X2 or Raptors in Raid 0?

Copyright

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Nov 17, 2000
Messages
6,004
Looking to do an upgrade.. cant decide if I want to do another 74G raptor and set them up as Raid 0 or get an dual core processor. My specs are in my sig.. what would you do?
 
Why does Raid 0 suck? Ive had raptors in the past in raid and liked the performance gain.. espeically when loading games.
 
Copyright said:
Why does Raid 0 suck? Ive had raptors in the past in raid and liked the performance gain.. espeically when loading games.


This is also known as the placebo effect.

Most games do not benfit from raid0 at all. Loading benchmarks have show that most games are cpu dependent on level loading. RAID zero typically benifits large sequential operations like audio/video processing, large single file transfers or large data base queries(It improves data base performance because a large query has to scan the entire database so the faster you can access across the whole database, the better.) It doesn't help in random IO, it can increase latency. I'm sure there's more.

If the benfit was there was did you get rid of raid 0 with raptors? Are you still running raid 0?
 
Another raptor would be cheapest.
To do dualcore you will need cpu/mobo and new memory...
 
to go dual core all I would need is a processor... I would go with an opteron 170 dual core and clock it up... I wouldnt go to a conroe setup... to much $ to upgrade.
 
defakto said:
This is also known as the placebo effect.

Most games do not benfit from raid0 at all. Loading benchmarks have show that most games are cpu dependent on level loading. RAID zero typically benifits large sequential operations like audio/video processing, large single file transfers or large data base queries(It improves data base performance because a large query has to scan the entire database so the faster you can access across the whole database, the better.) It doesn't help in random IO, it can increase latency. I'm sure there's more.

If the benfit was there was did you get rid of raid 0 with raptors? Are you still running raid 0?

Besides the obvious that it isn't true raid in that it provides no redundancy and , unless you back up the striped hard drives, you have nothing to fall back on should your drives fail.

The OP wants opinions on what everyone else would do. Personally, I would look for the solution that provides the best performance boost, which would undoubtedly be a dualcore processor - you'll notice the effect in games, other applications, and just about every other aspect of computing over a RAID 0 solution, all other things being equal.
 
You've been fed a line of BS here.

I have dual core and no raid...my load timies suck compared to my friend with raid and a single core.

Drive performance makes a huge difference, loading 300-400 MB between levels can really slow things down.

But...I guess future games could demand dual core, but that won't be for a while.
 
BBA said:
You've been fed a line of BS here.

I have dual core and no raid...my load timies suck compared to my friend with raid and a single core.

Drive performance makes a huge difference, loading 300-400 MB between levels can really slow things down.

But...I guess future games could demand dual core, but that won't be for a while.

Premise: My friend's computer with one CPU and RAID 0 loads levels much faster than my computer with Two CPU's and 1 Hard drive.

Conclusion: RAID 0 is better for loading games than a Dual Core CPU.

Before I tear your argument a new one, is this actually what you wanted to say?
 
Now in BBA defence, SOME games do get an advantage from raid 0, but the vast majority do not, at least not enough to justify it.
 
Who cares if games don't benefit from it, it certainly doesn't hurt it. Hell, I put my two Raptors in Raid 0 just so they would appear as one drive. I realize there is probably other ways to do this, but I wanted to experience the placebo effect as well. It gives me peace of mind. :)
 
The bottom line is that adding a second core to the system will give you much more power overall in the long run than adding a single harddrive. Games are beginning to move towards dual core so they will perform better, the system will be smoother running and more responsive with multiple cpu's available for multi tasking, single processor intensive task will not make the system virually unusable.


Dual core uprade > raid 0 upgrade
 
neither one. From a performance standpoint, I lean towards the dual core CPU but, you are already at 2.8ghz. You aren't going to see a great benefit in a dual core CPU with gaming. If you multitask a lot you might see a good benefit. Plus, you are going to need to find one that runs at 2.8ghz or you'll be dissapointed. I say keep saving for your next major upgrade
 
I found some Opteron 170's with the stepping that should allow 2.8ghz+ but im looking at 260$ shipped to get it.. I think ill hold off. As fast as im running right now if im not going to see a difference in gaming with a dual core I dont need the upgrade.
 
I've built a few configurations on this query. Single Core + RAID 0, Dual Core + RAID 0, Single Core + Single HDD, Dual Core + Single HDD. And 5 of those RAID 0 builds out of 15 or so have been Raptors. There are way too many variables to list as far as performance and hardware goes. But like most people have said it really depends on what your using your rig for.

I am a big fan of 'snappy' desktop performance. Bringing up programs and search functions and the like, I'm also a big gamer. I've seen heavy specs on certain pc's that seem sluggish to me and vice versa. RAID 0 doesn't have many fans on these forums but from experience I really like it. No RAID 0 build I've ever done seems sluggish and delayed. The raw numbers might suggest that in everyday use its not that much of an upgrade, but don't let anyone fool you into believing it doesn't make a difference, because it does.

If I had to personally choose, I'd go with the dual core setup first then upgrade later to RAID 0 with the Raptors. Be advised, all naysayers of RAID 0 always bring up the possibility of doubling your drive failure rate simply because its 2 drives instead of one, which is true, but if you look at it that way noone would ever buy any electronics because of the fear of possible failure. Most people have run RAID 0 for YEARS without incident.
 
seanmcd said:
neither one. From a performance standpoint, I lean towards the dual core CPU but, you are already at 2.8ghz. You aren't going to see a great benefit in a dual core CPU with gaming. If you multitask a lot you might see a good benefit. Plus, you are going to need to find one that runs at 2.8ghz or you'll be dissapointed. I say keep saving for your next major upgrade


That would be my response too. Your cpu/mobo/mem/hdd setup is great, pretty close to the max you would be able to get from that generation. Another 100-300mhz on a better single core processor (if you can squeeze it) isn't going to change much, and dual-core is only going to give you a decent benefit if you plan to take advantage of it. Also, if you can't match that nice 2.8, you are likely to 'feel' like it's not performing as well.

Looking at your sig, if you are a gamer, your big bottleneck is in that 7600GT. Maybe sell that and upgrade to a 7900GTO or 7950GT for a $100-200 difference.
 
Tweakin said:
That would be my response too. Your cpu/mobo/mem/hdd setup is great, pretty close to the max you would be able to get from that generation. Another 100-300mhz on a better single core processor (if you can squeeze it) isn't going to change much, and dual-core is only going to give you a decent benefit if you plan to take advantage of it. Also, if you can't match that nice 2.8, you are likely to 'feel' like it's not performing as well.

Looking at your sig, if you are a gamer, your big bottleneck is in that 7600GT. Maybe sell that and upgrade to a 7900GTO or 7950GT for a $100-200 difference.

Agree.
 
Tweakin said:
That would be my response too. Your cpu/mobo/mem/hdd setup is great, pretty close to the max you would be able to get from that generation. Another 100-300mhz on a better single core processor (if you can squeeze it) isn't going to change much, and dual-core is only going to give you a decent benefit if you plan to take advantage of it. Also, if you can't match that nice 2.8, you are likely to 'feel' like it's not performing as well.

Looking at your sig, if you are a gamer, your big bottleneck is in that 7600GT. Maybe sell that and upgrade to a 7900GTO or 7950GT for a $100-200 difference.
I agree, too.
 
I was just telling my friend I should probalby spend the money on a video card to get the best performance upgrade... It runs pretty good now.. maybe I should wait for the DX10 cards? Although BF2142 comes out next week and running my native res will probably be a problem with this video card. Thanks again for all the replys.
 
Back
Top