G92 = GF 8700 GTS

The thing is, if the card is gonna be below the 8800gts why would they be so secretive about it? You'd think they would announce it, so that people would stop holding off on the 8800gts/gtx. Are they trying to protect 8600 sales? they can't be selling that many of those...

It seems to me that the reason to be secretive is because it will be faster than the 8800 series and they don't want everyone to stop buying them.

I hope its something like that so I can get some kinda upgrade out of it :D
 
Why do people keep saying that nvidia is getting killed in the low end market? ALL of their cards are much better price/performance than ATIs this generation. The only card that beats out the 8600 series is ATI's last gen 1950xt/pro. The 7900gs is a bit faster, but lower IQ.

ROTFL yeah the "only" card that beats the 8600 is the x1950 but they also share the same price point.

It's pretty clear that the 8600's cannot perform well enough in DX10 to count so when you compare DX9 in the 8600 vs 1950 then who buys a 8600 when it costs the same?

-JB
 
ROTFL yeah the "only" card that beats the 8600 is the x1950 but they also share the same price point.

It's pretty clear that the 8600's cannot perform well enough in DX10 to count so when you compare DX9 in the 8600 vs 1950 then who buys a 8600 when it costs the same?

-JB

People who want to do DX10 in the future with more optimized games/drivers, people who don't just game and watch movies as well, people who are making HTPCs.

Proper DX10 coding will reduce the amount of work that the card has to do, so it will run better in dx10 mode than dx9 with the same amount of eye-candy. The problem so far is that dx10 code hasn't differed from dx9 to reduce that overhead, while extra eye-candy has been applied. Bioshock however seems to run better in dx10 mode (or about the same) according to [H]'s review with the 8 series cards. Waiting for them to do the low end review now :)
 
People who want to do DX10 in the future with more optimized games/drivers, people who don't just game and watch movies as well, people who are making HTPCs.

Proper DX10 coding will reduce the amount of work that the card has to do, so it will run better in dx10 mode than dx9 with the same amount of eye-candy. The problem so far is that dx10 code hasn't differed from dx9 to reduce that overhead, while extra eye-candy has been applied. Bioshock however seems to run better in dx10 mode (or about the same) according to [H]'s review with the 8 series cards. Waiting for them to do the low end review now :)

And by the time this happens the 8600's will be too slow to run those games anyway. Even the 8800's which are 3x the speed are not doing so well in DX10.

The problem with the 8600's is not DX10 or it's features but rather the 128-bit slow memory. How making DX10 optimizations will help 128-bit memory is beyond me :)

-JB
 
And by the time this happens the 8600's will be too slow to run those games anyway. Even the 8800's which are 3x the speed are not doing so well in DX10.

The problem with the 8600's is not DX10 or it's features but rather the 128-bit slow memory. How making DX10 optimizations will help 128-bit memory is beyond me :)

-JB

Well if you can't understand how having to do less work will make the card run faster, I'm guessing we are finished with the discussion.

Also these cards will be running 1024x768 -> 1280x1024 game resolutions not 1600x1200. And the 8800s are doing great in bioshock which is one of the first dx10 coded games unlike the patched games which were written for dx9. Even CoJ is garbage with its faked DX9 textures (Compare DX9 on X-Box to DX9 on computer.. funny how DX9 Xbox = DX10 computer?)
 
I agree with jmackay's assessment. Not only are the drivers not well optimized yet for GF8 architecture, but games aren't well optimized for DX10. There are plenty of ways for DX10 cards to see improvements without higher memory bandwidth: that's what registers are for.

Whatever the G92 is, i hope it is hard-released sooner rather than later. The smaller process means it will be much better performance/W, which is mostly what excites me these days. When it comes right down to it, that's all that matters (to a certain extent) because the more efficient a chip is, the more performance that can be wringed out of it before hitting thermal limitations.
 
We still haven't seen a game really "try" at DX10. Games like Crysis, Wake Alan, etc. should provide an accurate picture, not this DX10-on-top-of DX9 business which people call "DX10". No, I don't think software/drivers are going to help the 8600s 128-bit bus, but the higher end cards have yet to prove themselves eitherway. Bioshock looks as good as LP or CoJ (horrid performance on any card really), yet it's performance is clearly more acceptable.

All the implementations in the world are useless if it's a poorly coded slide-show when you try to max them out. Even the Crysis builds that have been at GC and E3 this year (only one had DX10 though) were running nicely with much better visuals. So there's certainly room (as always) for improving "how its done". Don't worry though, 2 more weeks and we'll know for sure.

EDIT: Ditto to jmackay ;). I just don't think JB like DX10 *cries :p.
 
Like DX10 or not the simple fact that you 8600 owners seem to be in denial is that the 8600's have no bandwidth. This has nothing to do with DX10. I am on record saying that if the 8600 had a 256-bit interface instead of only a 128-bit interface that I would have prob bought it.

Now right now the 8600's are either 50% or 75% the bandwidth of the DX9 only 1950. Now the other specs of the 8600's are actually more impressive than the 1950's but, alas, the rotten memory will always keep the cards down.

