What about these for an upgrade?

Nazo

2[H]4U
Joined
Apr 2, 2002
Messages
3,672
I realize this is probably the hundredth thread of this nature just today alone, but I need to get second opinions. Lately I just haven't had enough spare time to do the sort of digging around for product reviews and etc that I used to do, so I can't really do the sort of quality digging around right now. I hate to ask like this, but I kind of need to right now.

Anyway, I'm looking to upgrade to something a lot more modern. Specifically, it's time to go Core2... I don't need an uber CPU -- it's already going to be so much more powerful than my current one that it isn't even funny (and my current one is good enough for modern games like Bioshock, just I'm hoping to get better results from things such as DosBox, ffdshow, and so on as well as catch up more and of course as always improve encoding/decoding.) Also, it would be nice to have a video card that doesn't have extra-cheap memory and such, more memory (and hopefully PC6400 with medium latencies for DDR2 will be good enough to equal my current memory if not exceed it,) and etc. Hopefully the video card will be notably more powerful than my current one? (Bear in mind that there is more to a video card's capabilities than just its memory, shader model, and DirectX version, so the X850XT-PE, while admitedly quite outdated now, is still not necessarily something to sneeze at. I got some quite decent quality settings out of Bioshock for example.) One thing I want to be sure about. I've seen a very marked difference between ATi and nVidia cards depending on the video methed. Namely, ATi cards have traditionally been far better at Direct3D while nVidia cards were far better at OpenGL. Since lately more games have been Direct3D and inefficient Direct3D at that, I do want to make sure that the 8800GTS I'm looking at is quite capable of getting good settings at my LCD's native resolution (1280x1024.) I'm pretty sure that it will from reviews and benchmarks, but it would be nice to get confirmation because most reviewers seem to tend to use somewhat less realistic settings (namely, I really do want to get a bit of FSAA and AF at least.) I do plan to stay with DX9 for a bit longer mind you as I have no desire to switch to Vista any time soon and, besides, most DX10 games these days actually look the same if you patch then to allow DX9. Still, I figure that if the 8800 series really is as much more powerful as it seems it makes more sense to go ahead and be ready should I ever actually use DX10. Also, I don't really want to go quad core. I personally believe that overall a dual core (preferably with a larger L2 cache) for the same price (and thus faster and/or with more L2) will serve me better for the time I'm planning on using it.

My biggest problem is my budget. $650 is approximately the maximum I can spend right now. I just don't make enough to really splurge a lot and had to save up a while just to do this much... Also, I hate to say it since waiting is better, but I'm in kind of a hurry -- well, not anything like "I have to buy it tomorrow," but I don't want to wait around months or whatever it takes for whatever is around the corner anymore. At this point I'm starting to have troubles with many games that I'd like to be playing (not just the new ones, but thanks to the memory problem and general issues that I can only guess must be somehow related to this motherboard's chipset or something, even older games aren't exactly running ideal.) I'd really like to go ahead and move on while I finally have the money to actually do so.

Anyway, here's the list I've come up with so far: https://secure.newegg.com/NewVersio...=9147607&WishListTitle=Possible+Core2+Upgrade
GIGABYTE GA-P35-DS3L LGA 775 Intel P35 ATX Intel Motherboard - Retail - $90
XFX PVT80GGHD4 GeForce 8800GTS XXX 320MB 320-bit GDDR3 PCI Express x16 HDCP Ready SLI Supported Video Card - Retail
Model #: PVT80GGHD4
- $300
Intel Core 2 Duo E6550 Conroe 2.33GHz LGA 775 Processor Model BX80557E6550 - Retail - $170
Crucial Ballistix 2GB (2 x 1GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 800 (PC2 6400) Dual Channel Kit Desktop Memory Model BL2KIT12864AA804 - Retail - $60
Total: About $620 + $6.61 S&H = about $626.61 (I'm not sure why, but it's showing the shipping at a mere $6.61.)

PS. I'm not getting enough sleep lately, so if I missed anything vital, please let me know. Bear in mind that I intend to keep a lot of my current hardware such as PSU, harddrive, and etc. Some I may swap out later, but the main point here is to get the basics in place so that I'm back on a normal upgrade path rather than stuck as I currently am with several roadblocks in the way... I don't mind swapping out one or two things here and there over the next years, but as you can see, my current hardware has left me having to buy CPU, motherboard, memory, AND video card all at once... (And naturally the video card is the real killer...)
 
