Confused: Go quad or not?

Joined
Sep 22, 2005
Messages
19
I've been researching the new intel processors all weekend and still I am not 100% sure what I want to go with.

I am getting a new pc and I've decided on all the hardware but the cpu. I'm getting it custom built since my disability prevents me from doing it myself. I decided to go with Intel for my processor. I was originally going put the X6800 into the pc, but the place I'm getting it built at suggested to get the Q6600 and pay $500 less and they will overclock it to 3.0 GHz free of charge.

Basically I'm using the PC to play games, and do video production on the side. Reviews say that a quad core really shines in for video production but it doesnt really do much for games.

Would it be recommended to purchase the Q6600 and have it overclocked to 3 GHz? I havent seen any benchmarks or anything with the Q6600 being overclocked so I'm not sure if it'll truly provide better performance.

If it helps I'm also putting in 4 GB of ram and 2x ATI HD2900XT's (crossfire) Needless to say I like saving money (doesn't everyone?) but I dont like giving up performance.

I'd appreciate any advice you may give and I thank you for taking the time to read this,
 
4 > 2.

What's confusing about that, especially if you're going to be doing video editing? Most if not all serious video editing software is properly multithreaded, and because of that the quad core would eat a dual core (even an overclocked one to some degree) for breakfast and a late night snack to boot.

4GB of RAM automagically implies the necessity of a 64 bit OS, sooo... keep that in mind before you put all this together or you'll never get the full use of that much RAM.

If the place you're buying this machine from will pre-overclock it to 3 GHz for you, make sure you get some kind of warranty in writing that says you're buying an overclocked PC or they could throw it back in your face if you need support.

Just trying to cover all the bases...
 
people keep asking the same question, and its because noone is getting a real answer, and its because noone knows, they just have guesses....

My guess

If you game, stay with dualcore, you can get it up to a higher clock speed than the quad

If you do other stuff other than game, get the quad

a little of everything, higher clockspeed with the dual again, not much takes advantage of the quad, and wont for a while
 
Just get a quad core. You have nothing to lose. E6600=Q6600 for gaming but Q6600>>E6600 for many other multitasking ei. video editing...rendering...many others 3D applications...

Wait for the Q6600 to drop within 2 weeks.
 
if you want to save money and get more bang for your buck drop those x2900xt's and get 2 x 8800gts 640's. as for the quad core, why not! sounds like a good deal.
 
Go Quadcore.

Why?

1. Gaming - you say you are a gamer, well games in the future are only going to take advantage of multiple cores. Some games already do. Anyone who plays Supreme Commander can tell you the difference of switching from dual core to quad core and how much smoother their gaming experience was. Also - many soon to be released are going to be taking advantage of quad cores - those being Crysis, UT3, and Half-Life 2 Ep. 2 to name a few...and those are some big name games where developer's have said to expect "significant" performance/feature increases from going from dual to quad cores.

2. Video editing - you say you do a little video editing/production on the side? Well, whatever a dual core can do a quad core will almost cut the time in half if not more.

3. Comparing a 3.0Ghz Q6600 to a 3.6 E6600 Ghz dual core - Why am I comparing these two processors? Because those are typical overclocks for these processors. And because the MHz speed has little performance increase in gaming at this point. Now, I'm not saying overclocking isn't something you should do but you have to understand why. Typically, it's for increased performance, but also for bragging rights or pushing a piece of equipment to it's limits. In the real world gaming the E6600 is sporting at least a 600 MHz speed gain over the Q6600, but the actual in game performance may be between 7-10% or 5-10 fps (if that, being generous). That being said, you can't add more cores to a CPU. And if you take into the consideration that you might be missing out on future features or large in-game performance boosts for multi-threaded games...it's kinda easy to see why I suggest getting a quadcore.

Edit: See link! The actual benefit between dual and quad core seems to be equal in gaming now...with a slight 1-2 fps benefit for quadcores shown from Anand. I don't believe this was the case back when Kentsfield first came out.

http://www.anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/intel/showdoc.aspx?i=2963&p=8
 
Nightvision,

The real question is, how you propose to cool it, the quads make the Prescotts cower in fear in terms of heat.

