x4 pcie slot

Yes it will. They're designed such that smaller cards work in larger slots. So x4 cards will work in x16 slots.
 
Technically, yes. However, some of the x16 slots are electrically and physically different, meaning it is not a x16 slot just x16 compatible. You should always consult the motherboard manual for what that slot that is about to be used actually is. Also, some slots cannot be used if other logic or slots are in use; so consult motherboard manual first.
 
Technically, yes. However, some of the x16 slots are electrically and physically different, meaning it is not a x16 slot just x16 compatible. You should always consult the motherboard manual for what that slot that is about to be used actually is. Also, some slots cannot be used if other logic or slots are in use; so consult motherboard manual first.

Proof that an x16 slot is physically different?

The only time an x16 sized slot isn't an x16 slot is when they're an x8 or x4 slot but used in an x16 full size slot.
 
Proof that an x16 slot is physically different?

The only time an x16 sized slot isn't an x16 slot is when they're an x8 or x4 slot but used in an x16 full size slot.

You just said it, as I mentioned too, but without much detail in my previous post: "However, some of the x16 slots are electrically and physically different, meaning it is not a x16 slot just x16 compatible." So, you can have, as we both have said, a compatible x16 slot but it is wired at x4 to x8 PCIe physically and electrically depending on board and configurations of lanes and such.

This is why it is important to always consult a motherboard manual to see how all the PCIe lanes are allocated to peripherals and other logics on the board.
 
They are not physically different that would prevent an x4 card from fitting in an x16 slot. Al x16 slots are identical. Making them the same physical connector on the motherboard. Missing pins doesn't make it physically different.
 
They are not physically different that would prevent an x4 card from fitting in an x16 slot. Al x16 slots are identical. Making them the same physical connector on the motherboard. Missing pins doesn't make it physically different.

Incorrect PCIe is similar to networking in that part of the physical layer is the amount of lane (logical) and electrical links. We are not talking about the slot which as long as as it can accommodate will "fit." However electrical and logical specifications are not always to slot size. Wiki it, you will see.
 
Physical and electrical parameters are different. An x16 physical slot does not have to have 16 signal pairs. Don't confuse physical and electrical, they are completely separate and thinking they are the same thing and coming up with stuff like " meaning it is not a x16 slot just x16 compatible." just confuses the issue.

An x16 slot does not need x16 signalling. The end. It could easily have x1 signalling. Or x4. Or x8. Any valid PCI-E lane configuration >= x16.
 
Physical and electrical parameters are different. An x16 physical slot does not have to have 16 signal pairs. Don't confuse physical and electrical, they are completely separate and thinking they are the same thing and coming up with stuff like " meaning it is not a x16 slot just x16 compatible." just confuses the issue.

An x16 slot does not need x16 signalling. The end. It could easily have x1 signalling. Or x4. Or x8. Any valid PCI-E lane configuration >= x16.

You are saying what I said and then place a restriction that has nothing to do with my preferences, but with the regulation of lanes to any motherboard; due to design. As I said before in the first post consult motherboard manual for EXACT lane configuration. Because the only guarantee that you have to any slot is x1 as per PCIe specification. Beyond that it can vary, and even the version of PCIe lanes can vary.

So you can be confused all you want.....I rather consult as to what configurations are available as they have been configured for by the manufacturer. Even Wiki has it, basically, all right here:

A PCIe card fits into a slot of its physical size or larger (maximum ×16), but may not fit into a smaller PCIe slot (e.g.,a ×16 card in a ×8 slot). Some slots use open-ended sockets to permit physically longer cards and negotiate the best available electrical connection. The number of lanes actually connected to a slot may also be less than the number supported by the physical slot size.
An example is a ×16 slot that runs at ×4. This slot will accept any ×1, ×2, ×4, ×8, or ×16 card, but provides only ×4 speed. Its specification may read: ×16 (×4 mode); "×size @ ×speed" notation (×16 @ ×4) is also common. The advantage is that such slot can accommodate a larger range of PCIe cards without requiring motherboard hardware to support the full transfer rate
.
 
oh man nerd wars, if the op had to ask this in the first place he surely did not need as in depth an explanation as this.
 
Well I don't think he's wanting to use a graphics card if the item in question is x4. Most items that are x4 are SSD hard drives, which would still work fine in a x4 electrical slot. So the real question that no one asked is, whats being used that's x4 here?
 
Nah, it is nothing but a case of asinine fucking ignorance,and someone that did not RTFM; actually people apparently. Besides the best answer still is this:
Technically, yes. However, some of the x16 slots are electrically and physically different, meaning it is not a x16 slot just x16 compatible. You should always consult the motherboard manual for what that slot that is about to be used actually is. Also, some slots cannot be used if other logic or slots are in use; so consult motherboard manual first.

Its simple really...motherboard manual says it all-always. Do any of you know that with the Asus Sabertooth Z77 if any of the PCIe x1's are in use will mean that you can never have a x4 capable in use with PCIe slot 3? It is either 4 x1's or 1 x4. Or that PCIe x16 slot 3 is maxed at x4 mode, and it is only version 2.0? 2-12 of the manual look it up.
 
It's not being asinine, it's your choice of words. Compatibility in your case is taken to mean physically and electrically compatible. It's taken to mean that if one part is not compatible, the other is not compatible as well. It's your unclear words that are generating the misunderstanding, and you seem to fail to realize that.

