X800 XL > 6800GT?

Joined
Jun 19, 2005
Messages
31
Ive heard that the X800 XL is faster than the 6800GT, is this true? Has anyone had experience with both of these cards? Please help, I am new to the video card stuff and I do not feel like blowing 300 dollars and then finding out I bought the wrong one! :eek:
 
They are the same speed pretty much. X800XL is slightly faster.

If you're going PCIe you should go with the X800XL.
 
the difference in gameplay is almost nothing. I have the x800xl, my friend has a 6800gt. We can both play at the same resolutions and same detail levels with similar framerates. Both are great cards...you should be happy with either one.
 
nst6563 said:
the difference in gameplay is almost nothing. I have the x800xl, my friend has a 6800gt. We can both play at the same resolutions and same detail levels with similar framerates. Both are great cards...you should be happy with either one.

First and foremost, thanks to both of you that replied. Lots of people take my ignorance towards video cards as a joke, its just a lot of money to spend on something you are unsure of. Do you play BF2 on your X800XL? I noticed that the X800xl doesnt need the extra power connector that the 6800gt requires. Also, are the drivers good for ATI? For NVidia I could simply open up the nvidia manger and turn AA on or off and AF on or off, is there a simiular program for ATI cards? Thanks fellas!
 
ATi's drivers are known to be more "noob" friendly. You can simply open them and go to the 3D tab and it presents a simple slider to change AA and AF, that easy and even shows you a little 3D car scene of the effects, though AA isnt so clearly shown on it, lol.

Before we get a big flame war going about each companies drivers, I'd like to say that both are equally easy to use and equally stable, they are both great driver sets.
 
Well they way I see it, its the PRICE, whichevers cheaper. Both are GREAT CARDS, the 6800GT being slightly(unnoticeable maybe) better, so if they have the same price Id go for the 6800GT just because Ive been wanting one for so long hehe.
 
I know that nvidia has something like Microsoft Shadar Model 3.0 or something along those lines. Does ATI have the equevilent of that? The reason I am leaning towards ATI is because I just sent back a EVGA 6600gt that I really wasnt that impressed w/ and then it blew on me after only 10 days! I got horrible pixelation when it blew. Check it out...

This is the sign on screen of BF2:

 
well i don't have an x800xl but i do have a x800pro modded to xt
and i do have a 6800gt .

their good cards and play games fine --either should do a good job on about anygame you use.

i suppose it would depend on the cost and wether your going to sli or not .

i got the x800pro because i could get it for $220--this is back when they were really expensive

now a xl--i see in the hot deals a new one for $250--thats tough to beat.
if a gf6800gt was the same price then i would get the 6800gt for SLI . without sli it is a coke or pepsi type of thing--lol
 
JSF35rhino said:
well i don't have an x800xl but i do have a x800pro modded to xt
and i do have a 6800gt .

their good cards and play games fine --either should do a good job on about anygame you use.

i suppose it would depend on the cost and wether your going to sli or not .

i got the x800pro because i could get it for $220--this is back when they were really expensive

now a xl--i see in the hot deals a new one for $250--thats tough to beat.
if a gf6800gt was the same price then i would get the 6800gt for SLI . without sli it is a coke or pepsi type of thing--lol


I have one, single, PCI-E slot...
 
Then get the X800Xl, no questions.

You brought up SM3.0, it really does not matter at all of these cards. You see, neither card has the power to run SM3.0 effects decently, about the only card out right now that does is the 7800GTX.
 
just fyi, you asked if I ran BF2 on my x800xl. Yes, I do. And the settings in case you're interested are
1600x1200 @ 85hz
ALL details on HIGH
2xaa

That's with the setup in my sig (1.5gb ram). Consistently gets around 50fps, drops to high 30's when there's a LOT of stuff on the screen...but if I want to stay close to 80-100 fps, then I can drop the resolution down to 1280x960 with all the details on high and 4xaa.
 
wickedld9 said:
Save yourself $50 and order this one.

I only ordered pc supplies once online, and that was from newegg and they were real good with the return. Does this monarch place have good customer service, or have you ever ordered anything from here?
 
Triumphdog34 said:
I only ordered pc supplies once online, and that was from newegg and they were real good with the return. Does this monarch place have good customer service, or have you ever ordered anything from here?

Monarch is a pretty damn good company, I'd esaily put them up towards Newegg level of service.
 
Skrying said:
Monarch is a pretty damn good company, I'd esaily put them up towards Newegg level of service.

