Phenom VS. Intel Quadcores (Q6600) ?

Then we wouldn't have to hear that "But Phenom is cheaper" drivel all the time. Some people may actually buy into that nonsense.

Instead I think we'll just see a drop in price on the Q6600 soon after the release of the mainstream Penryn quads.
 
Yea, if anything, Intel overestimated AMD this time.
They probably thought that a quadcore at 'only' 2.4 GHz would be a good entrylevel point.
I bet they wish they'd made a 2.13 GHz quadcore aswell, so they could actually compete at the same performance level as AMD, and just beat them with the price.
Then we wouldn't have to hear that "But Phenom is cheaper" drivel all the time. Some people may actually buy into that nonsense.

I am sorry but when you can buy a Phenom 9500 and a motherboard for the same price as just the Q6600, it is going to be a factor. I picked my 9500 up to play with the overclocking (16x16 mobo also) and have I noticed any major difference in performance between my Q6600 and 9500 setup? Not really, unless I have fraps running or play everyone favorite game 3Dmark.

Would I buy a 9600, probably not since the locked 9500 and 9600 seem to overclock exactly the same and the price is so close to the Q6600 ($40 cheaper).
 
man oh man! :p I went from an E6420 @ 3.2 to a Q6600 @ 3.85 I really didn't notice a diff in anything except vid encoding times and supreme commander, and seeing as with amd you can get a 9500 for under $200 and a quad xfire mobo for $170, why not? you do save a fair amount and you can probably spend the diff on vcards, a second 3870 for xfire, or 3850 w/e

-if money is no issue and you're going to OC go with intel,
-if you have a budget and you don't plan on doing any hardcore ocing get the phenom
 
I don't think alg7_munif realizes that second part. Else, why would he recommend a CPU that is bound to become considerably slower in games as soon as you upgrade your GPU?
The few dollars price difference really don't account for the large difference in performance that is just around the corner.
Therefore his whole "it doesn't matter in games, so get the Phenom" is rather ill-advised.

http://www.hothardware.com/articles/AMD_Spider_Platform__Phenom_790FX_RV670/?page=12
http://firingsquad.com/hardware/amd_phenom_preview/page5.asp
http://enthusiast.hardocp.com/article.html?art=MTQyMiw4LCxoZW50aHVzaWFzdA==

So with the fastest video card in the future, you will be limited to 70fps by a 2.2GHz Phenom, 80fps by a 2.3GHz Phenom and you will get 100fps using stock Q6600? By the time you can get a GPU that can run Crysis with 70+fps with maximum graphic settings even at 1280x1024, I'm think that even Nahalem will be replaced by another CPU.
 
So with the fastest video card in the future, you will be limited to 70fps by a 2.2GHz Phenom, 80fps by a 2.3GHz Phenom and you will get 100fps using stock Q6600? By the time you can get a GPU that can run Crysis with 70+fps with maximum graphic settings even at 1280x1024, I'm think that even Nahalem will be replaced by another CPU.

Not at all, GPUs scale at a tremendous rate, because graphics are embaressingly parallel. Add the upcoming triple SLI option to that, and we will be seeing Crysis at 60+ fps much sooner than you think.
I think it may be possible in the second half of 2008.

Other than that, these figures are off, you're better off taking the ones with high settings, or the ones with medium settings from X-Bitlabs. Else the geometry and other processing is so much lower that it no longer is representative, because the CPU also does much less work.
The most realistic test would be to use very high settings on everything, except for purely graphical things like resolution, AA, texture quality. Then the CPU at least does the full workload.
As you can see, it is still CPU-limited with the other settings (faster CPUs result in higher framerates, almost a perfectly linear scaling based on clockspeed difference), but the framerates are about 40-45 fps, which is playable, but not perfect.

Why do you insist on trying to find the most optimistic and unrealistic data to 'defend' Phenom? You also spread lies about how the TLB bug wouldn't affect anything other than virtualization.
What is your game?
 
Not at all, GPUs scale at a tremendous rate, because graphics are embaressingly parallel. Add the upcoming triple SLI option to that, and we will be seeing Crysis at 60+ fps much sooner than you think.
I think it may be possible in the second half of 2008.

