Please Critique This Upgrade

Jucius_Maximus

Weaksauce
Joined
Dec 30, 2006
Messages
66
I've been out of the game for so long that I don't know my stuff anymore, so I'm looking for feedback. I already own the Corsair 620HX PSU and a Lian Li PC-6070 case plus other HDDs, DVDRw, etc. I have 2 LCD screens (19" and 20.1" Widescreen.)

Mobo: ASUS P5KC
CPU: Intel E6600 (after July 22 price drop)
Video: BFG 8600GTS 256 MB
RAM: 2GB DDR2, undecided on brand

I would mainly use the machine for multimedia, watching videos, movies, DVDs, websurfing, and moderate gaming on XP SP2. I am not some crazy hardcore gamer who needs 2 video cards and stuff. Quietness is important to me and I'm not interesting in OCing.

Questions:

Do you think I should use the stock cooler or get something else? Zalman?
What's the right custom cooler for modding the 8600GTS for being more quiet?
What brand of RAM do you recommend? I would probably choose Corsair or Mushkin
 
I would personally stretch for an 8800 GTS over that 8600 GTS, but that is, in the end, entirely up to you.

If you want quiet a Thermalright Ultra 120 Extreme and a Scythe S-Flex 120mm fan will do it, though it'll be around $80. A Sunbeam Tuniq Tower is another slightly less expensive option.

RAM is RAM is RAM is RAM if you're not OCing it. Any Cas 4 DDR2-800 will do, or even Cas 5, if budget is that tight. G.Skill tends to be reliable and cheap. Crucial. Corsair. Muskin. OCZ. GEIL. PQI. Doesn't really matter. If you know for a fact that you will never OC you could even go with DDR2-667.
 
I would personally stretch for an 8800 GTS over that 8600 GTS, but that is, in the end, entirely up to you.

If you want quiet a Thermalright Ultra 120 Extreme and a Scythe S-Flex 120mm fan will do it, though it'll be around $80. A Sunbeam Tuniq Tower is another slightly less expensive option.

RAM is RAM is RAM is RAM if you're not OCing it. Any Cas 4 DDR2-800 will do, or even Cas 5, if budget is that tight. G.Skill tends to be reliable and cheap. Crucial. Corsair. Muskin. OCZ. GEIL. PQI. Doesn't really matter. If you know for a fact that you will never OC you could even go with DDR2-667.

Thanks for your comments.

The 8800 is a lot more expensive than the 8600 so I would prefer to spend the cash on a quiet CPU cooler.
 
Thanks for your comments.

The 8800 is a lot more expensive than the 8600 so I would prefer to spend the cash on a quiet CPU cooler.

Are you familiar with benchmarks and reviews of both? It costs more, yes, but it's literally that much better. If you feel you don't game enough to justify the cost, however, I can certainly understand.
 
Yeah, I'm only casually into 3D games and really I can't afford the the 60% premium to upgrade from 8600GTS to 8800GTS. Thanks again for your advice.
 
8600* are the real overpriced cards, esp. GTS. thing's slower than the way cheaper 7600gt. more expensive than a 7900gt!
 
I vote no on the E6600.

I would go for either the E6750 or E5500 after the price drop.
 
It's a real shame to have a core 2 and not overclock it, even if you don't feel safe with it. There really isn't much of a risk if you don't screw with the voltage.

As silent-circuit said the Thermalright is the way to go for a cooler.

The 8600 isn't worth it by any means. Even go crappier and safe the money for something else. It is a very expensive card for the power it delivers (on par with the 7600, maybe even less perfomance in certain games) I'd say shoot for a 7900gs even if you plan on playing games.
 
Thank you for your feedback. What is your reasoning on this?

I'm thinking the E6750 is a 1333Mhz FSB chip, which could give it something of an advantage over the E6600 if you don't plan to OC at all, and would allow a bit higher OC if you decided to after all.

I think you'll be surprised what that heatsink and fan will allow you to do while keeping it quiet, however. Don't completely write off OCing just yet. My system for example is actually no louder at its current 3.2Ghz OC than it is at the E6420's stock speed of 2.13Ghz. Should be a similar situation with that HSF.
 
It's a real shame to have a core 2 and not overclock it, even if you don't feel safe with it. There really isn't much of a risk if you don't screw with the voltage.

As silent-circuit said the Thermalright is the way to go for a cooler.

That Thermalright Ultra 120 Extreme honestly looks dangerous. Firstly, it is really long and heavy (0.790kg without fan) and I worry about whether it would risk breaking off the mount if I tried to move the PC. Secondly, I worry that it might be too damn big to fit in my case. This thing is 160.5 mm in length and my case has just under 170 mm clearance above my current mobo. That leaves very little margin for error... How can I know that it will fit?
 
That Thermalright Ultra 120 Extreme honestly looks dangerous. Firstly, it is really long and heavy (0.790kg without fan) and I worry about whether it would risk breaking off the mount if I tried to move the PC. Secondly, I worry that it might be too damn big to fit in my case. This thing is 160.5 mm in length and my case has just under 170 mm clearance above my current mobo. That leaves very little margin for error... How can I know that it will fit?

Is the CPU and socket 10mm tall? No. So it'll fit. Barring a long car trip or something, in which case you could always unmount it -- it's just 4 phillips head screws -- it should be fine. Comes with a huge stiff back plate to limit flexing of the motherboard. I've yet to hear of anyone breaking their board by moving a machine with that HSF installed.
 
Is the CPU and socket 10mm tall? No. So it'll fit. Barring a long car trip or something, in which case you could always unmount it -- it's just 4 phillips head screws -- it should be fine. Comes with a huge stiff back plate to limit flexing of the motherboard. I've yet to hear of anyone breaking their board by moving a machine with that HSF installed.

My worries are about inaccuracies in measuring. For example, I moved to a new home and bought a new desk. The advertised measurements of the desk were a few inches within the room measurements given to me by the builder. But upon building the desk, it was too big for the room!

Can anyone else confirm installing this into the mid-tower size Lian Li case? (Most Lian Li mid-towers have the same basic chasis design and same overall size.)
 
OK I have done some research now and I'm pretty sure the Ultra 120 Extreme will fit in my case. Thanks again for all the info on this.

Now tell me this... why is it next to impossible to find the E6750 in Canada!? Most major shops don't even list it!
 
Yeah, no one is supposed to be listing it yet, actually...

Well that explains it... thank you. A few shops that list the E6750 can be found here but I don't frequent any of those.

Looks like I'll be going for a somewhat lower end video card and then maybe upgrading when the 8800's get cheaper.
 
Well that explains it... thank you. A few shops that list the E6750 can be found here but I don't frequent any of those.

Looks like I'll be going for a somewhat lower end video card and then maybe upgrading when the 8800's get cheaper.

Yah, the new chips don't officially launch until the 22nd. I also agree with the E6750/E6850 suggestion, since you don't want to OC. These chips are basically factory OC'd (1066Mhz -> 1333Mhz), lol.

If you don't game much, then definately go for a DX9 card instead, since there aren't many DX10 games out (2 I believe). I'd suggest the X1950GT or Pro, whichever is cheaper. The GT is just clocked lower, but can easily be OC'd if you are so inclined.

As for keeping the vidcard quiet, you may want to look into a silent (passively cooled) vidcard. Though, they do charge a price premium for such things. So, check out the zalman GPU HSFs, or the Arctic Cooling ones.

I believe the Scythe Ninja Plus Rev.B is lighter (even with fan) than the Thermalright Ultra 120, and performs rather well for around $40 USD. So, thats another alternative you could look into.
 
Back
Top