Your thoughts on an external power supply?

tpfaff

2[H]4U
Joined
Jan 30, 2006
Messages
2,526
Ok so the recent rumor ive been seeing is that the g80 and r600 will both require an external power supply, what do you guys think of it, I dont like it one bit, if g80 had one nad r600 didnt or vice versa im definately going to go with the one that doesnt, I have enough wires back there besides having to lug around a power brick now.
 
I think its a bit rediculous, but i dont think one's electricity bill will go up much in price after one buys one of these.
 
Where has it been linked to the R600 using an external power supply (even just a rumor)?
 
You never know. nVidia might do something as rediculous is taking their current architecture, slapping on 10 more pixel pipelines and then welding two more cards together on top of the GX2 and calling it the G80, your quad GPU solution.
 
Both ATI and NV are considering external psu's for this gen, if the rumours can be believed. NV has already stated that G80 will come in at ~500 million transistors, and GeCube techs have stated that R600 is the hottest chip ever.

Personally I don't mind the idea (as a stopgap solution that is). Replacing my competent psu seems more anoying than simply having an extra transformer and plug. Plus I don't like the ever increasing trend of dumping more heat into our cases.

Just head over to Beyond3D forums and check the G80/R600 threads, if references are your thing.
 
What I find disturbing is that peripherals GPU's and CPU's are heading back to the 12 volt rail... It would not surprise me at all to see an external power brick supplying 24 volts to a videocard.

Its actually extremely silly if you think about it. Your CPU is drawing on a 12 volt, ramped down to approximately 1.4 volts, it has to do *twice* the downvolt conversion from the wallsocket, which is a very inefficient way to do it (but can also be more stable as there are more capacitors inbetween the downvolts)

If it were possible to create a 40-pin ATX connector, that had several 1.5 or lower volt wires, that directly converted to 1.5 volt at the powersupply it would be more power efficient than what we are using today - In which we place an extra burden on the motherboard and videocard to convert the 12volt to something it can use.

If I had any say, I'd increase the ATX specification to include 1 1/2 to double the size of the physical ATX powersupply (for better cooling, and room for more components) and supply more varied voltages.
 
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ Thanks for sporting me some references and thats a damn shame the r600 is the hottest chip ever :eek:
 
I'd prefer not to have to use one. Hopefully it'll only come with the 'ultra-extreme XXXTXX' edition of the cards.
 
The only thing i would prefer is if these cards were to come with one, just have the brick internal much like the dual 6800GT did, just with the powercoord exiting the case, of course this would cause more case heat but i'm willing to put up with that then having to find a place to lay the brick down that won't cause heat build up in some corner on the carpet either.

But then again I have no qualm with these, if its required i don't care.
 
It will be strange if my FSP Epsilon 700W will not be enough for G80... Personally, I think that it will handle G80 and there will be no need to spend money for external PSU.
 
What I view about this is a nice way for those who are a bit tight with the budget to get something beefier without needing to fork out the money to upgrade the PSU and possibly the rest of the computer.

However, another idea would be to start to generalize GPU-only powersupplies like the few we have which fit a 5 1/4 slot so we can offload the power supply and leave him alone with the more important task to feed the motherboard and peripherals.
 
DaCoOlNeSs said:
I loathe power bricks.
As do I.

If, however, it's a small, lightweight transformer (either a small brick or one that plugs directly into the wall), and it plugs in using any standard low voltage connection to the back of the video card, I think it can be good. And it's cheaper (and more efficient) that getting a huge new PSU when you only need it for the video card (my current setup [with an x850], runs perfectly fine on a 350 watt. Getting some huge 700+ watt behemoth just to run a video card seems like complete overkill to me).
 
Forget it. If my 850w PC Power and Cooling can't handle it, well then screw it. If there's a videocard (single) that can put so much load on that an SSI PSU can't take it (a $449 one at that) then I'm just appalled....computer enthusiasts are not made of money/wattage.
 
Sovereign said:
Forget it. If my 850w PC Power and Cooling can't handle it, well then screw it. If there's a videocard (single) that can put so much load on that an SSI PSU can't take it (a $449 one at that) then I'm just appalled....computer enthusiasts are not made of money/wattage.
I think an 850 watt PSU is MORE than enough. I think this kind of thing is more aimed at those in the 350-500 watt range who wouldn't have enough wattage. And I doubt they'd make it external-only. Having both (and allowing complete power from both) would be a good solution.
 
This picture says it best :D
quadslixy1dt9.jpg
 
nice pic :p

Take note these bricks are not being placed in because the high end PSU's cannot handle the cards, its there so people who already have a well established system does not have to also think about replacing the PSU, and make sure it is a well rated PSU that can handle all the peripherals that is already in ones system

I think the brick is a good idea, just wish they were internal :( at least i hope so.
 
The only thought I really have on external bricks right now is how much interference are they going to create. Because the computers now days have gotten so sensitive most power supplies are using active filtering to eliminate unwanted harmonics. Are the bricks going to have active filtering? If not, I see where we could start getting noise messing with the rest of the computer by having the cards plugged into the brick.
 
if the brick is external it won't be anywhere near the computer, how ever if its internal i still don't see these things coming remotely close to what a stock HSF or a 10k RPM HDD puts off
 
So what is worse, a dongle or external power supply? This will be interesting if true.
 
Back
Top