Other than that, these figures are off, you're better off taking the ones with high settings, or the ones with medium settings from X-Bitlabs. Else the geometry and other processing is so much lower that it no longer is representative, because the CPU also does much less work.
The most realistic test would be to use very high settings on everything, except for purely graphical things like resolution, AA, texture quality. Then the CPU at least does the full workload.
As you can see, it is still CPU-limited with the other settings (faster CPUs result in higher framerates, almost a perfectly linear scaling based on clockspeed difference), but the framerates are about 40-45 fps, which is playable, but not perfect.

Why do you insist on trying to find the most optimistic and unrealistic data to 'defend' Phenom? You also spread lies about how the TLB bug wouldn't affect anything other than virtualization.
What is your game?
'

well according to everything I've read, the TLB bug only effects vms where is the proof to back up your claim?

and if you look at most reviews, @ stock speeds the Phenom 9600 and Q6600 are pretty close in gaming benchmarks, just as close as the 5-7W difference in power consumption you tried to downplay, whats your game :p?

instead of spending $300+ on a beefed up 680i, and $1500 on 3 gfx cards, I'd rather spend the $170 on a K9A2 Platinum and get Quad Fire 3850s for under $1000 all together,

thats right, 4 3850 512m cards cost half as much as 3 8800 GTX or ULTRA cards.

as far as how well quad fire will work, I guess we'll see pretty soon.
 
The thing is Digital Viper-X-, a Phenom @ 3GHz wouldn't be able to handle Quad 3850s or 3870s without CPU bottlenecking. You'd ideally need a Yorkfield @ 4GHz+ just to take advantage of such an impressive GPU setup. Ironic isn't it, that the platform touting quad CF doesn't really have the CPU muscle to power it sufficiently.

Another concern I have with with quad CF is the framebuffer limitation. 512MB isn't an awful lot for super high res gaming with maxed out AA/AF. The 1GB 8800GT is already showing significant gains over the 512MB 8800GT in certain games, and that is on a SINGLE GPU setup. We are talking QUAD GPUs here...

Quad CF just seems immensely imbalanced to me, CPU power is insufficient, as is the VRAM amount on current GPUs. Unless AMD releases 1GB 3870s, I don't think Quad CF will be seeing its true potential. It'll still be an awesome platform, don't get me wrong, but it'll be like a badly tuned performance car, if you know what I mean. ;)
 
well according to everything I've read, the TLB bug only effects vms where is the proof to back up your claim?

I don't need proof. The TLB errata from AMD simply don't specify anything relating virtualization only.
It wouldn't make sense either. If it was only virtualization, they could simply disable that feature and let the CPU run as if it didn't have hardware virtualization at all, but run all other software with no performance loss.
If you look into what the workarounds actually do, you'll understand that it's a general problem with a race condition on some bits in the TLB.
It just affects virtualization most, because it uses the TLB more extensively than regular software does (I think you just misinterpreted that).
However, the TLB is used with regular software aswell, so the bug can and will still occur there, just less frequently.
So if anyone wants to prove otherwise, go ahead and try, but AMD itself says otherwise.

and if you look at most reviews, @ stock speeds the Phenom 9600 and Q6600 are pretty close in gaming benchmarks, just as close as the 5-7W difference in power consumption you tried to downplay, whats your game :p?

Re-read the thread. I already covered this numerous times.

thats right, 4 3850 512m cards cost half as much as 3 8800 GTX or ULTRA cards.

as far as how well quad fire will work, I guess we'll see pretty soon.

Probably less than 2 8800GTs in SLI.
 
This is some funny crap.....

I think brand loyalty is the only thing that's really being argued here....:eek:
 
This is some funny crap.....

I think brand loyalty is the only thing that's really being argued here....:eek:

I disagree. I think this is one of the more intelligent AMD vs Intel threads around. There is useful discussion going on here.
 
This is some funny crap.....

I think brand loyalty is the only thing that's really being argued here....:eek:


There is nothing wrong with brand loyalty until people start lieing to to pursuade others into the same loyalty.

Bottom line is the Q6600 is the better buy, performance for the buck over the Phenom.
 
