Yet another "What should I buy?" topic!

DOOManiac

n00b
Joined
Jul 24, 2004
Messages
31
Hey guys. First let me preface this with an apology for my nubness. I only really keep up with hardware (other than the occasional glance at GPU benchmarks) when it's time to actually buy stuff, and so I'm a bit out of the game regarding knowing what is new, fast, and good. In the past these boards have always been a tremendous help in narrowing down my selection, and so I turn once again to you guys to point me in the general direction I should go.

It's been awhile (summer of 04, and even then only video card) since my last upgrade, and with Obilvion coming out and a few other games on the horizon, not to mention some extra cash on hand, I figured now would be a terrific time to throw away my hard earned cash.


My current rig is this, which isn't too bad I admit, but still I want to get a new Tiny God:
2.4Bghz Intel P4 (533FSB I think?)
2x512MB = 1GB pc2100 dual channel
MSI Master-L motherboard
PNY GeForce 6800GT AGP
SB Live! 5.1 Value
120GB WD 7200rpm ide HDD (almost full :X)
D-Link 108Mbps wireless
Plextor DVD Burner
And a 3.5 floppy drive!

(As you can tell, I know my current stuff quite well, its just the new stuff that I haven't kept up on. Hell I didn't even realize Intel stopped using ghz as their selling point)

Moneywise I'm pretty good, but if I spent more than $2000 I'd be really pissed at myself unless it was an omgpwn awesome deal.


As far as the usage of the box, primarily it's gaming, though I also do some coding in Visual Studio and/or Dreamweaver. Mainly gaming though. I like to run with all the bells and whistles at at least 50FPS. Fast boot times are nice too. However I'm also a big demander on stability. My current system is rock solid. Never crashed beyond the occassional software app that does it. I definately do not want to go to a less stable system. (I'm looking at you, AMD K6 & Athlon )



So while I'm looking for general suggestions regarding CPU speed and what mobo, i also have a few more specific points in other areas:

1) As for CPU, last I hear the 64-bit ones are still a little bit behind 32-bit in performance of 32-bit apps, and I don't expect to be running any native 64-bit apps soon (unless game developers suddenly start supporting it). But as far as Dual Core stuff goes, I'm ignorant as to any performance gains or losses it causes. If you're running just 1 app that is very processor intensive (like, oh I dunno, games) but not necessarily optimized as much as they could be for dual processors (again, games), is there a performance drop?

2) I'd like to get at least 2GB of uber fast RAM. Nothing too crazy, but faster than this PC2100 crap.

3) My 6800GT, despite being from August of 2004, is still holding up well I think. However it's AGP. All the new mobo's are probably PCIe. Has PCIe gotten to a point where its faster than AGP yet, or is it still in that "well theoretically it can be faster" category? Do I need to update to a 7800GT just for PCIe to go along w/ the mobo? Or should I get an AGP mobo (and then hope that whatever video card comes out in anoter year or two when it is time to retire the 6800 is still plenty fast on AGP)

4) If I do get a PCIe mobo, does it come with old fashioned PCI slots, or will I need to replace my other components like my sound card and wireless card?


5) My 120GB is getting full. And now that I have a x-box 360 with free Media Center Extender functionality, I'm going to be watching more and more content on the HDTV in the living room streamed from my PC, meaning more storage space required. So I'll definately be wanting to get a SATA hard drive, but I'm not sure if I should just get a 500GB 7200MB drive w/ a buttload of cache, or if I should fork out the extra cash for a speedy 10,000RPM drive in addition (for the OS and games, while leaving non-hdd intensive stuff like movies, mp3s, and documents on the 500gb)?

6) Are those new fancy pants SB XFI (or whatever) cards any good? I stayed away from Audigy cause I heard nothing but bad things about them, but I've heard nothing about these new ones. I'm by no means an audiophile, and the 5.1 does just fine on my cheapo $150 5.1 speakers. The only thing is that they're really 6.1 speaker and I just have the other one laying around somewhere, but that isn't really a big deal to me.

7) Should I get a new case, I wonder? I kind of like the Antec P180, but really hate that I'd have to open the door to turn it on and off (which I have to do to sleep at night, the fans make too much noise for me to sleep). Plus it's sexy. And apparently keeps things cool...

8) I'm not at all interested in a RAID, SLI, or overclocking.