I fail to see how DX10 optimizations will help reduce the bandwidth to any measurable extent. Right now turning on DX10 causes a huge slowdown with nearly no benefit, I understand that in the future that games made from the ground up will be better able to overcome this but my contention is that by the time this occurs the 8600's will be just too darn slow to run those games.

How do you overcome the poor fillrate? The only way I know is to reduce the resolution so the video card bandwidth is less an issue. Now if you want to run the games at 1024x768 then I guess "maybe" the 8600's will be able to overcome that rotten memory. Anything higher and those cards are held back big time.

Hate DX10? No I do not. I am hoping that the next round of cards will drive the price down for the real DX10 cards which are the 2900 and 8800 cards.

I prefer to get deals when I buy my hardware and while DX10.1 may or may not mean anything my point has always been to get the best deal.

The 8600's may someday be a good deal but not until they are well under the $100 price point because people who pay under $100 do not expect top-notch performce and are usually not playing at high resolutions where those cards choke.

-JB
 
I dunno but I'd take the actual tests performed by people who have the card over your opinion any day.

Also you can easily get a lifetime warranty on these cards vs the 1 year that most ati cards seem to get. Lifetime warranty = when the product is no longer made, you usually get a free upgrade to the next gen card if it dies.
 
The 8600's are very competitively priced. Here are prices from newegg:

GDDR3 8600GT = $95AR, or $100AR for OC version
X1950GT= $115
7900GS=$120
8600GTS=$135AR (has HDMI too)
X1950PRO
=$137 (I excluded the Jetway)

The 8600GTS might have low memory bandwidth, but performance wise it competes directly with the X1950PRO. Add DX10+HDMI+HD video decoding, and we have a winner.
 
The 8600's are very competitively priced. Here are prices from newegg:

GDDR3 8600GT = $95AR, or $100AR for OC version
X1950GT= $115
7900GS=$120
8600GTS=$135AR (has HDMI too)
X1950PRO
=$137 (I excluded the Jetway)

The 8600GTS might have low memory bandwidth, but performance wise it competes directly with the X1950PRO. Add DX10+HDMI+HD video decoding, and we have a winner.

Most definitely. They weren't good buys when they were first released and was competive to 1950xt prices with 1950pro performance. Since prices have dropped considerably it is a superior option IMHO. Better Aniso, upto 16xAA, Sm4, and better HDCP support.

It might be 75% memory bandwidth but it also has superior Texturing abilities, Unified shaders that can turn effects on without much of performance drop. Pure performance point of view 1950pro loses to 8600gts with just Aniso since 8600gts takes barely any hit when Aniso is applied. 1950pro wins in AA performance because of higher memory bandwidth and ROP assignment especially 1600x1200 resolution and beyond.
 
spotted some pics of the card. And it seems the G92 is going to be named as 8800GT (old news I guess)

8800GT pic

edit:

Atleast the new cards start to look like video cards again and not like frigging sledge hammers.
 
Like DX10 or not the simple fact that you 8600 owners seem to be in denial is that the 8600's have no bandwidth. This has nothing to do with DX10. I am on record saying that if the 8600 had a 256-bit interface instead of only a 128-bit interface that I would have prob bought it.

Now right now the 8600's are either 50% or 75% the bandwidth of the DX9 only 1950. Now the other specs of the 8600's are actually more impressive than the 1950's but, alas, the rotten memory will always keep the cards down.

I fail to see how DX10 optimizations will help reduce the bandwidth to any measurable extent. Right now turning on DX10 causes a huge slowdown with nearly no benefit, I understand that in the future that games made from the ground up will be better able to overcome this but my contention is that by the time this occurs the 8600's will be just too darn slow to run those games.

How do you overcome the poor fillrate? The only way I know is to reduce the resolution so the video card bandwidth is less an issue. Now if you want to run the games at 1024x768 then I guess "maybe" the 8600's will be able to overcome that rotten memory. Anything higher and those cards are held back big time.

Hate DX10? No I do not. I am hoping that the next round of cards will drive the price down for the real DX10 cards which are the 2900 and 8800 cards.

I prefer to get deals when I buy my hardware and while DX10.1 may or may not mean anything my point has always been to get the best deal.

The 8600's may someday be a good deal but not until they are well under the $100 price point because people who pay under $100 do not expect top-notch performce and are usually not playing at high resolutions where those cards choke.

-JB


you keep referring to the cards memory bandwidth as the cards bandwidth. Everyone seems to be content to stare at that bus width number and seem to forget the speed. Yes, its a 128bit bus, mainly because its cheap to manufacture. But clocked at 1Ghz your getting a good 32Gb/s out of that bus. To put that in perspective, the 7900GT gets about 40Gb/s. The X1950 Pro manages 44Gb/s throughput.
 
I'm convinced that a card could deliver 8800 GTX performance, consume 5 watts, and come for free with the purchase of a box of Cracker Jacks and people on this forum would still lambaste it if its memory bus was only 128 bit.
 
Back
Top