Looks like brand hatred actually because from what I've seen, 2x HD3870 in Crossfire are trading blows in benchmarks with 2x 8800GT in SLi because of Crossfire scaling is a bit better than SLi. Even Tri SLi would give a performance benefit over two cards but saying 4x HD3850 would be slower than two cards is just... ;) You know it.
 
The thing is Digital Viper-X-, a Phenom @ 3GHz wouldn't be able to handle Quad 3850s or 3870s without CPU bottlenecking. You'd ideally need a Yorkfield @ 4GHz+ just to take advantage of such an impressive GPU setup. Ironic isn't it, that the platform touting quad CF doesn't really have the CPU muscle to power it sufficiently.

Another concern I have with with quad CF is the framebuffer limitation. 512MB isn't an awful lot for super high res gaming with maxed out AA/AF. The 1GB 8800GT is already showing significant gains over the 512MB 8800GT in certain games, and that is on a SINGLE GPU setup. We are talking QUAD GPUs here...

Quad CF just seems immensely imbalanced to me, CPU power is insufficient, as is the VRAM amount on current GPUs. Unless AMD releases 1GB 3870s, I don't think Quad CF will be seeing its true potential. It'll still be an awesome platform, don't get me wrong, but it'll be like a badly tuned performance car, if you know what I mean. ;)


I was just comparing Scalis Tri-SLI theory ^^

2 or 3 reputable hardware sites have stated already what the TLB issue is, and they hold a bit more credibility then you do. and if you think Quad CF would be slower then 2 8800GT cards in sli when 2 CF 3870s already seem to out do the 8800s in 2 card config most of the time, well I don't know what to say to you ^^
 
2 or 3 reputable hardware sites have stated already what the TLB issue is, and they hold a bit more credibility then you do.

I'm just repeating what AMD says. But if you think that it's impossible that there are 2 or 3 'reputable' hardware sites that may have not understood the technical info that AMD has given properly (wouldn't be the first time, most of those reviewers have absolutely no idea about the inner workings of a CPU), and that AMD is actually the one who got the TLB issue wrong... well, what can I say?
And I take it you don't believe what the people who are actually writing the BIOS and linux workaround code are saying either then? Perhaps they got it all wrong!
At least Tech Report got it right: http://techreport.com/discussions.x/13724
In order to better understand this problem, TR spoke with Michael Saucier, Desktop Product Marketing Manager at AMD. Saucier confirmed that the TLB erratum can cause the system to hang when the chip is experiencing high utilization. AMD has stated previously that virtualization workloads can lead to this problem, but Saucier clarified that other workloads can trigger system hangs, as well. He characterized the issue as a race condition in the TLB logic "where the other guy wins who isn't supposed to win," and said the likelihood of the erratum causing a system hang is extremely rare.

So it's not about my credibility, I'm just referring to what AMD, the BIOS and linux kernel developers are saying. They don't have credibility either?
I'd say they have a lot more credibility than some of these internet 'journalists' who usually just parrot some whitepapers and other promotional material they've been spoonfed by the marketing department. A lot of the time they don't actually understand what they're talking about anyway. Not at the level of a TLB at any rate. In fact, some of these journalists didn't even know what a TLB was... I've seen one site that called it a Transaction Lookaside Buffer, lol.

Tell you what, since you think you've got it all figured out... Why don't you explain to us what the TLB issue entails exactly? I've already given my explanation. Tell me what is wrong about that, and what the real deal is, and how that somehow is so selective that only virtualization is affected.... Well?
 
Have you used any Phenom system and encountered any stability issue yourself? I have built two Phenom systems and never encountered the issue so far, Manny has built 3 Phenom systems, ask him whether he has encountered the issues? Pepsiennis also uses a Phenom system, has he encountered this issue? Kyle also said before that the TLB bug is not what most user will experience.
 
Have you used any Phenom system and encountered any stability issue yourself?

I want to point out two things: first, yes, I agree, the consensus is that 99% of people using it won't have an issue with this bug.

Second: What I quoted above isn't a good test of a product. Just because you haven't experienced it personally doesn't mean that the problem isn't there. Think about the Ford Pinto. Just because you didn't have any issues with your Pinto doesn't mean that if it were hit in the right way you wouldn't end up in a fiery ball of death.

It's an exaggeration, but I think it proves a point.
 
