Generally what will be cheaper, prebuilt or self built?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Rusky

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jan 4, 2005
Messages
380
I'm looking to upgrade my PC in the near future, it's a gaming computer.

What do you guys think will be cheaper.

1. Wait for a good deal at slickdeals.net or another site with the the core parts I need, mobo, cpu, ram. And then upgrade the video card, put more ram into it and whatnot.

2. Fully build my computer from scratch.

A few things to note.
I'm waiting for more DX10 cards to come out and drop in price.
I already have a monitor, HDs, CD/DVD-RW which I'll be reusing.
 
building from scratch will always be cheaper and u get much more better parts then buying pre built

and plus its fun and not hard
 
building from scratch will always be cheaper and u get much more better parts then buying pre built

and plus its fun and not hard

You can't say "will always" be cheaper since that is not true.
Dell quite often has deals that there is no way you can build cheaper yourself due to the cost of the OS.
 
Yeah I'm looking for a Dell deal.

Does anyone know of any time a Dell sells without an OS? I have a legit version and it would save me monies.
 
Currently only on business systems IIRC. You could get one with Ubuntu Linux when they come out.
 
If non-OC, then a dell will do.
However, if you want more quality components, then self-build is cheaper.
 
Can you point me to a nonOS system.
I've looked through the site and wasn't able to find such a system.
 
usually for budget systems where you need everything (case, components, hdds, monitor, etc.) an oem is generally better. but when you have stuff from older builds that you want to reuse than it is definitely more cost effective and better in the long run to build it yourself.
 
I've really not been keeping up with the market on all the new things, can someone jsut throw together a good, not uber expensive, mobo, ram, video card, and cpu.
 
Can you point me to a nonOS system.
I've looked through the site and wasn't able to find such a system.

I used to buy Optiplex systems without an OS, but that was for a school. I don't think you can do that on any of the home/small business systems.

Like I said, you might wait until they launch systems with Ubuntu if you really don't want to pay for Windows.
 
I used to buy Optiplex systems without an OS, but that was for a school. I don't think you can do that on any of the home/small business systems.

Like I said, you might wait until they launch systems with Ubuntu if you really don't want to pay for Windows.

Is there a set date for that?
 
Nope. Just around the end of May I believe.

Now if we were to list a good build list, we need to know what you're planning to do with it and your budget as well.
 
how much do you value your time? [ how long will it take you to research, order, wait, assemble, test, (possible rma - restart from wait), debug. then future consider system level problems you will need to fix yourself. ]

is the intended computer a tool, product or hobby?
 
I will use the computer mainly for gaming since I have my laptop for school work.

I have lots of time to do all the research and build it.

As far as price I would like to stay under 1000, but keeping in mind that I only will need a motherboard, cpu, 1gig ram, 256mb dx10 video card, and maybe a case/power supply.

What are some really good review sites that I can start to research components. Preferable ones that have a list of the component I'm looking for in a best to worst list.
 
In Any case Here is the build I am putting together right now, that is cheap, with the latest components.

MSI P6N-SLI found here for $124 Alot of people are getting upto 495FSB on this board and in some cases up too 510
Intel E4300 found here for $114 I believe with this chip you can get around 3.2 without worries
Corsair XMS2 Found here for $89 Once again, this is very good ram, not the best overclocking ram by far but it is good quality ram, thats proven.
MSI 8600GT Found here for $179 Not quite sure as too the quality of this card yet, havent read too many reviews, but i would just stay shy of any card dx10 below the 8600 series.

All this for the low price of $506 then you gotta think of all the other stuff, case,psu,drives,KB,mouse, but for this price, try finding any dell with anywhere near those quality parts for anything near that price.

hope this helps.

~~john michael~~
 
Yes it does help a lot, I just needed something to start with.

Maybe you could explain to me, on video cards they can be 256mb memory and then can be 256bit or 128bit. What's the difference between having 128bit vs 256bit?
 
oops, i read one of your replies a few posts back and didnt realize their was a 1,000 cap. i still stick by all the other items i listed, but you may wanna step up too a 8800GTS found here for $279 this one comes with a 320bit MI for only a hundred more
 
my GENERAL observations:

For low to midrange systems prebuilt is cheaper than scratchbuilt.

For highend systems scratchbuilt is cheaper...
 
my GENERAL observations:

For low to midrange systems prebuilt is cheaper than scratchbuilt.

For highend systems scratchbuilt is cheaper...

Price wise (average) what do you consider mid range and high end.
 
Price wise (average) what do you consider mid range and high end.

