Core 2 Duo or Extreme??

BaGGy

Limp Gawd
Joined
May 23, 2005
Messages
155
Is there really a BIG difference? I mean I saw the review a while back, and it didnt seem there was much. However, I am usually wrong, and I know its probably a sales thing. Like when Kemps makes Kemp's Ice Cream and they also make Cub's Ice Cream, but Cub's is a lot cheaper. Is that the same idea?

And what core is the better one these days? Conroe or Kentsfield or Allendale or whatever...
 
You mean the Core 2 Quads and the Core 2 Extreme?

What are you going to be using the computer for? That will determine weither the Extreme will be a worthwile upgrade.
 
Extreme chips are always an extreme waste of money. Your ice-cream analogy isn't far off.

Mark.
 
Conroes have 4MB L2 cache, while Allendales have 2MB L2 cache. Kentsfield is the name for two conroes stuck on one chip, with 2x4MB L2 cache.

In the past, extreme edition chips had more L2 or L3 cache than the regular chips. However, the only advantage they have now, over non extreme chips, are the things coolxboxgamer mentioned: higher stock clock speed and an unlocked mulitplier. They do not have more OC potential than the regular Core2's, so the only thing they're good for is the unlocked multiplier. So, unless you want to break OC'ing records, don't bother with an Extreme chip.
 
Well for $186 dollars, I purchased an e6420 (2.13ghz, 4mb L2 cache) a few days ago. I installed it last night and easily have it clocked to 3.2ghz at the moment. This processor is very capable of 3.4ghz - 3.6ghz with good ram. Save HUNDREDS upon HUNDREDS of dollars if you don't plan on overclocking any further than 3.6ghz. I had an e6600 that took some effort to get it to do 3.6ghz and this e6420 "feels" easily capable of doing 3.6ghz. 3.2ghz came with only 1.4v of vcore. Not bad for a "lower end" processor..
 
Well for $186 dollars, I purchased an e6420 (2.13ghz, 4mb L2 cache) a few days ago. I installed it last night and easily have it clocked to 3.2ghz at the moment. This processor is very capable of 3.4ghz - 3.6ghz with good ram. Save HUNDREDS upon HUNDREDS of dollars if you don't plan on overclocking any further than 3.6ghz. I had an e6600 that took some effort to get it to do 3.6ghz and this e6420 "feels" easily capable of doing 3.6ghz. 3.2ghz came with only 1.4v of vcore. Not bad for a "lower end" processor..

How do we know this guy knows anything about overclocking? It's not THAT easy to hit 3.4 on the E6420. I do agree,do NOT buy any EXTREME processor,they are a waste of money. Buy whatever the fastest you can afford,that ISNT an extreme,UNLESS you plan on o/c. Let us know what your plans are.
 
How do we know this guy knows anything about overclocking? It's not THAT easy to hit 3.4 on the E6420. I do agree,do NOT buy any EXTREME processor,they are a waste of money. Buy whatever the fastest you can afford,that ISNT an extreme,UNLESS you plan on o/c. Let us know what your plans are.

Hey Dirtychavez.. I didn't know it was required for me to label my life long accomplishments in the field of computers as it relates to overclocking. I can assure you that I do know my fair share about overclocking. If you are still not satisfied, I don't know what else you want from a person when they offer their input / help. I gave my .02 cents for what it's worth. Certainly, your tone suggests that I am a noob or dufus or even that I just decided to comment on a topic that I have no idea what I am talking about. Please, we can all get along without the personal insults. If you want to attack the credibility of a person, before you start an accusation, just simply ask the person. It's a forum after all.. That's the intention of this thread. To "educate" someone about a specific topic or if that person wants some input about their related issue, question, problem, topic, solution or agenda.

FOR THE RECORD, 3.2ghz is NOT hard to hit. Not at all. 3.7ghz - 3.8ghz, sure, its certainly going to be a task. 3.2ghz - 3.4ghz is NOT hard. Let me repeat that just in case you didn't see it the first time... 3.2ghz - 3.4ghz is NOT hard to achieve. A decent motherboard, decent HSF, decent ram and a good power supply is all that I have and here is how I achieved it with ONLY ddr2-800 "low end" gskill ram..