For the money one of these graphicscards are a much better bet, the XFX8800GT goes as low as $269.99 and outperforms everything but the 8800GTX and Ultra currently.

The $30 saved could go towards the E6750 which is $20 more than the E6550 or maybe towards a new heatsink for the CPU.
 
Man that's one of the longest paragraphs I've seen today.

Anyway I concur with Darth Bobo. Ditch the 8800GTS and get the 8800GT. It is significantly faster than the GTS. At 1290x1024, it's a bit overkill but its one of the best bang for the buck card out there.

Pick up this 8800GT card right away before stocks runs out:
http://accessories.us.dell.com/sna/...etail.aspx?c=us&l=en&s=dhs&cs=29&sku=A1350995

That's an extra $65 to play with in addition to the leftover $23. So about $78.

I say use that money to pick up a new power supply. That 450BL might be overly stressed with your new setup. I recommend any of these PSUs for your setup. The more you spend, the more power and quality you get:
XClio Goodpower 500W PSU - $50
Corsair 450VX 450W PSU - $70

Other than that, looks good to me.
 
For the money one of these graphicscards are a much better bet, the XFX8800GT goes as low as $269.99 and outperforms everything but the 8800GTX and Ultra currently.
The GT outperforms the GTS 320? Does the extra memory really make that much of a difference with modern games? Anyway, right now Newegg doesn't have a single one of those in and I consider it a bad sign that they don't even bother with an ETA...

The $30 saved could go towards the E6750 which is $20 more than the E6550 or maybe towards a new heatsink for the CPU.
I think I didn't spend enough time looking at CPUs. For only $20 more I'd just go ahead with the 6750... In fact, I'm going to go ahead and switch them.

I say use that money to pick up a new power supply. That 450BL might be overly stressed with your new setup. I recommend any of these PSUs for your setup. The more you spend, the more power and quality you get:
XClio Goodpower 500W PSU - $50
Corsair 450VX 450W PSU - $70
Well, I do plan to look at PSUs in the near future as mine may be close to the end of its life, but I'm not really wanting to change it just yet. In particular, I should point out that just because it is only 450 watts doesn't mean it's bad. In fact, I might just be looking at LESS total power usage after this upgrade with the CPU, memory, and quite likely even the video card each being notably more efficient than my current hardware supposedly (I realize the 8800 series isn't exactly made to be super-efficient, but if I remember my last tests correctly, my X850XT-PE uses about as much as everything else in my PC combined... The card was not at all designed to be efficient, but instead is designed to get the absolute maximum possible out of its generation, and at that it suceeds amazingly well considering that it is still doing so well even today. Also, I will not be using any kind of SLI type setup.) I'm not even 100% sure that I'm going to be overclocking in the near future as that hardware should actually be good enough for me to get along quite nicely for a while.


BTW, anyone care to comment on the motherboard? I didn't have time for a lot of investigation. I remember reading a bit ago that the P35 chipset was supposed to be extremely good for some reason or other (but forget the exact reason or reasons, lol.) I wasn't 100% sure though and didn't have time to pull up any good reviews.

EDIT: That deal on Dell is incredibly nice looking though... I think I'm going to seriously consider that one for the savings if nothing else. With that much of a saving it may be worth it even if it does perform some tiny amount less than the GTS 320. And yes, it does make consideration of a new PSU in a nearer future a little more likely.

EDIT2: BTW, one thing of note on the video card. I'm kind of trying to find one with a stock HSF that exausts the heat outside the case. I'd rather not have to install a third party HSF for once like I've had to do in the past, but exausting into the case usually goes pretty badly even with the kind of airflow I've tried to get going in there (I have pretty good airflow, but I've noticed that that type of video HSF tends to end up recycling air a bit more than I want since I mostly focused on the CPU and memory -- I may have to redo that regardless, but that means cutting the case again and patching up the old hole, which obviously won't be pretty but more importantly, which requires a fair bit of time to get just right.) From what I can tell though, the card on Dell does have that sort of HSF.
 
The DS3L is a pretty good board. The P35 chipset is very stable and can OC pretty high. It also supports Intel's new Penryn CPUs, which gives you a bit of an upgrade path.

