What will play Bioshock better?

Akram

Weaksauce
Joined
Oct 26, 2005
Messages
105
I have a 7800gtx and i was wondering if you think a 8600gt would play bioshock better then it.

follow up question: how long do u think this 7800gtx will last before i have to get a good dx10 card.
 
You shouldn't have problems. people with 7800gt play it fine.

8600gt is downgrade at best. If you are trying to upgrade you need to go with 8800gts or better.
 
I have a 7800gtx and i was wondering if you think a 8600gt would play bioshock better then it.

follow up question: how long do u think this 7800gtx will last before i have to get a good dx10 card.

The 8600 GT is roughly equal, in performance, to a 7800 GTX 256. So unless you need DX10, keep your 7800 GTX.
I have a 7800 GTX 256 aswell and it runs Bioshock at max seetings @ 1280x1024, very well. It's not exactly smooth, but very playable. Only when there's alot of water around and a couple of enemies, does the framerate tank.

Well, until now, I've been able to play new games, very well. Sometimes I have to lower some settings, but for the most part, I play games @1280x1024 with most of the settings set to high and it's been playable. I think you should be fine until the end of this year. At least I know I'm thinking of upgrading my PC, near the end of the year, which coincides with the release of Crysis.
 
The 8600 GT is roughly equal, in performance, to a 7800 GTX 256. So unless you need DX10, keep your 7800 GTX.
I have a 7800 GTX 256 aswell and it runs Bioshock at max seetings @ 1280x1024, very well. It's not exactly smooth, but very playable. Only when there's alot of water around and a couple of enemies, does the framerate tank.

Well, until now, I've been able to play new games, very well. Sometimes I have to lower some settings, but for the most part, I play games @1280x1024 with most of the settings set to high and it's been playable. I think you should be fine until the end of this year. At least I know I'm thinking of upgrading my PC, near the end of the year, which coincides with the release of Crysis.

I think 7800gtx is better than the 8600gt actually unless you want to go dx10 and play at low frame rates. 7800gtx performs like 7900gt. They are very similar cards.
 
I think 7800gtx is better than the 8600gt actually unless you want to go dx10 and play at low frame rates. 7800gtx performs like 7900gt. They are very similar cards.

Depends. In shader heavy games, the 8600 GT will win (if not by much). In any other game, it's more or less a tie or the 8600 GT loses by a small margin. Overall, they're pretty much equal, in terms of performance, but the 8600 GT is a better card, in terms of features and image quality.
 
Depends. In shader heavy games, the 8600 GT will win (if not by much). In any other game, it's more or less a tie or the 8600 GT loses by a small margin. Overall, they're pretty much equal, in terms of performance, but the 8600 GT is a better card, in terms of features and image quality.

What you are thinking is the 8600gts. 8600gt is much slower.
 
All 8600's use a crap 128-bit bus. The GTS version is somewhat better because it's clocked alot faster.

The specs on the 8600's mean little because at higher resolutions they will be locked due to the poor memory bandwidth.

IMHO a x1950XT is a MUCH better pick.

-JB
 
Gotta add in the price of a million watt powersupply with it though

Well the x1950Pro version does not need a huge PS.

Keep in mind that the Xbox 360 basically has an x1950 video card inside. The game was designed for the Xbox 360 thus this is the perfect card for this game.

x1950Pro = 12/36 pipes
x1950XT = 16/48 pipes

-JB
 
What you are thinking is the 8600gts. 8600gt is much slower.

Not at all. You can OC the GT to GTS speeds quite easily. They are exactly the same card, with different clocks. We've seen that in [H]'s own evaluations.
 
Well the x1950Pro version does not need a huge PS.

Keep in mind that the Xbox 360 basically has an x1950 video card inside. The game was designed for the Xbox 360 thus this is the perfect card for this game.

x1950Pro = 12/36 pipes
x1950XT = 16/48 pipes

-JB

That makes no difference. Xenos, though based on R580, is not the same. Plus the Xbox version of the game, is optimized for its hardware. The PC version is quite different and is not optimized for that card.
But the X1950 XT is more powerful than a 8600 GT for sure and because of that, also an upgrade from a 7800 GTX 256.
 
Not at all. You can OC the GT to GTS speeds quite easily. They are exactly the same card, with different clocks. We've seen that in [H]'s own evaluations.

Not many 8600gt overclock to GTS speeds even with heavy mod and cooling.

You are also forgetting you can overclock the 7800gtx which would further pull away from 8600gt.
 
i run bioshock fine with 7800gtx. about that other topic, i would say that its not worth upgrading yet... not many directx 10 card choises out there yet.
 
Not many 8600gt overclock to GTS speeds even with heavy mod and cooling.

You are also forgetting you can overclock the 7800gtx which would further pull away from 8600gt.

That's true, but overclocking a 8600 GT, to GTS speeds, would not be to reach 7800 GTX performance, but rather to surpass it.
Anyway, I already answered the OP's question, in my first post. From 7800 GTX to 8600 GT, he would not see any major difference, so he's better off in keeping his GTX. At least that's where we all agree on.
 
