X800XL vs. 6800GT

MoBsTa

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jan 22, 2005
Messages
241
I will build a new system over the summer and I was wondering what card I should get.

I want to OC, do both cards OC well?

I am also a casual gamer, I do not do 16+ hrs. of gaming a day

Can you guys also recommend a cooler for the X800XL? I was thinking the NV silencer but idk if that's the best one.

Would really like your opinions on this

I play games like HL2, CS:S, and WoW
 
id say 6800gt.

from an overclocking perspective.

the nvidia cards are clocked much lower , thus its sufficient to say that if you manage to overclock a 6800 you will get more performance gain per mhz than an ati card since ati cards are running at higher frequencies in order to try to close the gap.

now i dont overclock my card... really cant say what ranges you will get on either an nvidia or an ati in that area.
 
So you are saying the X800XL is not overclockable at all?

And like I said, I will be building in summer so maybe prices will go down on the 6800GT by then.......
 
MoBsTa said:
Can you guys also recommend a cooler for the X800XL? I was thinking the NV silencer but idk if that's the best one.

Do you mean ATI silencer... ? Wouldn't recommend an NV silencer for the X800XL :rolleyes:
 
somebody asked the exact same question here

Both of the cards are pretty close in performance I doubt you will be able to tell the difference without knowing what the actual FPS is. the 6800 overclocks better but even after overclocked it will probably at the most only give you a few more FPS than stock speeds.
 
WSlyce said:
somebody asked the exact same question here

Both of the cards are pretty close in performance I doubt you will be able to tell the difference without knowing what the actual FPS is. the 6800 overclocks better but even after overclocked it will probably at the most only give you a few more FPS than stock speeds.
If by a few, you mean 30+, then yes, a few.
 
shadowbreaker513 said:
I mean by overclocking a 6800GT.

Look at the ultras, which is basically what your going to OC to.

No more then about 10 FPS, not very noticeable in game. At least I wouldnt notice between 80FPS and 87FPS
 
aZn_plyR said:
I would notice quite a bit 35 vs 42 :)

7 FPS? I doubt it, even if you are getting an avg of say 90fps, pretty much at leat 6 times a minute, your FPS will drop by 10 or more FPS, and you dont even notice.
 
Hate_Bot said:
7 FPS? I doubt it, even if you are getting an avg of say 90fps, pretty much at leat 6 times a minute, your FPS will drop by 10 or more FPS, and you dont even notice.

7 fps in this case is 20 % :rolleyes:
 
Hate_Bot said:
7 FPS? I doubt it, even if you are getting an avg of say 90fps, pretty much at leat 6 times a minute, your FPS will drop by 10 or more FPS, and you dont even notice.

Perhaps it would be better to compare it to what an x800xl can get from overclocking instead of just denying that there's any tangible benefit...
 
I would recommend the 6800GT to get the benefits of FP16 HDR, DirectX9.0C and SM3.0, which the x800 does not support. A lot of games coming out soon will use these features (BF2, Unreal 3, HL2 Lost Coast, etc.).
 
Do you guys think the 6800GT's will go down in price by summer with all the new stuff coming out?
 
MoBsTa said:
Do you guys think the 6800GT's will go down in price by summer with all the new stuff coming out?

You can bet the farm on that - at least by late summer or early fall. The 6800 GT's have got to drop as soon as the new cards come out this fall - probably quite a bit.
 
MoBsTa said:
Do you guys think the 6800GT's will go down in price by summer with all the new stuff coming out?

Prices are already dropping (yay!). :cool: So it's a good bet that in a few months they should slip down even more.
 
Ahhh there's been so many thread/debates/arguements of this, and yet people who own NEITHER card still post like that have some ability to guess the cards performance, that cracks me up :rolleyes:. Anyway, I have a 6800GT because I got it for a good price and it overclocked well (see sig). Dunno about the x800xl, I've never used one, but it looks like they're pretty much on par with each other. However, I think that if you can overclock your 6800GT to my speeds, you'll be hard pressed to find an x800xl, even when overclocked, that can keep up. But either card is a great card, you cant go wrong here :cool:
 
The only reason I am asking the price question is because I'me kind of on a budget and can't afford a $350 video card.

The X800XL is atractive because I can get it for like $275-$300. I also want a cooler so that I can OC (for either card)

But if prices dropped to about $300 or lower for a 6800GT I would probably get the GT (PCIE) for overclockability.
 
I have my X800XL overclocked to 440/540 with an AC Silencer on it in an SN25P and I have had zero propblems and this thing runs like a champ. I play mostly Planetside which tends to be hard on GFX cards and this thing runs it no problem with all the in game graphics turned up and 8xAA/16xAF turned on in the ATI controls. I get a consistent 80 or so FPS.
 
idk what I'me going to do......

I'me going to wait till July to buy everything anyways, a lot could change in 2 months.

Could take longer if I don't get the money.
 
If money is your issue than definitely get the X800XL. I think you'll enjoy the extra money in your pocket more than a few FPS. With that being said, you might get a really nice X800XL that could out-perform a GT that didnt overclock as high as you had hoped. I wouldn't gamble if you're tight on cash *looks down at S754 system* :D
 
Back
Top