That's the question I'm trying to find the answer to: how the hell am I going to keep this inferno under 60c @3.0
 
go with the quad if your going to be messing with lot of videos.
 
You have the option to have seks with two women (twins) or with 2 pairs of twins. You might not be able to play with 2 or even the 4 women at the same time, but oh, the bliss to have them all 4 in your bed. Then, when you're ready to play with them at the same time, you won't be disappointed that you only got one pair of twins on each side of you, noooooo, you sir!, have 4 women in your bed!!!!!!
 
You have the option to have seks with two women (twins) or with 2 pairs of twins. You might not be able to play with 2 or even the 4 women at the same time, but oh, the bliss to have them all 4 in your bed. Then, when you're ready to play with them at the same time, you won't be disappointed that you only got one pair of twins on each side of you, noooooo, you sir!, have 4 women in your bed!!!!!!

lawl, best answer yet.

Im going for the Q6600/Asrock 4coredual-VSTA combo at the end of July.
 
You have the option to have seks with two women (twins) or with 2 pairs of twins. You might not be able to play with 2 or even the 4 women at the same time, but oh, the bliss to have them all 4 in your bed. Then, when you're ready to play with them at the same time, you won't be disappointed that you only got one pair of twins on each side of you, noooooo, you sir!, have 4 women in your bed!!!!!!

lmao. that's a funny analogy
 
Thank you all for the advice, and thank you ScYcS for the analogy. Perhaps Intel should take it up as their new motto or something for the quadcore cpus

I'm going go with the Q6600, but now as someone earlier mentioned its a question of what's the best way to cool it, I was originally going to go with aircooling (Case was a Coolermaster Stacker 832) Will aircooling be enough or should I be looking at water-cooling?

I'm going wait the week or so for the price drop, hopefully that'll let me play around with the other components and add some things.
 
I saw a C2D vs Quad article on one of the major hardware sites (maybe Tom's) last fall and the benchmarks were about even for everything EXCEPT video - the quad was over 60% faster. If your doing a lot of video then quad is the way to go. Otherwise I'm not sold on quads just yet. Just last fall, in another article, the top Intel guy was saying dual core was the way to go "for now". I can't see what could have changed in 7 months aside from the prices. In fact, just last May an Intel researcher was complaining at a conference that software developers weren't keeping up with hardware:

http://weblog.infoworld.com/realitycheck/archives/2007/05/intel_has_gripe.html

Since the cost is so cheap now its hard not to get the quad for under 300 USD (I paid 345 for my E6600 last October). But I wouldn't spend much more on a quad. The only negs I read about (and I cant confirm them from experience) had to do with extra cores sometimes bottlenecking the FSB, and also some extra heat issues. SOmeone who games witha quad can probably speak about those.
 
My pc

22in Samsung WideScreen LCD
cM Stacker 830
Enermax Galaxy 850
Q6600 @ 3.2
Zalman 9700
Evga 8800 GTX 650/1100
Evga 680i A1
4GB Crucial Ballistix
150 GB Raptor
X-fi Xtreme MusiC
ZalmaN 5.1 Headset
QCK
Mx-518
Saitek EclipsE

Now my cpu idles at 40c, load 55(in games like farcry, bf2, css) but in prime95 with all 4 cores being stressed it goes up to 65c.
my GTX idles at 54c, but I have 4, 140mm fans and 3, 120mm fans in my case.. also a window air conditioner to keep my room about 70ish... I can get stable at 3.3 but it takes 1.4 voltage and at 1.4 voltage my temps go up about 5c, 1.45 voltage another 5c lol... oh and at 3.2 my voltage is only 1.36... My 3dmark06 score = 14,250.. hope this helps ya!
 
Just get a quad core. You have nothing to lose. E6600=Q6600 for gaming but Q6600>>E6600 for many other multitasking ei. video editing...rendering...many others 3D applications...

Wait for the Q6600 to drop within 2 weeks.

