Building a budget system

one swell foop

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Nov 16, 2004
Messages
1,091
I want to build a system, on a budget, that will last me 1.5-2 years and do what I need it to do. This consists primarily of messing around on the internet, watching movies, playing with modeling and rendering in MAYA, photo editing in photoshop, and playing a lot of Counterstrike. The machine doesn't need to be the fastest out there, if it did I'd either throw the budget out the window or give up, I model, render, and photo edit for fun so optimizing the system for that isn't necessary if it ups the cost. I've built my last 3 systems and know how to put one together, but am hopelessly out of date in terms of knowledge of the current hardware.
Don't care about overclocking, built a couple of machines with the parts for and intent to overclock and never wound up doing so. I'd rather have a dependable and quiet machine.

-Looking to replace the Processor, Mobo, and RAM. Would prefer to wait to replace my BFG 6800 AGP card, but not sure how many decent Mobo's out there even have an AGP slot anymore. Got all the DVD-RW drivesm HD's, and sound cards I need, so try and stick with replacing the Proc, Mobo, and RAM.
-Cooling is taken care of as I got in on the Cooler Master RL-HUC-E8U1 buy at newegg that was posted in the Hot Deals forum here. Cooling may not be taken care of if the Cooler Master Kit does not contain the bracket for whatever socket mobo and proc I get, but I sure hope it does.


-I would prefer not to spend much over $200 on a motherboard and processor combined. AMD or Intel proc, doesn;t matter to me. I've gone with AMD in the past because of lower pricing for the performance, but they seem to be getting closer to even.

-RAM, need 2 gigs, sad that I don't have it. Considered just upgrading my current system to have 2 gigs to delay the other upgrades, but don't want to spend the $ on DDR when my next system will probably have DDR2 or whatever the hell is out now, and the onboard LAN on my MSI got fried by lightning.

-OS - Sticking with my copy of XP-Pro as Vista is expensive and would help slow down my gaming. If I get a good enough deal on Vista, then maybe, but probably not.

Please help someone stuck in the technological past with some advice.
 
you're better off just going with PCI-e, and doing the card now. There are so few boards out there with both, and they are all pretty crappy (Jetway and AsRock make ones that I know of)

Right now, I'd consider going after an AM2 option, now that it's been officially announced that Barcelona chips will be drop in ready with only a BIOS flash. That will help extend the future longevity of the board. They've also just done some very drastic price cuts, which make some of their fairly higher performing chips pretty reasonably priced.

That said, see below mobo / processor combo at $200.

AMD Athlon 64 X2 4600+(65W) Windsor 2.4GHz 2 x 512KB L2 Cache Socket AM2 Processor
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16819103749

GIGABYTE GA-M55SLI-S4 Socket AM2 NVIDIA nForce4 SLI ATX AMD Motherboard
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813128321

I'm not sure what your budget is on RAM, but I've used this DDR2 800 Geil, and it's good. ($157 after rebate.)
GeIL 2GB (2 x 1GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 800 (PC2 6400) Dual Channel Kit Desktop Memory
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820144047
 
Since you still want to use your 6800 AGP, I'm going to recommend an AMD build here:

Intel Core 2 Duo E4400 - $133 (being released on April 22nd)
ASRock 4CoreDual-VSTA LGA 775 Motherboard - $60
G.SKILL F2-6400CL5D-2GBNQ 2GB (2 x 1GB) DDR2 800 RAM - $125

That mobo I linked to has both AGP and PCI-E ports. So whenever you upgrade to a PCI-E card, you don't have to throw out your mobo right away. That G.Skill 2GB ram kit I linked to is a pretty decent kit. I have a pair of those myself.
 
I found 2 gigs of crucial DDR2 for about $110. Manufacturer's part number CT2KIT12864AA667
Have had Crucial in my boxes for years and never had a problem.
Is a Cas latency of 5 good, bad, or middle of the road for DDR2?
 
Since you still want to use your 6800 AGP, I'm going to recommend an AMD build here:

Intel Core 2 Duo E4400 - $133 (being released on April 22nd)

Danny meant an Intel build.

I found 2 gigs of crucial DDR2 for about $110. Manufacturer's part number CT2KIT12864AA667
Have had Crucial in my boxes for years and never had a problem.
Is a Cas latency of 5 good, bad, or middle of the road for DDR2?