That's true, but overclocking a 8600 GT, to GTS speeds, would not be to reach 7800 GTX performance, but rather to surpass it.
Anyway, I already answered the OP's question, in my first post. From 7800 GTX to 8600 GT, he would not see any major difference, so he's better off in keeping his GTX. At least that's where we all agree on.

So you are saying stock 8600gts surpasses 7800gtx now?

You got any proof?
 
So you are saying stock 8600gts surpasses 7800gtx now?

You got any proof?

I always said that. 8600 GTS is faster than a 7800 GTX 256. 8600 GT is roughly equal. Here are some numbers:

http://www.hardocp.com/article.html?art=MTM1NywsLGhlbnRodXNpYXN0

http://techreport.com/reviews/2007q2/geforce-8600/index.x?pg=1

My 7800 GTX at stock (always at 1280x1024), is slower than even the 8600 GT, in games like STALKER and Oblivion. In Oblivion specifically, the 8600 GT has more in-game settings, set to max or close, while I usually have mine set to medium. I usually run with 4xAA, no HDR, but I did test with HDR, with the same results i.e. 8600 GT is faster overall. Overclocking my 7800 GTX, it's more or less the same or my GTX wins by 4-5 fps. Other games it's either a tie, or my 7800 GTX wins, but not by much. The 8600 GTS is usually faster than either card.

Also take into account, that these numbers are not directly comparable, since both systems are very different, but it's still an indication.
 
I always said that. 8600 GTS is faster than a 7800 GTX 256. 8600 GT is roughly equal. Here are some numbers:

http://www.hardocp.com/article.html?art=MTM1NywsLGhlbnRodXNpYXN0

http://techreport.com/reviews/2007q2/geforce-8600/index.x?pg=1

My 7800 GTX at stock (always at 1280x1024), is slower than even the 8600 GT, in games like STALKER and Oblivion. In Oblivion specifically, the 8600 GT has more in-game settings, set to max or close, while I usually have mine set to medium. I usually run with 4xAA, no HDR, but I did test with HDR, with the same results i.e. 8600 GT is faster overall. Overclocking my 7800 GTX, it's more or less the same or my GTX wins by 4-5 fps. Other games it's either a tie, or my 7800 GTX wins, but not by much. The 8600 GTS is usually faster than either card.

Also take into account, that these numbers are not directly comparable, since both systems are very different, but it's still an indication.

That isn't proof. :rolleyes:

So 1 or 2 games makes it faster? LOL... Oblivion who is owned by Bethesda makes 1 game every few years. Stalker isn't even fun and is based on some Russian engine we never even heard of or any other games based on that engine. Stalker looked like crap BTW.

What about 20-30 other titles that are popular? What about Bioshock that is based on Unreal 3 engine. Did you know that unreal engine is probably will be most used engine out of all the engines? Gears of War is based on it. Unreal 3 is based on it and more to come.

Although 7800gtx eat more power than say 7900gt, they are essentially the same card. Both have 20 pipes and 24 textures per clock and similar clock speed and memory bandwidth. They perform very similar too.

An overclocked 8600gt is not a better card than 7800gtx. 7800gtx has more raw power and beat 8600gt in most games by a huge margin. :rolleyes:
 
Oh BTW this thread was about how card performs in bioshock. You said they perform similar I want to see results compared to 8600gt vs 7800gtx. Stock settings on both or overclocked.
 
Oh BTW this thread was about how card performs in bioshock. You said they perform similar I want to see results compared to 8600gt vs 7800gtx. Stock settings on both or overclocked.

First off, i never said the 8600 GT was better than the 7800 GTX. I said they were roughly the same in terms of performance, in my first post, so the OP was better off in keeping his GTX.

Second, yes, I don't have results for Bioshock and indeed you will see many games using UE3, but as I said, these numbers should not be directly compared, but are an indication.
A 7900 GT is indeed very similar to a 7800 GTX 256, but it's faster overall. And you seem to be making the mistake of comparing two cards with different architectures, based on specs. Forget about specs. Before we had Unified Architectures, peak computing power would almost everytime, translate into performance. This is not the case anymore. As I mentioned, everything depends on the game and I used two AAA titles to try and show how a 8600 GT is actually a good card, for the money. It's just not an upgrade from a 7800 GTX, because although it is faster in a few games, it's not by much, while in others it performs essentially the same or a bit worse.
The small gap between the 7800 GTX and 8600 GT, may only increase (in favor of the GTX) @ higher resolutions than 1280x1024, which I can't compare. But other than that, if you consider 4-5 fps a "huge margin", I don't. Only if we are talking about 15 fps vs 20 fps, where we are saying that one is unplayable and the other is borderline playable.
 
First off, i never said the 8600 GT was better than the 7800 GTX. I said they were roughly the same in terms of performance, in my first post, so the OP was better off in keeping his GTX.