All processors have errata, this one is way over publicized. If you want to argue performance, that's fine, but unless you personally have seen the TLB error, stop arguing it as a huge point -- it isn't one.
 
I believe phenom actually provides better value than a Q6600, for gamers at least:
$190 - AMD Phenom 9500 Agena 2.2GHz 4 x 512KB L2 Cache 2MB L3 Cache Socket AM2+ 95W Quad-Core Processor - Retail
$93 - MSI K9A2 CF-F Socket AM2+/ AMD 790X/ DDR2-1066/ CrossFire/ A&GbE/ ATX Motherboard

Add two 3870's (which scale pretty well in CF if it works, being comparable to 8800GT SLI. link) for $220 each (lowest on froogle), and you got the barebones for an extremely powerful system.

Now try doing that with an Intel setup...
 
I believe phenom actually provides better value than a Q6600, for gamers at least:
$190 - AMD Phenom 9500 Agena 2.2GHz 4 x 512KB L2 Cache 2MB L3 Cache Socket AM2+ 95W Quad-Core Processor - Retail
$93 - MSI K9A2 CF-F Socket AM2+/ AMD 790X/ DDR2-1066/ CrossFire/ A&GbE/ ATX Motherboard

Add two 3870's (which scale pretty well in CF if it works, being comparable to 8800GT SLI. link) for $220 each (lowest on froogle), and you got the barebones for an extremely powerful system.

Now try doing that with an Intel setup...

Indeed, but if you are a gamer why get a quad core in the first place?

Seriously, gamers are better off with a higher clocked dual core than a lower clocked quad core.
 
I want to point out two things: first, yes, I agree, the consensus is that 99% of people using it won't have an issue with this bug.

Second: What I quoted above isn't a good test of a product. Just because you haven't experienced it personally doesn't mean that the problem isn't there. Think about the Ford Pinto. Just because you didn't have any issues with your Pinto doesn't mean that if it were hit in the right way you wouldn't end up in a fiery ball of death.

It's an exaggeration, but I think it proves a point.

Exactly, I've already explained it elsewhere, but some people are too AMD fanboyish to pay attention to common sense and reality.
In short, not all CPUs will suffer from the bug in the same way. The thing is mostly a timing problem, it's much like overclocking a CPU to the limits. It may not crash 99% of the time, but it might hang every once in a while. And not all CPUs have the same limits. You can't say "My CPU overclocks to 4 GHz, so all CPUs of that type overclock to 4 GHz", it doesn't work that way.
So, if you're not experiencing the bug, good for you. That doesn't mean the bug doesn't exist. It's just that not all CPUs are affected equally badly by the bug.
I'd like to see some numbers on stress-testing... Like, getting 25 of the same CPUs, and running virtualization stuff on them 24/7, and then just keep track of how often each system crashes. You'll probably see some CPUs that never crash during the entire test, and some CPUs that crash every few hours and really can't be used reliably without a fix.
 
Tell that to Scali2 lol.

I never said it's a huge point.
I'm just correcting some people here and pointing out that AMD itself says that the bug doesn't only apply to virtualization software, but can also occur in other situations, just less frequent.
So you are not immune to the bug if you're not using virtualization software. Doesn't mean you'll actually experience it. I never said that. Go read up on the other threads I posted in, I was actually one of the first to say you may get CPUs that never experience the bug at all.

Now stop blaming it on me, it's AMD who says this. So you should be saying "Tell that to AMD lol."
 
Indeed, but if you are a gamer why get a quad core in the first place?

Seriously, gamers are better off with a higher clocked dual core than a lower clocked quad core.

I was thinking the same thing. If I was going quad core, I would go with the Q6600 because it is clearly superior. If I was on a budget, I would go for the e2xxx or e4xxx series. If I was really on a budget I would go for the cheap X2's with a cheap AM2 mobo.

I know the Phenoms are cheaper, but if you are spending that much money and NEED a quad, why wouldn't you pay a bit more for the Q6600? If you need a quad core, you probably need all the power you can get.
 
All processors have errata, this one is way over publicized. If you want to argue performance, that's fine, but unless you personally have seen the TLB error, stop arguing it as a huge point -- it isn't one.

