Xbox specs leaked? ATi 10MB EDRAM

ZenOps

2[H]4U
Joined
Jun 11, 2000
Messages
2,914
http://forums.xbox-scene.com/index.php?showtopic=231928

Ouch, freaking hella risky design if true having 10MB of EDRAM for a framebuffer. I think Bitboys wanted a similar design for thier chip (and look where it got them) Still, if ATi can pull it off, its going to make DDR3 or any external chips look slow. It does make sense though, given the Xbox2 needs to be within a certain size constraint (You can't just arbitrarily put 3 CPU's a GPU, and still have room to paste on seperate main and graphics memory) Since it will be on a PCI-E interface, the textures will be stored in main memory without as much of a performance hit.

So the graphics core will probably include another layer or two, sort of like how the Pentium 4EE has its 2MB L3 cache on a 7th layer so the chip can double in transitor count and yet still be the same size.
 
ZenOps said:
So the graphics core will probably include another layer or two, sort of like how the Pentium 4EE has its 2MB L3 cache on a 7th layer so the chip can double in transitor count and yet still be the same size.

the layers you are referring to are just interconnect layers. Using more layers decreases the chance of crosstalk, etc. Supposedly helps higher yields.

The 2MB of L3 is part of the same die layer as the core (single layer core). The thing that makes it doable is that they already had taped out that core for server chips. Its size is much larger than a normal northwood, however, the chip still has a lot of room on it for a larger core. (it used to have a Williamette at one time) so the package could hold a large core.

Though by the time Xbox2 comes out, it may be stacked on stop or using 3D circuitry. Though I would think it would be more likely that they package it almost like Nvidia did with its HSI, on the same package but right next to it. See anand's review of NV45. http://www.anandtech.com/video/showdoc.html?i=2096&p=3
 
So thats how Intel does it, thanks for clearing up the interconnect layers.

Anyhow, onchip Edram running at a native 32GB/sec, but of infinitely greater importance than that is that it uses only one clock cycle to access the memory. Which means a theoretical (although its probably not a good idea to mention and get peoples hopes up.) 256GB/sec when using multisampling and all the other Z-goodies ATi can fit in it. Gotta love not having to add wait states and buffers to go two inches to a seperate DDR/DDR3 chip. It will help to fill out the ~48 billion shader instructions/second.

If this is indicative of the R500 to show up late next year or early next, next year :p (just a guess), its going to be a completely different beast than current chips. Of note: Pushing data as Colour+z, which is closer to the way Nvidia is doing it in the 6800. Then again, it does make sense in certain places, if a texture like a stopsign is solid or a shade of red, why even bother to pass a blue and green value and get 3x less performance on that texture.

So far the specs only show 256MB+ for main and videomemory, hopefully expandable or they may change thier mind and go with 512 base memory, but maybe not. I get the feeling 3Dc and advanced texture compressions were designed with the Xbox2 in mind.
 
ZenOps said:
So far the specs only show 256MB+ for main and videomemory, hopefully expandable or they may change thier mind and go with 512 base memory, but maybe not. I get the feeling 3Dc and advanced texture compressions were designed with the Xbox2 in mind.

The system needs far less ram b/c of its integrated nature. Its software is optimized for just playing games... OS functions are cut to a minimum.

Also, when its that fast you dont need as much. Ex. the first celeron with 128Kb on die (or P3 with 256KB ondie) beat the Pentium with 512KB off die cache, clock for clock.

So smaller & faster is better than larger & slower.

That type of core would probably be the basis of the R600.
Kinda like the Xbox was basically a GF3+(almost a GF4), and the Xbox was released before either. So dont get your hopes up for something soon.
 
these specs have been out there since last year (the first time they "surfaced"), the problem is, back then a 3.5GHz PPC processor was still a possibility. Here it is one year later and the 3GHz PPC processor is a no show. The fact that Apple's top of the line is a dual processor 2.5GHz right now makes you seriously question the Xbox 2's supposed dual 3.5s. Even ONE 3.5GHz chip at this point would put it ahead of a current high end Mac...highly unlikely

don'tcha think?
 
Steve said:
these specs have been out there since last year (the first time they "surfaced"), the problem is, back then a 3.5GHz PPC processor was still a possibility. Here it is one year later and the 3GHz PPC processor is a no show. The fact that Apple's top of the line is a dual processor 2.5GHz right now makes you seriously question the Xbox 2's supposed dual 3.5s. Even ONE 3.5GHz chip at this point would put it ahead of a current high end Mac...highly unlikely

don'tcha think?


That, and I'm skeptical about how reasonable it is to put two 3.5Ghz G5 CPUs (the 970FX is around 25W @ 2Ghz) into the same box that's meant to be a console. Seems like it'll be one big, hot running console.
 
Not to mention that they have to keep the price reasonable. I think any console mfg. would lose a ton of buisness going over say, about a $300 release price just for the bare system. Not to mention that consoles typically have used tech that is not bleeding edge to keep costs down on R+D. JMO (educated guesses)

--Ed
 
the only reason to use such good ram is because its being heavily rumored that almost all xbox 2 games will support HDTV 720p/1080i resolutions which put a extreme strain on the systems memory bandwith. i mean i can't even think of playing halo 3 at 1080i on my 37 inch LCD *droolz* but with all that bandwith its completely possible. The cpu also excites me considering that it will be mostly used for A.I and other functions . Its good to see them planning on the GPU really doing all of the graphics work thats what has been promised for years from video card makers and it will finally come true on xbox 2 it seems. wouldn't it just rock to buy a new system and not have to worry about the CPU effecting the frame rates? i know i would love it . Frankly i think the PS3 doesn't stand a chance . Microsoft is going the smart path while sony is throwing darts into the dark.
 
You already answered your own question.

Remember that XBOX2 will not be out until 2006. The current variation of the 970PPC chip has reached its current limit. Be on the lookout for a 'mobile' variation with lower voltage requirements.

The powerbook line is going to be ramped up and expect a similar processor that can be placed in a multi proc/multi core XBOX.

3.5ghz will be very obtainable. The question will be whether or not it will actually be needed.
 
I agree. Microsoft I think, has been on top since the XBox has come out. My PS2 has gathered dust since then. I will definatly be firing it up when GT4 comes out though.

And I do agree, the games now look great, especially on my 57" Hitachi widescreen. My wife could not get me away from Rainbow Six 3 for months after I got it. :) The Matrix looked nice also and that was *only* 720p. It really makes me drool to think that we may have true HD games with the next generation....1080i will look oh so sweet! Big screen and 5.2 surround gaming with voice (another good move by Microsoft to integrate it into the system ) is just so awesome! Makes me feel like a kid all over again...

--Ed
 
Its all about PS3's XDR DRAM!

http://www.rambus.com/products/xdr/

3.2ghz clocked RAM! Come on!

While I don't know what the next gen will bring I find the rumors of the PS3 more mouth watering mainly because it sounds so unreal... I mean if its even half of what they claim it will be amazing... Xbox 2 just sounds like the Xbox... a PC that hooks up to the TV...

Don't get me wrong, I love my Xbox (mainly the secret functions MS doesn't want us to know about) but I also love my PS2 (Gotta have RPG's!).
 
Back
Top