X1900XTX or SLI7800GT's

Scubastevie00

Limp Gawd
Joined
Aug 15, 2004
Messages
200
I'm about to start building my new rig after I sell of the one I'm currently on. I'm trying to figure out whether I want one X1900XTX or SLI7800GT's. They're roughly the same in price to me off of Newegg. I doubt I'm gonna need more power any time soon seeing as how I'm still running off a Sapphire 9800Pro. I can live without the upgrades for awhile but its coming time. What do you guys think.
 
X1900XTX. The 7800 GTs lack in features and you would no longer have an upgrade path for another card.
 
x1900xt is pretty much the same speed.
x1900xt has more features (AA+HDR and HQ AF being the main ones)
x1900xt is on its first release drivers or beta drivers and preformance will get better.
x1900xt has twice the ram and will play "Ultra" settings in games better because of it.

x1900xt all the way.
 
i would just get the x1900XT and oc it.
i would rather have 1 gpu then 2 if they were about the same.
 
ClearM4 said:
x1900xt is pretty much the same speed.
x1900xt has more features (AA+HDR and HQ AF being the main ones)
x1900xt is on its first release drivers or beta drivers and preformance will get better.
x1900xt has twice the ram and will play "Ultra" settings in games better because of it.

x1900xt all the way.

Agreed, this is all the OP needs to know.
 
ClearM4 said:
x1900xt is pretty much the same speed.
x1900xt has more features (AA+HDR and HQ AF being the main ones)
x1900xt is on its first release drivers or beta drivers and preformance will get better.
x1900xt has twice the ram and will play "Ultra" settings in games better because of it.

x1900xt all the way.

should be set in stone like the 10 commandments :p ;)
 
Digital Viper-X- said:
doesnt the 7800GT offer TRSSA/MSAA?


But: The image quality and LOD is better on the ATi, now throw in ATi's HQ AF mode...no comparison.
 
BBA said:
But: The image quality and LOD is better on the ATi, now throw in ATi's HQ AF mode...no comparison.

HQ AF aside i dont think many of us stop the game and take screenshots so we can zoom in and test out the higher "IQ"
 
I personall think from the screenshots that HQAF is enough of an improvement in IQ that it would be noticable without pausing the game. The shot that the [H]ard review gave of the wall (i think in FEAR) really stood out to me, bump mapping looked much better with the HQAF
 
stelleg151 said:
I personall think from the screenshots that HQAF is enough of an improvement in IQ that it would be noticable without pausing the game. The shot that the [H]ard review gave of the wall (i think in FEAR) really stood out to me, bump mapping looked much better with the HQAF

I Said HQ AF aside =p otherwise the IQ seems way to close to ever notice while playing
 
Digital Viper-X- said:
HQ AF aside i dont think many of us stop the game and take screenshots so we can zoom in and test out the higher "IQ"
Even the regular AF is better than others so HQ AF sets it apart even further and you don't need to stop to notice.
 
man this thread is just a massive can of worms....

but i would go with the 7800gt, the g70 models have more pixel pipes, where as the 1900's have more shader pixels, ALOT more... like 3x more, which means:

---> Nvidia is going for higher res's and i suspect that in future games, the 7800 will start to slowly outshine the x1800 and 1900 in higher those higher res's. (like res >1600x1200)
--->and ati is going for (future) really really high aa, so its aa vs high res, and if you can get high res at steady fps, then you dont need aa....

then of course theres the question, can you cram anymore pixels into the average 19" thru 24" monitor... if you cant, n-vidia is in trouble.
so im bigger on n-vidia, and this is where some ppl might get angry at me, ati ppl anywho...
sli performs better then crossfire....
i said it... but its true, while crossfire has some cool aspects to it, just they've had less time to perfect it... so its just not as good... yet anyways...

anywho go with the 7800gt, and dont get the dual core one, 2 processers on a 16x pci slot its a waste, the bw is to small for 2 gpus.
 
R1ckCa1n said:
Even the regular AF is better than others so HQ AF sets it apart even further and you don't need to stop to notice.

show me where regular AF is better =p
keep in mind I've had an X1800XT, X850XT PE X850XT, x800XT PE and X800 PRO, 6800Ultra, 7800GTX, 7800GT ^_^
 
I would say X1900XT is a better buy. 7800GTX 512MB is another good one but sadly I don't think we will be seeing it anymore.

For now, I prefer ATI cards because of their better LOD and AAF. Whether it benefits you or not is dependent on the games you play. I do play alot of racing games esp. FIA GTR and F1 Challenge. When you are concentrating on looking at the track, the image quality becomes more important and any improvements in image quality will greatly improves your gaming experience.

If you are playing games that concentrating on the game play itself rather than environment, then the minor improvement in image quality isn't really noticeable. FYI, FX5800 has very good AAF quality, unfortunately, its lackluster performance killed itself. I am hoping that Nvidia will put implement back the same AAF they used in FX5800 series.

I don't believe in getting 2 slower cards and SLI them to match or exceed a faster card. I always believe in getting the single fastest card you can afford. If you have extra budget later on, get a 2nd one and SLI them. If not, you still have a very fast card that will run all your games.

Regarding what MrWizard6600 has mentioned, I have to stressed that few monitors are capable of displaying 1600 x 1200. For LCDs, you need a 21" to do that. 17 and 19" are limtied to just 1280 x 1024. If you have the budget for a LCD that could display 1600 x 1200, you wouldn't even bother about 7800GT SLI.
 
noobracer said:
I would say X1900XT is a better buy. 7800GTX 512MB is another good one but sadly I don't think we will be seeing it anymore.

