Pulled memory chip off video card, what to do?

redman223

Gawd
Joined
Oct 28, 2006
Messages
1,013
Ok, this is bad. I don't know what to do. The ram chip itself came off when I pulled off the heatsink, so now I am stuck. Will the video card still work if I fire it up with just one less memory chip? And it is an 8800gtx...

Better yet, where can I send this thing to get the memory chip re-soldered on? Are there usually local places that do this type of work?

THIS THREAD TOOK OFF!!! But most of it is arguing about morality and whatnot. Just read the first and second pages and then go straight to the fifth page, where I updated the situation.

BTW - Thanks for all the support guys. I appreciate it.
 
I wouldn't count on it but it might work with one less memory chip.

Depending on where you live you might find a place to get it repaired. It might cost more than it's worth and it won't be guaranteed.

Do you have pictures?
 
More like his foreskin. Him and I are like brothers now. Both, taken from us before we even had a choice.
 
Ok, I have an idea and it might work. Since the chip came off cleanly and didnt break in half or anything, and it somewhat goes into place, though it doesnt snap in or anything like that, I might be able to hold it against its contacts with a full cover waterblock.

I just have to "snap" it in place, then place the block over it and clamp it down, thus pressing it against its contacts. I will have this done in about 30 minutes and will post up with the results.

I hope it works, otherwise I am gonna have to make some calls to the video card company and ask how much its is to replace one ram chip.

I can't give up yet.
 
+1 solder it back on yourself and pray

hopefully your waterblock-squish method works out for ya!
 
Ok, so the waterblock squish method was a no-go. Looks like I am gonna have to think of something else, as the card needs all the ram chips functioning to work. I know how to solder wires together, but I dont know how to solder chips on a board, though it might work if I could find someone to do it.

If you were in this situation, and couldn't do it yourself, where would you take it?

I dont want to buy another card, and am willing to pay a decent amount to get it working again, so sending it back to the manufacturer is not out of the question, though it will be my last resort.

Good thing there are no good games coming out for about a month, lol. Well this is part of the risk you take when you modify things.
 
Gamer over brother unless you find some real geek with masochistic habits in fixing broken computer components. I for atleast have never seen any company or small firm who does these kinda things. I really think you are wasting your energy on this one.

ps. Gotta ask OP, did you stick the card into a freezer for awhile before you started yanking the heatsinks off the card forcefully? With that little trick the "glue" or what ever should have lost some of its grip and the card would probably be alive today. Well its allways easy to be wise ass after the harm has been doned.
 
im assumiong you have a bga style ram chip, if the smash it back on method didnt work, then chances are the silicone on the inside of the substraight is broken... game over... i dont know if you can get it fixed, but chances are its not worth it. use this as an excuse to upgrade...
 
aboves got it right.

How the hell did you manage that?

id wager 50% chance the columns are out of allignment. GG memory.

40% trying that waterblock idea crossed two contacts and shorted some of the silicon.

10% you can sauder it back on. Get someone you know whos a pro at saudering stuff back together and buy the thinest sauder you can find for him to use.
 
aboves got it right.

How the hell did you manage that?

id wager 50% chance the columns are out of allignment. GG memory.

40% trying that waterblock idea crossed two contacts and shorted some of the silicon.

10% you can sauder it back on. Get someone you know whos a pro at saudering stuff back together and buy the thinest sauder you can find for him to use.

im pretty darn good with souldering, i have done souldering via microscope, the problem with bga is that all of the contacts are under the substraight, you have to 'float' the chip back on... it requires a machine, pretty much end of story..., he would have better luck trying to flash heat the whole card to the soulders melting point... iirc, pc grade soulder float is higher temp than consumer grade tin/lead/silver mix by around 100°f (400-450°f) (more or less your 25 to 30w radioshack iron wont cut it, they max out at about 350°f...) but to flash soulder somthing like that would require heat on the order of 1000 to 1200°f for about 1 seconed... a cutting tourch would do it, but it would also end the life of all of the traces on the card...

and as wiz said, if you didnt have the bga lined up EXATCLY when you hit the power button, sending 1.2~v down a data only path did it in for sure, your best bet at this point is talking to a manufacture and see if they offer repair services... other wise... its time to put it to rest...(by what ever means ;) (and we will require pics))
 
Absolutely 100% dead. You can ask the manufacturer about repair, but I'd bet against them offering it.
 
Well, at least you didnt pull off the GPU lol.

With computers, force is the last viable option. If it doesn't go in or out, it probably doesnt belong there so there is no need to force it in/out.
 
Appears to be a 8800 Class card:

http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1221176

Stock style aftermarket coolers for the 8800's? I have found several made my arctic, but they were for the older nvidia and ati cards. I am just asking because I have watercooled my card, but when I upgrade next year I will give the card to my dad, so he's gonna need a stock style cooler. I wish I knew where my stock one was, but I lost it during a move.

Anyone have any ideas? Is it possible to buy one of the coolers from an oem manufacturer like evga or anyone?

That sucks.
 