Hopefully this Charlie D is no relation to the infamous Charlie D of the Inq. aka 30K 3DMark06.

As an aside: will someone with some time price out a motherboard and the Q6600? Keep in mind that with the Intel platform you can go with straight DDR2-800 and achieve some pretty impressive overclocks without ever having to worry about your RAM speed. To an enthusiast, especially one who overclocks, a relatively insignificant price difference between both processors leaves only one option painfully obvious.
 
Nope, no relation :p I really only piped up because the conversation has so horribly derailed.

All the info we need is the following:

Performance (overclocking, and/or in specialized / benchmarking areas): Intel wins
Price: AMD wins

Any future speculation is irrelevant for the time being.
 
Performance (overclocking, and/or in specialized / benchmarking areas): Intel wins
Price: AMD wins

I'd like to add: For gaming dualcores win in both performance and price (Supreme Commander excluded).
 
Indeed, but if you are a gamer why get a quad core in the first place?

Seriously, gamers are better off with a higher clocked dual core than a lower clocked quad core.

The 9500 should "fast enough" for current single-threaded games. "Future" "CPU-intensive" games are supposed to be "multithreaded" and should fully utilize the four cores, since multi-core systems will be mainstream by then. Crysis doesn't utilize four cores so it is not a good example of these games. Look at SupCom...

Also, "gamers" might do some encoding/editing from time to time, where four cores should be useful. I've seen benchmarks and the results weren't impressive, but at least it is comparable to a high-clocked C2D...

I agree about the E2160/X2 suggestion, but my 9500 build is targeted as alternative to Q6600/SLI 8800 builds, where the savings would be ~$250.
 
Performance (overclocking, and/or in specialized / benchmarking areas): Intel wins
Price: AMD wins

I think what most supporting the Q6600 are arguing is that for an enthusiast requesting advice on which to go with, the price difference isn't significant enough to warrant going the AMD side.

This isn't an X2 3800 F3 or something; there isn't "World's Greatest Deal" written on these Phenoms. The only time I would personally consider Phenom would be if I were looking to pick up the cheapest quad core possible for an HTPC setup. Otherwise, as most are saying above, go with a significantly cheaper but higher clocked X2.
 
Now try doing that with an Intel setup...

I will take that money and go build a Q6600 setup and overclock it to 3.2Ghz and I will not have to buy another sytem as soon as you would. Perhaps I would get another year of gaming out of it before it started to suffer.

Seriously folks, why would you spend the same money on a slower less performaning part and system.

I asked myself this same question back when people were still buying Pentium 4 dual core systems. Why why?

I have been a solid AMD customer for 10+yrs, but they no longer are on top and or offer a greater value than Intel. For the AMD crew to now change their tune and say "Yaa, but you won't notice that your AMD stuff is slower for the same money", come on, get real.

If you want to stick to AMD becuase that is what you know or what you prefer, I can repsect that. But to blatantly spread FUD and say you won't notice it's slower, that is another thing.
 
Let see again the numbers:
Q6600 100% Load: 160W
Q6600 75% Load: 156W ======9600 100% Load: 155W
Q6600 50% Load: 150W ======9600 75% Load: 151W
Q6600 25% Load: 137W ======9600 50% Load: 140W
========================9600 25% Load: 128W
Q6600 0% Load: 108W =======9600 0% Load: 105W

I wonder why X-Bit labs left out the 9600 and 9500 in their power consumption test :rolleyes:
If the Hardocp paragraph is correct, then they got a ringer of a CPU since they got a 1.1V Phenom 9600.
 
I asked myself this same question back when people were still buying Pentium 4 dual core systems. Why why?

At least the redeeming value for Pentium 4 systems was the excellent SSE2-performance.
My brother bought one because of the video encoding that he does (and I bought the Athlon system it was replacing).
We overclocked that sucker to 4.2 GHz, I think there wasn't a faster PC system for video encoding around at the time :)
So there was at least one thing the Pentium still was good at.
He's still using it actually... and yes, he can actually play Crysis pretty well (with Radeon X1900XTX 512 mb overclocked).
 
I will take that money and go build a Q6600 setup and overclock it to 3.2Ghz and I will not have to buy another sytem as soon as you would. Perhaps I would get another year of gaming out of it before it started to suffer.

