capacitor on G71 fell off

n00btard

Gawd
Joined
Dec 10, 2005
Messages
922
Pulled 7900GTX out of PC, set it on desk. Then *pop!* a capacitor fell off :eek:

Probably attributable to the fact that it's a second-hand card off [H], or I f:mad:cked something while trying to wrestle card into the wiring hell that is the P180.

bustedGPU.jpg


Please please please... PLEASE tell me that repairing it is a simple matter of soldering the capacitor back on :(

(and feel free to photoshop "OWNED" onto it)
 
uhh..gg man..


nah i'm sure you can solder it back on, just make sure not to f*ck up when you do it. because then if you mess up, the cap won't just pop off, it'll blow up.
 
LoL, I had a evga card do that to me in past... There was something loose in my unopened 7800gt box from newegg. When I opened it, a capaciter was just chilling there in the plastic. It happens. Needless to say, I RMA'ed it back to newegg right away, but i'm sure it's fixable. Just a little dab of solder.

I'm not sure if it matters which way you put it on though... is there a + or - side? I don't know how that stuff works. ^_^
 
Should be fixable, i would call up and see if the card is RMAable if possible. Tell them it looked like a weak solder.
Just solder it back on otherwise, and since you asked,
bustedgpupf5.jpg
 
Great manufacturing quality, thats all Iam gonna say.

edit:

Forgot to wish good luck on the repairing project, I know I could not do it :(
 
I'm not sure if it matters which way you put it on though... is there a + or - side? I don't know how that stuff works. ^_^

You must observe the correct polarity when reinstalling the capacitor. It should be indicated somewhere on the capacitor. The board clearly shows the location of the positive terminal.

From Wikipedia:
Unlike most capacitors, electrolytic capacitors have a voltage polarity requirement. The correct polarity is indicated on the packaging by a stripe with minus signs and possibly arrowheads, denoting the adjacent terminal that should be more negative than the other. This is necessary because a reverse-bias voltage will destroy the center layer of dielectric material via electrochemical reduction (see Redox reactions). Without the dielectric material the capacitor will short circuit, and if the short circuit current is excessive, then the electrolyte will heat up and either leak or cause the capacitor to explode.

Prep the landing pads with a little solder first and tin the leads on the cap also. Set her on there and hit both sides with the iron just so the solder flows and wallah.
 
Read up on surface mount technology too - not the same as larger scale soldering where you thread the leads through a hole and solder to copper pads.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surface-mount_technology

The one major disadvantage of SMT is the difficulty in manual handling due to the very small sizes and lead spacings of SMDs, making component-level repair of devices using it extremely difficult, and often uneconomical.

But for that particular component, you shouldn't have too much trouble - keep the temp as low as possible. You might consider getting one of those "cold" soldering irons that works by conducting electricity through your solder to melt it without heating the PCB...
 
Repairing it will probably be harder than it looks... Use the smallest tip you can to get in there.
 
...or maybe a strand of wire from each contact on the PCB to each "leg" on the capacitor?

and capacitor in the picture is photographed in the orientation it was on the PCB, so I'll just use the picture as a reference, I guess...
 
Great manufacturing quality, thats all Iam gonna say.

edit:

Forgot to wish good luck on the repairing project, I know I could not do it :(

Has nothing to do with manufacturing quality. Heavy surface mounted devices like that place a great amount of stress on the soldered connections.

It is very easily fixable. I could probally walk you through it in 5 minutes.
 
The one major disadvantage of SMT is the difficulty in manual handling due to the very small sizes and lead spacings of SMDs, making component-level repair of devices using it extremely difficult, and often uneconomical.

That comment is utter bullshit. I do a lot of SMD reworks with my job, and its comes down to skill and experience, and the right tools.

Granted I have to do most of my work under a 6x-45x microscope, but with the right tools the repairs are not that hard.

The only thing impossible to do without very specific equipment is BGAs.
 
1) Cut two little pieces of solder, stick them onto PCB, position cap over, and hope that solder doesn't bridge

2) Do what a 14-year old kid did on XS: use wire, and have the cap dangling about 2cm from the PCB itself while making it easier to solder.

3) What other possibilities?

I was going to try #2 today, but found out I had to buy my own soldering iron because my mom doesn't want me using her's :(
 
#2 sounds good, just make sure the leads aren't ridiculously long.

PM me if you don't want to deal and are willing to let it go for a reasonable price ;) .
 
You might consider getting one of those "cold" soldering irons that works by conducting electricity through your solder to melt it without heating the PCB...

i would stay away from cold heat, think about it. they not only actually make the solder very hot really fast, but it does so by running a current through your solder(and subsequently through your board). chances are you'll damage the card, plus they are bulky and dont work(for any soldering task) near as well as the tv ad would make you believe(got one as a gift).

OP:for that purpose id just get the 15/30 watt soldering iron at radioshack for $15 or so. its no professional tool, but its cheap and safe enough for that kind of repair. and dont sweat it dude, like the others have said its not near as difficult as it seems.......use a couple(short) wires if need be.;)
 
i would stay away from cold heat, think about it. they not only actually make the solder very hot really fast, but it does so by running a current through your solder(and subsequently through your board). chances are you'll damage the card, plus they are bulky and dont work(for any soldering task) near as well as the tv ad would make you believe(got one as a gift).