Also, the extra cores will soon do a lot for newer games, so it's a win-win. You can overclock a quad-core to within a hundred mhz or so of an overclocked dual-core typically, so it'll be a beast in both games and apps even today, and a much bigger one in apps already, with games soon to come.
 
You know they said dual core was futureproof but ony a hand full of software can use it fully, now we have a quad. Is there something here i'm missing? I think i would like to see 100-150 pieces of software to support it instead of 2-5 we have now.

Dual core has been out a while now and nothing much is even out there even 64bit has been out ther a couple of years and still no great 64 bit software around.

The companies are just raking us(enthusiasts).
 
Here's another question.

Would Quad Cores help in a situation where..say I want to game while I'm encoding an .avi video to dvd format.


Or does it not work like that.
 
Those quad cores are starting to smell a little bit like Pentium D's.

"You might as well get quad core, cause software is going to be multithreaded".

haha...good luck with that...
 
]|[ Mar']['in ]|[;1031250300 said:
Here's another question.

Would Quad Cores help in a situation where..say I want to game while I'm encoding an .avi video to dvd format.


Or does it not work like that.

it should allow you to do exactly that.
 
You know they said dual core was futureproof but ony a hand full of software can use it fully, now we have a quad. Is there something here i'm missing? I think i would like to see 100-150 pieces of software to support it instead of 2-5 we have now.

Dual core has been out a while now and nothing much is even out there even 64bit has been out ther a couple of years and still no great 64 bit software around.

The companies are just raking us(enthusiasts).

I think this is an excellent point. Everyone is rushing to get a quad and all they do is raise their geek factor. You have to really look at you use. I think for you, nightvision, the quad will work because you are doing video. For anyone else, it's a waste. Early adopters get the headaches. Think about it, by the time a quad is a benefit for most people, there will be a new architecture and lower prices. Unless you need it, buy a good dual like a E6600 and wait until the real quads come out. Don't be a sucker for the marketing machine
 
You have the option to have seks with two women (twins) or with 2 pairs of twins. You might not be able to play with 2 or even the 4 women at the same time, but oh, the bliss to have them all 4 in your bed. Then, when you're ready to play with them at the same time, you won't be disappointed that you only got one pair of twins on each side of you, noooooo, you sir!, have 4 women in your bed!!!!!!

Pics or I call shens.... :D
 
A lot of people are missing the scope of the OP's question: Q6600 or X6800. The quad will be $400-$500 cheaper. Even after the price cuts, the quad will still be only ~$50 more, so why not get 2 more cores, even if they may sit idle 80% of the time. Less than 3 months ago the e6600 was $320 or more.....so the q6600 is still a bargain.

As for the video cards, just get an 8800 ultra, a gtx an oc it, or 2 8800gt 640mb. In case you missed the [H] review of the 2900 XT Crossfire performance, read up on it.

Radeon HD 2900 XT CrossFire is most certainly not a good gaming solution. It just does not deliver the kind of performance advantages ATI needs to compete with what NVIDIA already has in the marketplace.

There is absolutely no video card currently from ATI that can achieve a great gameplay experience at 2560x1600. The best solution they have are two Radeon HD 2900 XT card’s in CrossFire, and in this evaluation we have shown that they are no competition for two 8800 GTS card’s in SLI. That doesn’t even take into account that the GTS isn’t NVIDIA’s fastest GPU.
 
I think for you, nightvision, the quad will work because you are doing video. For anyone else, it's a waste.

Even that depends on the software. I convert a lot of AVIs to DVD with Nero Vision and it's multi-threaded but the the free video converters I use like Super are only single threaded. It's a big PITA.

 
hmm a lot of people seem to have different opinions which is quite funny.

From my understanding games benfit off faster mhz then more cores. someone stated "supreme commander runs moother off the quad" well the only thing I can agree here is possible since its RTS? alot of shit going on in the game. but also remember its not the only factor here.

for games like FPS, they benefit off higher speeds (more mhz) get better framespersecond.
\
Again. Quad core is not techincally futureproof. Yes it will do greatly when new games come out and when appllications are needed for the quad. But in a few years remember there will be cpus that run 32nm and 16mb cache. he hemmmm Gesher!!! And your telling me you wont upgrade then?? or upgrade next year when something better comes along?