1. My vcore was set to 1.42 in my BIOS on my eVGA 650i Ultra motherboard.
2. I raised the FSB voltage to 1.3v
3. I used a Coolermaster Gemini 2 with AS5 on my e6420.
4. My vdimm was set to 2.0v on my gskill ram (2gigs). The timings were manually input at 5-5-5-15 @ 2T. I am running at a 1:1 ratio on my ram. I am running it UNLINKED. My FSB was jacked up to 400 with a rated FSB of 1600.

I ran Orthos for several hours and I am stable as a table. The above setup is NOT hard to accomplish. Ask around Dirtychavez. Sir, I have been doing this for years and years. This setup is NOT even my real toy. This is a little setup that I built for my son. A look at my signature will give you an idea of what I personally run.. I have since entered the world of phase change. I'm talking about 3.8ghz - 4ghz on my QX6700 quadcore.

Moral of the story? Educate yourself before treating others around you like a "second class citizen". A little knowledge goes a long way. To the OP.. If you are considering the e6420, I will gladly PM you ANY information that you want. I am always glad to lend a helping hand to those who ask.
 
Lets stay cool, k?

So to answer BaGGy's questions:
- Difference is not that great. Frankly, IMO, I think anyone who buys any of the "Extreme" CPUs is damn crazy. The Extreme line is suppose to be the best at raw performance and OCing, but the entire Core 2 line is a much better deal because OCing is easy with the C2Ds and they're damn cheaper.
- As for which core is the best, best of/for what? Best speeds? Best OCing? Best overall? Best cooling? Best price to performance ratio? Best for multi-threaded apps? Best for games?
 
Hey Dirtychavez.. I didn't know it was required for me to label my life long accomplishments in the field of computers as it relates to overclocking. I can assure you that I do know my fair share about overclocking. If you are still not satisfied, I don't know what else you want from a person when they offer their input / help. I gave my .02 cents for what it's worth. Certainly, your tone suggests that I am a noob or dufus or even that I just decided to comment on a topic that I have no idea what I am talking about. Please, we can all get along without the personal insults. If you want to attack the credibility of a person, before you start an accusation, just simply ask the person. It's a forum after all.. That's the intention of this thread. To "educate" someone about a specific topic or if that person wants some input about their related issue, question, problem, topic, solution or agenda.

FOR THE RECORD, 3.2ghz is NOT hard to hit. Not at all. 3.7ghz - 3.8ghz, sure, its certainly going to be a task. 3.2ghz - 3.4ghz is NOT hard. Let me repeat that just in case you didn't see it the first time... 3.2ghz - 3.4ghz is NOT hard to achieve. A decent motherboard, decent HSF, decent ram and a good power supply is all that I have and here is how I achieved it with ONLY ddr2-800 "low end" gskill ram..

1. My vcore was set to 1.42 in my BIOS on my eVGA 650i Ultra motherboard.
2. I raised the FSB voltage to 1.3v
3. I used a Coolermaster Gemini 2 with AS5 on my e6420.
4. My vdimm was set to 2.0v on my gskill ram (2gigs). The timings were manually input at 5-5-5-15 @ 2T. I am running at a 1:1 ratio on my ram. I am running it UNLINKED. My FSB was jacked up to 400 with a rated FSB of 1600.

I ran Orthos for several hours and I am stable as a table. The above setup is NOT hard to accomplish. Ask around Dirtychavez. Sir, I have been doing this for years and years. This setup is NOT even my real toy. This is a little setup that I built for my son. A look at my signature will give you an idea of what I personally run.. I have since entered the world of phase change. I'm talking about 3.8ghz - 4ghz on my QX6700 quadcore.

Moral of the story? Educate yourself before treating others around you like a "second class citizen". A little knowledge goes a long way. To the OP.. If you are considering the e6420, I will gladly PM you ANY information that you want. I am always glad to lend a helping hand to those who ask.

I think maybe he was referring to the OP whether he knows about OCing, I don't think that he was referring it to you.
 
Conroes have 4MB L2 cache, while Allendales have 2MB L2 cache. Kentsfield is the name for two conroes stuck on one chip, with 2x4MB L2 cache.