I'm in Denmark, so it's hard for me to give you a number in $ but I venture a guess and say that in $ midrange would top out around $1000 +monitor.

Generally though I prefer to look at performance, right now, if you want anything with an 8800 series graphicscard I'd say you are in the highend catagory and should look to build it yourself, on the other hand if you are just looking for something to browse the internet on, mayby a little bit of gaming on the side, get a Dell or the likes.
 
Yeah I'm not looking to browse the net, I want to play a game like Spider-Man 3 with settings on high...
 
Building will always be cheaper, always. I don't care what's on Dell's site, I've yet to see a computer on their webpage that can't be built for less.....including a $70 OS. Dell does a good job of suckering in people like we're seeing in this thread by posting dirt cheap prices on what look to be good systems until you realize they're so bare you have to upgrade to make them even remotely useable and that's when they hit you with over the top pricing.

If you want a cheap system, I don't care what the pundits in this thread say, hit the [H]ot Deals forum and piece on together over a few weeks and build your own. If you can't build cheaper than a Dell you really suck at building computers.

And to save you the trouble, because this happens every week on this forum, the thread will go like this.

Dell fan, "Dell has a 1.3 GHZ P3, 20 gig HDD, 256 mb rig for $200. The closest thing I could piece together was a C2D, SLI 8800GTX, 4 gig ram, and a terabyte of storage for $1,000. Dell FTW!." Yeah I'm stretching the truth a bit but my point stands...they'll compare 1 gig of Dell crap ram against top of the line 1 gig OC'ing sticks and wonder why Dell's are cheaper :rolleyes:
 
i posted this some while ago, to a guy who was intending to buy a 2150 c2d build from boutique builders. my post was deleted because i was breaking the rules of 'computers and gadgets' forum, but luckily, i saved a copy of it just before clicking submit post
Dell XPS 410
Intel Core 2 Duo E6600 (4MB L2 Cache, 2.4GHZ, 1066FSB)
4GB Dual Channel DDR2 SDRAM at 667Mhz
320GB Serial ATA 3Gb/s Hard Drive (7200RPM) w/ DataBurst Cache
Dual Layer DVD Burner
256MB nVidia GeForce 8600 GTS
Sound Blaster® X-Fi™ XtremeMusic (D) Sound Card
19'' Dell LCD (DIGITAL ULTRASHRAP INCLUDED)
Windows Vista Home Premium
NO DELL BLOATWARE / SHOVELWARE
2 Year Dell Warranty Included
$2,123

Now I know the XPS 410 motherboard, Intel P965 Express Chipset, is basically maxed out at this config and does not support SLI. However, I can always upgrade the video card in the future.

this dell xps is pathetic at best. rest assured u will get the cheapest mobo/psu/ram available in the market. and they didnt even bother to add $60 and put a 8800gts 320mb. i thought this was a gaming build:confused: .
and 4gigs of crappy ddr2-667ram? maybe they have an overstock of them?
e6600 is an excellent cpu, but u wont have any chances in oc it on this setup :(
the xtrememusic has been replaced by the xtremegamer, but its still a nice card. hdd is also good, to be frank

this setup costs around $1200 w/ monitor if u buy its components from a retailer like newegg

Now I know the XPS 410 motherboard, Intel P965 Express Chipset, is basically maxed out at this config and does not support SLI. However, I can always upgrade the video card in the future.

My first choice as as follows:

Velocity Micro Gamers Edge 1500
850 Watt Velocity Micro® Power Supply - Nvidia® SLI™ Certified
Asus® P5N-E SLI nForce 650i SLI, Socket 775, PCI-E, DDR2
Intel® Core™ 2 Duo processor E6600, dual 2.4GHz cores, 4MB L2 Cache (+$125.00)
2048MB Corsair Dominator DDR2-800 Twin2X2048-6400 with Dual-path Heat Xchange (2x1024) (+$265.00)
320MB EVGA GeForce 8800GTS DDR3 PCI-E w/HDCP SUPERCLOCKED (700W+ PSU recommended for SLI) (+$140.00)
Creative Labs SoundBlaster® X-Fi™ XtremeAudio
250GB Western Digital WD2500JD 7200rpm SATA/150, 8MB Cache
1 YEAR VELOCITY MIRCO WARRANTY
Windows Vista Home Premium
NO MONITOR INCLUDED
$2,133


Now the VM MB listed above can support 8GB of RAM in the future and DDR2-800. I know it has more potential because of SLI, but really, how much can the processor take? Can the DELL last just as long without the available expansion? As of now, the MB on the Dell is maxed with the 4GB of RAM and oly DDR2-667. I am not sure of the power supply, but I hope the dell can support a 8800GTS card in the future?


