Z530 vs Core Solo 1.33?

Ronco

[H]ard|Gawd
2FA
Joined
Oct 6, 2005
Messages
1,308
I'm interested in what sort of performance disparities there are for a 1.6Ghz Atom vs a CS 1.33 in Windows Vista.
 
I don't have any numbers to give you, but I can tell you right off the bat that the Core Solo would be much faster. The Atom chips are designed for power efficiency, not performance.
 
Core Solo FTW!!! Well at least in this case. The clock for clock on Atoms can only be compared to early Pentium M chips. Core Solo is a more advanced cpu that has a higher IPC than Atoms.
 
The clock for clock on Atoms can only be compared to early Pentium M chips. Core Solo is a more advanced cpu that has a higher IPC than Atoms.
A Core Solo is essentially a Pentium M. Pentium M chips are also faster clock-for-clock compared to Atom CPUs.
 
A Core Solo is essentially a Pentium M. Pentium M chips are also faster clock-for-clock compared to Atom CPUs.

Agreed, it wouldn't even be close. The Atom is a direct descendant of the original pentium. Now that's not to say the Atom isn't cool--the atom is a really neat little chip and it works wonders for netbooks and crap like that. But practically anything will outrun it. I bet my old Athlon XP 2000+ rig is faster than an Atom. Of course, it draws like 10 times as much power lol.
 
I figured as much. I was wondering whether it would be worth upgrading the UX's. Looks like I should wait another year.
 
Core Solo FTW!!! Well at least in this case. The clock for clock on Atoms can only be compared to early Pentium M chips. Core Solo is a more advanced cpu that has a higher IPC than Atoms.

Thanks for the correction guys. Here's the real lowdown (at least according to Wiki) The Atom's performance is roughly half of that of a similarly clocked Pentium M, of which other members above have indicated is basically a Core Solo. My error is adding the "M" after Pentium.

So I still stand on the comment that the Core Solo is the best way to go if you're simply looking for performance per clock.
 
well okay perhaps I should have clarified: what I meant to say is that atom is the first in-order x86 cpu since the pentium. Itaniums are in-order but their entire design philosophy is different so it's apples and oranges.

I wouldn't say that. :p As Intel has said, it's a new core.

Atom: http://media.arstechnica.com/news.media/sv-diagram.gif
Pentium: http://www.laynetworks.com/images/help.gif

Other than a couple of superficial similarities from the outside, the architectures are very different.
 
Back
Top