Honestly Ive been in the same situation ever since "PRICE DROPS" came about in the forums. I honestly Want to pick up E6850 + Q6600 just for the simple fact, to Test them for myself. And see what is better.. I may honestly do this.

But until we actually see "benches" on both cores. Its techincally a guessing game. we honestly dont really know. Since we dont see too many people overclocking these cpus. On xtremesystems people have been showing what they have to offer. Q6600 has gotten 3.5ghz highest from what I have seen. E6850 has hit 4ghz on air. 4.3ghz on water.. and 5.3ghz on LN2 cooling. Soooo.. yAhhh..

Anywho. this is just my opinion of this whole ordeal here.

We will have to wait and see the truth behind these cores when everyone buys + overclocks..

GG
 
To the OP..

I have posted on several threads regarding this question several times before and I will touch on this again. I have owned several dual core processors (both AMD and Intel). When I had a few E6600 dual cores running, I could get that processor to as high as 3.8ghz on water. Was it stable? Not really. So, due to the high heat I backed it down to 3.6ghz. Stable? Yes. But again, I had alot of heat coming off of that E6600. So, in the end (both times I've owned an E6600), I backed it down to 3.2ghz. The heat was very acceptable. I didn't even have to "up the voltage" on my processor. Well, since then, I have moved on to the QX6700 quadcore. Again, I could hit 3.2ghz without ANY vcore increases on the processor. Having hit 3.8ghz on my E6600 and gaming under that speed compared to my E6600 running a 24/7 setup at 3.2ghz, you will NOT notice any difference between the two in the games you play. That is only an increase of 600mhz. If you benchmark, there WILL be a measureable difference between 3.2ghz and 3.8ghz. SiSoft Sandra, Everest Ultimate, 3dmark06, etc. are good examples where you can see the difference via a score, graph or chart where the difference can be measured.

A Q6600 at 3.0ghz is definately NO slouch. Gaming at 3.0ghz on a Q6600 will play ANY current game without any problems (in reference to processing power). However, if you are like the many in here, who are into the higher levels of gaming, you will want to purchase a REALLY good high end graphics card (8800 series card or maybe consider the ATI 2900xt alternative). As for video editing and production, I too am into that. I use Adobe and Pinnacle Studio. At it's stock speed of 2.66ghz, my QX6700 would run circles around my E6600 at 3.6ghz when I edited / produced videos. My TTTC (Total Time To Completion) was easily twice of fast on my quad vs my dual core.

In benchmarking, using Everest Ultimate and 3dmark06, I found that the speed of my FSB made a huge difference for me. That really holds true for both processors. In stock form, I felt that a very large increase in my overall performance was moving my FSB from stock to 400. With the help of some PC8500C5D Corsair Dominators, hitting a 400 (1600 rated) FSB REALLY pepped up my performance. It was mentioned in an earlier post but just reitterating, if you have 4gigs in mind, you will want to stay with a x64 bit operating system. Using Everest Ultimate, I could see just about what every tweak was doing. Whether it was good for overall system performance or if it was not. As a result, I was really surprised to find out that there was not "much difference" between a 400FSB vs a 450FSB. The performance gain was minimal but the extra workload on the ram was not worth the extra stress that I was putting it through.

It was also mentioned about the heat generated by the quadcore. This is a very important issue. I had my quadcore on a high end water setup. Although I took my quad up to 3.4ghz on water, I was hitting that "acceptable / not acceptable" threshold. It got HOT. So, I simply bumped it down to 3.2ghz (stock vcore) and I was back in the acceptable range. Remind you, that was a high end $400+ dollar water cooling setup. Don't expect to hit too much higher than what I was able to achieve. An awesome air cooling solution may get you up to 3.0ghz - 3.2ghz but again, I wouldn't push it beyond that. I have since remedied my cooling solution by going with a phase change unit. Price to performance ratio, phase change units are expensive and will generally allow you to push your processor little more. Unless you just want to be a little (and I stress a little) faster than other quadcore owners, I would stick to the highest end air setup or a water cooling setup and save yourself hundreds of dollars.

