X3350 vs Q9450 Whats the difference?

kiwi32

n00b
Joined
Mar 6, 2008
Messages
35
Besides the name difference i cannot find any information about how the xeon version of the Q9450 is different. Usually xeons have more cache and are designed to work with multiple processors but here both have the same amount of cache and both work as uni-processors. It would be great if someone could share more information about the processors.
 
Socket 775 Xeons are exactly the same as their Core counterparts, except for CPU Code. They have the same cache and optimizations and everything. The Xeon, however, is less likely to be recognized by motherboards so you should check beforehand (although most high-end motherboards you would pair with it likely would support it.)

A good analog is the Xeon E3110 (my cpu) versus the E8400.
 
any idea on what the support would be like in either the asus maximus formula (X38) or rampage formula (X48). Probably the boards I will go and since no places seem to really even have preorders for the Q9450 and the fact the Q9300 is $50+ more expensive than a Xeon 3350 preorder I'm thinking of adopting the Xeon. Asus doesnt seem to list any Xeon support but I doubt that means they arent supported.
 
A good analog is the Xeon E3110 (my cpu) versus the E8400.

this thread describes the "differences" between those two pretty well. http://www.xtremesystems.org/forums/showthread.php?t=178255

I hope the x3350 is the same, i will likely pick one up along with an asus maximus/rampage.

any idea on what the support would be like in either the asus maximus formula (X38) or rampage formula (X48). Probably the boards I will go and since no places seem to really even have preorders for the Q9450 and the fact the Q9300 is $50+ more expensive than a Xeon 3350 preorder I'm thinking of adopting the Xeon. Asus doesnt seem to list any Xeon support but I doubt that means they arent supported.

I'd like to know the answer to that one too.
 
I just got the X3350... I got tired of waiting for the Q9450... and it was cheaper too. Trying it out on a EVGA 780i board.
 
think it is worth it over a e6600? i game obviously, and encode and convert video enough but then again it ain't like that is time sensitive.
 
I find it extremely interesting that sites that we've never heard of before have these chips as opposed to sites like newegg, clubit, tiger, and zipzoom.
 
I find it extremely interesting that sites that we've never heard of before have these chips as opposed to sites like newegg, clubit, tiger, and zipzoom.

It happens, quite frequently.

There are no notable differences. Generally the Xeon counterparts are said to be binned differently and sometimes required to meet higher standards than the desktop counterparts.
 
There are no notable differences. Generally the Xeon counterparts are said to be binned differently and sometimes required to meet higher standards than the desktop counterparts.

Indeed they are usually better chips, but they are also meant to run like that at STOCK not overclocked, so im not 100% sure they have to be better chips.
 
i kno someone that got the xeon equivalent to a Q6600 and they are upset because they have used several boards and they are all quirky with identifiying it. you are always running a risk with server cpu's in desktop boards. not all play nice like hte opteron ;)
 
Indeed they are usually better chips, but they are also meant to run like that at STOCK not overclocked, so im not 100% sure they have to be better chips.

That argument can go either way. I'm not saying they are better chips, just that they are binned differently.

matrix563,
I've had a x3210 (quad core, s775) in a Asus P5WDG2-WS Pro for ~8months, and it identifies it fine. Have this person you know, update the bios.
 
Yep, if anyone could report if the X3350 works fine in the Maximus / Rampage Formula, I'd much appreciate it.
 
It happens, quite frequently.

There are no notable differences. Generally the Xeon counterparts are said to be binned differently and sometimes required to meet higher standards than the desktop counterparts.

Indeed they are usually better chips, but they are also meant to run like that at STOCK not overclocked, so im not 100% sure they have to be better chips.