It's not the extra VRAM of the GT that lets it outperform the GTS. It is higher clocked and has more stream processors. Here's a comparison between the GTS 640MB and the 8800GT:
http://www.anandtech.com/video/showdoc.aspx?i=3140&p=7

So get that Dell card now for $235 before it runs out. Everywhere else, the card sells for $270 to $300, well above the MSRP of $250. Little supply, high demand. Yeah.

I'm not concerned about the wattage. I'm concerned about the amperage. The minimum Amps requires for the 8800GT is 22A on +12V rail. The 450BL only has 25A on the +12V rail. Technically that should be enough but that's too close for comfort for me.
 
Alright. The 8800GT it is. At that price, that is hard to pass up. Also, I have to admit that I am rather happy to see those results for the Unreal 3 engine. I'm probably going to be spending a lot of time on U3 engine games, including UT3 or whatever the heck they have renamed it to most recently.

As for the PSU, well, I'll think about it. With the savings on the video card, it does make it a lot easier to reconsider the PSU matter. Honestly, I'm not convinced my current one isn't sufficient (remember, they tend to overestimate, assuming worse conditions usually -- in particular, it probably already takes into account CPU and memory) but I am uncertain as to whether my current PSU may be dying or not since it has been acting up lately. Of the two you suggested, I'm thinking about the Xclio. Not to sound cheap, but... er, I am. d-: It doesn't sound too bad though. The 500W should compensate for it being a bit cheaper I would hope while still not trying too hard to overcompensate.
 
Yeah the 8800GT is a good deal. I just caved and bought one not less than 5 minutes ago. :D

Remember that wattage doesn't mean as much these days. What matters most is where those watts are being delivered. For current rigs, it's all about how much amps are on the +12V rail since most PC parts draw their power from there. You determine the amperage on the +12V rails by first finding out what's the total combined wattage set aside for the +12V rails alone. In this case, the XClio Goodpower has 360W on the +12V rail. Divide that total wattage for the +12V by 12 and you get how much amps the PSU has on the +12V rail. In this case, 3960W divided by 12 is 30A. So the XClio Goodpower 500W PSU has 30A on the +12V Rail. So about 5A more than the 450BL.

For comparison, the Corsair 450VX I linked to above has 33A on the +12V rail.
 
Ok. All of this looks good and I've gotten confirmation on a couple of things. I had to switch the memory for mushkin 2GB (2 x 1GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 800 (PC2 6400) with EPP Profile Dual Channel Kit Desktop Memory (which does 4-5-4-11 and maybe not 1T command rate, but was the best bang for a relatively small number of bucks that I could find. It looks like it has some overclockability to it as well in fact.) And, of course, I got the E6750 rather than the 6550 because as much as I am on a budget, that mere $20 more would be stupid to pass up since I do want it to last me a LITTLE while at least... (Like the way this San Diego is still holding up decently today.) Actually, it's pretty cool because it will even be running at a higher frequency than my current CPU. Even if somehow a program managed to somehow run so inefficiently on a Core2 chip that it ran no better than it would on a same speed San Diego, it STILL would run faster on that chip... And I don't even think that's possible with the Core2 chips being so much better... Anyway, most people these days buy these chips and don't even come close to maxing them out, but, lol, I plan to push that thing pretty hard, so the extra speed is more than welcome.) I think after this upgrade I am going to be one very happy person for quite a while. It should even last me a good while without needing any immediate upgrades.

BTW, I'm not so sure that the Dell deal was so wonderful after all. They charge a boatload of tax on that... I don't live in the few places that Newegg charges taxes on, so with that huge amount Dell charged me for taxes, even having selected the free shipping I just barely came out better than I would have had I bought it from Newegg instead.
 
If and when you OC, you'll need a better HSF.

FYI, my E6750 does 3.8Ghz on 1.55v, idling at 28°C and reaching 52°C during full load (22°C ambient) -- all possible with Ballistix, DS3R, and an Ultima90 w/ 92mm Panaflo Hydrowave fan.
 
If and when you OC, you'll need a better HSF.
Gotcha. Lol, too bad I can't use my current one. It's compeletly wasted on my current CPU... It's a big pure copper deal with sleeves and a high CFM fan for maximum heat dissipation. Sadly, the CPU ended up being one of those San Diegos with the transistors that just don't go up to a really high speed but which do run incredibly cool. Luckily I shouldn't have to overclock soon. I'm hoping to not have to do it until at least some of the parts are outside of their waranty this time around.
 
