Is this a good water cooling setup?

Hardcore

n00b
Joined
Jun 6, 2006
Messages
44
Eventually want to cool quad core processor. How does this setup look?

I am planning to use the following parts in a water cooling setup. I'm hoping to mount the radiator inside of my Coolermaster Wavemaster at the top inside one of the 5 1/4 drive bays. There will be some delta fans pushing air through the rad, exiting out the top of the case.

The Main parts are as follows:

Pump: Swiftech MCP655-B
Radiator: HW Labs Black Ice GT Stealth 240 Dual 120mm
CPU Block: D-TEK Customs Fuzion CPU Water Block
Fillport: Danger Den Cooling System
Reservoir: Swiftech MCRES-MICRO Clear HI-FLOW Reservoir
Tubing: Masterkleer Pvc Tubing 7/16IN


Here are my questions about this setup:

1. Will it perform okay with inside the case? I really don't want to start mounting radiators outside the case

2. How will the selected radiator perform?

3. Any changes I should make/additions? I'm only really concerned about cooling the processor. How many fittings do I need to purchase? Clamps?

Btw, total for this system is approx $215.

Thanks
 
Ditch the resivior, they are nothing but trouble. You don't need it with the Danger Den Fillport anyway. Just use a t-line to bleed the air out of the system.

I don't know about that radiator, but everything else looks good.
 
Ditch the resivior, they are nothing but trouble. You don't need it with the Danger Den Fillport anyway. Just use a t-line to bleed the air out of the system.

I don't know about that radiator, but everything else looks good.
Reservoirs can go bad, but a good one is just as reliable as a T-line, bleeds muuuuch faster, and can be easier to fill. A bad one can flood your case faster than a T, so do some research.

The 2x120 GT Stealth will cool your quad core fine, but Deltas are overkill for it. If you really plan on using Deltas, Black Ice GTX Xtremes of Thermochill HEs will get more benefit out of that extra airflow. Unfortunately, those are $100+, so you might look into 2x120mm heater cores (like a 1977 Bonneville) - 2Fresh sells them premodded, you can ask him for more info.
 
OP: Don't go for that radiator...

Unless your using 2 fans that push upwards of 60cfm, you're not getting the full performance out of it. Get a swiftech MCR 220 radiator instead, and throw on some yate-loon fans.

That'll take the heat of any quad core CPU.

Rest is great. Reservoirs make getting air out MUCH easier, they risk cracking (not a huge risk, but a risk nonetheless) and they do restrict flow a tiny bit... not that it matters in such a simple loop.
 
Reservoirs can go bad, but a good one is just as reliable as a T-line, bleeds muuuuch faster, and can be easier to fill. A bad one can flood your case faster than a T, so do some research.

The 2x120 GT Stealth will cool your quad core fine, but Deltas are overkill for it. If you really plan on using Deltas, Black Ice GTX Xtremes of Thermochill HEs will get more benefit out of that extra airflow. Unfortunately, those are $100+, so you might look into 2x120mm heater cores (like a 1977 Bonneville) - 2Fresh sells them premodded, you can ask him for more info.

I do realize that they are much faster to bleed, and I've used them with success before. I have however had leak issues in my setups before and they always come from the reservior. Every single time I've had a leak it's always been there. I've always been able to correct it, but it's just more trouble that it's worth in my opinion. The t-line has it's drawbacks as do fill ports, but my experiences with that setup have been far better.
 
I guess I will weigh in here as the pro for reservoirs. They make bleeding your system much more easier, eliminate any problems with your pump not getting enough coolant (i.e. pump starvation), and depending on the type you pick out there is a definite bling factor involved. So long as you pick a good quality reservoir that uses BSPP fittings you will have no problems with leakage.

Since no one else has deemed to discuss it I would suggest that you consider going to 5/16" or 3/8" ID tubing. Unless you are looking to eek out the last 10-30 Mhz of OC your CPU is capable of you will highly unlikely see any difference. In addition you will find it much easier to route tubing throughout your computer case and have less potential damage to components related to using big tubing (i.e. torsional and lateral stress)
 
Thanks for all the tips. The deltas I'm using are 72 cfm. Should I get the swiftech or stick with my current selection?

I'm still up in the air on the reservoir and the t-line + fill port.

Keep the tips coming!
 
Forgot to mention that R1ckCa1n has a similar setup to your planned setup and went from using 1/2" tubing to 1/4" tubing and only saw a rise of 0.7 C in his temps.
 
