Zune vs IPOD vs Fuze

mrgreeen

n00b
Joined
Jun 25, 2008
Messages
2
I'm in the market for a portable mp3 player. My price limit is 149 bucks. I like the Sansa Fuze 8GB for 129 bucks and its coming with a free micro sd expansion card. However, the community seems to be more established for the zune offering hacks, mods ect. Of course the Nano is a nice product as well. I don't know what to get.
 
Find a used Zune somewhere, maybe eBay or Craig's List, etc. I saw an 80GB 2nd generation Zune on CL here in Las Vegas a few days ago for $150 with a bunch of accessories included. Great deal, and I was seriously interested in getting it, I just couldn't "seriously" come up with the cash. :)

The Samsung lineup these days is pretty nice stuff, but for what it can do, go for the Zune. Who knows what hacks will appear over time... sooner or later I bet someone gets Linux running on it, and that would open up a lot of neat stuff. It's solid hardware, built on the Gigabeat foundation Toshiba created - highly regarded DAPs - and very useful devices.

iPods... bleh. iPods are nice when you put Rockbox on 'em if the model supports it, but the native iPods? They're kinda boring to me. Enough has been said about 'em over the years.

Zunes sound better, too, if sound quality is important - that's an opinion shared by a lot of people, especially members at HeadFi.org.
 
if you don't want ur mp3 player to look like shit in about a week, get a zune lol
 
And... if you do get a Zune and want to find an easy uncomplicated tool to convert videos to Zune format (it only plays Windows Media Video files - WMV) this is the one I'd recommend:

Encode360

The guy wrote it primarily to convert videos to a format his Xbox 360 could play aka WMV files again, but the side effect was he added a simple preset to convert directly to the Zune 320x240 native resolution so it's pretty simple to use.

And... yeah, the brown Zunes are cheap as hell these days. That price of $99 is typical for a brand new one sometimes, but more often than not they're refurbs but they still have the same full warranty on 'em. Grab one before they all disappear forever.

And... remember that the 2nd generation software for 2nd generation Zunes is 100% backwards compatible for the 1st generation: you can install the 2nd generation software on the original Zunes like that brown one and get all the features that come on 2nd generation hardware.

You'll never see Apple come out with such stuff for iPods. They pretty much come out with new features for every new generation that basically say "Fuck you for buying last year's model, if you want <insert new feature here> you're gonna just have to buy another new iPod." Money grubbin' bastiges... ;)
 
I had an ipod video, and picked up a 30gb Zune about 6 months ago. (someone was selling them new on eBay for $100)

I gave the ipod to my girlfriend. :)
 
I have an 8 GB flash Zune, and I really like it. I've never used a Fuze, so I can't compare the two, but I'll take my Zune over the iPod classic & nanos any day. Hopefully updates continue to improve the PC software. It's gotten much better with the latest update, but it can still use some improvements. The firmware and the UI on the Zune is great though, in my opinion.
 
zune = great device. zune software = horrible.

however, i still go with everyone else, get a zune.
 
The Zune is a gay peice of crap, its just a stupid rectangle with a screen and a shitty circle, it looks so plain and is made by a even stupider company. The Ipod Wins.
Btw,
Zune = POS, Ipod = The best portable audio/video player.
 
I use a Sansa 6gig unit, a Nano 4gig, and a Zune 30gig. All three sound about the same using the Zunes headphones (only headphones I use).
I use the Nano in my car since I have a Kenwood radio with an Ipod interface so that I can control the ipod from the headunit.
Zune sits in an Altec Lansing Speaker dock so I can have music playing whenever I want, and it has a remote control.
Sansa was bought before I got the ipod and was $40 or so bucks, use it to listen to music outside while I take a smoke break.

Sansa is the easiest one to put music onto stock. you just drag the files over to it. not sure if the Fuze operates the same way, but I would think it would.
With Rockbox loaded onto it, you can drag the files over but you have to refresh the database to get the new songs to show in the list.
 
Yea Fuze operates the same way, I got the 8gb fuse with a 8gb A-Data Microsdhc in it. The fuze is a drag and drop style to transfer songs/pics/movies/etc instead of using a program. Bad part is if you have over 1000 songs like me and you want to get to your song your going to scroll alot because it doesn't have that fast scroll feature on ipods where you scroll down really fast and it like gets faster. My thumb gets a huge work out just scrolling to find my songs that i like. Also when you scroll you will hear the wheel sliding against the surface below it which gets annoying if you can hear it. So i spent about $180 for a 16gb Fuze it rocks, the quality of the body feels much stronger than the Ipod. I feel like opening my Fuze to see if they use compact flash, if they do i will replace it with a 32gb CF. But at the moment I don't know if they use CF or not. As far as Zune goes, I would have gotten one but all my friends who owns one says the software sucks ass. I don't really like the Ipod, owned a few in the past, because its over priced. Quality looks good but after a few days you can literally see the scratches all over it. If you want the best bang for the buck mp3/video player go for the brown Zune on newegg. Theres a 30gb one that goes for $99 but its usually out of stock.

