Generally what will be cheaper, prebuilt or self built?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I really like your selections

I'm just curious, how did you go about picking the RAM?

Is there a noticeable difference between a Cas Latency of 3, 4, or 5?
 
I really like your selections

I'm just curious, how did you go about picking the RAM?

Is there a noticeable difference between a Cas Latency of 3, 4, or 5?

Not too much of a noticeable difference in my experience. I picked that RAM simply because I've used the same set myself and they work well for me. I have to thank enginurd though for bringing my attention to that set of RAM.
 
Well looking at this page, is there really a difference in the 10 ram listed?

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produ...Subcategory=147&description=&Ntk=&srchInDesc=

What kind of voltage and Timing should I be looking for? And what exactly does it mean?

This is my last post for the night, I'll reply back tomorrow. Thanks for all the info!

There is probably a difference yes, it's just not that easy to spot, difference in used memorychips / binning of chips is not immidiately obvious...

What you want: lowest timings possible at rated speed (more speed, 4-4-4-12@800MHz is faster than 5-5-5-15@800MHz all other things being equal) with the lowest voltage (less heat). But remember that the C2D platform isn't as sensitive to timings as the AMD platform, so don't go spend a million on memory, just spend enough.
 
As Darth Bobo said, the price premium for tighter timings sometimes isn't worth it. While tighter timings are faster, you won't really notice the difference in every day usage, especially going from CL5 to CL4. Now, maybe going from CL5 to CL3 you'd notice a slight improvement, but the price premium for that luxury just isn't worth it. The good thing about those G.Skills is that they're rated for 1.8v, and as DB also said, this translates to less heat being produced in your case.

Danny's build is similar to mine... but alas, mine gets no love, even though it is a bit cheaper after rebate, lol. :( Danny's has the 620W instead :eek: so it wins, lol. I went with the E6420 because it can OC as much as an E6600, but the price difference between the two is minimal now, and the E6600's higher multiplier makes it easier to OC. The Leadtek, I think, performs better than the eVGA (I think I read a review that showed this, but I cant find the link), but I chose eVGA for its warranty coverage (lifetime, allows OC'ing, allows you to change coolers). I tossed in a base case to give you an idea of what to get.
 
Well I should point out I'm not planning on OCing, so I'm sure that would change some of my choices.

Also does it make a difference if I get a case and psu separately or together? From what I can gather it just opens up more options since I won't be limited by a psu when looking for a case.
 
Well I should point out I'm not planning on OCing, so I'm sure that would change some of my choices.

Nah, it'll just make us try harder at convincing you to OC. OC'ing properly won't shorten the life of the CPU, nor will it make the system unstable. These Core2Duos have so much headroom that they're rock solid even at 1Ghz overclocks! It would be a shame to not fully utilize your chip to its full potential. So why didn't Intel rate these chips that high if they could run that high? Simple... they wanted to beat AMD on power consumption. So, they lowered the power, which makes them run cooler, and they still outperform their AMD counterparts. Performance per clock has improved so much that even a modest OC would yield noticeable performance increase.

E6420: 8 * 266 = 2.13Ghz, DDR2-533 (stock)
E6420: 8 * 333 = 2.66Ghz, DDR2-667 (modest OC)
E6420: 8 * 400 = 3.20Ghz, DDR2-800 (good OC)

E6600: 9 * 266 = 2.40Ghz, DDR2-533 (stock)
E6600: 9 * 333 = 3.00Ghz, DDR2-667 (modest OC)
E6600: 9 * 400 = 3.60Ghz, DDR2-800 (good OC)
 
Worry of CPU damage was the only thing that had me worried about OCing, but from all the talk about it I might as well fall to peer preasure and do it.

One of the things that stopped me from OCing was just how hot my CPU ran right now without OCing it. I have a 2.8Ghz CPU and idle it runs at 50C and I've seen it spike at 79C, which is ridiculously high from what I understand.
 
Yah, those old chips ran hot because they required A LOT more power than the new chips. Your C2D should idle at around <30° and reach around 50°C during load, at stock speeds with stock cooling. How high the temps get should be a factor in how high you OC it. My E6400 with Scythe Ninja Plus Rev.B idled at 31°C and reached 50°C during load when I was running it at 3.2Ghz, which needed 1.33125v (stock is 1.325). When I bumped the voltage to 1.55v and increased the speed to 3.6Ghz, it idled at 37°C and reached 56°C during load. Remember, the more voltage you give it, the hotter it runs. So, since you're a bit paranoid, keep the voltage around 1.3v and increase the speed as much as possible for that voltage.
 
