Did The Funniest Thing Today

caleb2001r

Weaksauce
Joined
Jan 4, 2007
Messages
93
So I decided that for Christmas, I might upgrade my computer. I bought some nice upgrades, and one of them was going from an x800 pro (AGP) to a 8600 GT (PCI x16).

I built my PC last night, installed, everything worked great! Fired up a game to test the graphics, and it was nice. Noticeably better, especially with the new Core 2 Duo. The FPS still got low in a few areas, so I was unfortunately dissapointed.

Well, this morning I was looking over the control panel for the graphics card, and noticed that the card was operating on a x4 PCI-e bus. Whaaat? I thought. I could of sworn this was an x16 card. So doesn't that mean it's only operating at like 1/4 bandwidth?

Low and behold, I installed it into the wrong PCI-e slot on my mobo. Fixed, updated drivers, and fired up the same game.

FPS tripled. Holy crap!!

My blonde moment of the week. :cool:
 
Just curious but how much of an improvement did you see when you put the video card in the correct PCI-e slot?
 
It was a pretty nice improvement. In the particular case, I tried it in the Outlands of World of Warcraft.

My x800 pro was struggling with the graphics toned down a bit in the middle of Shattrah City, and would hit down to about 12fps sometimes. I know, pretty bad for a game like WoW.

I put in the XFX 8600 GT, and the new processor and all, and it jumped to about 20-21fps. That was with the 4x PCI though.

I did the change, and voila. FPS didn't go below 45fps, and most of the time is maxed at 60fps.

So how much of an improvement? Major one I'd say!

I'm about to do more testing on BF2, Oblivion, and maybe Crysis. I still have my old rig (did a whole new build), so I think I can do some pretty good benchmarks on improvements.
 
Sorry if this is a little offtopic, but if you use a radeon 3870 in the 16x slot and put another in the 4x slot for crossfire, would things only go about 1/4 faster?
 
Just out of curiosity, other than looking on the mobo, how would I check to make sure a GPU is in an x16 versus a x4 slot?
 
Just out of curiosity, other than looking on the mobo, how would I check to make sure a GPU is in an x16 versus a x4 slot?

The way I figured it out was to look at my graphics card control panel that usually loads on the start menu bar at the bottom of your screen. Inside, I found a system information link that gave details on the graphics card setup in relation to the motherboard.

This is where I found the bus speed to be listed at 4x the entire time. After moving the card up to the top slot (closest to the processor), it now reads 16x.
 
Just out of curiosity, other than looking on the mobo, how would I check to make sure a GPU is in an x16 versus a x4 slot?

Download GPU-Z and look at the Bus Interface.

Should say x16
GPUz.jpg
 
I really doubt going from x4 to x16 would triple fps on a midrange card like an 8600gt. In my testing I ran my 7800gt in pci-e x2 mode and got ~3500 3dmark06. In the x16 slot it got ~4000, so that's only a little more than 10% slower, not a big drop. It surprised me actually. Judging from my result I would guesstimate that an x4 slot would be enough bandwidth to not bottleneck a midrange card and an x8 slot should handle almost any card out there at full speed. Just my estimation though FWIW.
 
You bought an ellcheapo motherboard. If you look at a lot of the motherboards at frys that come with the combo, it will say pcie express 16x slot(working at 4x or 8x). If you didnt buy a cheap motherboard then post your board.
 
You bought an ellcheapo motherboard. If you look at a lot of the motherboards at frys that come with the combo, it will say pcie express 16x slot(working at 4x or 8x). If you didnt buy a cheap motherboard then post your board.

Well, as it says in my sig, I have an ASUS M2N-SLi Deluxe.
 
Well, as it says in my sig, I have an ASUS M2N-SLi Deluxe.
Check your bios settings. Also how do you know that gpuz is even a reliable program, I have read people talking about it misreading their card and what not.
 
Well, as it says in my sig, I have an ASUS M2N-SLi Deluxe.

The specs page for your motherboard is here:

http://www.asus.com/products.aspx?modelmenu=2&model=1160&l1=3&l2=101&l3=301&l4=0

The NVIDIA nForce 570 SLI runs both slots at x8 when it thinks you are running SLI. Check your manual to find out how to disable this (it is either inside the BIOS, or using an external bridge card).

If that yields no help, then try switching the slot. According to the Nvidia specs page, it looks like each slot is actually hardwired for x16 and x8, so if you put it in the wrong slot, you get the wrong speed.

See the Nvidia spec page here:

http://www.nvidia.com/page/nforce5_specs_amd.html
 
damn my 7600GT CO was running on the slower pci-e bus the entire time and i thought it was doing pretty good! haha!! ...wow...i'am a dumbass :mad::mad:

o well 8800GT is chillin' in the x16 slot now COD4 @ no lower than 70 FPS!!
 
damn my 7600GT CO was running on the slower pci-e bus the entire time and i thought it was doing pretty good! haha!! ...wow...i'am a dumbass :mad::mad:

o well 8800GT is chillin' in the x16 slot now COD4 @ no lower than 70 FPS!!

Hey, you're not a dumbass! I'd be one too then, lol.

Gratz! Glad that by me posting up my moment of duh'ness I was able to help someone with theirs. ;)
 
damn my 7600GT CO was running on the slower pci-e bus the entire time and i thought it was doing pretty good! haha!! ...wow...i'am a dumbass :mad::mad:

o well 8800GT is chillin' in the x16 slot now COD4 @ no lower than 70 FPS!!

Nah, that doesn't make you a dumbass. SLI motherboards (until recently) have been a kludge to give you x16 performance for the single slot, and x4 or x8 performance when running SLI/Crossfire. Only recently have they simplified the whole issue with dual x16 slots , and you still have to pay through the nose for those.

This is one reason why I have YET to purchase an SLI motherboard; I don't need SLI, and I really don't want the added complexity of working with an SLI board.
 
Nah, that doesn't make you a dumbass. SLI motherboards (until recently) have been a kludge to give you x16 performance for the single slot, and x4 or x8 performance when running SLI/Crossfire. Only recently have they simplified the whole issue with dual x16 slots , and you still have to pay through the nose for those.

It's actually been around for quite a while. The first AFAIK was the nForce4 X16, which was reviewed shortly after launch by AnandTech on August 15, 2005. IMHO, the main advantage isn't performance (yet at any rate, maybe next generation), but not having to use the annoying switcher cards.

This is one reason why I have YET to purchase an SLI motherboard; I don't need SLI, and I really don't want the added complexity of working with an SLI board.

My last board was a SLI board (MSI K8N Neo4 Platinum/SLI), but I never actually used the SLI capability; the 7800 GT was obsolete long before I felt the need for more graphical horsepower. There's nothing really more complex about SLI motherboards (especially on an AMD platform); the BIOS is still easy enough to work with. The problem is in the driver and software side of things, which don't crop up if you're not actually using SLI.
 
Back
Top