9) Should I keep the floppy drive? :p


Again, thanks in advance for the help guys. I'm sure that I'll get at least a push in the right direction to help me make up my mind. Thanks!
 
Nice thought-out post. I am by no means an expert, but I will give you some thoughts that I have. Looking at the Oblivion recommended requirements, it looks like your current computer is almost there. My first suggestion would be to wait until the game comes out and see how it runs on your current system before spending dough for a big upgrade.

1) Although there isn't much in 64 bit apps, AMD does currently hold the gaming crown with their Athlon 64 processors. Regarding dual core, you do lose some performance on single threaded apps, but upcoming games will include support for multi-cores. You might find this bit-tech.net interview with one of Oblivion's producers, Gavin Carter, interesting since he does mention that the PC game will include support for multi-cores.

2) 2GB of ram would be good, and be sure to get 2x1GB sticks for optimal performance. You should be fine if you stick with any of the well known manufacturers such as Crucial, Corsair, Kingston, OCZ, Patriot, G.SKILL, etc.

3) Your current graphics card is still good, so there is no need to replace it. Keep in mind, though, that AGP is currently being phased out, so you don't want to put any additional money into the AGP platform. You might look at a motherboard like this ASRock which has an AGP slot for your current card AND a PCI express x16 for your next graphics card. There are better mobos out there, but this could be a nice board to use for a year or two. In case you have never heard of ASRock, they are ASUS' budget brand, so the quality should still be there.

4) The current mobos do come with PCI slots.

5) If you are going to be saving TV shows and movies to your PC, then you definitely want to go with the highest capacity. The Western Digital Raptors do have the best speed, but the largest capacity is only 150GB - and you will be paying a large premium for it. Be sure to note that your new computer will need Windows XP Media Center Edition for you to take advantage of the Media Center Extender of your xbox 360. A dual core processor might also benefit you here if you wanted to game while recording or streaming media.

6) Stick with the sound card that you have now. The X-Fi cards may be nice, but probably not worth the money. You can always add it later.

7) I don't know what case you currently have, but I agree that the P180 looks nice. It is designed to be quiet, so you might be able to sleep with the computer on. I will recommend that you get a new power supply since your old one will probably not be up to snuff for your new parts.

8) OK :)

9) There have been no advancements in floppy drive technology so you can keep your floppy drive. :D

Keep in mind that nvidia will be releasing their new graphic cards soon and AMD will be moving to a new socket (AM2) later this year. There is a benefit to waiting, but I know waiting sucks. Hopefully this helps some.
 
I agree with everything said above although I would add that ASRock isn't really Asus' budget brand - they are more like the brand Asus uses for experimental purposes. This is why you see things in ASRock mobos like the AGP-on-PCI-E setup (which isn't AGP, actually, but emulated AGP that works with 90% of cards out there, including the 6800 series) and that future processor slot.
 
I have no problem w/ getting a great AGP mobo now and then having to upgrade mobo AND video later down the road. I don't think I want to mix w/ "experimental" stuff as I'd much rather be out of pocket a bit more and have the extra stability.


I guess my bigest headache is processor itself. It uses to be easy: pick the biggest mhz speed. Oh for the days of my celeron 300a... I just have no flippin idea what to choose.

I'm running Media Center OS right now, so that's no worry. However there isn't a 64-bit version of that is there, so that eliminates 64-bit CPUs right (unless there's just such a huge performance boost w/ 64-bit that it merits just using this existing box as a 2nd pc for media center, which I doubt).


I think I've decided to just go w/ a 500GB 7200RPM drive w/ the 16mb cache and skip the 10,000rpm.


And yeah, 2GB of RAM is what I'm aiming for minimum, but I want fast fast fast ram (but not Rambus :p)



So, narrowing down my choices a bit, does anyone have specific CPU's and mobo's to recommend so that I can start review hunting?


Thanks guys! :D
 
personally I saw wait until Conroe chips come out from intel and then get a conroe chip and motherboard if you are patient enough... only until June.
 
I don't know if I am that patient or not... hmm...

I've been reading up on the 7900GT, and I'm thinking now that I may get one of those along w/ everything else.

So I still need to decide on:

1) CPU
2) Mobo
3) RAM type

For RAM, is Coursair (or however you spell it) still the best around, or should I go w/ some other brand? Do they have a lifetime warranty like Crucial does/did?
 
Back
Top