Mark
 
.... its just a stupid rectangle with a screen and a shitty circle, it looks so plain and is made by a even stupider company. ....
Oh, I thought you were talking about the Ipod there. :p :eek:
 
creative zen 8gb

it has upgradable memory
its the size of a credit card
best audio quality
supports alot of formts
 
Lol I had almost all the the ipods from the first gen to the last two gen of the nano. I had a 30gb zune, and a crap load of Creatives that I cant name from the top of my head. Here's my point the all have a strong suit and whichever you like the most you should get. Zune is great piece of hardware and its interface is really great. The creative's have great support for media files, awsome sound quality but lacked a very polished interface. The ipod has the best interface but breaks to often, and sound is not where it should be
for a MP3 player that has crap load of units sold and has been around for so many years.
 
The Zune is a gay peice of crap, its just a stupid rectangle with a screen and a shitty circle, it looks so plain and is made by a even stupider company. The Ipod Wins.
Btw,
Zune = POS, Ipod = The best portable audio/video player.

lol look ipod fanboy.


Btw, if yo uwant to keep ur ipod decent looking, you HAVE to buy a case. They get scratched sooo easily it's like you put your nails on it and BAM SCRATCH. If you look at most people's ipods that are more than 6 months old, they look like shit cause there are scratches all over the place.
 
lol look ipod fanboy.


Btw, if yo uwant to keep ur ipod decent looking, you HAVE to buy a case. They get scratched sooo easily it's like you put your names on it and BAM SCRATCH. If you look at most people's ipods that are more than 6 months old, they look like shit cause there are scratches all over the place.

Lol thats how they get you to buy accessories then ultimately upgrade.
 
lol everyone likes zune
i wont start stuff about the zune, but if you were like me and move lots of large files between some computers, you may want to buy the 160 gig iPod video, as an ipod and external hard drive
and the zune
A-does not go up to 160 gigs
B-can not be used as a usb flash drive/portable hard drive
the zunes software sucks anyway, my friend has the halo 3 one and he cant upload new songs on his because the softwares crap (im sorry big zune users but it is)
 
lol everyone likes zune
i wont start stuff about the zune, but if you were like me and move lots of large files between some computers, you may want to buy the 160 gig iPod video, as an ipod and external hard drive
and the zune
A-does not go up to 160 gigs
B-can not be used as a usb flash drive/portable hard drive
the zunes software sucks anyway, my friend has the halo 3 one and he cant upload new songs on his because the softwares crap (im sorry big zune users but it is)

Not sure where you've been or what you've been smoking, but the Zune has always been able to function as a portable hard drive with a simple Registry edit - yes, it's somewhat lame that's the method to enable it, but the point is: you can use it as a portable hard drive, period. Of course, that kinda ties it to the machine where the Registry edit was made, unless you do it on all the machines you'll be connecting it to. And yes, that could be considered a negative against the Zune but, it's primarily a DAP anyway, just like an iPod is.

As for the software being crap, most would agree, but it functions to do what it was designed to do. If your "friend" is having issues, tell him to go back and read the instructions and use the latest version.

All of them have pluses and negatives - not one on the market is perfect overall.
 
The software is crap... but look at iTunes. rofl. I wouldn't install that if someone wanted to pay me $100.
 
Not sure where you've been or what you've been smoking, but the Zune has always been able to function as a portable hard drive with a simple Registry edit - yes, it's somewhat lame that's the method to enable it, but the point is: you can use it as a portable hard drive, period. Of course, that kinda ties it to the machine where the Registry edit was made, unless you do it on all the machines you'll be connecting it to. And yes, that could be considered a negative against the Zune but, it's primarily a DAP anyway, just like an iPod is.

As for the software being crap, most would agree, but it functions to do what it was designed to do. If your "friend" is having issues, tell him to go back and read the instructions and use the latest version.

All of them have pluses and negatives - not one on the market is perfect overall.

My Zune 80 is the biggest POS I have ever purchased. I don't even want to go into it. The software is more atrocious than people say it is.

That registry hack no longer works I think with the latest firmware, and is only for the Zune 30.

The software is crap... but look at iTunes. rofl. I wouldn't install that if someone wanted to pay me $100.

Have you ever used the Zune software?

Shit is so bad you sometimes have to edit the extension, like from mp3 to wma for the software to recognize songs. That and it reads tags like a complete piece of shit, mixing up songs, reading songs as others, or sometimes duplicating, etc. etc.
 