Danny's build is similar to mine... but alas, mine gets no love, even though it is a bit cheaper after rebate, lol. :(

Well either one of our builds will be good for the OP :). Don't worry enginurd, I'm pretty sure someone out there will give you some love one of these days. LOL!
 
I have mentioned this before but I will again for the sake of anyone unaware. Mwave.com has prices similar to the egg and also has a build option for 80 bucks. So basically you pick all your components one by 1 adding the build option to your cart as well. So now instead of building yourself when you get all the stuff. it comes all done for ya. They assemble, test, burnin, test for compatability, and load all drivers and the OS with no extra bloatware.

So in summary you get the prices we all are used to paying for the individual parts and for an extra 80 bucks they take out all the headaches of testing and rma bullshit. I love it.
 
I have mentioned this before but I will again for the sake of anyone unaware. Mwave.com has prices similar to the egg and also has a build option for 80 bucks. So basically you pick all your components one by 1 adding the build option to your cart as well. So now instead of building yourself when you get all the stuff. it comes all done for ya. They assemble, test, burnin, test for compatability, and load all drivers and the OS with no extra bloatware.

So in summary you get the prices we all are used to paying for the individual parts and for an extra 80 bucks they take out all the headaches of testing and rma bullshit. I love it.

However, if you're a cheapskate or a sado-masochist, then don't spend the extra $80. :)
 
However, if you're a cheapskate or a sado-masochist, then don't spend the extra $80. :)

So uh... I like building the thing myself, just because its fun. Though, I rarely go through RMA bullshit... and when I do go through RMA, its usually a quick and easy experience, lol. Does that make me a cheapskate? :D
 
Ok, show me a full build for $480 shipped, without rebates... including a dual core CPU at least 2Ghz stock speed, 1GB of ram, 160GB HDD, a 19" LCD monitor, and xp. And remember, don't use shitty parts, lol.
The cheapest thing on Dell's site as of 5 minutes ago. Scratch and dent
http://outlet.us.dell.com/ARBOnline...line/en/InventorySearch?c=us&cs=22&l=en&s=dfh
Vista Home Basic
512 MB DDR2 SDRAM 533MHz
160 GB SATA
256MB nVidia Geforce 7300LE
Pentium D Processor 915
16X DVD ROM

Sub $429
Ship $29.99
Tax $33.96
Total $492.95

A 5 minute search:
NSK 4400 with PSU $49.99 at Fry's
E4300 w/ mobo $129 at Fry's
WD 160g $52.99 at Newegg
MSI 7300LE $49.99 at Newegg
Corsair 512mb $32.99 at Newegg
Vista Basic $94.99 at Newegg
Lite-on DVD $11.99 at Newegg

$442 Total after shipping/tax. All new parts vs dell's scratch and dent, current prices as of now, no shopping for deals/rebates and there's definitely better deals than that out there. EAD
 
So uh... I like building the thing myself, just because its fun. Though, I rarely go through RMA bullshit... and when I do go through RMA, its usually a quick and easy experience, lol. Does that make me a cheapskate? :D

No, just a sado-masochist. LOL. :D j/k

Anyway, Rusky, why did you choose the ASUS Commando? It's not a bad board but it's terribly expensive and I don't think it'll fit within your budget. Plus there's better boards to be had like the Gigabyte GA-965P-DS3 or the mobo that enginurd and I suggested in our earlier posts.
 
I chose it based on suggestions in a thread I made on the motherboard forum
http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1189590

But I am still 100% open to suggestions.

What I want from a motherboard is:

1. Has SATA and allows a Raid 0
2. Memory Standard : DDR2 800
3. Form Factor : ATX
4. IEEE 1394 : 1 x IEEE 1394a

Here is a list of 56 motherboards with those requirements

I'm more than happy to get more motherboard suggestions for me to research and pick. I really rather not research all 56 boards, so the 3 I already have to research is a great start.

I'm open to any motherboard from $100-$150, I only picked the Commando because of all the praise it got from a few other posters.
 
