XP Firewall VS Router Firewall

  • Thread starter Deleted member 143938
  • Start date
D

Deleted member 143938

Guest
I used to have no firewall but I recently read an article on lifehacker about what the users thought was the best firewall.

The 3 top choices were router firewall, XP/Vista firewall, and Comodo firewall.

Now I know how to properly use the internet and was and still not concerned about Hackers of any kind, and view them as simply a resource hog and an annoyance with the ports.

But now I'm thinking of turning them on "just incase", if anything, for a nice placebo effect.

I recently turned on both my router firewall, and XP's, both are painless and had no trouble so far, but then again all I do is browse Firefox and play World of Warcraft.

So in general, which would perform better for my minimal needs? I rather not have both working at the same time. My router is a pretty new Netgear WNDR3300 with DD-WRT installed
 
Have both. You never know what will try to get through and whatnot.

I would say a router firewall is better, but having Windows Firewall and router firewall is best combination IMO.

EDIT:
If I was to choose just one, the I'd go for the router firewall.
 
Best bet is to leave them both on, you shouldn't see any any performance decrease. XP firewall is a built-in component. If anyone knows the Windows API and internals. . . it's MS themselves.

As for the hardware firewall, that would be your strongest point, but use them both. . .
 
If your PC is behind a "router"...you're already behind a firewall which blocks all unknown/untrusted incoming traffic. This is rule number 1 to have...keep your PC behind the NAT of a home router.

Many ISPs are shipping "modems" which are actually combo modem/routers...especially DSL, so even if you don't "think" you have a router, you may and just don't know it.

The NAT of the router hides your computer behind it, your computer is not on a public IP address directly, and all 65,000+ ports of your computer are hidden.

Having the XP firewall enabled if you're behind a NAT router really doesn't gain you anything else, unless there are other untrusted computers on your local network. It's not like traffic "slips" past NAT..and the XP firewall comes into play as a second layer of protection. Exception to this being if you intentionally DMZ your computer or something crazy like that. But it's harmless to leave the XP firewall enable too.
 
The only reason I like having a firewall on my computers is to see what programs are trying to access the Internet. If it wasn't this aspect to using a "software" firewall then I wouldn't use one at all on my home computers.
 
I tend to just use hardware firewalls, I hate dealing with software firewalls as it usually ends up creating more of a hassle then it prevents IMO.
 
Back
Top