In the end, quadcores are a great choice. As with technology, dual cores will fall to the same fate as the single core processors. They will be phased out. And over time, so will the quads in lieu of an eight core processor.. and so on and so on.. If the quadcore fits your computing needs, then hands down, no doubt, I would go with the q6600. If all you will ever do is listen to .mp3's and check email, dual cores will be more than enough. You will win either way with todays current games, with either processor. Just be sure to look beyond gaming if you do more than just shoot em up on your computer. Now that I have owned my quadcore for several months now, it's a no brainer for ME.. I will NEVER go back to a dual core.
 
Officermartinez, excellent explaination. He should go quad because it will actually benefit him, not for the sake of going quad. The x6800 is nice, but almost 3X the price of the next lower proc and 2x the Q6600 and only about 300Mhz faster, not worth the money. I see a lot of people by PCs for the sake of specs and waste a lot of money. It doesn't sound like the OP will be constantly upgrading so a Q6600, 2GB of some good RAM and 2X Nvidia 8800GTS would be his best bet. Anything higher would not be worth the added investment.
 
people keep asking the same question, and its because noone is getting a real answer, and its because noone knows, they just have guesses....

My guess

If you game, stay with dualcore, you can get it up to a higher clock speed than the quad

If you do other stuff other than game, get the quad

a little of everything, higher clockspeed with the dual again, not much takes advantage of the quad, and wont for a while

"Noone" isn't a real word. I believe what you are going for is "no one" which would be the correct usage of the two words used to create the grammatical abortion known across the web as "noone".
 
You know they said dual core was futureproof but ony a hand full of software can use it fully, now we have a quad. Is there something here i'm missing? I think i would like to see 100-150 pieces of software to support it instead of 2-5 we have now.

Dual core has been out a while now and nothing much is even out there even 64bit has been out ther a couple of years and still no great 64 bit software around.

The companies are just raking us(enthusiasts).

Well said. I'm not sure how my old A64 3200+ would run 64bit software. :D I'd say dual core until quad D's get refreshed or replaced. ;)
 
grammar police detected. shat i didnt capitalize my g. Ahh or my S. Ohh im not using commas. ahhhhh
 
grammar police detected. shat i didnt capitalize my g. Ahh or my S. Ohh im not using commas. ahhhhh

For some reason, "noone" is a particular hot button for me. The other thing that bothers me is the use of "u" and "ur" instead of "you" and "your."
 
For some reason, "noone" is a particular hot button for me. The other thing that bothers me is the use of "u" and "ur" instead of "you" and "your."

When I'm reading a post I actually say "ur" to myself like it reads... makes me sound retarded, but hey, it's what it says....
 
When I'm reading a post I actually say "ur" to myself like it reads... makes me sound retarded, but hey, it's what it says....

I know this isn't true 100% of the time buy anytime I read "u" or "ur" in a post I assume the person who typed it is a complete moron.
 
I apologize for the late reply my internet has been going out alot so whenever it was up I only got to reply to one thread. At least it`s fixed now

I`m going with the q6600 not only because of the price but because i lean more heavily to video production then i do to gaming, and i hate the long encode times and other waiting periods i had with my old pc. So anything that would help make it faster is great in my book.

The video card I am still torn on. I have a thread on that in the video card forum but it`s hard in deciding as right now the money is no issue but in 3-4 months when the new cards come out it would be. Generally I wouldnt be buying right now, if I had a choice I`d probably wait. Worse is that even if I get a cheap card it wouldnt help when it comes time to get the new cards.

I want to keep sli as that is what i had previously. It`s just a tossup between getting a BFG 8800gtx OC2 (626mhz 2.0 ghz) or the MSI 8800 GTX Ultra (660 mhz 2.3 ghz) the major thing holding me back is the price difference (seems to be almost $200 Canadian) But a lot of people are saying i can OC the BFG to ultra speeds without causing too much problems so I don`t know.

Regardless with the Q6600 I`m sure whatever one i go with it`ll be a good pc.

Thank you for your opinions and advice it is greatly appreciated.
 
Back
Top