Review my build please

defenseman

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Nov 20, 2000
Messages
1,738
ive definitely been out of the game for a while. currently, im running a P4 2.8Ghz Prescott with a 6800GTS. ive recently been playing STALKER and its a pain with all the slowdowns. ive been looking to upgrade for a couple months now. im trying to get the best bang for the buck with the best future technology.

I decided to possibly go three routes:
1) upgrade route
2) AMD route
3) Intel route

1)
Motherboard: ASRock 4CoreDual-VSTA LGA 775 VIA PT880 - $70.00
PS: Rosewill RP550V2-D-SL 550W SLI - $78.00
CPU: Intel Core 2 Duo E6420 Conroe 2.13GHz - $186.00
Case: COOLER MASTER CAVALIER 3 CAV-T03-UW - $76.00
use my current 1GB RAM and 6800GTS, but have the potential to get a 8800GTS and better RAM later on.
Total: $410.00

2)
Motherboard: ASUS M2N-SLI Deluxe AM2 NVIDIA nForce 570 SLI - $140.00
PS: Rosewill RP550V2-D-SL 550W SLI - $78.00
CPU: AMD Athlon 64 X2 5200+ w/ HSF - $129.00
Case: COOLER MASTER CAVALIER 3 CAV-T03-UW - $76.00
RAM: CORSAIR XMS2 2GB DDR2 800 (PC2 6400) - $80.00
Video: XFX GeForce 8800GTS 320MB 580Mhz - $280.00
Total: $783.00

3)
Motherboard: ASUS P5N-E SLI LGA 775 NVIDIA nForce 650i - $127.00
PS: Rosewill RP550V2-D-SL 550W SLI - $78.00
CPU: Intel Core 2 Duo E6420 Conroe 2.13GHz - $186.00 (i should def be able to OC this baby)
Case: COOLER MASTER CAVALIER 3 CAV-T03-UW - $76.00
RAM: CORSAIR XMS2 2GB DDR2 800 (PC2 6400) - $80.00
Video: XFX GeForce 8800GTS 320MB 580Mhz - $280.00
Total: $827.00
 
Whats your budget?
What size monitor do you have and/or plan to get?
Are you dead set on that case?
 
No real budget...but I was hoping for under or close to $600.

I'll be resuing my BenQ 24inch

I like the case because it has a good plain look it unlike a lot of others...and its cheap.

For 1920x1200, I'd strongly suggest an 8800GTX at least. Though, there are a couple problems with suggesting that right now:
1) you only want to spend $600, but the GTX alone is ~$500
2) new DX10 cards are due out before the end of the year

With the 8800GTS 320MB, you'll be severely VRAM limited. So, you'd have to turn down the detail A LOT to play at native resolution. Therefore, I'd strongly suggest waiting for the new DX10 cards to come out. That should push the 8800 series lower, to much more affordable prices, hopefully.



If you'd rather not wait and still plan on choosing one of the options you listed, these are my suggested changes to options:

applies to all options listed:
Change the Rosewill PSU to the XClio 500W Goodpower - a better quality PSU.
The Cooler Master Centurion line is usually cheaper, and still has a nice simple look.

1) Change the board to the 4CoreDual-SATA2 instead of the VSTA
2) See GTS comment above
3) The MSI P6N SLI-FI is cheaper and overclocks better. Theres a huge thread on it at the mobo subforum.
See GTS comment above.
 
For 1920x1200, I'd strongly suggest an 8800GTX at least. Though, there are a couple problems with suggesting that right now:
1) you only want to spend $600, but the GTX alone is ~$500
2) new DX10 cards are due out before the end of the year

With the 8800GTS 320MB, you'll be severely VRAM limited. So, you'd have to turn down the detail A LOT to play at native resolution. Therefore, I'd strongly suggest waiting for the new DX10 cards to come out. That should push the 8800 series lower, to much more affordable prices, hopefully.



If you'd rather not wait and still plan on choosing one of the options you listed, these are my suggested changes to options:

applies to all options listed:
Change the Rosewill PSU to the XClio 500W Goodpower - a better quality PSU.
The Cooler Master Centurion line is usually cheaper, and still has a nice simple look.

1) Change the board to the 4CoreDual-SATA2 instead of the VSTA
2) See GTS comment above
3) The MSI P6N SLI-FI is cheaper and overclocks better. Theres a huge thread on it at the mobo subforum.
See GTS comment above.

Go IP35E, better motherboard and has better overclock potential. Plus, P35 is more optimized and efficient than nvidias NF6 series chipsets clock for clock
 
With the 8800GTS 320MB, you'll be severely VRAM limited. So, you'd have to turn down the detail A LOT to play at native resolution. Therefore, I'd strongly suggest waiting for the new DX10 cards to come out. That should push the 8800 series lower, to much more affordable prices, hopefully.

Well I also have a good NEC 17" LCD I could probably get away with using. Even with my 24incher, I dont mind playing at a lower resolution if things are maxed.

Change the Rosewill PSU to the XClio 500W Goodpower - a better quality PSU.

I wonder if this will really support two 8800GTS's or above in SLI though...
 
Well I also have a good NEC 17" LCD I could probably get away with using. Even with my 24incher, I dont mind playing at a lower resolution if things are maxed.