Hmm..the Zune seems to be pretty popular here. :D However, I'm going to have to put my vote behind the Fuze. I've had one since it came out and have been perfectly happy with it. 8GB+expansion (with seamless integration), FM tuner, great sound/screen quality, all for $129, is a pretty good deal IMO.
 
Zune FTW!
Software and device are easy to use. Love the simplicity of the Zune and its software over Itunes. :cool:
 
My Zune 80 is the biggest POS I have ever purchased. I don't even want to go into it. The software is more atrocious than people say it is.

That registry hack no longer works I think with the latest firmware, and is only for the Zune 30.

Have you ever used the Zune software?

Shit is so bad you sometimes have to edit the extension, like from mp3 to wma for the software to recognize songs. That and it reads tags like a complete piece of shit, mixing up songs, reading songs as others, or sometimes duplicating, etc. etc.
Nope, I always just drag and drop songs onto mp3 players. No need for shitty software. There's always a workaround. And it still works for the newest firmware and Zunes, you just have to know where to look. ;)
 
In terms of functionality, itunes software owns, not so much attractive, but it makes organizing a dream.

I had an ipod Video 30GB, only when it filled up I decided to get the recently released (in Canada), the Zune 80. The software is so easy to use, it comes close to itunes, but its not good enough. In terms of looks however (not important, but meh, always nice to have), the Zune software looks awesome

As far as the players go, I prefer the Zune 80 soooo much more over my old Video 30GB or my friend's 160GB Classic. The Zune Pad is hard to get used to at first, but once gotten used to, I think it better and easier to handle over the ipod. The headphones included with the zune are crap, but I prefer them so much more over the stock apple headphones.

I only have two drawbacks to the Zune:
1) No EQ, not really a big deal, you get used to the sound really fast.
2) Max Volume isn't really that loud. Its loud enough, but not loud enough to blow your head off. An amp with a good set of headphones attached to the zune is like audio sex with very nice volumes. I think the Zune has an underpowered port, I feel the volume at max is rather low.

Other than that, why I prefer Zune over an iPod:

Larger screen
Looks great
Very easy to use (once gotten used to zune pad)
Wireless syncing (nice to have)

Please note this is coming from an ipod G3, G4, G5, G5.5, Nano G1, G3, and G1 shuffle user over the period of 4 years. Zune rocks.
 
I like my Zune. Software sucks and wish I could just copy music to it easily but whatever. It works. Most of the time I'm just listening to music on the Zune so I could really care less about the software.

Oh yeah one other side, no Xp 64 support-- meaning it doesn't work at all. Microsoft = homos.
 
I like my Zune. Software sucks and wish I could just copy music to it easily but whatever. It works. Most of the time I'm just listening to music on the Zune so I could really care less about the software.

Oh yeah one other side, no Xp 64 support-- meaning it doesn't work at all. Microsoft = homos.

Idk about xp 64 but vista 64 works perfectly, as I am using it right now with my zune.

Also if you have a 360 the zune connects to it seamlessly, pretty cool to listen to music from your zune on the 360 while you play games.
 
Yeah, odd how Zune created a Vista x64 version but never bothered creating one for XP x64.

Damnit microsoft and their evil plan to phase out XP.
 
The Zune itself is pretty awesome, especially for $99, but the software makes me want to hurt people.

Attention Redmond: I. Want. Simple. I do not need a complicated image/tile based grabastic mess. I want a source pane and a destination pane. That is all. AND STOP FUCKING WITH MY ID3 TAGS.
 
The Zune is a gay peice of crap. it is just a stupid rectangle with a screen and a shitty circle, it looks plain and is made by a even more stupid company. The Ipod Wins.
Btw,
Zune = POS, Ipod = The best portable audio/video player.

I corrected your fan boy grammar. :) But I disagree completely. The zune is a hell of a lot easier to use than an iPod (Give both to someone who has NEVER used either, and they'll figure out a zune quicker ;) )

You need to chill the hell out with the fan boyishness and learn the real ups and downs of competitior products. As soon as you do that, your mind will be opened to a whole WORLD of new products that are PROBABLY better than the ones you currently own, because you were too blinded to look around for the best deal. And the funniest thing, if MP3 players like the zune died out, so would yours. Competition breeds innovation. Without that key part, competition, innovation fades and you get left with garbage.

Just some words to mull over, enjoy :)
 
Nope, I always just drag and drop songs onto mp3 players. No need for shitty software. There's always a workaround. And it still works for the newest firmware and Zunes, you just have to know where to look. ;)

It works with the Z80? What the flip w1retap?
 
Back
Top