Slower Quad Core or? Faster Dual Core

NexusX

Limp Gawd
Joined
Sep 23, 2002
Messages
192
WHATS BETTER AN Intel® Core™2 Q6600 Quad-Core (8MB L2 cache,2.4GHz,1066FSB)

OR?

AN Intel® Core™2 Duo Processor E6850 (4MB L2 Cache,3.0GHz,1333 FSB)
 
With a little tweaking and possibly a better HSF, the Q6600 can hit 3.0 ghz, so definitely the q6600, or if you dont need to buy right now, wait a little while for the mainstream penryns.
 
im ordering this stuff pretty soon in about 1 week. the quad core seemed like a better choice for me. im not planning on ocing it right away.
 
Get the Q6600. You can probably get it up to 3 GHz easily.

It's not guaranteed, but most Core 2s are insane overclockers. My Q6600 goes up to 3.2 GHz with no voltage increase.
 
i havent upgraded in a very long time as u can see in my sig. its been a while and i plan for this stuff to last me just as long...planning for future proofing is part of my game

adding an 8800 GT 512 is like going from a bicycle to a 1300cc rocket bike
 
I recently got a q6600 and can say I'm QUITE happy with it. Runs cool and very fast. The bottleneck in my system now is the "slow" Seagte 320gb SATAII hdd with 16mb cache, but I can live with that.

if you get a G0 quad, I've seen quite a few of those hitting 3.6Ghz. Mine will do 3ghz (1333 fsb) without a bump in voltage. 3.2Ghz requires another .1v though. I figured I'll overclock it when I feel I need a speed increase :p
 
WHAT ABOUT COOLING? will it need extra?
Definitely yes.A good heatsink is a must for overclocking.

will i benefit from a 160GB - WD Raptor 10000RPM, SATA 3.0Gb/s, 16MB Cache
Yes, you will.Your pc's response time will certainly improve.Apps will load faster etc.

Raptors are a bit expensive though.You will probably be better off getting a smaller one for your OS and apps/games and another cheaper, slower HD for storage, or the one you've already chosen if 160GBs are enough for you or you can afford it.
 
if you're only planning on overclocking a little bit, the stock Intel cooler will actually do a good job, but I guess a little OC isn't very [H]ard|core :D but you won't need anything crazy unless you're really adulterating the core voltages
 
If all your doing is gaming I'd say go dual, but why not wait a month and get a 45nm?
 
If all your doing is gaming I'd say go dual, but why not wait a month and get a 45nm?

WHATS THE 45NM ALL ABOUT?

gaming is just one of the things i will be doing i figure multi threaded games are just around the corner, but ill prolly spend more time rendering in 3d design programs like 3D VIZ and MAYA and workin on AUTOCAD
 
Go for the quad. No reason not to, really.

45nm essentially makes the chip smaller, which means it produces less heat and uses less power. Smaller chips essentially make the chip over clock better to.

/Oversimplification.
 
oversimplification indeed :D it makes the chip much cooler too, and gives room for more transistors i believe. It also makes Intel release old 45 disks (for music) with ads about the chip ^.^
 
45nm essentially makes the chip smaller, which means it produces less heat and uses less power. Smaller chips essentially make the chip over clock better to.

/Oversimplification.

doesnt seem too impressive at this point, maybe i need to see this in context
 
45nm is basically for benifits on both sides, we get cooler running chips andthey get more chips per waffer. With the new design also comes new architecture, which in the case of core 2 can be a huge benifit to speed and effiency. Basically it could mean an awesome new chip that will continue to be the best. BTW i also recommend a quad core. Alot of software is starting to come out that takes advantage of mutliple cores. If you are willing to spend more money on a new cpu go for the QX series as well they have a huge OC potential, and can handle alot.
 
WHATS THE 45NM ALL ABOUT?

gaming is just one of the things i will be doing i figure multi threaded games are just around the corner, but ill prolly spend more time rendering in 3d design programs like 3D VIZ and MAYA and workin on AUTOCAD

I would imagine that most of those design programs take advantage of multiple processors.

Going from 65nm to 45nm does two things:
1. Each transistor is smaller and generates less heat
2. They can put more transistors on a chip, making it faster

It's probably worth waiting for the 45nm chips, since they'll be available in December/early January.
 
I just picked up a GO stepping Q6600 from Compusa and put it on a p5b-plus, micron DDR2-533 ram. I set the ram voltage to 1.85 (+ 0.05 ) and the timings to 4-4-4-12, then set the fsb to 300 ( 2.7ghz ), and it runs folding@home at 100% load at 46C. I am quite impressed.

Quad ftw!
 
