has since been fixed, or at least it appears so.
 
I'd recommend purchasing the newegg replacement plan. After dealing with the 680i and RMAing through evga only to receive worse (used) boards in exchange replacement plans are worth it IMO (especially with new hardware).
 
My EVGA 680i never gave me any problems and tomorrow I'm shipping it off to Brea, California for the 780i step-up.

When I first purchased the board I did clean up the thermal putty, yeah it was putty, from the southbridge and MCP.

http://picasaweb.google.com/drjester/EVGA680iThermalpasteGoop/photo#5044036264003782386

I read the 780i was much better as far as thermal goop went, has any one else here removed the cooling setup on that board and checked it?
 
Do the 780i boards still throw C1 errors? I was ready to attack something as 680i board after 680i board threw those terrible C1s at me. I went through two evga 680i and one asus p5n32-e sli. None of them every actually functioned correctly with the corsair 8500C5D dominators in them, more than half of the post attempts failed with a C1 error.
 
Do the 780i boards still throw C1 errors? I was ready to attack something as 680i board after 680i board threw those terrible C1s at me. I went through two evga 680i and one asus p5n32-e sli. None of them every actually functioned correctly with the corsair 8500C5D dominators in them, more than half of the post attempts failed with a C1 error.

Well I'll be finding out shortly. I'm going to try some of that RAM on a EVGA 780i SLI later this after noon.
 
I read somewhere that the 680i boards had/have issues with 4 sticks of RAM, do the 780i boards run into the same issue? I'm looking to upgrade, and skip the whole 680i if possible.
 
I read somewhere that the 680i boards had/have issues with 4 sticks of RAM, do the 780i boards run into the same issue? I'm looking to upgrade, and skip the whole 680i if possible.

The 780i supports up to 8GB of DDR2 Running at 1066mhz. Anything above that is pushing it.
 
I read somewhere that the 680i boards had/have issues with 4 sticks of RAM, do the 780i boards run into the same issue? I'm looking to upgrade, and skip the whole 680i if possible.

I know quite a few people on the eVGA forums report no problems with all four slots full, particularly when using 8GB of ram.

As an aside, I'm loving my 780i. I hope there's more love for it on [H]ardforums soon.
 
Well I'll be finding out shortly. I'm going to try some of that RAM on a EVGA 780i SLI later this after noon.

Well I have probably been one of the first adopters on the forum and so far so good. Right now my machine has been up for 7 straight days quad priming and chugging along. Then again the only major thing I am ocing on my board is the cpu. The ram and all other voltages are set to stock or the lowest possible voltages.
 
So I finally went with the XFX 780i. Looks like all my stuff will come in tommorow, I'll probably start a new thread with pics and results. It's a E8400 that I'm going to try to leave at 4.5 GHz long term on air (ultra 120 extreme cooler) to match it I got the 2 G92 GTSs and 4 Gigs of 1066 DDR2. Hope it all goes well and is stable. I might cry if the CPU doesn't over clock, or I might just e-bay it and try again. :D
 
Usually the reference boards overclock well. The problem is that they are a pain in the ass with RAM compatibility and their longevity is in question. I've looked at the 780i SLI reference design and while it is better than the 680i SLI reference design in some ways it largely suffers from the same failings. I'm not sure if highly overclocked 780i SLI boards will suffer a similar failure rate compared to the 680i SLI reference boards.
 
Well I have probably been one of the first adopters on the forum and so far so good. Right now my machine has been up for 7 straight days quad priming and chugging along. Then again the only major thing I am ocing on my board is the cpu. The ram and all other voltages are set to stock or the lowest possible voltages.

Again it took a couple of months to find out how unreliable the 680i SLI reference boards were.
 
Again it took a couple of months to find out how unreliable the 680i SLI reference boards were.

Thats true, but I want to get my credit card debt killed off now so I am selling my EVGA 780i board off and other 8800gtx. When i do post the board for sale It will have the advanced exchange warranty added on which included Saturday delivery. Just fyi guys.
 
I'm usually a huge fan of Asus...I've been buying their boards for close to a decade...with an abit and a msi board thrown in every now and again...but I have gotten 3 bum Asus 680i boards in a row from them(thank god for fry's return policy)

First one would not post at all
Second one posted with 1 stick of ram, I attempted to install windows, but it was incredibly slow. then it stopped working all together.
Third one let windows install with 2 sticks of ram, but then one of the caps on the board near the ps/2 connectors popped (fortunally I was near and the case was open at teh time)
and shut it down fast.
I am going tomorrow and exchange it for a 780i xfx board and try to get my damn system up.
 
I'm usually a huge fan of Asus...I've been buying their boards for close to a decade...with an abit and a msi board thrown in every now and again...but I have gotten 3 bum Asus 680i boards in a row from them(thank god for fry's return policy)

First one would not post at all
Second one posted with 1 stick of ram, I attempted to install windows, but it was incredibly slow. then it stopped working all together.
Third one let windows install with 2 sticks of ram, but then one of the caps on the board near the ps/2 connectors popped (fortunally I was near and the case was open at teh time)
and shut it down fast.
I am going tomorrow and exchange it for a 780i xfx board and try to get my damn system up.

My ASUS Striker Extreme is a shitty overclocker but it has never let me down. It has trouble running RAM past 800MHz speeds but its' better than the 10 reference 680i SLI boards I've fried.
 
Based on what I have read, I would go with a 780i simply because it's just a more mature 680i and offers a little bit more future protection.

Honestly, I would have to say that you should consider foregoing the SLI idea and going with an X48. I have a feeling that you will see dual 8800GT(s) on one board coming up soon to compete with ATIs part. It has been shown in the past that SLI is not a cost effective way to gain performance over time. A perfect example is me with a 8800gts 320...upgrading with another one is a bad idea because performance will be mixed depending on titles, power consumption doubles, cost is not great, heat is increased, more clutter in my case and so on.

Essentially, what I am saying is that you shouldn't let SLI determine what chipset you get, unless you really have an SLI fetish.
 
Back
Top