Y-USB cable for 2.5" external drive question(s)

amd7674

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jan 1, 2007
Messages
1,813
I'm thinking about buying a 2.5" drive at BB zdata 500gb 2.5" external usb drive, which comes with Y-USB cable. Since PC's USB port spec says the max it can provide is 500mA it can provide, there is a good chance I might need to use Y-USB cable. Problem is I only have 1 free USB 2.0 port to play with on the PC I want to buy this for... From a feedback by one user looks like zdata uses samsung 2.5" drives, which more likely to some specs I found it uses 850mA @5VDC, hence I believe it will need a Y-USB cable.

My qestions are:

1) Would I be able to use an external USB power adapter (power brick) along with USB 2.0port on my PC with the Y-USB cable? Would that be safe? I don't want to take any chances to blow-up my PC :rolleyes:

2) If the drive will seem to be working with using a single USB cable (without need for Y-USB cable) is there a chance the data might get corrupted on the drive if there is not enough "juice" being provide to it? or will HDD either work or not work at all if there is not enough juice being provided?

TIA
 
1) The Y-cable usually has one full connector and one for power only. You can figure out which is which by connecting the drive (or some other device) and seeing which of the connectors allows it to be recognized by the system. That's the full connector - you want the other one. If you use a decent brand-nameUSB adapter, you should have no problem powering the drive via the power connector without risking damage to your system.

2) The current rating is typically the MAX current, which is usually only needed upon drive spin-up. There's a good chance the drive will work just fine with only the USB cable. No, if there's not enough "juice", the drive will not work at all - it won't spin up and may make a click/whine sound. In this case the drive may show up in Windows but you may not be able to access it.

3) Why not just get a powered USB hub?
 
1) It should work fine, but it's probably not the best idea either. Since the spec is not very tight, the voltage from your PC PSU and external PSU will probably have enough difference to cause a fair amount of additional current to be sourced from whichever supply is higher, and the other supply will have to sink it. I don't think it's really worth mentioning, but if you're willing to have external gadgets, it'd be better to power the drive *just* from an external supply, but that's trickier; easiest way would be to use a cheap powered hub.

2) I've seen them spin up and work for a bit and then drop back offline. Actually had this problem with the deck in my car, the music would just cut out while driving and the deck would go back to scanning the disk after a few seconds. If you turned the volume off and listened carefully you could hear the drive hiccup and spin up again. I never diagnosed the problem to know if the current limit was the problem for sure, but I'm fairly certain it was. Ended up having to ghetto rig a separate 5V power supply for it.

That said, most computers these days are pretty soft on the current limit for USB devices. Even though the spec says 500mA, you can usually get significantly more out of them. Though once you get up to higher currents voltage drop starts to be a problem, even if you're not actually being limited by the port yet.
 
Back
Top