I just picked up a GO stepping Q6600 from Compusa and put it on a p5b-plus, micron DDR2-533 ram. I set the ram voltage to 1.85 (+ 0.05 ) and the timings to 4-4-4-12, then set the fsb to 300 ( 2.7ghz ), and it runs folding@home at 100% load at 46C. I am quite impressed.

Quad ftw!
With the stock CPU fan?
 
I'm using this cooler with my G0. I have 2x120 mm fans running on low and with the cpu overclocked to 3.2Ghz, the highest I've seen is 53c-55c. Idle is in the low 30's. I think it would do better if I had better cooling in my case thought. That cooler is a monster and with 2x120mm fans it leaves very little space in my Antec 3700AMB. I also only have 1x120mm fan as exhaust right now as the other 120 intake fan died.

If you don't want to break the bank on cooling and get a great performance/price ratio take a look at that monster. I see it has rebates on it quite often, and I jumped on the deal when it was 28.99 at newegg with a 28.99 rebate. Hell I just noticed now that it's 30 with a 30 rebate...AND free shipping... can't beat free. Throw in a couple decent 120mm fans if you don't have any already and you still are paying less than $30 for a cooler that performs not too far off from an Ultra120 (albeit bigger :p )
 
i dont think the Q9300 will be worth the 6mb L2 vs. the Q6600s 8mb



When overclocked,and taking heat into account,plus SSE4 and better L2 cache,Radix- 16,super shuffle engine,split load cache enhancements,etc,I'd say it is worth it.

Not to mention better IPC and lower prices,and faster FSB,and it runs 100Mhz faster clock for clock.... :D Shall I go on ?
 
looks like everyone is going crazy about 45nm, now my decision has just got alot harder.
 
doesnt seem too impressive at this point, maybe i need to see this in context

45nm can overclock past 4.0ghz with a good cooler, 65nm has trouble making it past 3.8GHz on water. Either way I wish I would have went with a Q6600 instead of my E6750. Number of cores is always better then clock speed these days, within reasonable measures ofc. *waits for a post about a .0000000001khz 200 core cpu*
 
as intel is on track for 32nm by 2009 i definitly can wait for it and deal with the q6600 till then. by then 10x performance will be worth the wait!
 
looks like everyone is going crazy about 45nm, now my decision has just got alot harder.

45nm isn't as awesome as everyone is thinking. The quadcore 45nm chips already come at 333FSB (1333 for those that drank the marketing koolaid) . Unless you have a motherboard that is capable of a *very* high FSB, you are going to be getting a lousy OC.

Q6600 is 9x 266MHz for 2400MHz.
Bring it to 400, you get 3.6GHz.

Q9300 is 7.5x 333MHz for 2500MHz
Bring it to 400, you get 3.0Ghz.

In order to bring the 45nm chip to 3.6GHz you need 480FSB.
There are some boards that can do that, but not too many.

Q9300/Q6600 because the Q9300 is supposedly going to be introduced at the $266 pricepoint, where the Q6600 is now.
 
45nm isn't as awesome as everyone is thinking. The quadcore 45nm chips already come at 333FSB (1333 for those that drank the marketing koolaid) . Unless you have a motherboard that is capable of a *very* high FSB, you are going to be getting a lousy OC.

Q6600 is 9x 266MHz for 2400MHz.
Bring it to 400, you get 3.6GHz.

Q9300 is 7.5x 333MHz for 2500MHz
Bring it to 400, you get 3.0Ghz.

In order to bring the 45nm chip to 3.6GHz you need 480FSB.
There are some boards that can do that, but not too many.

Q9300/Q6600 because the Q9300 is supposedly going to be introduced at the $266 pricepoint, where the Q6600 is now.


SOB i never even thought of that...i might just go for a G0 Q6600 now.
 
OR, get the friggin' dual core E8500 (9.5x multi) and have hella 4GHz+ overclocks for $266. I don't do any rendering/mm or video stuff, just games. And so far, the games I've seen don't care if you've got a dual-core or quad-core. They only care how fast it's going. I'll be upgrading my E6600 to an E8500.
 
will i benefit from a 160GB - WD Raptor 10000RPM, SATA 3.0Gb/s, 16MB Cache


Yes,nice jump in speed will be had with that.The Raptors have been on sale at NCIX for near two months straight.I picked up two Raptor X's,for 198 each Cdn last month.
 
The G0 stepping is the newest model/version/stepping of the Q6600. The G0 stepping runs cooler and can OC higher than the previous B3 stepping Q6600. ClubIT.com guarantees a G0 stepping but not newegg:
Intel Core 2 Quad Q6600 G0 Stepping CPU - $277
 
Yes they are. Every C2D and C2Q is a 64bit CPU to my knowledge.
 
Back
Top