Seriously folks, why would you spend the same money on a slower less performaning part and system.

I asked myself this same question back when people were still buying Pentium 4 dual core systems. Why why?

I have been a solid AMD customer for 10+yrs, but they no longer are on top and or offer a greater value than Intel. For the AMD crew to now change their tune and say "Yaa, but you won't notice that your AMD stuff is slower for the same money", come on, get real.

If you want to stick to AMD becuase that is what you know or what you prefer, I can repsect that. But to blatantly spread FUD and say you won't notice it's slower, that is another thing.
Never said it was slower. It just provides better value. Try beating this:
http://www.hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1031816449&postcount=5
At this price-range, the best you can do for an Intel CPU + mobo that supports SLI/CF will force you to go dual-core, probably even E4500 or E2160 range. I'm seeing the phenom to offer better longetivity than these CPU's.
And yes, the Q6600 will perform much better once you overclock it, but remember that phenoms also overclock. Not as impressive as Q6600's but still...
 
Well, here's a reasonably cheap CF-capable board for a Q6600 anyway: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813130096R

Might be cheaper ones around... haven't checked. At any rate, most boards with a P965, 975x, P35 or X38 chipset and two physical PCI-e 16x slots will do crossfire.
Some may run 16x/4x, but I have yet to see if that makes any difference, especially with mid-end cards like the 3800-series.
 
And yes, the Q6600 will perform much better once you overclock it, but remember that phenoms also overclock. Not as impressive as Q6600's but still...

And don't forget that the Phenom's peformance scales quite poorly.
 
And don't forget that the Phenom's peformance scales quite poorly.

As long as one could reach about 2.6GHz, I don't think that it is a bad deal considering the lower price. Mind you that Phenom is faster clock to clock than the X2 so the performance is not that bad actually, true it is not as fast as an OCed Q6600 but what do you expect from a cheaper build?

Regarding to the TLB bug, this is what a person who worked with AMD said:
This is not directed toward anyone in particular, but more as a general statement: A new chip takes several years to develop, and 70% of that time is spent testing, verifying, and validating. Literally hundreds of millions of test hours have been spent in various forms testing the chip. The fact that it was caught so late in the process shows just how extremely rare it is. Should it have been caught earlier? Definitely. But things like this occasionally happen when you are dealing with permutations between several hundred million elements. It sucks, but c'est la vie. Should it be fixed? Most definitely, and it will be very soon.
 
Abu Som3a, with all due respect, it seems you are trying to justify 'reasons' for a Phenom 9500 system that just aren't there.

I think the Phenom 9500 is mainly ideal for a non overclocker who happens to need multithreaded performance, but can't afford the step up to a Q6600.

A gamer is still better off with a faster dual core for the next 12 months. From a gaming perspective, it makes more sense to get a cheaper CPU and to put the money saved on a faster GPU.

Finally, please, stop trying to associate CF with 'value' builds. The vast majority of people still run single GPUs. No value conscious buyer should even consider CF or SLI. It is NOT a cost efficient technology. You spend the money on 2 GPUs, but you don't get anywhere near twice the performance. CF / SLI is a high end feature, it's most definitely not for the mainstream. We shouldn't pretend otherwise.
 
People make a big deal when someone buys the lower performing Phenom at a lower price but say nothing when someone buys a $1000 QX CPU.
 
As long as one could reach about 2.6GHz, I don't think that it is a bad deal considering the lower price. Mind you that Phenom is faster clock to clock than the X2 so the performance is not that bad actually, true it is not as fast as an OCed Q6600 but what do you expect from a cheaper build?

Regarding to the TLB bug, this is what a person who worked with AMD said:

The 9600 and the Q6600 have similar performance at 2.4Ghz, but run both at 3Ghz or higher, and the Q6600 runs away.

If AMD were to revise the Phenom so that when it reached the speeds in the range of 3Ghz, peformance scaled proportionally to the clockspeed increase, AMD would have a winner.

People make a big deal when someone buys the lower performing Phenom at a lower price but say nothing when someone buys a $1000 QX CPU.

I apologize, I thought were talking about equivilant priced platforms such as the 9600 and the Q6600. I missed the part about the 9500. My bad.
 
Back
Top