Thanks for the suggestions. Especially that Tuniq looks really nice considering. I like the way it uses copper and heatpipes to pull the heat away from the CPU, then aluminum to better actually dissipate that heat. I guess at some 2.66GHz with 4MiB of L2 I shouldn't need to overclock any time soon, but if I do, I'm probably going to refer back to this thread and see if those products are still around first. d-:

BTW, Newegg has already shipped everything but the video card. It should only be a few days before I at least have those parts. Certainly I hope that Dell hurries up and ships my video card. I'm really sick of being so far behind in so many ways. Especially I'm sick of the nForce 3 chipset... I swear, even if nVidia creates another absolutely incredible chipset like the nForce 2 was when it was new (well, other than the memory bugs) I may think twice before ever considering it. They are FAR too quick to abandon older products like that the moment technologies such as the graphics port change... All of the NF3 problems could probably be solved with drivers, but they just can't be bothered with it. I pray I don't have to deal with problems like I'm currently dealing with (such as the horrible SATA performance that forced me to go back to IDE -- one cool thing though, my solution to the problem was to get an adapter that lets me plug in SATA, IDE, or even mini-IDE drives into USB 2.0, so the IDE drive I bought can become a download/etc drive after the upgrade.)
 
BTW, my Ultima90 performs nearly identical to my Tuniq, yet its smaller, lighter, and easier to install.
 
BTW, Newegg has already shipped everything but the video card. It should only be a few days before I at least have those parts. Certainly I hope that Dell hurries up and ships my video card.

Damn. Did you notice what your shipping date was? Mine was 12/10/07. So you might be waiting up to two weeks for that card. If that happens, you can pick up this cheap card so that you can get your PC up and running by the time Dell ships you your card:
NX7300LE-TD128EH GeForce 7300LE 128MB PCI-E Video Card - $30
 
Oh you have got to be kidding me... They are estimating 12/11... That's absolutely ridiculous! Why did they pretend to have them available when they did not? I understand that there is apparently a shortage, but the item should not even be listed as being available when they can't actually ship it out... That's why people like Newegg actually let you know when something is out of stock. Can I actually count on them to actually ship it close to that time? I ask because if they are willing to sell a product they don't actually have, I can't really even be sure of that much...

I guess I'm just stuck. I'm going to have to wait on the video card. Though I do mean to use it for stuff like video watching where the CPU is the important thing, I also want it for a lot of gaming and a 7300LE or any other such extra cheap video card isn't going to cut it for me. So I guess I'll have all the basic parts just sitting around. Ironically, I actually let Dell use my debit card while on Newegg I used credit, so Dell is already paid for something they don't actually have. And now Newegg is out of those too with only auto-notify as an option, so it wouldn't do any good to try to cancel the purchace and get one from Newegg instead.

PS. Why did Newegg stop doing ETAs on products? What, were people complaining that ETAs weren't 100% accurate? That's just stupid, but it's all I can think of other than sheer laziness.
 
PS. Why did Newegg stop doing ETAs on products? What, were people complaining that ETAs weren't 100% accurate? That's just stupid, but it's all I can think of other than sheer laziness.

If they have an ETA, they'll list it. If they don't have an ETA, how can they list it? :p
 
I guess my point is that at least it seemed like they used to always have an ETA on every single product, now I haven't actually seen any ETAs on any of the products they had out of stock so far (not just the 8800GTs.)

Anyway, I worked out one partial solution that makes sure I won't have to wait some half of a month or so before I can at least mostly upgrade. My father has two 6600GTs in his system as he had hoped to hook up four monitors someday. He won't be doing that in the next few weeks certainly, so I'm just going to use one of them. It's quite a large step down from my current card and even quite a notable step down from the unlocked 6800nu I'd had before it, but it's still something I could tolerate for a few weeks certainly. Beats the heck out of a 7300LE too...
 
I guess my point is that at least it seemed like they used to always have an ETA on every single product, now I haven't actually seen any ETAs on any of the products they had out of stock so far (not just the 8800GTs.)

Off the top of my head, there was an ETA for the 2x2GB G.Skill PQ kit that went out of stock last week. In fact, theres an ETA for a bunch of RAM thats out of stock, lol. My point is, they still list ETA's if they have them. If they don't have them, I seriously doubt its because they didn't bother to get one rather than the supplier not providing one. If something isn't expected for quite some time (I believe if its over a month), they deactivate the page.
 
Back
Top