quad tempertaure readings which do you trust.

liamo

Limp Gawd
Joined
Sep 21, 2002
Messages
336
ok here is the thing

some people on here praticaly screamm "71 degrees is the absolute max your chip should run otherwise its dangerous"

many people quote their temps and dont say how they are monitoring or what with.

for example my g0 q6600 (420x9@1.5v) on full load of 4 cores for 3 hours in -

CORETEMP: 78 degrees
SPEEDFAN: 63 degrees
UGURU: 63 degrees

so while i love the 3.8g quad speeds i have clocked back down until i sort out my temps as i like to er on the side of caution.

BUT which temps are the temps that should max out at 71ish?

is it coretemp temps or speed fan temps?

i know coretemp is higher as it measures from a different senso on each core and the speedfan and uguru read from the traditional socket temp the i have been used to readng off for years. but does that mnean that back in the day when my p4 was its 40's that it was actually 55 for example but i didnt have coretemp or in core readings so i just didnt know?
in this case you would sy its safe enough to run 78 maxed out in core temp. [edit: ah, not neccessarily as they were different chips but you get the idea of what i am saying!]

can someone set me straight! thanks

oh and for all you quad core oc'rs please state what utiliy you use to get your temps instead of "yo my quad @ 4gig 55 degrees load yeehah" thanks!
 
Coretemp and Speedfan both use the same sensors. The temp measuring on C2Qs and C2Ds is basically just a delta from a known max temp, the tjunction. The difference between Speedfan and Coretemp is due to Speedfan assuming an incorrect tjunction of 85C while Coretemp uses the correct 100C. This is how Speedfan reports 45C when Coretemp reports 60C.
 
Coretemp reports the highest of the three you used as examples therefore I'd go with that. I personally use core temp just to be on the safe side.
 
ok here is the thing

some people on here praticaly screamm "71 degrees is the absolute max your chip should run otherwise its dangerous"

many people quote their temps and dont say how they are monitoring or what with.

for example my g0 q6600 (420x9@1.5v) on full load of 4 cores for 3 hours in -

CORETEMP: 78 degrees
SPEEDFAN: 63 degrees
UGURU: 63 degrees

so while i love the 3.8g quad speeds i have clocked back down until i sort out my temps as i like to er on the side of caution.

BUT which temps are the temps that should max out at 71ish?

is it coretemp temps or speed fan temps?

i know coretemp is higher as it measures from a different senso on each core and the speedfan and uguru read from the traditional socket temp the i have been used to readng off for years. but does that mnean that back in the day when my p4 was its 40's that it was actually 55 for example but i didnt have coretemp or in core readings so i just didnt know?
in this case you would sy its safe enough to run 78 maxed out in core temp. [edit: ah, not neccessarily as they were different chips but you get the idea of what i am saying!]

can someone set me straight! thanks

oh and for all you quad core oc'rs please state what utiliy you use to get your temps instead of "yo my quad @ 4gig 55 degrees load yeehah" thanks!



Coretemp 95 is what I use.
 
Running over 65C for prolonged periods will probably reduce the life of the chip, running over 80C for prolonged periods will probably kill your chip pretty fast.

But consider that even playing games, your CPU isn't loaded with Small FFT-like processing, the hottest that it will get is probably what you see when you do a Blend Test.

Personally, Id say as long as your Blend Test Temps are around 65C, you are safe :)

On Air cooling, for longevity, 3.6 is probably safe, 3.8 is pushing it a bit unless you can drop your temps somehow.

Personally I am running at 3.6 on 1.4750V (bios) - Small FFT temps at 24C ambient are around 74C, at 25C ambient, they jump to 77C, Im hoping to somehow get good stability at 1.4625V, but Im not sure if I will be able to... In any case, Im trying to keep my Ambient at 23C or lower so that my max temps hover around 70-71C, only then I will be happy with my temps :)

Im already running a Push-Pull setup with a TR Ultra Extreme in an Antec 900 case...im almost to the point of going water! haha

Edit: My temps also dropped a solid 2C when i dropped Vcore from 1.4750 to 1.4625
 
my only problem with coretemp is it requires a driver, and i cant use it in vista64 unless i go through the trouble of enabling unsigned drivers every time i reboot.
 
Back
Top