X800XT PE or 6800U

X800XT PE or 6800U

  • X800XT PE

    Votes: 138 63.6%
  • 6800U

    Votes: 79 36.4%

  • Total voters
    217

smcgee85

Limp Gawd
Joined
Mar 23, 2004
Messages
174
Exactly that. I want you to vote on which card you think will be better.
I'm not sure if this has been done yet, but I'm just curious to see where the general opinion lies.
 
I think that was a long time ago though and the opinion has probably chnaged with new drivers, etc.
 
Yea we just had one of these polls. There is no point in starting more because they just lead to flame wars.
 
If the view change that will show in the poll. That was quite interesting really. In the beginning there was a big 6800 U lead. Then X800XT came back and even took a lead. Then 6800 ULTRA came back but now it seems like X800XT is a bit ahead last time I checked.

I think you should be able to vote more than once since they are so close though :D
 
Only problem is probably 80% or more of the voters didn't even look at the thread other then to vote and that 80% most likely doesn't hardly even know the difference between the two cards. Polls are pretty pointless because you just get a bunch of point, click, voters that dont know what their talking about.
 
But that is still the minority.

Noone really knows what they are talking about anyway with such new hardware ;) Those who thinks they got it all covered knows nothing.

It represents what people here lean against that´s all.
 
lol
i hope not
so people are still voting on that other poll?
its like on page 3 or 4 or something
dont see how peeps would notice it
and whether i open a poll or not the ati and nvidia people are still guna be argueing no matter what
its inevitable
 
Well noone stops you from starting your own if you like but that is a bit more representive since it has so many votes I think. It of course don´t say that the X800XT PE is 20 % better since it has 20 % more votes. As said both ATI and nVidia have proven that there is still big performance gains to be had with new drivers since both are quite different from the old gen. ATi with their new programmable memory bus and nVidia with their new aa and aniso theme.

I guess within 2 months or something when Half Life 2 and Doom 3 are released we should have a pretty good way of telling how they stand at eachother since they have had time for drivers to mature. Though it´s pointless waiting so long to getting one if you want one since they are so similar in price and performance.

Just go with what your heart tells you and don´t care what anybody else are saying is my advice you can´t go wrong.
 
the only prob is im looking to upgrade very soon and i don't no which to go with although i am leaning toward the ati card
 
smcgee85 said:
the only prob is im looking to upgrade very soon and i don't no which to go with although i am leaning toward the ati card

Ither one of them will give you more performance than you need and both of them are overly expensive compared to just getting an 6800GT or X800Pro and OC'ing.
 
ur right im prob over anaylysing this
im just trying to make sure if i spend 500 dollars i get the better of the too cards
but i guess the truth is there is neither one is much diff from the other
can some1 give me a link to something comparing far cry with and with Sm3
im curious to know what dfff it makes
 
X800XT, less heat, less power, smaller, 1slot, and in many cases, faster in DX-9.
the only thing the 6800U has going for it is lots of speed and SM 3.0
 
ok iv just been made aware of what double posts are and that they r bad
sry guess iv been doing a triple post here
didnt know
once again sry
 
V0ltage said:
X800XT, less heat, less power, smaller, 1slot, and in many cases, faster in DX-9.
the only thing the 6800U has going for it is lots of speed and SM 3.0

The only thing in all of those reasons that actually matters is the less power and thats not an issue ither if you have a 400w PSU like most educated people would if they set out to buy a 6800u or X800XT to start with. If you can afford ither of these cards you can afford a new PSU to go with it.

There isn't an issue with heat and the 6800u. The 1 slot issue is irrelevant for everyone except the people that have SFF cases or are just stupid enough to want to try and fill up slot #1. Most people that buy these cards are going to have 5 PCI slots at their disposal.

And with the new drivers its the exact opposite in DX9 games. The 6800u is faster in the majority of DX9 games without AA or AF enabled and the cards run tied when it is.

So really it all comes down to the features supported and the X800XT PE doesn't support anything worth mentioning compared to support for Shader Model 3.0 on the NV40. The NV40 is also alot stronger in OpenGL which Doom3 will be based off of.

I keep seeing all these reasons to get the X800XT PE over the 6800u and they are all pretty ignorant. The ONLY reason to get an X800XT PE over a 6800u is the price advantage right now. You can possibly grab an X800XT PE for $100 or more less then the 6800u. Thats the only selling point i can see because the X800XT PE is nothing but a speed boost to current cards ATI already has out.
 
burningrave101 said:
And with the new drivers its the exact opposite in DX9 games. The 6800u is faster in the majority of DX9 games without AA or AF enabled and the cards run tied when it is.

Do you have the links to show this? Also, what is the 6800u clocked at in these tests?
 
splooger said:
Do you have the links to show this? Also, what is the 6800u clocked at in these tests?

Far Cry is as good as it gets when it comes to DX9

http://www.anandtech.com/cpu/showdoc.html?i=2091&p=18

At 1280x1024 noAA/AF the 6800u is out ahead of the X800XT by 25 fps.

At 1600x1200 noAA/AF the 6800u is out ahead of the X800XT by 15 fps.

At 1600x1200 4xAA/8xAF the X800XT has less then a 1 fps lead.