I was talking to a friend and he mentioned that if I get a ATI video card (which I am getting) I should look for a motherboard that has ATI components on it.

How true is this? Should I got out of my way for such a board or will it not really matter?
 
I was talking to a friend and he mentioned that if I get a ATI video card (which I am getting) I should look for a motherboard that has ATI components on it.

How true is this? Should I got out of my way for such a board or will it not really matter?

Totally not true. Whoever told you that is GROSSLY misinformed. You can use an ATi video card on mobo with Nvidia chipsets and vice versa. It's not good business practice to lock people in like that.
 
Totally not true. Whoever told you that is GROSSLY misinformed. You can use an ATi video card on mobo with Nvidia chipsets and vice versa. It's not good business practice to lock people in like that.

I didn't mean it wouldn't work with the different chipset, I mean it would perform better with a like chipset.
 
Well you and everyone else in this thread has been amazing in helping me.
If all of this poor college students money wasn't going to the PC I would be tempted to throw money at you for such great help.

Hopefully that's the last of my questions, but don't let your guard down. A question could sneak attack you at any time :D

Thanks again
 
Keep us posted on the build and when you get it up and running. Gl. :)

Will do, and thanks for the site.
Never hurts to have extra sources of parts.

Also with all this talk of OCing...I've never done it before.
I will check out the OC forum, but are there any general tips I should know about OCing? And what should I OC? CPU, RAM, Motherboard?
 
If all of this poor college students money wasn't going to the PC I would be tempted to throw money at you for such great help.

Yeah I'm also a poor college student :)

As for the OCing, of course you OC the CPU!!
 
The cheapest thing on Dell's site as of 5 minutes ago.

I was right... you're just not looking at the dell deals, but instead going off everyday bullshit. We never recommend everyday bullshit, we always recommend DEALS. Hence, your statement, "building it yourself is always cheaper" is FALSE. ..and you're telling me a free ECS mobo from Fry's is of better quality than a Dell mobo?! :rolleyes: you're so funny.

Anyway, Rusky, why did you choose the ASUS Commando? It's not a bad board but it's terribly expensive and I don't think it'll fit within your budget. Plus there's better boards to be had like the Gigabyte GA-965P-DS3 or the mobo that enginurd and I suggested in our earlier posts.

While the commando is a very nice board, its just not worth its price tag.

What I want from a motherboard is:
2. Memory Standard : DDR2 800

All current decent C2D boards out right now support DDR2-800. Newegg's listing of "Memory Standard" is irrelevant (and nearly useless). Instead, it should list all the memory speeds its compatible with, but it doesnt. So, check the manufacturer's site for the complete list. Though, again, all boards that have been suggested support DDR2-800.

The P6N SLI-FI fits your needs perfectly, as Danny mentioned.

Also with all this talk of OCing...I've never done it before. I will check out the OC forum, but are there any general tips I should know about OCing? And what should I OC? CPU, RAM, Motherboard?

Yah, follow a guide exactly, since its your first time. Theres a huge thread on the P6N SLI board we've been recommending to you over in the mobo subforum. You raise the FSB speed on the motherboard so that the CPU runs faster. Its best to get RAM thats already rated to run at the overclocked speed of the FSB, so you don't have to worry about OC'ing it.

Well you and everyone else in this thread has been amazing in helping me. If all of this poor college students money wasn't going to the PC I would be tempted to throw money at you for such great help.

no prob... we love doin this stuff... yes, even for FREE, lol.
 
I was right... you're just not looking at the dell deals, but instead going off everyday bullshit. We never recommend everyday bullshit, we always recommend DEALS. Hence, your statement, "building it yourself is always cheaper" is FALSE. ..and you're telling me a free ECS mobo from Fry's is of better quality than a Dell mobo?! :rolleyes: you're so funny.
I gave you Dell's specials page vs. every day prices on individual parts that could have been found a hell of a lot cheaper by skimming the deals section of this forum. And yes, an ECS motherboard is every bit as good as what Dell ships. My comments are true and I took the time to back them up, deal with it.
 
You raise the FSB speed on the motherboard so that the CPU runs faster. Its best to get RAM thats already rated to run at the overclocked speed of the FSB, so you don't have to worry about OC'ing it.

I'm assuming the G.Skill ram is already rater for that?