OP:for that purpose id just get the 15/30 watt soldering iron at radioshack for $15 or so. its no professional tool, but its cheap and safe enough for that kind of repair. and dont sweat it dude, like the others have said its not near as difficult as it seems.......use a couple(short) wires if need be.;)

Not true:
http://www.epemag.wimborne.co.uk/cold-soldering.htm

1. I might have misspoken - no current runs through the solder. It all runs through the tip which allows it to heat up in 1 sec, and cool down in 3.

2. You use very fine solder with a "cold" soldering iron because of the lower temperature / energy transfer.

These two characteristics make it the perfect match for soldering fine, heat sensitive SMT components.

Of course you are free to form your own opinion provided they are based on facts. The two objections you stated are incorrect because no current travels through your solder or your device and the tip has remarkable low heat capacity compared to a standard soldering iron - this means that prolonged contact with your PCB will not be likely to damage it since there is not enough energy to heat up the board, traces, other contacts like you can with a 15 watt conventional iron.
 
one of those capacitors fell off one of my old GF4 Ti4200. Amazingly the card still works and plays games!
 
You can re-solder it, but it's not easy. It might be easier to use a replacement cap that is not DSM.
 
Not true:
http://www.epemag.wimborne.co.uk/cold-soldering.htm

1. I might have misspoken - no current runs through the solder. It all runs through the tip which allows it to heat up in 1 sec, and cool down in 3.

2. You use very fine solder with a "cold" soldering iron because of the lower temperature / energy transfer.

These two characteristics make it the perfect match for soldering fine, heat sensitive SMT components.

Of course you are free to form your own opinion provided they are based on facts. The two objections you stated are incorrect because no current travels through your solder or your device and the tip has remarkable low heat capacity compared to a standard soldering iron - this means that prolonged contact with your PCB will not be likely to damage it since there is not enough energy to heat up the board, traces, other contacts like you can with a 15 watt conventional iron.




From the site you linked...
This is why a Coldheat Soldering Iron should only be used with great care (if at all) on any circuit containing semiconductors (diodes, transistors, integrated circuits). The voltage across the 'split tip' can power up the circuit being soldered, or forward/ reverse bias a semiconductor junction, possibly destroying it. Here, an ultra high power l.e.d. is easily illuminated by the tip.


The sole reason you should NEVER use an induction soldering iron on electronics components.




And to the orginial poster. You will have to be careful soldering that back on, both of your pads appear in the power regulation section of the card, and both are on large conduction planes. You will have to use more heat than normal to get those pads to the melting point.

If you don't feel comfortable doing that your self, I would be willing to do it for free provided you paid for shipping both ways. However all I will warranty is that the component is soldered on properly. Not that the card would work afterwords, (I have no way of knowing weather the card was damaged to begin with)
 
WAIT!! Before you attempt any repairs team with the manufacture to see if it’s under warranty. Many times the manufactures are willing to work with the customers in a case like this if there is not physical damage on the video card (evidence that the video card was dropped or improperly put in the system..for example). If you try to fix the video card yourself and then contact the manufactures they will be unable to help. If its an XFX video card please start a support ticket at www.xfxforce.com then PM me the ticket number so I can try and help.


XFX Support
 
Better to be told no then to miss the chance on a replacement video card. Especially since this is not your fault.


XFX Support
 
Of course you are free to form your own opinion provided they are based on facts. The two objections you stated are incorrect because no current travels through your solder or your device and the tip has remarkable low heat capacity compared to a standard soldering iron - this means that prolonged contact with your PCB will not be likely to damage it since there is not enough energy to heat up the board, traces, other contacts like you can with a 15 watt conventional iron.

did you read the article you linked?
The answer is that the tip’s electrodes have to be bridged by applying them across an electrically-conductive part (such as a component lead). This causes both electrodes to short together, and a substantial current then flows.

If the red light does not turn on, please reposition the tip so that both electrodes make contact with your electrically-conductive work or joint.

it works by using the solder and/or work joint as a medium to bridge the two tips, the 4-5 amps of low voltage running through the work surface(and tip) creates the heat. and although the tip doesnt retain heat easily, so it cools down fast, that brief period of heat can get quite hot. dont believe a few aa batteries can do that? take a thin gauge wire and connect it to both ends of an AA battery and see what happens.


now that youve read the first page of your link, maybe gander at the second?

For the electronics hobbyist, one particularly disconcerting side-effect of the Coldheat way of doing things is that localised arcing and sparking may be produced sporadically when the heating circuit opens or closes. There is of course no such effect when using an ordinary soldering iron: sparks anywhere near a semiconductor are an anathema to the electronics enthusiast. High reverse voltages can be produced in inductive circuits as well.

There is an additional warning about using the Coldheat iron with sensitive electronic components. A voltage exists across the two electrodes that is sufficient, for example, to illuminate a very powerful 3.6V white l.e.d placed across the tips (see photo). If the Coldheat tip were placed across (say) the base and emitter pins of a transistor, or across a diode and forward-biasing it into conduction, this could damage the component permanently.

Since almost all electronic circuits are full of semiconductors, often operating at very low voltages, the Coldheat iron could only be used with caution in such applications, though it is claimed to be suited to larger p.c.b.s, presumably where there is less chance of the iron's electrodes shunting or powering the components. Again, the distributors warn users about this aspect, but this runs contrary to claims that the iron is suitable for 'electronic projects'.
 
Back
Top