Thats some DDR2-667 RAM. AM2 performs best on DDR2-800. If you go with Danny's build, that Crucial kit would be perfect. CL5 is on the high side for DDR2-667. CL5 is avg for DDR2-800. However, you most likely won't notice the performance difference between the two timings, since you're on a budget.

If you want to keep your AGP card, go with Danny's build.

http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/cpu/display/core2duo-e6420_10.html
 
As much as I'd like to be able to upgrade my video card to a lower end DX10 model right now, I simply can't spend the extra $300-$400 right now, that would double or more my limit. I'm probab;y going to be going with the ASRock board and do an intel build like danny suggested. After that I can upgrade my Vid-card when ready and then, if I want move back to an AMD setup.
Thanks for the advice and links guys....I spent a lot of time trying to convince myself to buy a new video card.
 
When I get a new card I want to get one with more RAM than the one I currently have, maybe move up to one of the 320meg cards. I'll likely wind up upgrading once the price on the card with more RAM falls and more games come out that support DX10.
 
now my only remaining concern that I should have asked about earlier.....How's power consumption on the intel chips, especially the Core 2 Duo E4400 and will the 380 watt queit power supply that was included with my Antec Sonata case be able to handle it?
If not what's a dependable power supply that won't be loud? My comp already got louder than my initial setup when I added the cooler-master unit, I'd like to keep it quietish.
If I must replace it, the idea of a modular power supply is appealing to reduce the excess wiring in my case but which ones have a stable voltage rail? I know a lot of fancy looking units are liable to fry your hardware and I don't want to risk that.
 
Power consumption is very low on the new Core2Duos. Your A64 2800+ was rated at 89W, while most C2Ds are rated at 65W. I doubt you'll have to replace your PSU. However, it is old, so it may need to be replaced soon.
 
Thanks for the quick replies. At this point I have no reason to suspect that my power supply is failing, so if it will provide all the power my new components will need I'll stick with the current one.
 
if you have the first gen sonata case like i once had, you definitely may want to get a better psu. the if i remember correctly that case came with a 380w psu with a pretty weak 12v rail, plus the atx connector is only a 20-pin (not sure if that matters with the asrock board).
 
Is DDR 800 the way to go if I'm getting the Intel Core 2 Duo E4400? If not what speed should I be going for?
 
Is DDR 800 the way to go if I'm getting the Intel Core 2 Duo E4400? If not what speed should I be going for?

It all depends on what you plan on running the CPU at. Most Allendale core CPUs have a max OC of about 3.2Ghz. The E4400 has a stock multiplier of 10 * 200 = 2Ghz. In order to reach 3.2Ghz, you'll need a 320Mhz FSB, which is DDR2-340 ram speed. So, your best suited with some DDR2-667 ram if you're going with the E4400/E4300. If you don't plan on OC'ing at all, then all you need is DDR2-400, since at stock settings, the FSB is 200 (2*200=DDR2-400).
 
The OC thing get more and more appealing the more I think about it. I've previously avoided doing so as I don't want to shorten the life of my components, but if the intel chips actually overclock as easily and well as they seem to be doing, why not?
and according to the following link, those new Nvidia cards seem to kick quite a bit of ass:
http://enthusiast.hardocp.com/article.html?art=MTMyNCwxLCxoZW50aHVzaWFzdA==
 
The price gap between the 8600GTS and 8800GTS isn't too great considering that the XFX GeForce 8600 GTS XXX Edition is priced at $239.99 while the 8800GTS is priced at $280. And the 8800GTS beats the 8600GTS by a wide margin.

While the 8600GTS are good cards, they're just a bit too expensive. The non-OC'd versions of the 8600GTS can barely beat x1950Pro or the 7900GS and it's much more expensive. Since there won't be any DX10 games for a while and AMD's R600 is close by, I say you should og ahead and buy this video card:

SAPPHIRE 100176L Radeon X1950PRO 256MB PCI-Express - $155

It's cheaper and can beat non-OC'd 8600GTS cards.
 
it will be a while before I move on a new card....Gonna go for the MoBo and Intel core duo E4400 when it comes out, along with a couple gigs of RAM. that'll hold me for long enough.
 