250 - 850 Watt Velocity Micro® Power Supply - Nvidia® SLI™ Certified (should cost around $200-$250)
$129 - Asus® P5N-E SLI nForce 650i SLI, Socket 775, PCI-E, DDR2
$235 - Intel Core 2 Duo E6600 Conroe 2.4GHz 4M shared L2 Cache LGA 775 Processor - Retail
$175 - CORSAIR XMS2 DOMINATOR 2GB (2 x 1GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 800 (PC2 6400) Dual Channel Kit Desktop Memory - Retail
$260 - EVGA 320-P2-N811-AR GeForce 8800GTS 320MB 320-bit GDDR3 PCI Express x16 HDCP Video Card - Retail ($280-$20MIR)
$54 - Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi Xtreme Audio 7.1 Channels 24-bit 96KHz PCI Interface Sound Card - Retail
$67 - Western Digital Caviar SE WD2500JS 250GB 7200 RPM 8MB Cache SATA 3.0Gb/s Hard Drive - OEM
$110 - Microsoft Windows Vista 64-Bit Home Premium Single Pack DVD OEM
$150 - VM case and case badges :p

-----------------------------------------------
TOTAL PRICE = $1430 ~ $1450
-----------------------------------------------

psu: massive overkill. a psu with half the price is enough
mobo:cheap and sli ready
proc:decent cpu, but u are strongly advised to get an aftermarket cooler if u are willing to overclock
ram:even more overkill than the psu. it will give a negligible performance increase in real world applications. its only use is giving more oc headroom, which wont be needed by the e6600, as it has a high multiplier (any ddr2-800 ram will suffice)
vid card: great, and will run the games u listed very smoothly at high settings, but i dont recommend u go sli, since the 320mb will choke it to death. if u really want sli, get 640mb version
sound: xtremeaudio is a rebranded audigy zs (ie lacks eax5.0 and hardware acceleration), if u really want the best sound experience in the games u listed, u better get the xtremegamer
hdd:$3 more and u can get the 16mb cache version from newegg
os: dunno if its 32-bit or 64-bit but they are equally priced








$196 - Intel Core 2 Duo E6420 2.13GHz Desktop Processor - 2.13GHz - 1066MHz FSB - 4MB L2 - LGA775 Socket - BX80557E6420
$170 - EVGA 122-CK-NF67-A1 LGA 775 NVIDIA nForce 680i LT SLI ATX Intel Motherboard - Retail ($195-$25MIR)
$100 - STT DDR2-800 2GB (2x1GB) CL5 Dual Channel Memory Kit
$100 - STT DDR2-800 2GB (2x1GB) CL5 Dual Channel Memory Kit
$528 - EVGA e-GeForce 8800 GTX Graphics Card - nVIDIA GeForce 8800 GTX 575MHz - 768MB GDDR3 - PCI Express x16 ($559-$30MIR)
$528 - EVGA e-GeForce 8800 GTX Graphics Card - nVIDIA GeForce 8800 GTX 575MHz - 768MB GDDR3 - PCI Express x16 ($559-$30MIR)
$80 - Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 ST3320620AS (Perpendicular Recording Technology) 320GB 7200 RPM 16MB Cache SATA 3.0Gb/s Hard Drive - OEM
$116 - Corsair HX CMPSU-620HX ATX12V v2.2 and EPS12V 2.91 AC Power Supply - 620 W Ball Bearing Single Fan - - ATX 12V ($135-$30MIR)
$78 - Creative Labs Sound Blaster X-Fi XtremeGamer Audio 7.1 24-bit PCI Sound Card
$110 - Microsoft Windows Vista 64-Bit Home Premium Single Pack DVD OEM
$150 - a nice case and an aftermarket hsf

----------------------------------------
$2156 + Taxes and shipping
-----------------------------------------
THIS is wut u should get
8800gtx sli + 4gigs ram + c2d(should oc to 3.4-3.6GHz with a good hsf) is wut u are supposed to get.this build is far from being perfect but u have a basic idea of wut u can get if u go through the build-it-yourself route
 
Well it looks like I'll be building my own PC.

Does anyone have any good sites other than tomshardware for info on components?

Right now I'm kinda lost on which motherboard I want.
 
Just go to dailytech.com and search for daily hardware reviews to find component reviews.

You can also lurk around this forum to see other people's build list. There's always two or three people every week asking for help on their build list. You can learn something from them.
 