For now, I prefer ATI cards because of their better LOD and AAF. Whether it benefits you or not is dependent on the games you play. I do play alot of racing games esp. FIA GTR and F1 Challenge. When you are concentrating on looking at the track, the image quality becomes more important and any improvements in image quality will greatly improves your gaming experience.

If you are playing games that concentrating on the game play itself rather than environment, then the minor improvement in image quality isn't really noticeable. FYI, FX5800 has very good AAF quality, unfortunately, its lackluster performance killed itself. I am hoping that Nvidia will put implement back the same AAF they used in FX5800 series.

I don't believe in getting 2 slower cards and SLI them to match or exceed a faster card. I always believe in getting the single fastest card you can afford. If you have extra budget later on, get a 2nd one and SLI them. If not, you still have a very fast card that will run all your games.

Regarding what MrWizard6600 has mentioned, I have to stressed that few monitors are capable of displaying 1600 x 1200. For LCDs, you need a 21" to do that. 17 and 19" are limtied to just 1280 x 1024. If you have the budget for a LCD that could display 1600 x 1200, you wouldn't even bother about 7800GT SLI.

i have 2 20" lcds capable of doing 1600x1200 =)
 
Mayhs said:
Originally Posted by ClearM4
x1900xt is pretty much the same speed.
x1900xt has more features (AA+HDR and HQ AF being the main ones)
x1900xt is on its first release drivers or beta drivers and preformance will get better.
x1900xt has twice the ram and will play "Ultra" settings in games better because of it.

x1900xt all the way.

should be set in stone like the 10 commandments :p ;)

No, should be set in Jelly till the next refresh.
 
Inglix_the_Mad said:
No, should be set in Jelly till the next refresh.

Haha, so true, ATI's on top... for now probably will be till*gasp* march or maby a little later, whenever Nvidia gets around to lauching it's 7900, of course I could be wrong, but I'm just going to wait till Oblivion come out and I get my tax returnes back before I buy a new pc. (I upgrade about every 2 years)
 
Directx 10 cards are 7-8 months away, if you need a card now that doesn't help you much. If you do have to buy one video card now and are deciding between the 7800GT SLI and X1900XTX i would completely recommend the X1900 card.

You will have less configuration or performance issues with 1 card and you don't have to worry about game profiles or any of that to get optimal performance in different games. As well in this case a single X1900XTX generally performs better than a pair of 7800GT cards in SLI, especially at higher resolutions.
 
ClearM4 said:
x1900xt is pretty much the same speed.
x1900xt has more features (AA+HDR and HQ AF being the main ones)
x1900xt is on its first release drivers or beta drivers and preformance will get better.
x1900xt has twice the ram and will play "Ultra" settings in games better because of it.

x1900xt all the way.

wow dude you didnt even list the biggest change from 1800 to 1900....
there are 3x more pixel shader processers.....

atis banking on this, you ask me, theres a line beeing drawn between ati and n-vidia (eye candy+AA+AF vs res)
 
MrWizard6600 said:
man this thread is just a massive can of worms....

but i would go with the 7800gt, the g70 models have more pixel pipes, where as the 1900's have more shader pixels, ALOT more... like 3x more, which means:

---> Nvidia is going for higher res's and i suspect that in future games, the 7800 will start to slowly outshine the x1800 and 1900 in higher those higher res's. (like res >1600x1200)
--->and ati is going for (future) really really high aa, so its aa vs high res, and if you can get high res at steady fps, then you dont need aa....


A few problems with that...ATi X1900 has larger Z Buffers and does not loose acceleration in high res like the nvidia does. This makes a difference if you plan on high res gaming on a flat screen that does 1920 or more.

PLUS: The X1900 XTX already beats SLi 7800 GTX's when oc'd. All by itself (not even talking crossfire)

PLUS: The X1900 has DUAL Dual link DVI, meaning it can do dual monitors at 2560x1600 on two monitors at the same time. You have to go with nvidia's Quadro to get that (real money there)

PLUS: The X1900 has Adaptive AA to stand up to nvidias tr and ss aa.

PLUS: The X1900 has 512 MB memory available, the SLi GTX does not (unless you can get the 512 MB version, which costs more than the XTX if it can even be found anymore.)
 
BBA said:
A few problems with that...ATi X1900 has larger Z Buffers and does not loose acceleration in high res like the nvidia does. This makes a difference if you plan on high res gaming on a flat screen that does 1920 or more.

PLUS: The X1900 XTX already beats SLi 7800 GTX's when oc'd. All by itself (not even talking crossfire)

PLUS: The X1900 has DUAL Dual link DVI, meaning it can do dual monitors at 2560x1600 on two monitors at the same time. You have to go with nvidia's Quadro to get that (real money there)

PLUS: The X1900 has Adaptive AA to stand up to nvidias tr and ss aa.

PLUS: The X1900 has 512 MB memory available, the SLi GTX does not (unless you can get the 512 MB version, which costs more than the XTX if it can even be found anymore.)
Good points.

Hell the X1800XT had a hard time competing with the 7800GT when launched and now wins/draws even with the 7800GTX and GTX 512. Image what the X1900 will be like in a few driver releases (or months).
 
Digital Viper-X- said:
SLI 7800GT's are currently faster then an X!900XT even at high resolutions

No they are not. They are faster in some, and the XT is faster in some. Making a blanket statement like that is false.
 
^
l


I didn't even see that post...thanks for correcting him.
 
Back
Top