SO........if I spend the extra $ and get the SAPPHIRE 100176L Radeon X1950PRO it will drastically increase my options on the mobos' I can get as I won't have to look for something with an AGP slot. What is a good mobo for the intel 4400 proc that is still in the sub $100 range? A board that overclocks easily would be a good thing since this time around I might just experiment with turning it up a notch..
Some of these mobo's are crazy expensive, I remember back in the day when $120 was a lot to spend on a mobo unless you were building a server.
Any benefit to sticking with the Intel chipset as opposed to a proprietary one?
 
SO........if I spend the extra $ and get the SAPPHIRE 100176L Radeon X1950PRO it will drastically increase my options on the mobos' I can get as I won't have to look for something with an AGP slot. What is a good mobo for the intel 4400 proc that is still in the sub $100 range? A board that overclocks easily would be a good thing since this time around I might just experiment with turning it up a notch..
Some of these mobo's are crazy expensive, I remember back in the day when $120 was a lot to spend on a mobo unless you were building a server.
Any benefit to sticking with the Intel chipset as opposed to a proprietary one?

The Biostar TForce965 is good and cheap. The open box version of it is REALLY cheap. The Gigabyte alternative would be the GA-965P-S3. One of the better overclocking boards is the DS3, but the S3 and TForce are great boards for around $100. If you want firewire, theres a Foxcon P9657AA flavor that comes with it, and can OC a bit (around 430Mhz). Stability would be the benefit of sticking with intel. NVIDIA's nForce 600i Series is great, too. Avoid VIA unless you need a super cheap board or an agp board for C2D. I'd also go for the E4300 instead of the E4400. It already has a 9x multiplier and that extra $20 could be used on an Arctic Cooling Freezer 7 Pro from eWiz ($20). They most likely both have the same barrier for overclocking, around 3Ghz, since they're both Allendale cores.
 
Looked at the DS3 and may go with that. Going with the 4300 would allow me to order now(really, really want to upgrade. Since I made the decision to do so my current setup just doesn't seem to be doing it for me). In the intel processor forum, some people seemed to think that the 4300 doesn't overclock really well. Of course that could be my misinterpretation, or they could have meant relative to the 6000 series procs. The cooling aspect is taken care of as I have a two drive bay cooler-master unit that I got for $20 after seeing it in the hot deals forum. Price on the 4300 is going to drop on the 22nd right? Is it worth it to wait?
With the following DS3 the item description says the memory standard is DDR2 800. Going with 667 for OCing purposes wouldn't cause any problems right?
 
The DS3 supports more than just DDR2-800; it also supports DDR2-533/667. So no, it wouldn't any problems. The E4300 is now $135, days before the rumored price drop to $113. If waiting a few days to save $20 isn't a big deal to you, then go ahead and wait. Personally, my time is worth more than that, lol. The Allendale core CPUs cant reach as high as Conroe cores. They typically reach 3Ghz, ± 200Mhz. Drive bay coolers? I was talkin about CPU HSFs, not case fans. You'll need a better HSF to reach 3Ghz than the stock intel cooler.
 
the cooling unit that I have is this, a water colling unit that services only the CPU and can be installed externally, but will also fit in two 5.25" drive bays(although it raises overall case temps by a bit it provides a cleaner look and this is currently where I have it installed).
also, when looking at RAM, if I'm going with DDR2 667, newegg offers 667 in two flavors; PC2 5300 and PC2 5400. How much difference does this make? Will DDR2 667 be good enough for a decent overclock or should I look at faster stuff(though if I did I assume I'd have to also loo at a mobo that supported something past DDR2 800)?

~sigh~I'm so sick of being out of the loop. I used to know my hardware really well. I must be getting old or something.
 
also, when looking at RAM, if I'm going with DDR2 667, newegg offers 667 in two flavors; PC2 5300 and PC2 5400. How much difference does this make? Will DDR2 667 be good enough for a decent overclock or should I look at faster stuff(though if I did I assume I'd have to also loo at a mobo that supported something past DDR2 800)?

If you're only getting the E4300, then DDR 667 will be good enough. That being said, the cost difference between DDR2 667 RAM and DDR2 800 is negligible. So basically, get whatever is the cheapest of the two speeds.

As for PC2 5300 and PC2 5400, there is no difference. It's just how manufacturers rounded out RAM speed. From another forum:

PC5300 = PC5400

The difference is that manufacturers round the spec differently.
5336Mbit/s = ~5300 or ~5400
 
Back
Top