Second, yes, I don't have results for Bioshock and indeed you will see many games using UE3, but as I said, these numbers should not be directly compared, but are an indication.
A 7900 GT is indeed very similar to a 7800 GTX 256, but it's faster overall. And you seem to be making the mistake of comparing two cards with different architectures, based on specs. Forget about specs. Before we had Unified Architectures, peak computing power would almost everytime, translate into performance. This is not the case anymore. As I mentioned, everything depends on the game and I used two AAA titles to try and show how a 8600 GT is actually a good card, for the money. It's just not an upgrade from a 7800 GTX, because although it is faster in a few games, it's not by much, while in others it performs essentially the same or a bit worse.
The small gap between the 7800 GTX and 8600 GT, may only increase (in favor of the GTX) @ higher resolutions than 1280x1024, which I can't compare. But other than that, if you consider 4-5 fps a "huge margin", I don't. Only if we are talking about 15 fps vs 20 fps, where we are saying that one is unplayable and the other is borderline playable.

So what are you saying. You have no proof? :rolleyes: Post results for bioshock. Let some other members chip in here with 8600gt.

Your processor is probably holding you back some as well as your 1 gig memory.
 
So what are you saying. You have no proof? :rolleyes: Post results for bioshock. Let some other members chip in here with 8600gt.

Your processor is probably holding you back some as well.

I only have numbers for a 8600 GT/GTS, in Bioshock DX10.

http://www.amdzone.com/modules.php?...s&file=index&req=viewarticle&artid=315&page=1

As for DX9, I can say that with my 7800 GTX @ 1280x1024, I can set everything to its max and performance is around 20-25 fps and drops in heavy fighting or in areas where there's alot of water.

And no, I'm not CPU bound.
 
I only have numbers for a 8600 GT/GTS, in Bioshock DX10.

http://www.amdzone.com/modules.php?...s&file=index&req=viewarticle&artid=315&page=1

As for DX9, I can say that with my 7800 GTX @ 1280x1024, I can set everything to its max and performance is around 20-25 fps and drops in heavy fighting or in areas where there's alot of water.

And no, I'm not CPU bound.

You have athlon 3500+ with 1 gigs and you think you are not cpu bound? Bioshock recommends dual core processor and is multi-threaded. :rolleyes:
 
BioShock Download Recommended System Requirements

* Windows XP (SP 2) or Windows Vista
* 3.0 GHz dual core processor
* 2.0 GB RAM
* Pixel Shader 3.0 compliant video card with 512 MB RAM (NVIDIA GeForce 7900 GT or better)
* 100% DirectX 9.0c compatible sound card
* 7.0 GB free hard disk space
* DirectX 9.0c or DirectX 10
 
You have athlon 3500+ with 1 gigs and you think you are not cpu bound? Bioshock recommends dual core processor and is multi-threaded. :rolleyes:

I'm talking about the other games I used to compare the 8600 GT with the 7800 GTX. Especially Oblivion, which is largely GPU bound.
 
But we were talking about bioshock were we not?

No, we were not, since my intention was to compare 8600 GT and 7800 GTX, with some numbers that could indicate their similarity in performance.
I already said I can't provide DX9 numbers for 8600 GT/GTS, so why do you keep insisting on this ? As you yourself recommended, let's wait for someone with an actual 8600 GT/GTS, to come in here and show his/her DX9 results for Bioshock, shall we ?
 
No, we were not, since my intention was to compare 8600 GT and 7800 GTX, with some numbers that could indicate their similarity in performance.
I already said I can't provide DX9 numbers for 8600 GT/GTS, so why do you keep insisting on this ? As you yourself recommended, let's wait for someone with an actual 8600 GT/GTS, to come in here and show his/her DX9 results for Bioshock, shall we ?

So you just want to talk about Stalker and Oblivion. I guess that's all you play.

There are many games that bounds your cpu with your 7800gtx.

Unreal engine is one of them. Battlefield, quake 4, half life 2
 
Unreal engine has always been CPU dependent as well as graphics.

Unreal was very cpu dependent

Unreal Tournament as well as Unreal 2004. UT3 is no different.
 
So you just want to talk about Stalker and Oblivion. I guess that's all you play.

There are many games that bounds your cpu with your 7800gtx.

Unreal engine is one of them. Battlefield as well.

No, I just used them as an example and their are good examples of games that stress graphics cards.
Yes, of course there are many games where my CPU will bottleneck my 7800 GTX, but that's not the point I was trying to make. I was trying to show you that a 8600 GT is roughly equal in performance to a 7800 GTX in performance. However, as you may or may not have noticed, performance is not always consistent across the board, since they are too very distinct architectures, that will work better in some games and worse in others. But overall, the difference between them, is not much. As for Bioshock, let's wait for the DX9 numbers on 8600 GT/GTS shall we ?
 
No you haven't shown me anything other than those 2 games. Everything else 7800gtx rips through 8600gt like butter.
 
No you haven't shown me anything other than those 2 games. Everything else 7800gtx rips through 8600gt like butter.

In any shader intensive game, the 8600 GT will win. FEAR is also a good example. In others, it will be close.
 
I hate hotlinking, but here is a chart from the link Silus posted. In dx9, the 8600GTS beats the 7900GT. Therefore, I believe it is reasonable to say the same for 8600GT vs 7900GS/7800GTX. The difference may not be huge, but it is present.

I'm having a hard time believing that my 8600GT will run Bioshock better than FEAR...My card card is starting to show its true colors, i guess.
 
Back
Top