I wonder if this will really support two 8800GTS's or above in SLI though...

are you going to run SLI or something? your imaginary budget you're setting yourself doesn't really allow for that btw......
 
The MSI P6N SLI-FI is cheaper and overclocks better. Theres a huge thread on it at the mobo subforum.

Go IP35E, better motherboard and has better overclock potential. Plus, P35 is more optimized and efficient than nvidias NF6 series chipsets clock for clock

yea, but both those boards dont have regular DDR support nor AGP in order to save me money in the short run. then again, I hate buying those "best of both worlds" boards...they always suck in the long run.
 
I wonder if this will really support two 8800GTS's or above in SLI though...

If you want GTS' in SLI, you need the 640MB version, since an SLI setup only uses one set of VRAM.

Neither the XClio nor the Rosewill you selected would be good options for 8800GTS cards in SLI. You'll want either the Corsair 520W for $95AR or the Corsair 620W for $125AR.

Actually, a single GTX is a more cost effective solution for a 24" monitor than GTS' in SLI. The performance of a single GTX is on par with a GTS SLI setup, and it costs much less... in fact, the Ultra costs less.

Go IP35E, better motherboard and has better overclock potential. Plus, P35 is more optimized and efficient than nvidias NF6 series chipsets clock for clock

I agree, though I was assuming he wanted to keep SLI as an option for that build option (3).
 
haha. not right now, but i'll surely have some more bucks by the time say...COD4 comes out.

Keeping SLI would be a good idea, but your budget is too low, still. An ideal setup for you monitor would cost double what you want to spend.
 
Actually, a single GTX is a more cost effective solution for a 24" monitor than GTS' in SLI. The performance of a single GTX is on par with a GTS SLI setup, and it costs much less... in fact, the Ultra costs less.

i would disagree. in lower resolution's ive seen (2) 8800GTS beat the Ultra not mention the GTX. I definitely didnt know about the VRAM issue though. Good to know.

Keeping SLI would be a good idea, but your budget is too low, still. An ideal setup for you monitor would cost double what you want to spend.

I'm definitely holding firm on insisting that can play games at lower resolutions even if its not my native res.
 
For 1920x1200, I'd strongly suggest an 8800GTX at least. Though, there are a couple problems with suggesting that right now:
1) you only want to spend $600, but the GTX alone is ~$500
2) new DX10 cards are due out before the end of the year

With the 8800GTS 320MB, you'll be severely VRAM limited. So, you'd have to turn down the detail A LOT to play at native resolution. Therefore, I'd strongly suggest waiting for the new DX10 cards to come out. That should push the 8800 series lower, to much more affordable prices, hopefully.



If you'd rather not wait and still plan on choosing one of the options you listed, these are my suggested changes to options:

applies to all options listed:
Change the Rosewill PSU to the XClio 500W Goodpower - a better quality PSU.
The Cooler Master Centurion line is usually cheaper, and still has a nice simple look.

1) Change the board to the 4CoreDual-SATA2 instead of the VSTA
2) See GTS comment above
3) The MSI P6N SLI-FI is cheaper and overclocks better. Theres a huge thread on it at the mobo subforum.
See GTS comment above.


What do you think about going with the 8800GTS 640 Superclocked SLI. I have read charts where the performance is close to the 8800GTX but you save lots of money.
 
i would disagree. in lower resolution's ive seen (2) 8800GTS beat the Ultra not mention the GTX. I definitely didnt know about the VRAM issue though. Good to know.

I'm definitely holding firm on insisting that can play games at lower resolutions even if its not my native res.

Right, the GTS SLI setup is better, because of SLI. My point is, the performance for a single GTX instead of GTS SLI setup is more cost effective. With GTS SLI, you get a 15% (max) performance improvement (@ 1280x1024) with a 40% price increase... hardly cost effective. Also, with GTS SLI, your max vram is 640MB, whereas with a GTX or Ultra, its 768MB... VRAM is needed for high detail settings at high resolutions.

Sure, if you don't mind playing at lower resolutions, then go for the cheaper card.

What do you think about going with the 8800GTS 640 Superclocked SLI. I have read charts where the performance is close to the 8800GTX but you save lots of money.

Again, two GTS in SLI costs 340*2 = $680 AR, while a single GTX is $485. It also depends on your monitor.

SLI is less of a benefit at lower resolutions. SLI is only worth it if you're buying two of the best card on the market, to push 2MP or more (at least 1920x1200, or higher). Otherwise, a single card solution will suffice. Remember, the GPU is the fastest depreciating component in a gaming PC.
 
Again, two GTS in SLI costs 340*2 = $680 AR, while a single GTX is $485. It also depends on your monitor.

SLI is less of a benefit at lower resolutions. SLI is only worth it if you're buying two of the best card on the market, to push 2MP or more (at least 1920x1200, or higher). Otherwise, a single card solution will suffice. Remember, the GPU is the fastest depreciating component in a gaming PC.

well whatever the case, im not buying a second card right now anways. im just leaving room for upgrading...which coud be as soon as November = COD4 :cool:

I just cant force myself to buy a $400+ video card.
 
That was in response to solaris54's questions. :p

I strongly agree with Danny... ditch that PSU.
 
Back
Top