x48 - DFI or ASUS

Deeky

Gawd
Joined
Feb 7, 2008
Messages
982
Another mobo thread from me! The gear hunt continues. Thanks for your patience.

In the interest of x16/x16 Crossfire and potential Q9550 OC, I'm looking into x48. I realize P45 is the 45nm quad OC champion, but I have a hard time pulling the trigger on a UD3P wondering if it'll cripple my Xfire possibilities with x8/x8. GPU performance is more important to me than the difference between 3.6 and 4.0GHz. Not sure if the new DX11 generation of cards will saturate PCI 2.0 x8, but am I willing to risk it ...?

I realize 775 is EOL, but I'm certainly not willing to invest an additional $350-400 CDN to move to i5. The potential performance gain simply isn't worth it. Given the choice between the following x48 boards, which would you choose?

DFI LANPARTY UT X48-T2R ($178)
ASUS Rampage Formula ($220)
ASUS P5E Deluxe ($169)

Is there an obvious choice? The DFI looks nice, but I've heard it has BIOS issues and the layout can be tricky with big CPU coolers. I've also heard it's hit and miss with quads. The Rampage is great, but expensive. The P5E appears to be a stripped down version of the Rampage, but I've run across several end users reporting horrible failures (such as fried CPUs), so I'm a little leery of it. Thoughts? Thanks in advance for your input!
 
Last edited:
Wait what, you're building LGA775 X48? Terrible value right now and so much money to put onto an end of life chipset.. why? With that budget you can afford better.. You can get x16 on AM3 or you can get LGA1156 at x16x8 and see no real performance decreases. x8 2.0 is like running x16 1.0. It's just not anything to be fussed about. You should be aware that while you personally feel more concerned about not losing any GPU performance, you will actually GET better performance not worrying quite so much about it.
 
Wait what, you're building LGA775 X48?

No. God no. Give me SOME credit.

I'm not building from scratch, sorry for the confusion. Obviously, if I were building from the ground up I'd go with i5 or i7. In this case, I'm simply upgrading the mobo of an existing 775 system. I'd LOVE to get an LGA1156 board, but that would necessitate an additional $3-400 investment for a new processor and RAM, an investment that would net me no where near $3-400 worth of additional performance over my Q9550. Not interested.

You should be aware that I'm not a total noob. If you have an opinion about the boards, great. If not, I appreciate your time.

EDIT: Let me bottom line it for ya: If you can tell me with confidence that a PCI 2.0 x8 won't bottleneck an ATI 5890 ... OR ... even if it does, that I only stand to sacrifice a 2-5% of maximum performance, I'll happily save a wad of cash and go with P45. I haven't been able to find a respectable test result (at least nothing showcasing the new gen cards), but I've failed at Google before.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps this will help: http://www.anandtech.com/mb/showdoc.aspx?i=3649&p=2

It's x58 and not X48 but you get the idea with the full x16 vs. x8. It does not appear to be a difference that you will be able to experience, only benchmark. That's what I've seen other people talking about as well.

I tried to CF two 4890 on P45, its a nightmare...

the performance is a huge difference in games like Crysis in my test, its about 5+fps difference for me, and it stutter randomly in some part.

this is also a reason why I stick with a x38 board instead.

also, X38 and X48 are very similar, or I should say they are the same beside the FSB support..
 

Thanks for the link. It makes me wonder though, how would a single card Xfire/SLI solution like the 5890 fare in a x8 PCI 2.0 slot? I guess they don't bother to test as the result is fairly obvious, and anyone spending that kind of coin on a single card behemoth likely won't be running x8/x8. I'm sure Nvidia's answer to ATI's DX11 cards will raise the bar even more. As with every benchmark I've seen discussing this issue, "What we cannot answer right now is if the dual x8 PCIe capability on Lynnfield will become a true bottleneck with the GPUs that follow the current/planned releases from AMD/Nvidia." Still, it's good to know that the current crop of GPUs (excluding the 5890) are not entirely hobbled by x8.