Now I just have to figure out which video card I want to get. I'm a fan of ATI for their price and performance.
I kinda wanted to wait for the DX10 cards, but seeing that my computer died just 3 days ago I don't want to wait too long.

Are there any ATI cards that you have a personal liking towards?
 
I gave you Dell's specials page vs. every day prices on individual parts that could have been found a hell of a lot cheaper by skimming the deals section of this forum. And yes, an ECS motherboard is every bit as good as what Dell ships. My comments are true and I took the time to back them up, deal with it.

Clearly, you're missing the point. You stated DIY is ALWAYS cheaper than a Dell, but its NOT. Clearly, you don't even know what a Dell DEAL is, lol. You're too proud to admit you're wrong, so whatever.

Anyhow, sorry for dumping this crap into your thread Rusky.

I'm assuming the G.Skill ram is already rater for that?

Now I just have to figure out which video card I want to get. I'm a fan of ATI for their price and performance.
I kinda wanted to wait for the DX10 cards, but seeing that my computer died just 3 days ago I don't want to wait too long.

Are there any ATI cards that you have a personal liking towards?

Yes, the DDR2-800 G.Skill RAM is rated high enough for a good CPU OC without having to OC the ram itself.

ATI only has DX9 cards out right now. However, that isn't a huge bummer because there arent any DX10 games out yet anyhow, lol. If you wanted to grab a cheap DX9 card for now, and sell it when there are more cards and actual DX10 games on the market, go for an X1950Pro.
 
The extra posts don't bother me enginurd, it's all more information to be.

Thanks for the video card suggestion Danny and enginurd, I'll probably end up getting that one. Though I heard that the DX10 cards are supposed to come out in June, or around then. If it's only a month I can wait, but seeing as my PC died I can't wait TOO long.

Now the biggest decision I have to make it which case to get.
Unless you know a brand/model offhand, the only thing I need from the case is:

- At least 1 external 3.5'' drive
- At least 2 external 5.25'' drives
- At least 3 internal 3.5'' drives
- ATX mid tower

Other than that any case with good airflow and lots of fan power would be fine.

Recommending a case is probably harder than recommending a computer build, if you know any good site, other than newegg, or great case that would be great.

I'm looking at a few cases, but lots of them have the internal 3.5'' drives perpendicular to the case and I've been told that it kills the airflow from the front fan.
 
Clearly, you're missing the point. You stated DIY is ALWAYS cheaper than a Dell, but its NOT. Clearly, you don't even know what a Dell DEAL is, lol. You're too proud to admit you're wrong, so whatever.

Anyhow, sorry for dumping this crap into your thread Rusky.
Because you've done a spectacular job of proving it :rolleyes: It's clear you can't back up your statements so I'm done wasting my time with you....I'll simply unsubscribe to this thread, lol.

As for Rusky, this discussion pertains to his original question, there's nothing to be sorry about.
 
I'm looking at a few cases, but lots of them have the internal 3.5'' drives perpendicular to the case and I've been told that it kills the airflow from the front fan.

Never heard of that. I like having those drives perpendicular to the case, it makes taking out or adding in hard drives easier.

As for case recommendations, it depends on how much you wanna spend and whether or not you'll be able to live with it.

Here's a short lists of good cases IMO:

Antec 900
Antec P180B
Antec P182
Antec Solo
Antec Sonata II
Coolermaster Centurion 5 (only $30 from SVC.com)
LIAN LI PC-7B plus II
 
I didn't want to crowd this thread, but since you don't mind, Rusky, I'll prove my point to you, and everyone else except Blown, since he's unsubscribed.

Because you've done a spectacular job of proving it :rolleyes: It's clear you can't back up your statements so I'm done wasting my time with you....I'll simply unsubscribe to this thread, lol.

As for Rusky, this discussion pertains to his original question, there's nothing to be sorry about.

Sure I did...
Ok, show me a full build for $480 shipped, without rebates... including a dual core CPU at least 2Ghz stock speed, 1GB of ram, 160GB HDD, a 19" LCD monitor, and xp. And remember, don't use shitty parts, lol.