And keep in mind this is a regular 6800 ultra vs the X800XT Platinum Edition. nVidia hasn't even released their 6800u extreme yet. ATI decided not to release their vanilla X800XT for 8x AGP. It was the vanilla X800XT that was to compare to the 6800u. Just wait till the 6800u extreme hits shelves and the reviews for it against the X800XT PE start flowing in :).
 
youl will also notice that when the amd 3400 was used the 6800u got kicked in the ass
it wasnt even close
which simply means prescott heavily favors nvidia
this bench is bs
 
smcgee85 said:
youl will also notice that when the amd 3400 was used the 6800u got kicked in the ass
it wasnt even close
which simply means prescott heavily favors nvidia
this bench is bs

OMFG lol...Do you even know what the hell your talking about?

How can Prescott heavily favor nVidia? lol

There is nothing wrong with that bench other then the fact it doesn't show ATI doing what you want.

The 3400+ was used in every one of those benches so it had nothing to do with it. And it wasn't a Prescott core used on the Intel side ither. It was a P4 EE.
 
ok sry i thought it said prescott at the top
well it doesnt matter
ati still beats the crap out of nvidia with the amd processor

the ones that say (agp 8x) r the intels cus thats what their doing the review on
and the ones that say (3400+) r the amd comparison

right?

all im saying is that in no way shape or form does nvidia beat ati in that bench
if anything on the contrary
 
smcgee85 said:
ok sry i thought it said prescott at the top
well it doesnt matter
ati still beats the crap out of nvidia with the amd processor

the ones that say (agp 8x) r the intels cus thats what their doing the review on
and the ones that say (3400+) r the amd comparison

right?

all im saying is that in no way shape or form does nvidia beat ati in that bench
if anything on the contrary

The X800XT is scoring alot lower on the 3400+ also. Its not just the 6800u. All i can think of is that its ither a driver issue of some sort on the A64 board or both cards just perform alot better running with an P4 EE. But whatever is happening the 6800u is still outscoring the X800XT on the Intel platform, especially when AA and AF are not enabled. When they do get enabled the cards perform relatively the same. I dont really see any place where the X800XT has any kind of lead on the 6800u.

And if nVidia rolls out their 6800u extreme pretty soon i'm sure it will take a descent lead on the X800XT PE as the ultra already holds its own in every bench.

If you look at some of the other game benches like X2 then you will see that the 6800 ultra performs just fine on the 3400+ and even leads the pack on several occassions.

http://www.anandtech.com/cpu/showdoc.html?i=2091&p=13
 
ok dude i think u misunderstood i am deciding whether i want to get an x800xt pe or 6800u
i have an amd
this means according to ur bench
i would be better off with and X800XT PE
plus u cant base anything on one bench

besides it doesnt matter i pretty sure im going with ati
 
Well, if you had an nForce 3 board, the 6800U would always win in that board, since nForce 3 is a boon to the 6800's. But you have a stupid VIA. Why?! WHYYY?!?!! :confused:
 
what r u talking bout my mobo rocks as i assume does my chipset
also i think the reason the intel on both cards is better frame rates then the amd because the intel is a faster cpu and bottle neck is occuring
this will not be a problem when xp 64 and 64 bit games come out
well for my processor at least
 
in a gpu review they would be more careful to make sure everything is more equal between the two card and they would also mention quality and other things that count

all this review cares about is that both cards do better with the intel
not which card does the best with the intel

i wonder if any of the mobos had an nforce that could change things they wouldnt have done that in a gpu review

it would make it unfair
 
smcgee85 said:
in a gpu review they would be more careful to make sure everything is more equal between the two card and they would also mention quality and other things that count

all this review cares about is that both cards do better with the intel
not which card does the best with the intel

i wonder if any of the mobos had an nforce that could change things they wouldnt have done that in a gpu review

it would make it unfair

first, intel has no nforce. second, why would that be unfair considering like half of the athlon64 users are using an nforce board. if i owned an nforce board and pairing it with a gf6800 would be faster than the ati board, i'd want to know that.

it's pretty obvious you want the ati card and are grabbing at straws, trying to find any reason to buy it. it's not that the ati card is a bad card; it's plenty fast. just than when you ask for benchmarks and the benchmarks didn't show what you expected, you said you were just going to get the ati anyway
 
smcgee85 said:
in a gpu review they would be more careful to make sure everything is more equal between the two card and they would also mention quality and other things that count

all this review cares about is that both cards do better with the intel
not which card does the best with the intel

I dont think that was their intentions at all. The whole purpose of the GPU part of the review was the new PCI Express cards and how they performed. Not how well the 6800u and X800XT PE performs on an Intel platform. And the review was covering the new 3.6E Prescotts. They used a regular P4 3.2EE for the AGP 8x game benches.

It does seem strange that the 3400+ didn't perform better then it did but the 3.2EE does have 2MB of L3 cache which gives a big boost in games.
 
dualblade said:
first, intel has no nforce. second, why would that be unfair considering like half of the athlon64 users are using an nforce board. if i owned an nforce board and pairing it with a gf6800 would be faster than the ati board, i'd want to know that.

it's pretty obvious you want the ati card and are grabbing at straws, trying to find any reason to buy it. it's not that the ati card is a bad card; it's plenty fast. just than when you ask for benchmarks and the benchmarks didn't show what you expected, you said you were just going to get the ati anyway


lol ur funny
u think im the one pulling at straws? rofl
ur the one defending a cpu review and using it to to say that the 6800u has better performance when the review doesnt show that at all
lol im just saying that ur "bench" is bs
also ur absolutely wrong
y would i defend a card i ahvent bought yet
at any given time i could change my mind and go with nvidia
if i thought the nvivida was truly better i would be going with it not trying to justify that the ati card is better
and ur taking this way too far
we have no idea how these cards will perform in the REAL benches in the coming weeks
so just chill out
be patient
 
Back
Top