Ok. the card looks identical. So is it that Rosewill slapped there name on it and charged an extra 50 bucks because of it? Do they ship it in 4-6 days like newegg?
 
first off neither one at stock speeds is greater than the other and they are now about the same price. However the x800xl doesnt oc worth a damn and the 6800gt has about a 95% success rate of ocing it higher than 6800 ultra speeds so id say go with the 6800gt
 
cell_491 said:
first off neither one at stock speeds is greater than the other and they are now about the same price. However the x800xl doesnt oc worth a damn and the 6800gt has about a 95% success rate of ocing it higher than 6800 ultra speeds so id say go with the 6800gt

Cheapest 6800GT I can find on Newegg is $350 upfront with the *chance* of a $50 rebate going through, the next cheapest is $360 with a $14 rebate later on. So no, they are not about the same price, in fact about a $100 difference.
 
From skrying's x800xl link,
"Remonster, 6/26/2005 5:43:03 PM
Best bang for buck out there. This card compares to the 6800GT directly but is actually as fast as a 6800ULTRA or an X800XT because it was added later and has newer architechture and a new generation GPU (R430 rather than R423) I got this and an arctic cooling silencer and it overclocks to X850XT speeds no problems, totally happy overclocked and at stock speeds, a best buy for sure."

A reader review, all the way up to X850XT speeds? That's amazing.
 
Triumphdog34 said:
First and foremost, thanks to both of you that replied. Lots of people take my ignorance towards video cards as a joke, its just a lot of money to spend on something you are unsure of. Do you play BF2 on your X800XL? I noticed that the X800xl doesnt need the extra power connector that the 6800gt requires. Also, are the drivers good for ATI? For NVidia I could simply open up the nvidia manger and turn AA on or off and AF on or off, is there a simiular program for ATI cards? Thanks fellas!

I use ATITool. It sits in your tray (you can set it to display GPU temps) and you just right click the tray icon to pick whatever AA/AF level you want. Best of all, it's free!
 
Wow. Reading some more reviews, the X800 XL does sound like the card for me. Thanks for everyones help, I appreciate it. take care fellas
 
illgiveumorality said:
From skrying's x800xl link,
"Remonster, 6/26/2005 5:43:03 PM
Best bang for buck out there. This card compares to the 6800GT directly but is actually as fast as a 6800ULTRA or an X800XT because it was added later and has newer architechture and a new generation GPU (R430 rather than R423) I got this and an arctic cooling silencer and it overclocks to X850XT speeds no problems, totally happy overclocked and at stock speeds, a best buy for sure."

A reader review, all the way up to X850XT speeds? That's amazing.

Yeah, considering my vmodded XL will only go 490/600 on watercooling without artifacts. But I've heard of some that will go into the low 500s on water.
I believe most people get about 440-450mhz on the core and around 550mhz on the mem with air cooling and no vmods. That's not bad and the performance is very good. Mine did 450/565 before the vmods.

Oh.........btw, the AGP X800XL uses and X800XT core. That may be how he got X850XT speeds.The PCI-E XL uses a 16-pipe Pro core. Don't believe me? Pull off the HSF. See what the core says.
 
Lol, yeah, so many talk about the great OCing abilites of the 6800GT, on yes, that amazing 50Mhz core OC and the small memory one they all get. :rolleyes:

X800XLs have no problem doing that either, mine does 480Mhz core with an ATi Silencer and 580Mhz memory.
 
Skrying said:
Lol, yeah, so many talk about the great OCing abilites of the 6800GT, on yes, that amazing 50Mhz core OC and the small memory one they all get. :rolleyes:

X800XLs have no problem doing that either, mine does 480Mhz core with an ATi Silencer and 580Mhz memory.
yea but 50 mhz for the ati card doesnt provide as much punch as 50mhz for the nvidia card....by the way you were right about the price I was still thinking about the price drop on the agp version
 
wait.. is this agp or pci-express???? if this is agp, I vote 6800gt b/c they are alot cheaper on agp than on pci-Expess...if this is a pci-express system, get the x800xl just b/c it is alot cheaper than the 6800gt on pci-express platofrm.
 
aZn_plyR said:
wait.. is this agp or pci-express???? if this is agp, I vote 6800gt b/c they are alot cheaper on agp than on pci-Expess...if this is a pci-express system, get the x800xl just b/c it is alot cheaper than the 6800gt on pci-express platofrm.

PCIe, read the thread next time.
 
Skrying said:
PCIe, read the thread next time.

I didnt feel like it, but I would've said the same thing even if I knew if it wa agp or pci-e ;)
 
Awesome fellas. Just orederd my X800 XL PCI-E! Will I notice the difference in ram and pipelines as they are both doubled?
 
Back
Top