Best 120.1 Rad for $$?

Joined
Feb 15, 2006
Messages
780
Which one is good for the $$? I'm planning on using 2 for my P182, It will cool, cpu, nb, pwm, and possibly a gpu soon as well. I'm guessing the thermochill is best but it also costs more than some other 120.3 rads.
 
A Black Ice pro offers the best bang for the buck. It's a pity that the Swiftech MCR120QP has soldered barbs as it's a really good single 120mm rad. Thing is that if you want to use anything other than 3/8" tubing you have to use adapters at the rad(s).
 
A Black Ice pro offers the best bang for the buck. It's a pity that the Swiftech MCR120QP has soldered barbs as it's a really good single 120mm rad. Thing is that if you want to use anything other than 3/8" tubing you have to use adapters at the rad(s).

Meh, I've fit 1/2 over 3/8 barbs, you just have to put a little elbow grease into it.

Just put the tubing in boiling water before and them apply.
 
Meh, I've fit 1/2 over 3/8 barbs, you just have to put a little elbow grease into it.

Just put the tubing in boiling water before and them apply.

I think you're thinking backwards...
 
If you truly are looking for best bang for buck and can handle doing some custom mounting my choice would be.

http://www.dangerden.com/store/product.php?productid=47&cat=14&page=1

1/2 id barbs too.

Consider the shroud it helps with mounting, but mounting is not difficult, there are special nylon rods that go through the gaps in the fins that allow you to secure the rad to mounting holes. But still a bit more work and fabrication than the fancier ones. However IMO no other 1x120 is going to out cool it with a decent fan.
 
A Black Ice pro offers the best bang for the buck. It's a pity that the Swiftech MCR120QP has soldered barbs as it's a really good single 120mm rad. Thing is that if you want to use anything other than 3/8" tubing you have to use adapters at the rad(s).

Agreed, I think the black ice pro is a good choice. The MCR120QP is not even nice for 3/8", the tubing would sometimes leak, the soldered fittings are not good. I mean, it's livable, but not ideal at all.
 
If you truly are looking for best bang for buck and can handle doing some custom mounting my choice would be.

http://www.dangerden.com/store/product.php?productid=47&cat=14&page=1

1/2 id barbs too.

Consider the shroud it helps with mounting, but mounting is not difficult, there are special nylon rods that go through the gaps in the fins that allow you to secure the rad to mounting holes. But still a bit more work and fabrication than the fancier ones. However IMO no other 1x120 is going to out cool it with a decent fan.

that is a good price!!!!
i was going to use a 1986 chevy chevette heater core....

advance auto parts part number 399069
price $19.99
I read it over here...
http://www.overclockers.com/tips1022/
 
that is a good price!!!!
i was going to use a 1986 chevy chevette heater core....

advance auto parts part number 399069
price $19.99
I read it over here...
http://www.overclockers.com/tips1022/
DD sells basically the same thing, just with barbs installed. If you can mod barbs on yourself, you'll save money just buying a Chevette HC and modding it, in lieu of shipping. The nice(r) thing about Chevettes is that the right piece of Tubberware will act as a perfect shroud. The only drawback is you might not be able to fit them so easily in a P182, not to mention mounting it. BIPs don't perform as well as a modded heater core (especially if the HC has a shroud), but they are much easier to mount without possibly damaging the fins and causing a leak.

So, best bang for buck is definately a heater core, but BIP beats it on ease of use.
 
Note the dimensions, the heater core is much thicker and bigger. Beat the shit out of bix. But it will work best with a stronger fan, nothing crazy, I am just saying you could use the Bix with a low speed fan and it would be OK, the heater core would need a medium speed fan and you could turn it down a bit with a cheap speed control like a vantec fan mate 2 but to get the max cooling out of the heater core you need the med speed, bix not so much.

heater core - note thickness is ALL core.
HxWxD = 6 1/8" x 7 3/8" x 2".

bix - note thickness includes mounting flange core is probally 1 1/2 thick.
(5.9 x 5 x 1.69 inch) dimensions


In short Heater Core for MEN with drills and big hammers and other implements of destruction. :eek:

Bix for wimps with $9.95 computer tool kits in imitation leather organizers. :p


Heater core could be pain to install, actaully both probally do the job with just a C2D its not a P4 furnace.

all that stuff you going to cool, I would be looking at the double but thats not what you asked.
 
heatercore, OR, a compact transmission cooler! They are quite small, many are copper, and very cheap!
 
Well I already have a 120.2 heatercore, I wanted to fit everything in case, I think 3 BIX 120.1's should handle it but idk.
 
Three 120.1's will be fine. It's a bit less area than a triple rad but very little.
 
The most convenient radiator out there is the Black Ice Pro from Danger Den. They now come with G 1/4 (BSPP) threads so you can literally put on just about whatever fitting you would like (or like to in the future). :D
 
Back
Top