There's the deal you couldn't beat. You want more detail on it? Here: http://hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1030822149&postcount=5
Here's that good dell deal you were talking about (w/monitor):

http://forums.slickdeals.net/showthread.php?t=478279

AMD Athlon&#8482; 64 X2 Dual-Core 3800+
Genuine Windows Vista&#8482; Home Basic
1GB Dual Channel DDR2 SDRAM at 667MHz- 2DIMMs
160GB Serial ATA Hard Drive (7200RPM) w/DataBurst Cache&#8482;
48X CD-RW/ DVD Combo Drive
19 inch E197FP Analog Flat Panel
NVIDIA GeForce 6150 LE Integrated Graphics GPU
Integrated 7.1 Channel Audio
Dell USB Keyboard
Dell® 2-button USB mouse

479$

I asked you to...
Ok, show me a full build for $480 shipped, without rebates... including a dual core CPU at least 2Ghz stock speed, 1GB of ram, 160GB HDD, a 19" LCD monitor, and xp. And remember, don't use shitty parts, lol.

But then you go and show me this instead:

The cheapest thing on Dell's site as of 5 minutes ago. ...

A 5 minute search:
NSK 4400 with PSU $49.99 at Fry's
E4300 w/ mobo $129 at Fry's
WD 160g $52.99 at Newegg
MSI 7300LE $49.99 at Newegg
Corsair 512mb $32.99 at Newegg
Vista Basic $94.99 at Newegg
Lite-on DVD $11.99 at Newegg

$442 Total after shipping/tax. All new parts vs dell's scratch and dent, current prices as of now, no shopping for deals/rebates and there's definitely better deals than that out there. EAD

Now doesn't matter. You said DIY is ALWAYS cheaper. Clearly, its not, lol. Where's the 19" monitor? ECS = shitty parts, so you broke the rule. The point of DIY is to get equal or BETTER parts than Dell's OEM, so you could perform the specialized tasks needed (gaming, overclocking, etc). You can't OC much with an ECS board, lol. Maybe a little, but not much... especially if the board comes free with a CPU from Fry's, LOL. ECS from Fry's is of much lower quality than Dell's OEM. Why? Because Dell has better QC than Fry's, and this is proven by the long return lines at fry's, usually with ECS mobo in hand, lol.

That dell deal I'm referring to is from March 26th, 2007, and since you can't even beat that price point NOW, in MAY'07, when prices are even LOWER, that proves that DIY is NOT ALWAYS cheaper. FYI, the price for that build in March, for DIY, was $580, and thats after rebates!

Remember... AMD price drops didnt occur until April 9th...

$95 - AMD Athlon&#8482; 64 X2 Dual-Core 3800+ OEM
$10 - Arctic Cooling Alpine 64 Heatsink/Fan
$90 - Genuine Windows Vista&#8482; Home Basic (OEM)
$64 - 1GB Dual Channel DDR2 SDRAM at 667MHz- 2DIMMs (Super Talent, OCs to DDR2-800 @ 5-5-5-15 w/ 1.9v, better than Dell)
$53 - 160GB Serial ATA Hard Drive (7200RPM) w/DataBurst Cache&#8482; (Western Digital Caviar SE, same as Dell)
$25 - 48X CD-RW/ DVD Combo Drive (Lite-On, same as Dell)
$90 - NVIDIA GeForce 6150 LE Integrated Graphics GPU (Asus M2NPV-VM) Integrated 7.1 Channel Audio (better than Dell)
$20 - Dell USB Keyboard & Dell® 2-button USB mouse (Microsoft Comfort Curve 2000, better than Dell)
$180 - 19 inch E197FP Analog Flat Panel (Samsung 920NW, better than Dell, $20MIR)
========
$627 for better or equal parts to the Dell...

$480 vs $600... 'nuff said.

Some people just don't understand english. "Always" and "Never" are continued to be misused/misunderstood.



Rusky, Danny listed some good case choices there.
 
A bit miffed aren't we? :D

Anyway Rusky, came upon a few more cases last night that may help you out:

Cooler Master Praetorian 730
Gigabyte Aurora
 
A bit miffed aren't we? :D

Anyway Rusky, came upon a few more cases last night that may help you out:

Cooler Master Praetorian 730
Gigabyte Aurora

I actually liked those 2, but after looking at the V1000B, I think I'm sold.
It's a bit pricey, but it's really awesome and worth it IMO.
 
Yeah that Lian Li case is an awesome case. Hope you enjoy it!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top