Additionally, an x16 electrical card will work in an x1 electrical slot. It is by the definition of compatibility, compatible. As long as the slot can physically accept an x16 card, the card will accept x1 electrical connection. Therefore, it's compatible. Is it ideal? No, but it is compatible. In reverse, a slot with x16 electrical interface will accept an x1 card. Again, an x1 electrical card is compatible with an x16 slot.

Compatibility and ideal connectivity are two very different concepts. It's your poor choice of words, not anyone else's ignorance issues.
 
It's not being asinine, it's your choice of words. Compatibility in your case is taken to mean physically and electrically compatible. It's taken to mean that if one part is not compatible, the other is not compatible as well. It's your unclear words that are generating the misunderstanding, and you seem to fail to realize that.

Additionally, an x16 electrical card will work in an x1 electrical slot. It is by the definition of compatibility, compatible. As long as the slot can physically accept an x16 card, the card will accept x1 electrical connection. Therefore, it's compatible. Is it ideal? No, but it is compatible. In reverse, a slot with x16 electrical interface will accept an x1 card. Again, an x1 electrical card is compatible with an x16 slot.

Compatibility and ideal connectivity are two very different concepts. It's your poor choice of words, not anyone else's ignorance issues.

It is not my choice of words; only my choice of words if one wishes to be defensive or attack me. Since, again I said that it all about the motherboard manual, we shall see what significance you have to say since you rather attack.

It's taken to mean that if one part is not compatible, the other is not compatible as well.

Nope, consult motherboard to see what is compatible. However in the mean time read what I posted previously.

It's your unclear words that are generating the misunderstanding, and you seem to fail to realize that.

Unclear to whom? You only? Motherboard manual for concise description of what can be...hmn I guess that is where RTFM came from?

Additionally, an x16 electrical card will work in an x1 electrical slot.

I never said it would not-read above posts

As long as the slot can physically accept an x16 card, the card will accept x1 electrical connection.

I never said it would not-read above posts

Therefore, it's compatible. Is it ideal?

No such thing, consult manual

It's your poor choice of words, not anyone else's ignorance issues.

Hmn, really.....seriously....some people

I do not know what you people do not understand about the manuals that you have for your motherboards. I did not need to get into a description until ignorant shit was a flying my way from Skillz. Read the manual if you want to know what your motherboard can do, what you can use with it, and how. Beyond that keep posting and be ignorant..I do not care until I read a post being posted that says: reading the manual is what the end user should not do. You will be wasting your time for everyone. Seriously....man the ignorance.

Here I will help this is my first post :
Technically, yes. However, some of the x16 slots are electrically and physically different, meaning it is not a x16 slot just x16 compatible. You should always consult the motherboard manual for what that slot that is about to be used actually is. Also, some slots cannot be used if other logic or slots are in use; so consult motherboard manual first.

It is simple, really...might as well stop "arguing" because it is nothing but asinine to argue NOTto read the manual for PCIe installations.
 
Fine. Show me a motherboard that does completely shut off PCI-E slots when something is installed/enabled elsewhere. I have yet to come across one that does so. Shifting of lanes, yes, but completely shutting it off? Nope. If he wanted it to work optimally, yes, read the manual. Otherwise, 90% of the time, just putting it in will work as long as it physically fits. On modern motherboards with plenty of lanes and bandwidth, that probably goes up to 99.99999% of the time.

And yes, your post could have been taken to mean that way. An x16 slot is physically an x16 slot, no two ways around it. You just added extra convoluted information that had nearly nothing to do with the OP's question.
 
This is why I gave up on this thread and it looks like I forgot to unsubscribe from it. Le Sigh.
 
Fine. Show me a motherboard that does completely shut off PCI-E slots when something is installed/enabled elsewhere. I have yet to come across one that does so. Shifting of lanes, yes, but completely shutting it off?

You didn't read my post about the Asus Sabertooth Z77? In which I mentioned that if I used an x4 card all the x1 slots are disabled? It was right before yours. So here I will post what I said: "Do any of you know that with the Asus Sabertooth Z77 if any of the PCIe x1's are in use will mean that you can never have a x4 capable in use with PCIe slot 3? It is either 4 x1's or 1 x4." By the way negotiation (you say shifting) of lanes can mean a slot will be disabled. Obviously if the lanes are allocated to another slot(s) and none can be provided then it is basically disabled. As it does say in my manual on 2-12.



Otherwise, 90% of the time, just putting it in will work as long as it physically fits.

Depends if the the host logics can provide and requisites of the peripheral card are met. Obviously, this is a generalization too and I have addressed this multiple times too. (q.v. previous posts). Note, I did say technically yes long time ago. As I said technically...yes. So there is a bit of agreeing here, but as previous post said consult manual for proper card installation. Because, at least even according to you, you acknowledge that 10% of the time it will not work either. So it is exactly, as I said before, which you think is so "convoluted."


An x16 slot is physically an x16 slot, no two ways around it.

Again no and here is Wiki to your rescue:

A PCIe card fits into a slot of its physical size or larger (maximum ×16), but may not fit into a smaller PCIe slot (e.g.,a ×16 card in a ×8 slot). Some slots use open-ended sockets to permit physically longer cards and negotiate the best available electrical connection. The number of lanes actually connected to a slot may also be less than the number supported by the physical slot size.


You just added extra convoluted information that had nearly nothing to do with the OP's question.

Nope, it just is, what it is. And I told him as so. Because of that 10%........
 
Back
Top