x1900xtx vs 7800gt sli

Rash

2[H]4U
Joined
Jan 3, 2005
Messages
2,557
My bro is undecided, hes building a new rig, hes seen mine and is really impressed, he hasnt seen a 7800gt sli setup,he doesnt want to spend any extra on modding (getting extra coolers/fans etc) we know that the xtx and the 7800gtsli get similar scores in 3dmark06 but what about real world performance in games? are there any reviews comparing the 2 anywhere, what are your thoughts on which is better for todays games and future games. My brother will be getting a 4400+ or better processor with 2 gigs of ram etc, and wants to play games at at 1440x1050 up to 1920x1200. Any links to comparisons on real world gaming welcome. Proof from reliable sources would be great.
Thanks
 
Cheers Quadnad! Those are pretty interesting results, is toms hardware regarded as a majorly reliable source?
 
Rash said:
Cheers Quadnad! Those are pretty interesting results, is toms hardware regarded as a majorly reliable source?

Most definetly. They've been around for quite a while (they're celebrating their 10th....anniversary? Not sure if thats the proper term) and I check it quite frequently. Pretty good for tech reviews.

They've been putting these charts together for quite a while now, but this is their first "select a comparison" chart.
 
quadnad said:
Most definetly. They've been around for quite a while (they're celebrating their 10th....anniversary? Not sure if thats the proper term) and I check it quite frequently. Pretty good for tech reviews.

They've been putting these charts together for quite a while now, but this is their first "select a comparison" chart.

Reliable? Tom's? YEAH RIGHT!

They've gone through periods of trustworthyness followed by periods by WTF are these people smoking. Have they "righted the ship"? They've been superceded by other sites, including this one.
 
KENNYB said:
Reliable? Tom's? YEAH RIGHT!

They've gone through periods of trustworthyness followed by periods by WTF are these people smoking. Have they "righted the ship"? They've been superceded by other sites, including this one.

lol, I've heard that kind of stuff, but have never been able to verify with any of their articles. I dunno, I've always had a decent amount of trust in Toms, especially in benches like vid card benches, where editorials aren't involved. Either way, I've always checked multiple sources, and for what this dude needs, their bench charts are just what the doctor ordered.
 
They may have righted the ship... may have. Still, won't excuse the BS that they've pushed over the years. The last major infraction was, IIRC, a 1600xt beating a 7800GTX. Don't remember the game, but come on, how the hell is a 1600xt going to beat a 7800GTX in anything? I was about to give them another chance but after reading that crap, i said screw them for another year.

Hehe... i had to go looking for it.

http://www.tomshardware.com/2005/10/06/ati_enters_the_x1000_promised_land/page17.html

Sure... it could have been a "driver issue", but the GTX had been out for months when this was written.
 
tom is some what trustworthy, he sometimes "exagerate" the truth, sometimes doesn't give out important details. You just got to decide if he gives complete details or just partial truth. As far as benchmarks goes, I don't like how they did it, it doesn't give a detail graph of FPS over time, just straight numbers. The problem is, you don't know where they got the FPS number from... ie at what frame? is it average? My experience with reading review sites is: half of understanding any review is understanding what information is given to you, then you got to decide if the information given is justified.
 
If Toms says a card is an absolute must buy winner, then it means if can contend with whatever else is in the market. If Toms says something sucks, its probably the most badass thing out right now.

I dont read the site anymore, but with all the horse crap they feed people in the past, I dont trust them at all.
 
well..the x1800xt is doing sm3...but the xtx shouldn't be beating 7800gt sli in EVERY GAME. i don't bother with toms anymore. look at xbitlabs.com. very clear benches with lots of cards. anand is good too. i don't like this site's benchmarks because they're not apples to apples! what's the point? i can figure out what's playable, you tell me which card gets 3 more frames than the other.
 
I used to check Tom's site every day a couple years ago. They've gone through a total overhaul a little while back, and they never seemed the same to me after that. Their new editor is an apple fanatic (not like I give a shit what computer platform he likes, I just don't want to read his subliminal BS all the time). Their reviews seem to be mostly on par with a lot of other sites, you just have to decide what is realistic or not. The kicker seems to be unless its something really big and new like a new processor or graphics card and the sort, they decide to pick some worthless shit to review. Nothing ever seems to catch my eye as something I really would want to read. OH, and don't get me started on that queer british "guy" doing that weekly article. Every time I see his sideways face on the front page, all I want to do is kick in his fucking 20 lbs. gonzo nose until it takes the shape of something more natural and smaller; like a horses cock. While you're there, don't forget to stop by the forums and catch up on some Intel fan boys make fun of everyone else while they insist that they don't prefer one chip maker over the other. Fun times had by all.


Alright, put the beer down. What were we talking about again? x1900xtx or a couple 7800gt's? They both kick ass, you win either way. I'd pick the x1900xt and overclock it if it were me, so since its not pick the platform that best suits the type of games your brother likes best and rock and roll with that new system he's working on.
 
Back
Top