If you ripped pads off the board your chances of repair go down even further. Try Googling something like "quick turn pcb assembly house" for places that would even have a chance at repairing it. The cost of repair is probably higher than a new board especially since this sounds like a BGA device. If you have access to a good soldering iron, heat guns that can melt solder, and thermal couples you might be able to get lucky with a home repair to a BGA component. I've easily removed parts with a heat gun, but putting them on is not so easy. The biggest risk is in damaging the board further. First remove all of the solder from the board and the part. It likely is lead free thus higher temperature solder. As evenly as possible put solder bumps on each pad on the board and solder flux on the part. Build a heat shield from aluminum foil to protect parts of the board not to be heated. Put the board in a board vise or equivalent. Place thermal couples on both sides of the board as close to the BGA as possible. Place one heat gun on the each side of the board. Using the lowest airflow possible preheat the board to where the solder doesn't quite flow. Should be something under 200C at the thermal couples. Quickly but carefully place the part on the board then increase the heat to reflow the solder, >200C a bit.The goal is to be as fast as possible while being accurate. You do not want to blow solder off the pads or reflow other parts. If you had the part reasonably close in alignment and the solder reflowed properly you can turn off the heat guns, let it cool, inspect surrounding parts for any further touch up work needed, clean the board and your done. Simple, right?
 
You can always call up the electronics teacher at a local trade school to see if they want to try resoldering it. A school I went to had all kinds of stuff people would bring in for them to try salvaging. I was impressed at how well the students repaired an old Heathkit HERO robot that was donated to the school. Your card sounds like it's probably toast though. :(
 
Surface mount soldering is very delicate work. Most often it is performed mechanically as in on a assembly line by automation.

OP, I feel your pain, I recently ruined my All In Wonder X800XT card when I broke off a small coil looking part while removing an adjacent memory heatsink. I was planning on using that card in my HTPC with it's tuner.
 
Buy another one, send that one back in its place saying it came like that. get your money back. =)
 
Buy another one, send that one back in its place saying it came like that. get your money back. =)

:rolleyes: This approach may not work as well as gluing it on and sending it back the manufacturer for warranty repair. Many retailers, realizing that modders are doing this, are not allowing a full return, but provide an "exchange".

This way the poster ends up with two working cards, sure, but local retailers are pricer than online and he's still going to take a hit when trying to sell the second card on ebay.

I'd try the warranty approach first, and the next approach after that (the warranty department has to send back your back card right?)
 
How about instead of trying to scam places, either get someone to fix it, or take the loss since you broke it.

Companies getting scammed results in higher prices on goods & weaker warranties.
 
Confused. Is growing a set:
1) Taking responsibility for your mistake?
2) Or trying to hide your mistake at a cost to others?

Exactly lol. What happened to the good discussions on the forums w/o all the flaming?
 
Today, it seems that the 'right' thing to do is to try to appear 'cool', 'tough', or 'manly' on the forums. Folks, it's easy to talk behind a monitor in your comfortable basement/desk, etc. It's also easy to say 'lol i can mess u up irl' as a response, but really, is it worth it to appear so lowly and idiotic on a forum? We really should try to mature a little. jmackay's response was the right thing to do. In response, he was told to 'grow a set'. This is a good example of how the 'right' thing is frowned upon and the wrong thing is encouraged for the sake of being a 'bada**'.

/rant

Anyway, OP, this is a good excuse to upgrade ;)
 
Ok guys, make it your mission to see to it that no one ever does that ever again, and youll see youll have zero effect on the pricing off goods and warranties. Its flat out funny to think that a card being written off as defective as opposed to the company not dealing with the damage cause by an individual would have any effect what-so-ever on their total profit, which is all the company gives a shit about.

Chances are if the card is still under warranty he could get it replaced. For all anyone knows he was removing the heatsync to clean dust out, and the ram chip popped off.
 
Today, it seems that the 'right' thing to do is to try to appear 'cool', 'tough', or 'manly' on the forums. Folks, it's easy to talk behind a monitor in your comfortable basement/desk, etc. It's also easy to say 'lol i can mess u up irl' as a response, but really, is it worth it to appear so lowly and idiotic on a forum? We really should try to mature a little. jmackay's response was the right thing to do. In response, he was told to 'grow a set'. This is a good example of how the 'right' thing is frowned upon and the wrong thing is encouraged for the sake of being a 'bada**'.

/rant

Anyway, OP, this is a good excuse to upgrade ;)

i dont need to appear cool or tough or badass behind text, i couldnt care less what someone thinks of me. Yes, its the "right" thing to do, but do you really think, that whatever company produce his video card, did the "right" thing, every single time? Your a fool if you think so. Im not saying go rip off company A, but believe me, business is business, and people will do whatever they can to get ahead, and im sure the company who made his video card isnt as clean as a preachers sheets. What goes around, comes around.

I also dont recall frowning upon anything, or encouraging anything.

EDIT: Agreed on the excuse to upgrade.
 
Chances are if the card is still under warranty he could get it replaced. For all anyone knows he was removing the heatsync to clean dust out, and the ram chip popped off.

Depending upon the company; that right there voids most warranties.
 
For the most part, you don't hear horror stories about little chips of RAM that get ripped out of the card when the heatsink is taken off. I'd say that warranty-wise though, some companies are just horrid, so that's definetley agreeable.

Sorry OP, but in this case, I don't think they are gonna do warranty service on it.
 
Depending upon the company; that right there voids most warranties.

Hope you have something to back that claim up because i highly doubt a company would prefer you to let the card over heat(and warranty a replacement) then simply unscrew the heat sync and clean accumulated dust out.
 
Back
Top