I'd almost pay money to see a build without a D-Tek FuZion. All the w/c builds are clones these days. Anyway, the Black Ice Stealth GT is a decent radiator and not big and bulky which is a good thing, if you desperately need that 1-2C° decrease in temps, get the Thermochill (yes, the one everybody else uses -except me:p ).

A res would make your w/c life much easier. I really don't see how a res would restrict flow, especially if the res is above the pump. Besides, a very slight flow restriction wouldn't affect temps that much at all, if at all.
 
I'd almost pay money to see a build without a D-Tek FuZion. All the w/c builds are clones these days. Anyway, the Black Ice Stealth GT is a decent radiator and not big and bulky which is a good thing, if you desperately need that 1-2C° decrease in temps, get the Thermochill (yes, the one everybody else uses -except me:p ).

A res would make your w/c life much easier. I really don't see how a res would restrict flow, especially if the res is above the pump. Besides, a very slight flow restriction wouldn't affect temps that much at all, if at all.

I do not have a D-Tek Fuzion in my rig, nor do I use the Thermochill radiator. (Or half the stuff that came with my Swiftech setup.)
 
LOL, besides Dan, Ikellensbro, and Arcy, I see others are hard at work on this thread to sway Hardcore with their agenda.
 
LOL, besides Dan, Ikellensbro, and Arcy, I see others are hard at work on this thread to sway Hardcore with their agenda.

I don't want to waste any words on your non-contribution to this thread so heres to ya!
finger.gif
 
I don't want to waste any words on your non-contribution to this thread so heres to ya!
finger.gif

Thirded

Forgot to mention that R1ckCa1n has a similar setup to your planned setup and went from using 1/2" tubing to 1/4" tubing and only saw a rise of 0.7 C in his temps.

Actually, yes. I just introduced a Fuzion GPU block (8800GTS) to the loop and are getting great results. All of this is with 1/4" tubing mind you. Time to crank back up the voltage and FSB to see if I lost any overclock.

FuzionGPU.jpg
 
Well, right or wrong, I decided to go with the reservoir system. I just hope I don't have to deal with leaks, but I really like the idea of it being easier to get the air out with. I also like the idea of being able to see the water moving throughout the reservoir. Peace of mind the water is still circulating.

Thanks for everyones help. I'm sure I will be back asking more questions when I get the parts and start modding my case. I will likely make a work log out of it. It should be interesting.
 
Well, right or wrong, I decided to go with the reservoir system. I just hope I don't have to deal with leaks, but I really like the idea of it being easier to get the air out with. I also like the idea of being able to see the water moving throughout the reservoir. Peace of mind the water is still circulating.

Thanks for everyones help. I'm sure I will be back asking more questions when I get the parts and start modding my case. I will likely make a work log out of it. It should be interesting.

Well I don't like reserviors, but I've used them and they can be nicer to work with than a T-line. Bleeding the system is about 100x easier with a reservior instead of the T-line.

You just need to be very careful when setting up your reservior, or any component for that matter. BTW the only reservior I recommend is the Swiftech Micro-res.
 
I'm thinking I will put the reservoir as far away from the motherboard as I can. Also, below any hard drives, just in case.

As for the res, I am getting the swiftech micro-res. Hopefully it will be leak proof.
 
I'm thinking I will put the reservoir as far away from the motherboard as I can. Also, below any hard drives, just in case.

As for the res, I am getting the swiftech micro-res. Hopefully it will be leak proof.

As long as your barbs are screwed in tight enough, you shouldn't have any problems.
 
You might also want to consider using one of the round reservoirs that either mount to the top of your case or in a front bay (AC, Innovatek, or a few other European companies). If you look around someone on this board also made some out of delrin and AC also produced some that were made of solid hunk of Plexiglas GS.
 
You might also want to consider using one of the round reservoirs that either mount to the top of your case or in a front bay (AC, Innovatek, or a few other European companies). If you look around someone on this board also made some out of delrin and AC also produced some that were made of solid hunk of Plexiglas GS.

that would be nikhsub1.
 
There will be some delta fans pushing air through the rad, exiting out the top of the case.

thats the bit I would change, suck cool air in, you just blew 3-5C of the temp delta between the temp of the rad and the temp of the airflow and that delta is the primary/major factor in how well the rad will dump heat. Or set up some kind of vent/shroud to pull air in from a frount bay or something. Cool air to the rad somehow.
 
Back
Top