People say this, but it is hard to prove. I'm not sure either way, but I'm guessing because they are socket 775, they are no different at all from the Core counterparts in performance or stability. I think they wanted to expand their core line to business buyers and labeling it a Xeon allows manufacturers to sell "Xeon" systems that are actually socket 775 systems. This is another reason why I think you don't find them on sites such as Newegg or Clubit as frequently as their Core counterparts -- because they were never really intended for the end user to piece together (also why it's hard to find information about mobo compatability).

I got my CPU from lagoom and shipping was fast and well packaged -- so the site is legit in my eyes.

think it is worth it over a e6600? i game obviously, and encode and convert video enough but then again it ain't like that is time sensitive.
Nope. The e6600 dual core is still more than enough for games, and if your encoding isn't time sensitive, you would get no value out of the upgrade. That being said, the new 45nm process runs cooler (although not sure about this 45 quad compared to that 65 dual). In your situation, though, I'd stick with the e6600 until upgrading makes more sense (nehalem + cheap ddr3 maybe?)

Yep, if anyone could report if the X3350 works fine in the Maximus / Rampage Formula, I'd much appreciate it.
Google is your only hope. I couldn't find the information on my DFI board, but I rolled the dice and got away with it. The Maximus/Rampage are ASUS's flagship motherboards though (their real "high end") so I'd bet my money on it working (I'd guess at least an 85% chance). ** With a new BIOS update. You might need another 775 cpu on hand.
 
I am getting the X3350 on monday and i will report how it works on a DFi X38 T2R with some CPU-Z verification in XP and Vista.
 
I am getting the X3350 on monday and i will report how it works on a DFi X38 T2R with some CPU-Z verification in XP and Vista.

Hope to do a comparo when I get the same parts except my mobo is the DFI X48 T2R :)

Hopefully the exrta money on the x48 was worth it.
 
You know you can flash an X38 and its an X48?

LOL.

Btw. The the difference between the two chips is that the Xeon has a backside bus while the desktop chip has a front side bus. Meaning your memory performance is directly correlated to the core speed.
 
... Xeon has a backside bus while the desktop chip has a front side bus. Meaning your memory performance is directly correlated to the core speed.

Thanks for the info Russian, but could you explain what you mean? you've lost me :(
 
Btw. The the difference between the two chips is that the Xeon has a backside bus while the desktop chip has a front side bus. Meaning your memory performance is directly correlated to the core speed.

NO! False.

Thanks for the info Russian, but could you explain what you mean? you've lost me :(

There is NO difference besides CPU Code (identifier motherboard uses to figure out what chip it's dealing with). Speaking from experience here as I'm running a Socket 775 Xeon

EDIT: Dan_D's (HardOCP Motherboard editor) response in another thread about X3110 vs E8400:
Bullshit. You do not need to re-install over a CPU change. Nothing will be accomplished by that. All Intel CPUs address memory the same. Your so called server CPU isn't a server CPU at all. It is a desktop Wolfdale that has been marked Xeon on the heat spreader and Xeon by some microcode at the factory. It is no different than any retail Core 2 Duo 45nm CPU. It is nothing but an unfounded misconception that there are differences between LGA775 Xeon CPUs and LGA775 Core 2's. There isn't any differences beyond what I've mentioned above.

People keep thinking that specific things about the LGA771 variety applies to the LGA775 chips and that isn't true. In any case the memory issues you mentioned above are totally incorrect and impossible. Shit even LGA771 CPUs are barely different than LGA775 chips. The main difference lies in the pin count and SMP capability. As I said all Intel x86/EM64T CPUs handle memory addressing the same. The memory controller is also in the chipset so there are no issues there.
 
NO! False.



There is NO difference besides CPU Code (identifier motherboard uses to figure out what chip it's dealing with). Speaking from experience here as I'm running a Socket 775 Xeon

EDIT: Dan_D's (HardOCP Motherboard editor) response in another thread about X3110 vs E8400:

This is good news, if its all true.

Well, thats what i was told. I cant substantiate it past what i was told. I will ask my intel rep directly and see what kind of response i get. :p
 
Back
Top