Also, thanks for the input, shansoft. Whether or not I consider 5+fps to be "huge" depends what your max rate is. If you're talking 130fps -5fps, no biggie. But 40fps -5? I'd consider that unacceptable.
 
I think you mean the 5970? Because the 5890 doesn't exist.. My opinion is that 5970 in x16 is practically pointless, so I don't know about x8. In the reviews I've seen there are a few basic conclusions.

In lower resolutions there is zero gain, or in some cases, drop in FPS from this, so it is totally pointless on all levels to do this unless you're going to be gaming at quite high res. Of course, I can't imagine anyone who is shelling out $1200-$1300 in gpus is gaming at low res anyway.

In many other high resolution (specifically the 2560x1600) instances the crossfire benchmarks flat out failed to complete, and those that did didn't always have any benefits.

In the cases where there were some decent performance gains, they were pointless because the FPS were already so high there would be zero notable difference in actual application.

It seems to me the extra $600-$650 would be better spent elsewhere. That's a lot of money to throw into something where the benefits can only be seen through benchmarks.

ETA: To answer your original question, DFI FTW on the X48, but if it were me I'd get a nice P45-Ud3p and keep that extra $100 aside for future upgrades. If you stick want to go x48, then just check into cooler fit as I've heard some of the bigger ones won't fit due to DFI's heatpipe design around the socket. No personal experience on this though.
 
Last edited:
I think you mean the 5970? Because the 5890 doesn't exist..

:D Correct. My bad. Whatever ATI's new dual GPU hotness is, these days.

I wouldn't be running dual GPU cards in Xfire. That flat out blows my mind. I certainly wouldn't be agonizing over a $40 difference in potential x48 boards if I could afford to do that. I was simply curious how a single 5970 would run in x8. If I were to run even a single 5970 (or in this case the eventual Nvidia counterpart), it would be as primary alongside my current Nvidia card as dedicated PhysX. Though I realize the setup yields minimal performance benefits in the current crop of games, I'm thinking down the road, hoping the relative success of PhysX in Batman catches on with devs. Beyond a dedicated PhysX/dual GPU config, I'd otherwise be running straight Xfire with single GPU cards. Either way, the x8 versus x16 discussion is of interest to me.

So you're a fan of DFI? I've heard the same regarding cooler mounting issues. Definitely one of my considerations (and related, yet another reason I've decided not to move to i5 - I'd be forced to buy a new CPU cooler on top of everything else). I still haven't 100% committed to the notion of x48, the UD3P is still a distinct possibility.
 
I've never owned a DFI, myself but I've built with DFI and know people who have had some mad overclocking results. They seem to be a rock solid company and they are really reasonably priced for the specs they give compared to a lot of other companies.
 
Thanks. The DFI is still a strong contender, though at this point I'm leaning toward the Rampage. It's a proven performer with 45nm quads (not quite up to P45 standards, of course), the BIOS is mature, the layout is awesome as is the stock cooling (though I'll likely add a fan to the NB). No CPU cooler installation problems that I'm aware of, plus other niceties like the CMOS reset button on the rear panel make the premium worth it. All in all, between additional features and peace of mind, I think I'm willing to spend the extra $40.
 
I'll give my vote for the Rampage Formula (although I am kinda biased, see sig :p)

I have never had any problems with it, booted my q9450 to 3.5 stable on nothing but fsb adjustments.

Love the great cooling, rear cmos, and the overall layout

Although I bought mine used off these forums a year ago during Dec, and only paid $170, so the $220 price tag is a deterrent.
 
Thanks for the input! $220 is dirt compared to what the majority of online retailers are asking. High-end 775 boards are becoming a rarity, I guess. Legacy gouging. Even on eBay sellers are asking over $400 CDN for the Rampage and mobos with similar feature sets. Crazy.
 
Last edited:
Newegg.ca may have just made my decision for me. They're suddenly offering a $50 instant savings on the DFI board, dropping it to $134.99. Compared to $220+ for the Rampage, which is on backorder until God knows when ... seems like the way to go despite the ASUS board offering more peace of mind, some additional features and fewer question marks.
 
Back
Top