In the past, extreme edition chips had more L2 or L3 cache than the regular chips. However, the only advantage they have now, over non extreme chips, are the things coolxboxgamer mentioned: higher stock clock speed and an unlocked mulitplier. They do not have more OC potential than the regular Core2's, so the only thing they're good for is the unlocked multiplier. So, unless you want to break OC'ing records, don't bother with an Extreme chip.
Out of all the posts, I find this one to be the best helpful to the OP. The most important difference was stated by coolxboxgamer:

-Extreme = unlocked multiplier, higher clock speed

-Non-Extreme = Locked multiplier, lower clock speed(with a lil overclock you can increase this to extreme performance and beyond)

*I am not putting down anyone's post, just saying this is the most helpful one to the OP

And lets not try to hijack the thread shall we :rolleyes:
 
<------ checks his gun at the door. I've been called several things but hopefully never a hijacker.. LOL. As for the OP, how is it coming along? Have you made a decision? I have since overclocked my wife's computer, completely stable to 3.4ghz (425 FSB x 8) with DDR2-800 ram. I'm idling around 28c and when I stressed both cores under Orthos for over an hour, I hit 50c. I have a little bit of Vdroop but thats about it.. 1.4685v in the BIOS but CPU-Z reports 1.432v. Everything else is smooth sailing. Scored a 10,442 in 3dmark06 with my 8800gts 320mb.
 
As I remember it, the newer batch of E6600 could only hit around 3.2Ghz to 3.4Ghz. So for overclocking, the newer batch of E6600 weren't great choices since the cheaper E6420 and E4300/E4400 could reach the same overclock as the E6600 and cost much less.

Also, the E6600 CPU you linked to only has a 90day warranty while a retail box has 3 years. If I was running the PC at stock with no plans to overclock, then I'd go with the E6600 you linked to. But for overclocking, I'd go with the E4400 for $120 instead. About the same overclocks and comes with a 3 year warranty and a HSF that does a decent job of cooling.
 
Hey Dirtychavez.. I didn't know it was required for me to label my life long accomplishments in the field of computers as it relates to overclocking. I can assure you that I do know my fair share about overclocking. If you are still not satisfied,
Is laughing permitted in the [H]? This aggressive and completely unnecessary defense of overclocking prowess is hilarious. :D

As to the OP, Extreme chips are indeed a waste of money. Almost regardless of usage, they are a bad investment. There certainly are applications in which the extra speed is noticable, but the price increase is still very rarely justifiable. The major exception is building an extension to your e-pen0r or winning some ridicilous overclocking competition.
 
As I remember it, the newer batch of E6600 could only hit around 3.2Ghz to 3.4Ghz. So for overclocking, the newer batch of E6600 weren't great choices since the cheaper E6420 and E4300/E4400 could reach the same overclock as the E6600 and cost much less.

Also, the E6600 CPU you linked to only has a 90day warranty while a retail box has 3 years. If I was running the PC at stock with no plans to overclock, then I'd go with the E6600 you linked to. But for overclocking, I'd go with the E4400 for $120 instead. About the same overclocks and comes with a 3 year warranty and a HSF that does a decent job of cooling.

I agree.

$130 - E6600 2.4Ghz stock, can reach 3.4Ghz OC, 90-day warranty, OEM
$125 - E4400 2.0Ghz stock, can reach 3.4Ghz OC, 3-year warranty, Retail

The 2MB larger cache of the E6600 only improves performance by 5% at MOST in today's current applications.
 
I agree.

$130 - E6600 2.4Ghz stock, can reach 3.4Ghz OC, 90-day warranty, OEM
$125 - E4400 2.0Ghz stock, can reach 3.4Ghz OC, 3-year warranty, Retail

The 2MB larger cache of the E6600 only improves performance by 5% at MOST in today's current applications.

Fair enough, I stand corrected.
 
Extreme are waste of money currently but they won't be for long. Nahalem is going to have an onboard memory controller for the extreme and xeon lines only :mad: Expect 09 to be the year of the xeon :p Remind you of something? *cough* Opteron *cough*
 
Why hasn't anyone recommended the E6X50 series? They're roughly the same price as the E6X00's but they have a higher FSB.
 
Damn the database rollback dug this thread up; however, I got double the information due to it happening which is quite nice.
 
Why hasn't anyone recommended the E6X50 series? They're roughly the same price as the E6X00's but they have a higher FSB.

It was recommended before...

Damn the database rollback dug this thread up; however, I got double the information due to it happening which is quite nice.

and thats why you don't see the recommendations from before, lol.
 
Back
Top