Building will always be cheaper, always. I don't care what's on Dell's site, I've yet to see a computer on their webpage that can't be built for less.....including a $70 OS. Dell does a good job of suckering in people like we're seeing in this thread by posting dirt cheap prices on what look to be good systems until you realize they're so bare you have to upgrade to make them even remotely useable and that's when they hit you with over the top pricing.

...compare 1 gig of Dell crap ram against top of the line 1 gig OC'ing sticks and wonder why Dell's are cheaper :rolleyes:

ROFL... I guess you only look at their everyday prices, and not the dell deals. :rolleyes:



Well it looks like I'll be building my own PC.
Does anyone have any good sites other than tomshardware for info on components?
Right now I'm kinda lost on which motherboard I want.

Check out the sample builds at arstechnica.com and start from there. Anandtech has some good articles as well as HardOCP.com.

What size monitor do you game on?
 
19 inch does it matter?

Not too much. Most good video cards can play most games at 1280 x 1024 resolution pretty well.

Anyway, what's your budget? Oh and what games are you going to or are planning to play on this system? Are you going to do anything else with this system?
 
ROFL, you're a funny guy :rolleyes:

Ok, show me a full build for $480 shipped, without rebates... including a dual core CPU at least 2Ghz stock speed, 1GB of ram, 160GB HDD, a 19" LCD monitor, and xp. And remember, don't use shitty parts, lol.

19 inch does it matter?

Yes. It determines which resolution you play at, if its an LCD (usually native res). A 19" usually uses 1280x1024, which is far from needing a 680i SLI board. If you have more than 2 IDE devices to reuse, then you could go with the MSI P6N SLI-FI board:

$189 - Intel Core 2 Duo E6420 Conroe 2.13GHz 4MB L2 Cache 1066Mhz FSB
$110 - MSI P6N SLI-FI LGA 775 NVIDIA nForce 650i SLI
$390 - eVGA 640-P2-N821-AR GeForce 8800GTS 640MB ($30MIR)
$90 - G.Skill 2GB (2x1GB) DDR2-800 F2-6400CL5D-2GBNQ
$105 - Corsair CMPSU-520HX 520W PSU ($20MIR)
$35 - Cooler Master RC-534-SWN1 Silver Centurion 534 Steel Mid Tower ATX Case w/ Side Window
=======
$920 plus tax and shipping - $50MIRs
 
My current setup is 2x WD 10k RPM raptor HDs setup in a raid 0 and a 300gb backup drive.

I want to be able to play the games out right such as WoW, Spider-Man 3, and Oblivion at a good speed with high settings. Then again WoW isn't an intensive game, but non-the-less.
 
My current setup is 2x WD 10k RPM raptor HDs setup in a raid 0 and a 300gb backup drive.

I want to be able to play the games out right such as WoW, Spider-Man 3, and Oblivion at a good speed with high settings. Then again WoW isn't an intensive game, but non-the-less.

Again, what's your budget?
 
Mobo, cpu, ram, video card, case, psu


Intel Core 2 Duo E6600 - $226
MSI P6N SLI-FI NVIDIA nForce 650i SLI Motherboard - $110
G.SKILL F2-6400CL5D-2GBNQ 2 x 1GB DDR2 800 RAM - $90
Leadtek WinFast PX8800 GTS TDH GeForce 8800GTS 640MB PCI-E Video Card - $370
Corsair 620HX 620W PSU - $144
---
Total: $940 Plus tax and shipping.

I didn't include a case because I believe cases are a personal choice item. So go on newegg and look for a case you like and go for it. Just make sure it has adequate cooling.
 
No matter what you do, I myself have always biult for my self a little more care and thought goes into it. No matter what you pick you can be limited buy budget. You pick the best you can for budget. I myself never had a budget but have been into comps for years, fixing biulding doing everything to them. Even owned my own comp store. I have had biulds left and right from the early days went through all cpus, os, videocards and mbs and different cases. You pick what you have to work with you think of the future and all upgrade paths. I would like to say though its more like a addiction at times changing this does that and so forth. No matter what you pick, for what you can afford and how youre going to use the comp, you read and read is all. Its like biulding a motor in a car when you fire it up for the first time u go through everything. In the long run all what matters is if it meets youre needs and thats it, yes something will come out better for sure. But right now myself the comp I have meets my needs i have not upgraded in about a year now except this week. Biuld it youre self no matter what, more satisfaction more gratification and all in all just another thing you can do. Reading is youre friend
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top